Philosophy
Certified Temperate
At the end, Charmides asks for help with the virtue his guardian was sure he already had.
The Platonic Dialogues: CharmidesCritias declares his ward exceptionally temperate before Socrates asks Charmides about the virtue. That kind of advance praise makes learning harder, and the dialogue shows what it costs both the boy and the man who gives it.
Orientation
At a Glance
- A public verdictCritias calls Charmides exceptionally temperate before Socrates asks the young man to judge for himself.
- The cost of praiseCharmides worries that saying yes would sound boastful and saying no would make his guardian look like a liar.
- A shared questionSocrates invites Charmides to examine the matter with him and later says there is little surprise in a young person being unsure.
- An honest answerCharmides ends by admitting he cannot say whether he has temperance and asking to continue the treatment.
Critias hands out the certificate before the exam has started. After hearing what the charm is for, Critias tells him that Charmides “is thought to surpass those his age not only in his looks, but in the very thing you say you have the charm for,” adding that he’s thought “far and away the most temperate of anyone nowadays, and in every other respect, as far as his years allow, second to none.” It’s a glowing report card, issued in public before this test has begun. It’s the guardian’s version of announcing that your kid is going to ace a test he hasn’t studied for.
That kind of advance verdict creates a very particular problem for anyone trying to learn. An ordinary student who doesn’t know something just has a gap in his education, which is normal and fixable, but a student who has been publicly certified as excellent can’t admit a gap without contradicting the certificate. In one 1998 experiment, fifth graders praised for being smart more often chose problems on which they could do well again, while those praised for effort more often chose problems they could learn from. It’s easy to see the resemblance. A label like Critias’ gives the boy a reputation to defend just when he’s being asked to learn something.
Charmides feels the weight of the certificate at once, the moment Socrates asks whether he already has temperance. Charmides says that claiming it would sound like boasting and denying it would make Critias and the others who praised him look like liars. The certificate has turned a simple question into a social crisis, and the most natural answer in the world, “I’m not sure,” suddenly feels awkward.
Socrates handles this with real care, and it’s worth noticing how. He makes his praise of the boy conditional, saying “if, as Critias here says,” and invites Charmides to look into the question with him. Later, when the boy’s borrowed definition falls apart and Critias jumps in, Socrates lowers the stakes on purpose, telling Critias that “it is no wonder that he doesn’t know, at his age,” which is a way of telling the boy that not knowing is normal and that the certificate was never fair to him. A good teacher gives a struggling student permission not to know yet, and that sentence is Socrates giving it.
The clearest warning about what advance praise does, though, sits right next to the boy on the bench. When the argument corners Critias, Socrates tells us that Critias is used to being admired on every occasion. Now he’s ashamed in front of the company and keeps covering up his perplexity. That’s what a certified pupil can grow into, an adult so used to being admired that he can’t bring himself to say three of the most useful words in philosophy, “I don’t know.” The praise Critias heaps on his ward might put him in the same bind.
The boy, to his great credit, escapes that trap by the end. After the whole inquiry has failed to define temperance, he says, “But by Zeus, Socrates, I don’t know whether I have it or whether I don’t,” and adds that he isn’t altogether persuaded by Socrates and thinks he “very much” needs the charm. The young man Critias called the most temperate hands the certificate back and admits a need, which is about the bravest thing a learner can do, and arguably the most temperate thing anyone does in the whole dialogue. It costs him the certificate, and it gains him an education.
And then, almost comically, Critias turns around and certifies him all over again. “Charmides, if you do this, it will be proof to me that you are temperate,” he says, meaning if the boy sticks with Socrates, so even the boy’s admission that he can’t tell whether he has the virtue gets turned straight back into evidence that he has it. Critias simply can’t stop issuing report cards, and the dialogue lets us watch the habit in action one last time, as a guardian who is used to admiration looks for a fresh reason to praise his ward. The habit runs so deep that he doesn’t seem to notice he’s doing it.
My verdict is that the certificate is one of the quiet villains of the Charmides. It turns an honest gap into a public threat and nearly locks the boy into protecting a reputation instead of improving himself. In Critias we can see what happens when keeping that reputation matters more than getting an answer. The boy’s willingness at the end to say he doesn’t know and needs help is the dialogue’s small victory over the certificate, even if his guardian, true to form, immediately tries to grade it, as if a gold star could improve on honesty.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
According to the article, why does Critias’s advance praise make Socrates’ question difficult for Charmides to answer honestly?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- When does praise encourage learning, and when might it create a reputation that a learner feels compelled to defend?→
- How does Socrates’ response to Charmides model a productive way of treating uncertainty or failure?→
- Is Charmides’ willingness to admit that he does not know itself evidence of temperance, or does interpreting it that way merely repeat Critias’s habit of issuing certificates?→