Time, flux and the moment

Inconstant modes or fashions

inconstant modes or fashions

Ways of being that do not stay: the first sentence of the Conclusion, and its name for the tendency of modern thought

From the book

The Renaissance

Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026

Browse this book’s lexicon →

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The wordA mode is a manner of being; a fashion is the shape a thing takes for a time; to call both inconstant is to say that nothing has a fixed form.
  • In The Renaissance"To regard all things and principles of things as inconstant modes or fashions has more and more become the tendency of modern thought" (CON §2).
  • In this editionThe note at the phrase gives the essay's history, omitted in 1877 and restored with revisions in 1888; the Key Word "Flux" says that the Conclusion asks what happens "when we regard bodies, objects, and states of mind as patterns undergoing continual change".
  • A place to readCON §2.

Meaning

Modus is measure and manner, and in the philosophers a mode was a way of being that belongs to a substance and can change while the substance stays: for the Dutch philosopher Baruch Spinoza, finite things are modes of the one substance. Fashion is the French façon, from factio, a making: the shape a thing is made in, and then the shape that is current for a season. "Inconstant" denies both their usual partner. The modes have no substance under them that stays, and the fashions no shape that lasts.

Use in the book

The sentence opens the Conclusion after its Greek epigraph, and translates the epigraph into the language of modern philosophy. "To regard all things and principles of things as inconstant modes or fashions has more and more become the tendency of modern thought" (CON §2). It is a sentence about a tendency, not a declaration of belief. Pater describes the drift of thought in his century and then tests it, first on the body ("Let us begin with that which is without—our physical life", CON §2; see Physical life), then on the mind. The words "all things and principles of things" make the claim as wide as it can be: not only objects but the principles by which we know them are to be regarded as passing.

The sentence had been written before. Pater's first published essay, on Coleridge (1866), had set the modern against the ancient spirit: "Modern thought is distinguished from ancient by its cultivation of the 'relative' spirit in place of the 'absolute.'" Ancient philosophy sought to arrest every object in an eternal outline and types of life in a classification by kinds; to the modern spirit "nothing is or can be rightly known except relatively under conditions".1 The Conclusion's first sentence is the same claim in a more unsettling image. A mode or a fashion is relative to the time that holds it, and the Preface had said that beauty itself, "like all other qualities presented to human experience, is relative" (PRE §1; see Relative).

"Fashion" in the rest of the book is a word for what is valuable in passing things. The Giorgione essay finds "what is valuable and justly attractive, in what is called the fashion of a time", which makes the trivialities of speech, manner and dress "ends in themselves" (GIO §8; see Fashion; End in itself). The Winckelmann essay sees classicism become "from time to time an intellectual fashion" (WIN §22), and warns against the superficial view by which the Renaissance "is represented as a fashion which set in at a definite period" (WIN §47; see Renaissance). In the Conclusion the word is turned on everything. If all things are fashions, the critic's task is the Giorgione essay's, to find what is valuable in each while it lasts.

The sentence can be read as the book's last account of history. The essays have studied the Renaissance as a mode of the human spirit that appears and disappears, now in twelfth-century France, now in fifteenth-century Florence, now in eighteenth-century Germany (see Renaissance). The Conclusion says that this is how all things are: not substances with histories but histories without substances.

Places to read

The paragraph in which "inconstant modes or fashions" occurs, with its 1873 text and three paragraphs in which "fashion" names the shape of a time, in the order of the book.

  1. GIO §8What is valuable in the fashion of a time elevates the trivialities of speech, manner and dress into ends in themselves.
  2. WIN §22Classicism has become from time to time an intellectual fashion.
  3. WIN §47The superficial view represents the Renaissance as a fashion which set in at a definite period.
  4. CON §2To regard all things and principles of things as inconstant modes or fashions has become the tendency of modern thought.
  5. C73 §2In 1873 the sentence is the same.

Source note

1. Walter Pater, "Coleridge's Writings", Westminster Review, n.s. 29 (January 1866); revised as "Coleridge" in Appreciations (London, 1889).