Beauty, pleasure and the senses

Physical life

physical life

The life of the body seen as the science of the day saw it: a passing combination of elements, which the Conclusion takes as its starting-point

From the book

The Renaissance

Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026

Browse this book’s lexicon →

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The wordThe life of the body, considered as matter in motion under the laws of physics and chemistry.
  • In The Renaissance"Let us begin with that which is without—our physical life" (CON §2).
  • In this editionThe note at CON §2 says that Pater "begins with a bodily sensation of relief in water", which "first supplies an example for scientific analysis and then furnishes a metaphor for the movement of consciousness".
  • A place to readCON §2.

Meaning

Physical is from the Greek physis, nature, the growing and becoming of things, and in Greek philosophy ta physika were the works on nature as against those on ethics or logic. In English the word came to mean bodily, as against mental or spiritual, and in the nineteenth century it took on the sense of the sciences that treat matter and force. "Physical life" in Pater's decade meant the life of the body as the physiologists described it: a set of chemical and mechanical processes, continuous with those of the world outside.

Pater's sentences of 1868 have a close neighbour in the English biologist Thomas Henry Huxley's lecture "On the Physical Basis of Life", given in Edinburgh on 8 November 1868, a month after Pater's review of William Morris appeared, and printed in the Fortnightly Review in February 1869.1 The two are independent, but they share a vocabulary and a claim: that the body is made of the same matter as the world, and that life is a process of that matter. Huxley drew from it the case for a scientific materialism held as a method; Pater drew from it an ethic of the passing moment.

Use in the book

The phrase comes three times, all in the second paragraph of the Conclusion, and it is the first step of the argument. Pater announces his method: modern thought tends to regard all things "as inconstant modes or fashions" (CON §2; see Inconstant modes or fashions), and he will test that tendency first on what seems most solid. "Let us begin with that which is without—our physical life." The body is "without", outside the mind, and the paragraph will show that even what is without does not hold still.

The example is chosen with care. Pater asks us to fix upon it "in one of its more exquisite intervals", and his instance is the moment "of delicious recoil from the flood of water in summer heat" (CON §2; see Recoil). Pater does not begin with the body at rest but with the body at a moment of pleasure, and the pleasure is a sensation of change, heat answered by cold. Then the question, what the whole physical life is in that moment "but a combination of natural elements" (CON §2; see Natural elements). The pleasure is resolved into chemistry. The same elements are found far from the body, and our physical life "is a perpetual motion of them" (CON §2; see Perpetual motion), the passage of the blood, the waste and repair of the eye, the changes of the brain under light and sound (see Elementary forces). By the end of the paragraph the outline of face and limb is "but an image of ours", a design in a web whose threads pass out beyond it (CON §2; see Web), and life itself is flame-like, a "concurrence" of forces (CON §2; see Flame-like).

The order matters. The Conclusion can be read as beginning with the physical because the physical is the strongest case for permanence, and if the body is a perpetual motion then the mind, which the third paragraph treats, must be more so: "the whirlpool is still more rapid, the flame more eager and devouring" (CON §3; see Whirlpool). Pater's physiology is the ground of his psychology, and the first word of the argument is the word that the science of 1868 made its own.

The rest of the book uses "physical" for the body's share in feeling, and those uses prepare the Conclusion's. Winckelmann's enthusiasm, "dependent as it is to a great degree on bodily temperament", reinforces the purer emotions of the intellect "with an almost physical excitement" (WIN §14; see Intellectual excitement); his friendships contain of passion and physical excitement only so much as sharpens the eye (WIN §19; see Beauty of living form); and the Hellenic ideal is one in which man is at unity "with his physical nature" (WIN §44; see Unity with one's self). The Winckelmann essay praised the Greek because the body and the mind were one in him. The Conclusion keeps the unity and changes its sign: the mind is as unstable as the body, because both are made of the same moving elements.

Places to read

Every paragraph in which "physical life" occurs, with the paragraphs on physical excitement and the physical nature of the Greek, in the order of the book.

  1. WIN §14Winckelmann's enthusiasm, dependent on bodily temperament, reinforces the purer emotions of the intellect with an almost physical excitement.
  2. WIN §19Of passion, of physical excitement, his friendships contain only so much as stimulates the eye.
  3. WIN §44In the Hellenic ideal man is at unity with himself, with his physical nature, with the outward world.
  4. CON §2Let us begin with that which is without, our physical life, a perpetual motion of natural elements.
  5. C73 §2In 1873 the paragraph is the same in substance.

Source note

1. Thomas Henry Huxley, "On the Physical Basis of Life", Fortnightly Review, n.s. 5 (February 1869); in Lay Sermons, Addresses, and Reviews (London, 1870), with the note that it was delivered in Edinburgh on 8 November 1868.