Philosophy
Reading a Blush
Socrates thinks Charmides’ blush makes him look more beautiful. A line from Homer later helps him test the boy’s account of temperance.
The Platonic Dialogues: CharmidesA red face can leave an observer guessing. The same Greek adjective for bashfulness returns in Charmides’ definition of temperance and opens a question about what his blush can tell us.
Orientation
At a Glance
- What the narrator seesCharmides blushes when asked whether he is temperate. Socrates thinks it makes the boy more beautiful and says that bashfulness suits his age.
- A feeling that can helpAristotle treats shame as a feeling and says it can restrain young people from mistakes. That gives it a place in growing up without settling whether it is a virtue.
- The same adjective comes backThe Greek adjective behind Socrates’ description of the boy’s bashfulness returns when Charmides says temperance makes people bashful.
- When shame gets in the waySocrates cites Homer’s line about modesty doing a man in need no good. If modesty can help or hurt depending on the situation, it differs from temperance as they understand it in the exchange.
Charmides 154b–c, 158b–c, 158c–d, 160d–e, 160e–161b · Aristotle, Nicomachean Ethics 4.9 · Odyssey 17.345–347
The blush comes at the moment Socrates asks the boy whether he’s temperate. “Charmides blushed,” Socrates tells his friend, and then he records two things he finds creditable. First, “he looked even more beautiful,” since “his bashfulness was becoming at his age.” Second, he gave an answer that did his breeding credit. Notice the order, because it tells you who is doing the looking. The first thing the narrator registers about a young man’s reaction is that it made him prettier, and only then does he get around to what the boy said.
It helps to separate what the body did from what the narrator made of it. Physically, all we know is that a young man’s face turned red when he was asked, in front of a crowd, a direct question about his own character. A blush like that can mean modesty, but it can also mean embarrassment, guilt, irritation, the discomfort of being stared at, or simply the heat of being put on the spot, and anyone who has blushed in a job interview knows the face doesn’t come with a caption. The body supplied a signal, and the narrator supplied the interpretation. A reddening face leaves a lot for the observer to fill in.
Socrates’ interpretation is an admirer’s, and we’ve been warned about his eye. He told us earlier that where the beautiful are concerned he’s a white measuring-line on white stone, a judge who finds nearly every young man gorgeous, and now that same uncalibrated instrument finds something beautiful and becoming in the boy’s blush. How much of that comes from the blush and how much from the admiration is exactly the question, and the boy’s answer gives us a little more to go on. He says he’s worried about how either answer will sound. That gives us a reason to read the blush as discomfort, even if the admirer sees an extra glow. The blush is the evidence, and the beauty is the commentary.
Socrates does deserve some credit for his choice of words, though. He says the bashfulness “was becoming at his age,” which leaves open what it says about the boy’s temperance. Aristotle later makes a related distinction. He treats shame as a feeling and says it is praised in the young because it holds them back from some mistakes. He expects older people to have learned to avoid doing things that would shame them. Socrates’ phrase leaves room for that difference. A feeling can help a beginner do better while the steadier habits are still taking shape.
Then the dialogue tests the reading, and it does it in a way that’s almost too neat. Socrates asks the boy to “look within yourself,” to consider what sort of person temperance makes you, and to say what it is, and Charmides, after thinking it over, answers, “Well, I think temperance makes a person feel shame and makes him bashful, and that temperance is the same thing as modesty.” The Greek adjective the boy uses for being bashful is the same one Socrates uses of him when he blushes. When Charmides looks within, he gives an account of the virtue that sounds a lot like what has just happened to his own cheeks.
And the definition is refuted almost at once, by an argument the boy agrees to step by step. Socrates asks whether temperance is good, gets a yes, and then reminds the boy of Homer’s line that modesty is no good thing for a man in need, so shame can be bad as well as good, while temperance is always good, which means the two can’t be the same thing. In Homer, Telemachus sends food to Odysseus, who is disguised as a beggar, and tells him to ask the suitors for more. A man too bashful to ask risks going hungry. The argument does to the blush what the narrator didn’t, separating a feeling that’s right in some situations and wrong in others from a virtue that’s supposed to be right everywhere.
There’s a gentle irony in how the second definition is set up, too. Socrates asks the boy to answer “properly and like a man,” and the narrator says Charmides thinks it over very much like a man. The boy can reflect seriously and still put forward the bashfulness that suited him a moment ago. Whatever a fuller account of temperance would be, this exchange shows that it has to explain more than a reddening face.
My verdict is that the blush tells us the question affected Charmides. What it says about his character takes more than an admirer’s look to find out. The boy offers bashfulness as part of his definition, and Homer’s line helps Socrates test it. The phrase Socrates chose, that bashfulness was becoming at his age, turns out to be exactly the right amount of credit, which is a nice example of an admirer being more careful than he first appears, and of an argument being more careful still.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
Why does the article treat Charmides’ blush as insufficient evidence of his temperance?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- What kinds of evidence, beyond Charmides’ blush, would be needed to judge whether he is genuinely temperate?→
- How does Socrates’ admiration for Charmides shape his interpretation, and can an observer ever fully separate perception from personal attitude?→
- If a feeling such as shame can be appropriate in some situations and harmful in others, what would distinguish a virtue from a merely useful emotion?→