Philosophy

Greater Than Itself, Smaller Than Itself

Plato makes a comparison fold back on itself and asks what breaks.

Socrates asks Critias to imagine something heavier than itself. The example reveals a limit of comparisons and gives them a sharper question about knowledge.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • Both ends of the comparisonIf a thing were greater than itself, Socrates points out that it would also be smaller than itself.
  • How Simmias can be tall and shortIn the Phaedo, Simmias is taller than Socrates and shorter than Phaedo because the comparisons have different terms.
  • Relations that work differentlySomething can be equal to itself, and a person can trust herself, even though nothing can be older than itself in the same respect.
  • The question left openSocrates’s comparisons help us ask whether knowing requires a difference between knower and known, and he leaves that question unsettled.

Charmides 168b–c, 168c–169a, 169a–b · Republic 438b–c · Phaedo 102b–c

After the senses and the longings, Socrates turns to comparisons, and the examples get stranger. He gets Critias to agree that knowledge has a power by which it’s of something, just as the greater is greater than something smaller. Then he imagines something greater than itself. If such a thing existed, he says, “it would also be smaller than itself.” Critias answers, “Absolutely necessary, Socrates.” It’s a firm answer to a very strange question.

The logic is tidy once you see it laid out. If one thing is greater than another, the second is smaller than the first. If you put one thing at both ends of the comparison, the same thing has to be greater and smaller than itself. Socrates does the same with doubling. If a magnitude were double itself, it would also be half of itself, “for there is no double of anything but a half.” He goes on to more and less, heavier and lighter, older and younger. In each case the two places in the comparison have different requirements.

The same comparisons turn up elsewhere in Plato. In the Republic, Socrates is talking about desire when he says that the greater is greater than the lesser and the double is double of the half. In the Phaedo, Simmias is taller than Socrates and shorter than Phaedo. There’s no difficulty in Simmias being tall in one comparison and short in another, because the people he’s measured against are different. The Charmides takes that difference away. The comparison has to do its work with the same thing at both ends.

Logicians call a relation like being older than irreflexive. Nothing can stand in that relation to itself. A box can be heavier than it was yesterday, because we’re comparing its weight at two times. It can’t be heavier than itself at the same time, on the same scale. The qualification matters. Once you keep the terms of comparison fixed, you can see exactly why the example fails.

Some relations work differently. Everything is equal to itself. If I’m at least as tall as you are, I may be taller than you or just the same height, so I can also be at least as tall as myself. Loving and trusting work differently again. A person can trust herself and can also fail to trust herself. Even a sentence can turn back on itself, as in “This sentence has five words.” To know what happens when a relation turns back on itself, you have to look at the particular relation.

So which sort of relation is knowing? If the knower and the known have to be different in the way that an older and a younger person do, the examples make trouble for Critias. If someone can know her own thoughts, there’s at least some reason to wonder how far the comparison holds. Socrates leaves himself room for that. He distinguishes the cases he thinks impossible, such as magnitudes and numbers, from cases such as sight, self-motion, and heat, where he recognizes that people might disagree. He can’t confidently place knowledge in either group.

The examples give us a clear picture of what could go wrong. It takes only a moment to see why something can’t be older than itself. A person noticing her own thoughts, though, isn’t obviously doing anything of the kind. We still need to ask what knowing requires of the thing known, and whether that requirement forces knowing and its object to be separate. The playful comparisons give that serious question a shape.

My verdict is that the greater-than-itself examples show something precise. A comparison that requires a difference, like older and younger, can’t work when it compares one thing with itself in the same respect. The examples make us ask whether knowledge works like that. Socrates says it would take a great man to distinguish what can turn its power on itself from what can’t. The comparisons give anyone who takes up the question a place to start.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

Why can Simmias be both tall and short without creating the problem raised in the Charmides?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.