Poetry, language and letters

Vagueness of subject

suppression or vagueness of mere subject; vagueness

Pater uses the phrase in his account of the lyric.

From the book

The Renaissance

Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026

Browse this book’s lexicon →

Meaning

Attested: suppression or vagueness of mere subject (GIO §7); vagueness (WIN §27). Pater uses the phrase in his account of the lyric. The very perfection of such poetry "often appears to depend, in part, on a certain suppression or vagueness of mere subject, so that the meaning reaches us through ways not distinctly traceable by the understanding" (GIO §7; see Lyrical poetry). The qualifications are many, "often", "appears", "in part", "a certain", and they keep the claim from becoming a rule that vague poems are good. What is suppressed is "mere subject", the part of a poem that could be stated; the form can be read as staying exact. The examples are some of Blake's most imaginative compositions and, often, Shakespeare's songs, above all the song of Mariana's page (GIO §7). The Winckelmann essay uses the noun for a vagueness of another kind. In the East, "from a vagueness, a want of definition, in thought, the matter presented to art is unmanageable, and the forms of sense struggle vainly with it" (WIN §27; see Inwardness). The two uses can be read as marking where vagueness helps and where it harms. In the lyric the subject is vague and the form exact, so the meaning passes through the form; in Eastern art the thought itself is vague, and no form can master it.