Philosophy

Does Desire Get in the Way?

Socrates’ attraction helps him pay attention to Charmides. It may also make him too ready to praise the boy’s character.

Attraction throws Socrates off balance and helps draw him into conversation with Charmides. The harder question is whether his admiration ever stops shaping how he treats the boy, and the last page suggests that it doesn’t.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • Attraction cuts both waysSocrates loses his confidence on the bench. When Charmides agrees with him about medicine, he feels his boldness return.
  • A patient examinationSocrates offers to investigate temperance with Charmides and takes his first answers seriously. The essay asks what admiration contributes to that patience.
  • A difference in toneSocrates makes allowance for Charmides’ age and expects Critias to know more. Both fairness and fondness could help explain the difference.
  • Charmides leaves it openSocrates calls Charmides most temperate in soul near the end. Charmides says he does not know whether he has temperance and asks to continue with the charm.

There are two easy pictures of desire in the Charmides, and both have the text on their side. In the first, attraction is an obstacle, the thing that scatters Socrates on the bench. His confidence has already gone when a glimpse inside the cloak leaves him beside himself. In the second, attraction is a bridge, the energy that draws Socrates toward the boy, makes him want to talk, and comes back as confidence when the conversation catches, since he says that when Charmides agreed with him he “was rekindled.” The real question is less about Socrates’ feelings than about the boy, and whether admiration ever stops shaping the way the person being examined gets treated.

The case for a happy redirection is strong, and it’s worth stating at full strength. Once the conversation starts, Socrates’ interest in Charmides becomes careful and patient, the interest of a good teacher in a student he likes, and he proposes to look into the question of the boy’s temperance together, “so that you won’t be forced to say what you don’t want to.” Charmides hesitates before answering, and Socrates takes his answers seriously and works through them patiently, so you could argue that desire has been turned into something like attentive care, the kind of interest in a person that makes you want to know what’s really going on inside him. There’s real warmth in that patience, the warmth of someone who wants the other person to do well, and it’s hard to imagine it without the attraction that started it.

The case for distortion starts with a difference in tone. When Charmides offers a borrowed definition and starts fumbling it, Socrates teases him, calls him a rascal, and turns his fire on whoever wrote the line, and when Critias jumps in, Socrates tells him, “it is no wonder that he doesn’t know, at his age. You, though, may reasonably be expected to know.” That’s a fair principle, since a young person still learning may need more room to make mistakes, but it also means the beautiful boy gets the gentle handling while his guardian gets the full examination, and it’s hard to be sure how much of the gentleness is fairness and how much is fondness. The rule is sound in itself, and it may also be exactly the rule a fond teacher would find easiest to apply.

The stronger evidence for distortion comes near the end of the dialogue. After an inquiry that has failed to say what temperance is, Socrates tells Charmides he is grieved for him, “being such as you are in your looks and, besides, most temperate in soul,” if the virtue should turn out to do him no good, and you have to ask on what evidence he calls the boy most temperate in soul. The inquiry has just failed to say what temperance is. The compliment may rest on impressions like the blush, the modesty, the good family and the face. That looks a lot like admiration quietly doing the judging.

There’s a counterweight, though, and it’s built into the same speech. The compliment sits inside a conditional, and Socrates immediately hands the question back, telling the boy to see whether he has temperance and needs no charm, and Charmides leaves the question open, answering, “I don’t know whether I have it or whether I don’t.” He asks to keep receiving the charm, and Critias takes that willingness as proof of temperance. Charmides himself stops short of a verdict.

Modern readers are right to feel uneasy about an older man’s attraction to a teenager shaping a conversation, and Plato doesn’t hide that it does. The frankness of the dialogue is what lets us see where admiration might tilt things, in the gentler tone and the generous closing compliment, and that visibility is part of the dialogue’s honesty rather than a defense of the arrangement. A version of this story in which Socrates felt nothing and judged with perfect neutrality would be less believable and, oddly, less useful, since it would hide the very pressure a reader needs to learn to notice. Plato lets us watch the pressure at work instead of pretending it isn’t there, which is the only way a reader can learn to correct for it.

So what can hold the distortion in check? The structure of the conversation helps. The boy answers questions in his own words, and everyone can hear whether the argument holds up. Socrates can still make a flattering judgment, and Charmides has room to say that he doesn’t know.

My verdict is that attraction in the Charmides is both engine and obstacle, and it never fully stops being either. It helps bring the two of them together and gives Socrates a reason to be kind. It may also tilt his judgment in the boy’s favor, most visibly near the end. The dialogue’s answer to the problem isn’t to pretend desire away but to rely on a kind of conversation that can survive it, one in which the boy can keep the question open, and that’s a more honest solution than pretending philosophers are above the feelings everyone else has.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

Why does the author treat Socrates’ closing praise of Charmides as especially strong evidence that attraction may distort judgment?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.