From the book
The Renaissance
Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026
Browse this book’s lexicon →Orientation
At a Glance
- The wordCorrect belief in matters of taste: a fixed standard of beauty held as a church holds its creed.
- In The RenaissanceRaphael's Parnassus commemorates "the classical tradition, the orthodoxy of taste" (WIN §22).
- In this editionThe note at WIN §22 says that Pater sees the Vatican room "as giving visual form to the transmission of two traditions".
- A place to readWIN §23.
Meaning
Orthodoxy is from the Greek orthos, right, and doxa, opinion: right belief, as the Church defines it against heresy. "Taste", the faculty of judging beauty, was in the eighteenth century the great subject of criticism, and the question of a "standard of taste" was much debated, whether beauty had a rule common to all or varied with each person.1 Pater does not mention the debate, but his phrase answers its question by joining the two vocabularies. Taste has a standard, and the standard is an orthodoxy: it was defined once, at a particular time, and handed down.
Use in the book
The phrase stands in the twenty-second paragraph, where Raphael's two frescoes in the same Vatican room set the Church's tradition beside the poets'. "In this fresco it is the classical tradition, the orthodoxy of taste, that Raphael commemorates" (WIN §22; see Castalia). The religious word is chosen to match the other fresco: the Disputation shows the Church's orthodoxy round the Sacrament, the Parnassus the orthodoxy of art round Apollo (see Beatific vision; Classical tradition).
The twenty-third paragraph explains how there can be an orthodoxy of art at all. "Again, individual genius works ever under conditions of time and place: its products are coloured by the varying aspects of nature, and type of human form, and outward manners of life. There is thus an element of change in art; criticism must never for a moment forget that 'the artist is the child of his time.' But besides these conditions of time and place, and independent of them, there is also an element of permanence, a standard of taste, which genius confesses" (WIN §23). The verb "confesses" keeps the religious figure: genius acknowledges the standard as a believer confesses a creed. The standard is kept in "a purely intellectual tradition" passed from work to work (WIN §23; see Conscious tradition). And it has a birthplace. "The standard of taste, then, was fixed in Greece, at a definite historical period. A tradition for all succeeding generations, it originates in a spontaneous growth out of the influences of Greek society" (WIN §23). The paragraph ends by asking what conditions generated "this ideal, this standard of artistic orthodoxy" (WIN §23; see Conscious tradition), and the essay's next twenty paragraphs answer, through Greek religion, the body and sculpture.
The phrase is bolder than it looks in a book so suspicious of orthodoxies. The Conclusion warns against "acquiescing in a facile orthodoxy, of Comte, or of Hegel, or of our own" (CON §5; see Orthodoxy), and the Michelangelo essay has the Roman Church fixing itself "in a frozen orthodoxy" (MIC §16; see Frozen orthodoxy). Pater keeps his one orthodoxy for taste, and the essay can be read as explaining why that one is different: it is not imposed by authority but "confessed" by genius, and it rests on a spontaneous growth, not on a decree. The two halves of the twenty-third paragraph are held together without being reconciled. The artist is the child of his time; the standard is outside time. Pater's criticism lives between them, attending to the "element of change" in each work and measuring it against the element of permanence.
Places to read
The paragraphs in which Pater names the orthodoxy or standard of taste, in the order of the book.
Source note
1. David Hume, "Of the Standard of Taste", in Four Dissertations (London, 1757).