Philosophy

Help, on One Condition

Socrates has a remedy for Charmides’ headache with a condition attached. An imagined conversation about a résumé tests when a condition helps and when it puts pressure on the person asking.

The Thracian doctor ties treatment of the head to treatment of the soul. Socrates’ later invitation gives Charmides a chance to decide whether to continue.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The Thracian’s conditionThe doctor tells Socrates to treat the headache only if Charmides first submits his soul to treatment with the charm.
  • Why the condition mattersThe doctor holds that bodily troubles can begin in the soul. The mentor in the modern example sees a similar connection between a job application and the applicant’s aims.
  • Why it can feel like pressureCharmides wants the remedy and has an audience and a guardian to contend with. The cost of saying no matters to how freely he can answer.
  • Socrates offers a choiceSocrates asks Charmides if he wants to examine temperance together. Charmides chooses to continue.

Imagine a young graduate who goes to an experienced mentor for help with a job application. She wants her résumé polished and her cover letter fixed, and she wants it done this week. The mentor agrees to help, but only on one condition, that first they sit down and talk about what she actually wants from her working life, what matters to her and why she is applying for this job at all. The graduate hesitates, because she came for a résumé, not an examination, and the mentor’s condition feels both caring and a little intrusive.

The Charmides opens with a version of exactly this bargain. Charmides has a headache, and Socrates has a cure, a leaf with a charm, but the Thracian doctor who taught it to him laid down a strict rule. “Mind that nobody persuades you to treat his head with this remedy,” he said, “unless he first hands over his soul to be treated by you with the charm,” and he charged Socrates “to let no one be so rich, or so wellborn, or so beautiful, as to persuade me to do otherwise.” Socrates says “I have sworn him an oath, and I must obey,” and so the boy can have the cure only if he submits his soul to examination first. The oath gives the condition the force of a professional rule, the way a doctor might say that hospital policy requires a full history before any prescription.

The bargain has a real justification behind it, and it’s worth stating fairly. The Thracian’s doctrine is that everything, bad and good alike, starts from the soul, so that treating the head without the soul is treating a symptom while ignoring the cause. A mentor might say the same about the résumé, since polishing the application of someone who doesn’t know why she wants the job may only help her into the wrong job faster. The condition, on this view, is an act of care, a refusal to give shallow help when deeper help is what’s needed.

But conditional help also carries pressure, and the pressure is greater when the helper holds something the other person wants. The graduate needs the résumé fixed, and the boy wants his headache gone, so neither is entirely free to refuse the larger examination. Charmides is also surrounded by a crowd and urged on by his guardian, which makes saying no even harder. A condition that would be an invitation between equals can become a toll when one side has the power to withhold what the other needs. The helper may not mean to exert that pressure, but good intentions don’t remove it, and a careful helper has to account for the power his position gives him.

The question of relevance is the one that decides most cases. A doctor who asks about diet and sleep before treating headaches is asking relevant questions, and nobody thinks that intrusive. A mentor who asks about a graduate’s goals before advising on a job application is probably on solid ground too. But a helper who demands the right to examine everything about a person’s life before helping with anything has to justify that breadth, and the Thracian’s justification is a doctrine that is asserted rather than argued, a theory that everything starts from the soul, which conveniently licenses examining all of it. Modern professions handle this with the idea of scope, the understanding that a helper’s questions should match the help being sought, and that widening the scope needs the person’s agreement.

What makes Socrates’ own conduct acceptable comes a little later, and it’s easy to miss. When Charmides is caught in the bind of having to say whether he is temperate, Socrates suggests they “look into it together,” telling him “you won’t be forced to say what you don’t want to,” and then adds the crucial words, “So if you’d like, I am willing to look into it with you; if not, let’s leave it.” Socrates gives Charmides a choice about whether to examine temperance, and the boy chooses to go ahead. The offer comes just after Charmides has admitted he doesn’t know how to answer, so Socrates makes room for him at exactly the moment the pressure peaks.

That shift is the model for the mentor, since help can reasonably be tied to a broader conversation when the helper can explain why the conversation is relevant, when the person can decline without losing face or losing all help, and when the broader examination really serves the person’s own aims rather than the helper’s interest in being needed. A mentor who says, “I think this will help, but if you’d rather just do the résumé, let’s do the résumé,” has the Thracian’s care without his toll.

My verdict is that making help conditional on personal disclosure can be a form of care, as the Thracian’s refusal to treat symptoms without causes suggests, but that it becomes pressure when the helper doesn’t justify the breadth of what he asks and the person can’t freely refuse. Socrates himself shows the better way, since he begins with the Thracian’s strict condition and ends by offering to examine the boy only if the boy wants it. Relevance explained and refusal permitted are what turn a demanding bargain into a genuine invitation.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

Why does the article regard the Thracian doctor’s condition as potentially caring rather than merely intrusive?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.