Philosophy
“How Could I Know?”
Charmides says he doesn’t know how to answer near the beginning, and says he doesn’t know whether he’s temperate at the end. The reasons he gives have changed.
The Platonic Dialogues: CharmidesAt first Charmides worries about what either answer would say about him and his guardian. At the end he asks how he could judge himself when the inquiry still hasn’t found a definition.
Orientation
At a Glance
- The first answer protects two peopleCharmides says that calling himself temperate would sound boastful and denying it would make Critias and others look mistaken. His first problem is what he can say in front of the room.
- The second answer asks for a standardAt the end, Charmides asks how he could know whether he has temperance when Socrates and Critias haven’t found out what it is. He is responding to the inquiry he has just heard.
- Reputation and judgment come apartThe praise Charmides receives is one kind of evidence. Working out what counts as temperance asks something further of him and the people who praise him.
- Uncertainty can lead somewhereSocrates earlier asks Charmides to start from whatever sense of temperance he has. At the end Charmides is unsure, and he asks to keep receiving the charm.
Charmides 158b–c, 158c–159a, 159b–d, 160b–e, 160e–161c, 175d–176a, 176a–b · Ola Svenson 1981 driver self-ratings, p. 146
At the start of the examination, Socrates puts the question to Charmides directly, asking him whether he agrees with Critias “and say that you already have a sufficient share of temperance, or that you are lacking in it?” The boy blushes and explains that it’s “not easy, in the circumstances, either to agree or to deny,” and he ends with “So I don’t know what answer to give you.” At the end of the dialogue, after the definitions have all collapsed and Socrates has told him to see whether he has temperance, he says much the same thing, “But by Zeus, Socrates, I don’t know whether I have it or whether I don’t.” Two admissions of not knowing, with the whole dialogue in between, and it’s worth asking whether anything has changed.
The first “I don’t know” is about what Charmides can say. If he denies that he’s temperate, he makes Critias and the others who vouch for him look like liars. If he agrees, he praises himself, which “will probably seem obnoxious.” There’s a crowd in the room and a guardian beside him. Both answers carry a social cost. Socrates tells him, “You seem to me to be talking sense, Charmides,” and offers to examine the question with him instead of making him choose on the spot.
The second “I don’t know” comes with a different reason. “For how could I know,” he asks, “when not even you two are able to discover what it is, as you say?” He’s now pointing to something everyone has heard. The two people who took the lead in the inquiry couldn’t give a settled account of the virtue. Charmides asks how he is supposed to recognize it in himself when they have yet to say what it is.
The public setting hasn’t gone away. What changes is the reason Charmides gives for hesitating. At first, he asks what either answer will do to his own reputation and to the word of his guardian. Now he asks what would justify an answer. He has heard people who began with confidence give up one proposal after another. Their willingness to speak first gave him little reason to treat the last thing they said as a final judgment.
It’s tempting to say Charmides has lost confidence. The dialogue gives us very little access to whatever opinion of himself he might have kept private at the beginning. It does show him offering accounts of temperance. He proposes doing things quietly, tries modesty, and brings in the claim that temperance is doing one’s own business. By the end he knows what it’s like to hear a plausible answer and then see it meet a case that puts it in doubt.
A study of driver self-assessment gives a small comparison. Ola Svenson asked people to place their driving skill in relation to others in their group. In his 1981 paper, 93 percent of the Americans who answered the skill question placed themselves above the median. The study asked how people rated themselves, and such a lopsided result makes it worth asking what evidence they had for their rankings. The question in the wrestling school is different. Here even the people doing the questioning have trouble saying what should count.
There’s a cost to putting the question entirely in the hands of the people conducting the inquiry. Socrates had asked Charmides to start from whatever sense of temperance he already had, on the thought that a virtue present in him might make itself felt. We often recognize someone’s generosity or self-control before we can give a definition of it. Socrates himself still entertains the thought that Charmides is “most temperate in soul.” The young man has reason to take his uncertainty seriously and to keep paying attention to what he can already observe.
My verdict is that the second hesitation shows Charmides making a better use of uncertainty. He can name a reason for withholding judgment that the other people in the room can examine with him. He still wants the charm. His last answer leaves open whether he has temperance and gives him something to do while he tries to find out.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
What is the most important change between Charmides’ first and second admissions of uncertainty?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- When does withholding judgment become a responsible response to uncertainty, and when might it become a way of avoiding commitment?→
- Can someone reasonably recognize a virtue in themselves or others without being able to define it? What kind of evidence would make that recognition trustworthy?→
- How should Charmides balance his own observations against the failed judgments of people who appear more experienced or authoritative?→