Supernatural explanations and disputed connections

Demonic apparitions

Demonic apparitions

“An apparition” is something that appears, especially a perceived spirit or ghost.

From the book

The Anatomy of Melancholy

Robert Burton · Diotimos Editions · 2026

Browse this book’s lexicon →

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The word“An apparition” is something that appears, especially a perceived spirit or ghost.
  • In the Anatomy of MelancholyThe spirit survey describes extraordinary appearances as part of a larger attributed capacity to deceive all the senses.
  • In this edition“Spectrums” becomes “apparitions” in the spirit survey; the death-omen “spectrum” becomes “an apparition”; the spectrum in the terror catalogue becomes “ghost.”
  • A place to readalleged appearances and sensory deception, with witnesses’ claims distinguished from verification

Meaning

“An apparition” is something that appears, especially a perceived spirit or ghost. Burton’s singular “spectrum,” plural “spectrums,” and the Latin plural “spectra” belong to this vocabulary. “Ambulones” means wanderers; Burton applies it to spirits said to walk at midnight, lead travellers astray or block their path. His “Pucks” are a kind of mischievous spirit with different local names. “Raise and lay” describes opposed actions: summon spirits and quiet or dismiss them. These are lexical meanings within reports, not proofs that the alleged beings exist.

“Apparitions” can also denote images conceived by the mind. When sick people imagine themselves kings, animals or dead, the word reaches beyond an externally appearing ghost. The heading gathers supernatural explanations and their disputed alternatives; it does not determine the explanation of every appearance.

Use in the book

The spirit survey describes extraordinary appearances as part of a larger attributed capacity to deceive all the senses. Spirits allegedly show castles, palaces, armies, apparitions and portents, as well as causing tastes and smells. The grammatical qualification, “most Writers of this subject credibly believe,” governs the preceding catalogue. The subsequent discussion distinguishes deception of eyes from real bodily transformation. Burton can accept an effective appearance while rejecting the alleged transformation of the thing seen. That distinction is essential to the sense of spectrum here.

The name can extend to a visible phenomenon among the spirit reports. Radziwiłł’s “apparition,” called “Sancti Germani sydus,” Saint Germanus’ star, is placed with Saint Elmo’s fires and lights on ships’ masts. The surrounding accounts disagree about what the lights are and whether they portend harm or good. The supplied note explains Saint Elmo’s fire as an electrical discharge; that modern explanation belongs to the edition and is not Burton’s definition of every apparition.

Other appearances function as omens or impersonations. A spectrum dressed as Arion plays music before a governor’s death; neighbouring accounts tell of spirits counterfeiting dead people and of birds foretelling death. The bird reports receive competing explanations: forewarning by familiar spirits, an animal’s response to the smell of dying people, or divinely permitted demonic intimidation. The appearance itself does not settle the causal account. In the ensuing necromancy passage, “take upon them” marks a claimed ability to raise and lay spirits, and the continuation extends that claim to the midnight wanderers.

The puck then leaves the survey and becomes a simile for habitual reverie. In solitude, beguiling thoughts creep in, detain the thinker and obstruct necessary work. The person is carried round like someone led over a heath by a puck at night. Burton says “they say”: the familiar story explains the experience of being led without arriving. The continuation develops a labyrinth of anxious meditation, initially pleasurable and later painful. A literal spirit is not asserted to be guiding each melancholic thinker.

Fear and imagination provide a further explanatory layer. Lavater is said to make fear the greatest cause of spectrums, and Weyer to give fear exceptional power over imagination. Burton’s later discussion says that people imagine what they fear and think they see goblins and devils. A marginal Latin formulation says brave people seldom see apparitions because they fear less: seldom is not never. Yet the same discussion also allows fear to invite demonic agency. Natural and supernatural explanations remain combined, rather than forming a simple progression in which the second has disappeared.

Elsewhere Burton gives an explicit natural explanation for particular distressing experiences. At the opening of his explanation of symptoms, he aims to reassure melancholic people that these proceed from natural inward causes rather than the devils, witchcraft or divine abandonment they fear. The next passage describes terrible “apparitions” through Galen’s darkened spirits and humoral fumes, before competing physicians dispute that mechanism. Later the printed “apparations” occur in accounts of disturbed imagination, organs, spirits and humours producing seemingly external images. The perceived location before the eyes is distinguished from the proposed inward cause.

In the section on terror, a sudden spectrum stands beside imitation devils used as jokes. Both can frighten, irrespective of the object’s supposed reality. The continuation recounts a child seeing a corpse swing after another child has thrown a stone at it and believing it pursued her: the movement and her interpretation are different parts of the narrative. In religious melancholy, excessive fasting, illness and solitude are treated as causes, precursors or companions of visions and as opportunities for demonic deception. Burton nevertheless preserves a positive place for temperance and contemplation before condemning their abuse. Neither the frightening catalogue nor the religious polemic makes every visionary experience equivalent.

