Argument and disputation

Trumpets of Truth

VERITATIS TVBAE; TVBAE VERITATIS duæ; Experientia; CONSENSVS Physico-Chymicorum, orthodoxè Philosophantium

The trumpets announce evidence against the denial that the Philosophers' Stone has existed or can be attained.

From the book

Heinrich Khunrath’s Magnesia Catholica Philosophorum

Heinrich Khunrath · Diotimos Editions · 2026

Browse this book’s lexicon →

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The wordThe trumpets announce evidence against the denial that the Philosophers' Stone has existed or can be attained.
  • In KhunrathPage 25 announces two trumpets, and its margin numbers experience as the first.
  • In this editionTubae Veritatis and Veritatis Tubae are reversible Latin arrangements retained by the source.
  • A reading distinctionPage 31 gives the Greek existence-formula in Khunrath's own margin; the modern note's discussion of an Aristotelian distinction is commentary on that formula, not an additional sentence of the treatise.

Meaning

The trumpets announce evidence against the denial that the Philosophers' Stone has existed or can be attained. The figure gives the opening defence an audible, public force: evidence calls the doubter to attention. It is Khunrath's designation for an ordered argument, not the title of another alchemical work.

Use in the book

Page 25 announces two trumpets, and its margin numbers experience as the first. Page 27 supplies the second: the consensus of rightly philosophizing physico-chymists, manifest in their surviving writings. After developing that pair, page 30 adds a third, the analogical harmony of the Stone with the incarnate Word, and conversely. The reader should retain the movement from an announced pair to an added third instead of silently regularizing it into an opening list of three.

The three grounds are not interchangeable. Experience asserts that powerful effects have been seen; consensus appeals to agreement about the matter, preparation, manifestations, and uses; the harmony gives those natural claims a scriptural and theological intelligibility. None is, at this early point, a disclosure of the matter's ordinary name. The margin on page 31 promises fuller proof of the ὅτι ἐστί, glossed as that there is a Philosophers' Stone, in a projected book. This is the question the trumpet section answers. Recognition of which thing is the proper subject receives a different, more discriminating treatment in the candidate test and in the extended description of the matter.

The later treatise also limits what the initial rhetoric might seem to license. A transmuter's visible success does not prove that he can prepare the Stone; a famous author's name does not excuse a Nature-violating interpretation. The trumpets therefore open a case, rather than abolish the need for further judgement. Their arrangement introduces the sources of conviction that the book spends its remaining pages sorting, qualifying, and combining.

Places to read

  1. 1599 p. 25Two Trumpets of Truth are announced against denial or doubt concerning the Stone's existence and attainability.
  2. 1599 p. 25 · margin23The marginal label explicitly says two trumpets and numbers experience as the first.
  3. 1599 p. 27 · marginConsensus of rightly philosophizing physico-chymists is numbered as the second.
  4. 1599 p. 30A third ground is added: the analogical harmony with Christ, and conversely.
  5. 1599 p. 31 · margin2A projected work will offer fuller proof that the Stone exists.

Translation in this edition

Tubae Veritatis and Veritatis Tubae are reversible Latin arrangements retained by the source. The English phrase must not be confused with Clangor Buccinae, a work cited on page 84, or with the Turba Veritatis named on page 10. The similar sounds belong to different textual objects.

Source note

Page 31 gives the Greek existence-formula in Khunrath's own margin; the modern note's discussion of an Aristotelian distinction is commentary on that formula, not an additional sentence of the treatise.