Philosophy
Every Day Until You Say When
Charmides offers to return for the charm every day. His eagerness is clear, and he leaves Socrates to decide when he’s had enough.
The Platonic Dialogues: CharmidesThe dialogue ends with a student who wants to keep going. It also leaves him relying on two other people to tell him what counts as progress.
Orientation
At a Glance
- Charmides wants to come backAfter admitting he can’t tell whether he has temperance, Charmides asks to receive the charm every day.
- Who decides when it’s enoughSocrates asks Charmides to see whether he has temperance. Charmides leaves Socrates to judge when he’s had enough of the charm.
- Critias gives an orderCritias says sticking with Socrates would prove Charmides temperate. Charmides promises to obey him as his guardian.
- Learning to make the judgmentA teacher’s guidance can help a learner see more clearly. The dialogue leaves open how far Charmides will learn to judge for himself.
Charmides 154c–d, 157a–b, 157d, 161b–c, 175e–176a, 176a–c · Theaetetus 150e, 151a · Immanuel Kant, What Is Enlightenment? opening paragraphs · Xenophon, Memorabilia 3.7.1, 3.7.4 · Xenophon, Hellenica 2.4.19
Charmides can’t tell whether he has temperance. Even Socrates and Critias, he points out, haven’t discovered what it is. Yet he thinks he needs the charm, and he offers to be charmed “every day, until you say it’s enough.” Socrates has described the charm as beautiful words that can bring temperance into a soul, so the boy is asking for more of what the conversation might do for him. Listen to the whole offer and you can hear how much depends on the last few words. He wants to go on, and he’s letting Socrates decide when they can stop.
There’s something promising about his eagerness. When Charmides arrived, the people in the wrestling school gazed at him. Critias soon told Socrates that the young man was thought to surpass his peers in temperance as well as in looks. Later Charmides offered a definition he had heard from someone else. Socrates suspected Critias was the source, and Charmides asked why that should matter. At the end, he goes further and says he’s still unconvinced by Socrates himself. He wants more conversation even after discovering that the people who seemed in a position to assess him have questions of their own.
The Theaetetus gives one reason to take that willingness seriously. There Socrates describes people who left his company before they were ready. They thought they owed their success to themselves, and some lost what they had discovered through keeping poor company. Some later begged to come back. Socrates says he could resume the conversation with certain people, who then made progress again. Beside that story, Charmides’s offer sounds like a student willing to give an uncertain inquiry more time. He has enough sense of what he might gain to ask for it to continue.
Now consider what Socrates has just asked Charmides to do. “So see whether you have it,” he says, talking about temperance. If he already has it, he can do without the charm. Charmides has a fair objection. How is he supposed to recognize a quality neither of the two older men could define? His response is to give Socrates the call about when he’s had enough. The examination may help him learn how to make that judgment, but for now the judgment still belongs to someone else.
Kant gives us another way to hear the offer. In his essay on enlightenment, he imagines how easy it is to let a book supply one’s understanding, a pastor one’s conscience, and a physician one’s judgment about diet. He asks what it would take to start using one’s understanding without someone else’s direction. That’s a question Charmides’s promise makes hard to avoid. When Critias says that staying with Socrates would prove him temperate, Charmides promises to obey Critias as his guardian. By the end, one man has been asked to say when the charm is enough, and the other is giving orders.
Xenophon gives us two later glimpses of the young man. In the Memorabilia, Socrates thinks Charmides could take part in public life and tries to persuade him to speak in the Assembly. Charmides says there’s a difference between a private conversation and speaking before a crowd. In the Hellenica, Xenophon records Charmides as one of the Ten who governed Piraeus and reports that he and Critias were killed in the same battle. These episodes put the question of whose judgment Charmides follows in a more serious setting. They leave plenty about his education and his choices for us to wonder about.
A music student may need a teacher to hear that a passage is uneven and to say when it’s ready for a performance. Part of the value of working with the teacher is learning to hear the trouble yourself. You still need help for a while, and that help can teach you to notice things you couldn’t notice before. Something like that could happen in the conversations Charmides is asking for. His readiness to come back gives Socrates more chances to ask him what he sees, and gives Charmides more chances to work out an answer of his own.
Charmides has already done one difficult thing. He’s admitted that he can’t tell whether the praise he’s received is deserved, and he wants to go on looking. It’s easy to hear the charm as the work of those further conversations. It’s harder to know what he’ll make of them. The day that would tell us most about his progress is the day he can say what he sees in himself, whether Socrates thinks he’s had enough yet or still has a great deal to learn.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
What central tension does the article find in Charmides’s offer to be charmed every day until Socrates says it is enough?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- When does trusting a teacher support the development of independent judgment, and when might it prevent that development?→
- Does Charmides’s willingness to continue despite remaining unconvinced show temperance, dependence, intellectual courage, or some combination of these? Why?→
- If neither Charmides nor his elders can define temperance, what evidence could Charmides reasonably use to decide whether he possesses it?→