Philosophy

Doctors of the Whole

A Thracian doctor treats the soul with beautiful words. In the Phaedrus, Socrates asks what a speaker would need to know to use words as deliberately as a doctor uses medicine.

A remedy for a headache and a theory of persuasion share a medical model. The comparison raises a question about what a speaker must know before trying to change a listener.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • From the head to the soulThe Thracian doctor tells Socrates to treat the soul first, even when the patient comes for a headache.
  • Words as treatmentThe doctor says that beautiful words can cultivate temperance. Socrates’ conversation with Charmides puts that promise into practice.
  • A speaker’s trainingThe Phaedrus asks a speaker to distinguish types of souls and speeches and to recognize which listener is actually present.
  • What the whole includesThe Charmides connects body and soul in a single person. The Phaedrus asks about the nature of the whole and leaves the scope of the phrase open.

The Charmides builds its whole opening on medicine, since Socrates claims to have a cure for the boy’s headache, a leaf with a charm, and explains the doctrine he learned from a Thracian doctor. Just as you must not cure the eyes without the head, or the head without the body, “so one must not try to cure the body without the soul either,” and the Greek doctors fail with most diseases because “they neglect the whole, which is what they ought to be caring for.” The soul is treated “with certain charms, and these charms are beautiful words,” and from such words temperance comes to be in the soul.

The Phaedrus reaches for the same model in a very different setting. Socrates and Phaedrus are discussing what a real art of speaking would require, and Socrates says rhetoric is like medicine, since medicine must understand the nature of the body to give it health and strength by drugs and diet, while rhetoric must understand the nature of the soul to give it conviction and virtue by words and practices. He then asks whether anyone can understand the nature of the soul without understanding the nature of the whole, and Phaedrus answers that if Hippocrates is to be trusted, you can’t even understand the body without that method. The comparison asks a lover of speeches to think like a doctor about what his words can do.

The shared idea is that treatment requires understanding the thing treated as a whole rather than as a collection of parts. A doctor who sees only an aching head will miss the cause in the body, and a doctor who sees only the body will miss the cause in the soul. A speaker who sees only an audience to be moved will miss what kind of soul he is addressing and what his words will do to it. In both dialogues, the medical model turns attention away from the symptom and toward the nature of what is being treated, which is exactly the shift Socrates makes with Charmides when he puts the boy’s soul ahead of his headache.

Both passages also make words the instrument of treatment for the soul. In the Charmides the charm is “beautiful words,” and the dialogue hints that the charm is the conversation about to begin. In the Phaedrus, the true rhetorician must know the kinds of soul and the kinds of speech, and which speeches will persuade which souls and why, so that he can choose his words as a doctor chooses his drugs. In each case the model treats speech as something that acts on a soul the way medicine acts on a body, for good or for harm.

The Charmides offers a healing tale, a story told to a teenager with a headache, framed by an exotic doctor from Thrace and a god-king named Zalmoxis, and it never explains how the charm works. The Phaedrus offers an account of an art, a methodical program in which the speaker must classify souls, classify speeches, and learn in practice to recognize which kind of person stands in front of him. The story lets us watch a proposed treatment begin. The account of rhetoric asks what would make someone capable of choosing that treatment well.

They also aim at different results, since the Thracian charm aims at a single virtue, temperance, and promises that once it is present, health will follow easily. The Phaedrus rhetorician aims, in the first place, at persuasion, and the dialogue has to work hard to show that a true art of speaking would aim at the listener’s good rather than merely at moving him. The Charmides takes the goodness of its charm for granted, while the Phaedrus knows that an art of moving souls could be used to mislead them, which is why it insists the speaker must know the truth.

What does the whole include? The Thracian doctor names the whole human being and makes the health of the body depend on the soul. In the Phaedrus, Socrates asks whether the nature of the soul can be understood apart from the nature of the whole. The phrase could point to the whole person or to a wider order in nature. The Charmides offers a clear example of the whole being the person in front of you. It leaves the other dialogue’s question open.

The shared medical model changes the questions both dialogues ask of a speaker. When Socrates offers Charmides beautiful words, we can ask what those words do to this boy in this room. The Phaedrus makes that question a demand on the speaker’s training. Knowing how to move a listener takes judgment about the listener, and the power to move someone still leaves the question of what to do with that power.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

What central shift does the medical model produce in both dialogues?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.