Apparitions also enter rival accounts of religious authority. Burton makes “Spectrums” instruments through which the Devil stirs conflict and secures worship; his account assigns the principal agency to the Devil. Later his “fained apparitions” belong to accusations that religious authorities manipulate fear and exploit natural events. The supplied note qualifies his citation of Curtius: that episode has priests reassure frightened soldiers, whereas Burton describes priests frightening people. At the other extreme, Vanini is reported to assign all apparitions and other extraordinary events to natural causes, including celestial influences and the intelligences moving the spheres. Burton condemns this account, and subsequently quotes Vanini’s own declaration that he rejects the doctrines he recites. The meaning of apparition alone settles none of these causal disputes.

Related entries

Daemon and genius; Familiar; Obsession and possession; Bugbear; Imagination; Fear and terror; Solitude; Ecstasy; Enthusiasm

Places to read

  1. · paragraph 39–48alleged appearances and sensory deception, with witnesses’ claims distinguished from verification
  2. · paragraph 12–17apparent transformation contrasted with real change of bodies
  3. · paragraph 46–50visible mast lights, the Saint Elmo name and conflicting portents
  4. · paragraph 25–35impersonated ghosts, death omens, disputed explanations, raising and laying, and Pucks
  5. · paragraph 8–10the puck as a simile for absorbing, eventually painful thoughts
  6. · paragraph 12–15, 19–21fear, imagination, and apparitions as images conceived by sick people
  7. Suppliedfear-generated sights and marginal note 2866 on seldom seeing apparitions
  8. · paragraph 7–12sudden sights, imitation devils and the distinction between a moving corpse and a pursuer
  9. · paragraph 18–21reassurance through natural causes and disputed humoral explanations of frightening appearances
  10. · paragraph 16–19internally caused images experienced as external; printed apparations
  11. · paragraph 18–21spectres as instruments of coercion in Burton’s demonic account
  12. · paragraph 36–39feigned apparitions and manipulation of religious fear; the supplied Curtius qualification
  13. · paragraph 6–13bodily and environmental conditions, demonic opportunity and the qualification concerning beneficial contemplation
  14. universal natural/celestial explanations attributed to Vanini and his quoted disclaimer

In this edition

“Spectrums” becomes “apparitions” in the spirit survey; the death-omen “spectrum” becomes “an apparition”; the spectrum in the terror catalogue becomes “ghost.” These are contextual choices, not different entities guaranteed by spelling. The second “apparitions” becomes “images,” making the mental conception explicit. The marginal “spectra” is rendered “apparitions,” with “rarò” preserved as “seldom.”

“Ambulones” is retained and explained as “wanderers.” The modern passage supplies “They claim the same power” to connect the passage with the necromancers’ preceding claim: those words are not a separate original assertion in that unit. “Raise and lay them” becomes “summon and dismiss these spirits”; the referent of “them” is made explicit. In the solitary-thought simile, “they say” becomes “as the story goes.” The disputed placement of marginal anchors beside the two passages is disclosed in the supplied notes and is not resolved by silently moving their words. No fresh collation of the historical cited witnesses is claimed here.

ambulones

Printed “Ambulones” (Latin; family). Attestation: word form.

Citation: Retains Ambulones as the quoted Latin plural designation; no unattested singular is asserted.

Wanderers: spirits said to move about heaths and deserted places at midnight.

Context: Mizaldus supplies the name; Lavater is cited for misleading or blocking travellers.

Source: original body

Source wording, Original wording: those which Mizaldus cals Ambulones

Modern rendering: those whom Mizaldus calls Ambulones, “wanderers,”

Word and construction: Ambulones is the quoted plural designation. Wanderers is the modern explanatory gloss, not a second printed Latin term; the wider clause retains Mizaldus as the reported naming authority.

Alignment convention

apparition · absurd apparitions

Printed “absurd apparitions” (English; lemma). Attestation: phrase.

Citation convention

Absurd mental images or self-conceptions, such as imagining oneself an animal.

Context: Melancholy and sick people conceive the images; Burton attributes these examples to disordered imagination.

Source: original body

Source wording: have such absurd apparitions, as that they are Kings, Lords, Cocks, Bears, Apes, Owls

apparition · spectrums and apparitions

Printed “spectrums and apparitions” (English; lemma). Attestation: phrase.

Citation convention

Visions or perceived spirits associated with solitary religious life.

Context: Burton attributes the causal explanation to Lavater while retaining demonic agency elsewhere in the same context.

