Images from nature and science

Chemist

chemist; alchemist

The critic as analyst of a compound

From the book

The Renaissance

Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026

Browse this book’s lexicon →

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The wordA chemist studies the composition of substances, separating compounds into their elements and identifying them.
  • In The RenaissanceThe critic notes the virtue he has disengaged "as a chemist notes some natural element" (PRE §3), and the image governs the language of the paragraph on Wordsworth: elements, combination, débris, heat, fusing, crystallising, transmuting (PRE §5). The Leonardo essay gives its ancestor, the alchemist (LEO §13).
  • In this editionThe note at PRE §3 says the chemist's image "makes criticism sound like a disciplined inquiry into what produces an effect".
  • A place to readPRE §§3 and 5.

Meaning

The word is a shortening of "alchemist" (French chimiste, Medieval Latin chimista from alchimista), whose root is the Arabic al-kīmiyā, and the two were not fully parted until the eighteenth century.1 By Pater's time chemistry was the model of an exact science of analysis: the chemist reduced a substance to its elements, isolated them, and named them, and the number of known elements was still growing.

Use in the book

The simile closes the Preface's account of the critic's function. He must "distinguish, … analyse, and separate from its adjuncts, the virtue" by which a work produces its impression, and "His end is reached when he has disengaged that virtue, and noted it, as a chemist notes some natural element, for himself and others" (PRE §3; see Disengage; Virtue). The comparison claims three things for criticism. Its object is a real property, as an element is real; its method is analysis, the separation of that property from what it is mixed with; and its result can be shown to others.

The fifth paragraph carries the image on. The virtue is found "in combination" with "commoner elements", and it takes "great nicety to disengage" it (PRE §5; see Element). Few artists work "quite cleanly", leaving only what their imagination has "wholly fused and transformed" (PRE §5; see Débris; Fuse). In Wordsworth the heat of genius has "crystallised a part, but only a part," of the work, and his faculty sometimes deposits "a fine crystal here or there, in a matter it does not wholly search through and transmute" (PRE §5; see Crystallise; Transmute). Then comes the term that ends the paragraph, "the active principle", from the chemistry of drugs (PRE §5; see Active principle). The artist's imagination works like heat on matter, and the critic's like analysis on the result.

The chemist has a predecessor in the book. Leonardo, over his crucibles, pursued "a strange variation of the alchemist's dream", seeking immortality not for the body but for the subtlest effects of painting (LEO §13; see Alchemy). The alchemist sought to transmute; the chemist only notes. The Conclusion returns to the science of elements with "phosphorus and lime and delicate fibres" (CON §2; see Natural elements), and there analysis no longer finds a virtue to keep but dissolves the self it studies (CON §3). The Preface's chemist can be read as the confident form of a method whose limits the Conclusion explores.

Places to read

Every paragraph in which "chemist" or "alchemist" occurs, and the paragraph in which the image is carried on, in the order of the book.

  1. PRE §3The critic notes the virtue he has disengaged, as a chemist notes a natural element, for himself and others.
  2. PRE §5The virtue is found in combination with commoner elements; the heat of genius fuses, crystallises and transmutes; the critic disengages the active principle.
  3. LEO §13Leonardo over his crucibles pursues a variation of the alchemist's dream, immortality for the subtlest effects of painting.

In this edition

The note at PRE §3 observes that "Pater's next image, the chemist isolating an element, makes criticism sound like a disciplined inquiry into what produces an effect", and the note at PRE §5 on "débris" says that the image "extends the Preface's comparison of criticism to chemistry".

Source note

1. William R. Newman and Lawrence M. Principe, "Alchemy vs. Chemistry: The Etymological Origins of a Historiographic Mistake", Early Science and Medicine 3 (1998), 32–65.