Source: original body

Source wording: puts solitariness a main cause of such spectrums and apparitions

apparition

Printed “apparition” (English; lemma). Attestation: word form.

Citation convention

Meaning: A visible appearance.

Here: The reported mast-light appearance called Saint Elmo’s fire, within the catalogue of fiery spirits.

Context: Burton reports a traveller’s name and sighting; the neighbouring account offers spirits or little clouds and competing favourable/unfavourable portents. The modern electrical explanation belongs to the supplied editorial note.

Source: original body

Source wording: Radzivilius the Polonian Duke cals this apparition, Sancti Germani sydus

apparition · apparitions

Printed “apparitions” (English; lemma). Attestation: word form.

Citation convention

Meaning: Frightening imagined appearances.

Here: The fearful images explained through darkened spirits and vapours in the reported Galenic physiology.

Context: Burton’s preceding statement gives reassurance through natural inward causes; the following passages debate the particular humoral explanation.

Source: original body

Source wording: divers terrible monstrous fictions in a thousand shapes & apparitions occurre

apparition · apparations

Printed “apparations” (English; lemma). Attestation: word form.

Citation convention

Meaning: Apparitions or appearances, in the printed variant apparations.

Here: Seemingly external images caused through the described disturbance of bodily organs, spirits and humours.

Context: Burton reports competing internal mechanisms; neither the apparent external location nor the observer’s conviction establishes an external object.

Source: original body

Source wording: cause such apparations before their eyes

apparition · Apparitions

Printed “Apparitions” (English; lemma). Attestation: word form.

Citation convention

Meaning: Apparitions or extraordinary appearances.

Here: The appearances included in a comprehensive natural and celestial explanation attributed to Vanini.

Context: Burton condemns the theory; Vanini’s own quoted disclaimer follows. All belongs to the reported explanatory claim, not to Burton’s accepted account.

Source: original body

Source wording: all Apparitions, Prodigies, Miracles, Oracles, Accidents, Alterations of Religions, Kingdoms

counterfeit devil

Printed “counterfeit divels” (English; phrase).

Citation convention

Imitation devils used to frighten people as a joke.

Context: Their feigned identity does not prevent harmful fear in the reported account.

Source: original body

Source wording: affrighted by some counterfeit divels in jest

feigned apparition

Printed “fained apparitions” (English; phrase).

Printed form, Source wording: fained apparitions

Citation convention

Meaning: Fabricated or pretended apparitions.

Here: Invented manifestations or their tales used to frighten people and secure obedience.

Context: Burton accuses religious authorities of exploiting natural events and fabricated narratives; the supplied note reports that his cited Curtius episode instead reassures frightened soldiers.

Source: original body

puck · Pucks

Printed “Pucks” (English; lemma). Attestation: word form.

Citation convention

A locally named kind of mischievous wandering spirit.

Context: Burton supplies the English name for beings already described in attributed accounts.

Source: original body

Source wording: we commonly call them Pucks

puck · a Puck

Printed “a Puck” (English; lemma). Attestation: phrase.

Citation convention

A mischievous spirit believed to lead travellers astray, here used as a simile for compulsive reverie.

Context: The story is expressly qualified and used comparatively; thoughts are what actually detain the described thinker.

Source: original body

Source wording: as he (they say) that is lead round about an Heath with a Puck in the night

raise and lay spirits

Printed “raise and lay them” (English; phrase).

Citation convention

Summon and dismiss the spirits.

Context: Necromancers claim the power; the passage does not independently establish it.

Source: original body

Source wording, Original wording: Negromancers take upon them, to raise and lay them at their pleasures

Modern rendering: Necromancers claim to summon and dismiss these spirits at will

Word and construction: Take upon them supplies the claim of power; raise and lay are the opposed actions summon and dismiss. These spirits explicitly supplies the referent of original them, and at will renders at their pleasures.

Alignment convention

spectrum · spectrums · local use 1

Printed “spectrums” (English; lemma). Attestation: word form.

Citation convention

Apparitions among extraordinary sights allegedly represented to the senses.

Context: The catalogue is governed by most writers’ belief; Burton subsequently distinguishes illusion from bodily transformation.

Source: original body

Source wording: pallaces, armies, spectrums, prodigies

spectrum · local use 1

Printed “spectrum” (English; lemma). Attestation: word form.

Citation convention

An apparition, here a musical death omen.

Context: Reported apparition appears before the governor dies; temporal sequence is part of the omen narrative.

Source: original body

Source wording: a spectrum, in the habit of Arion with his Harp appears

spectrum · spectrums · local use 2

Printed “spectrums” (English; lemma). Attestation: word form.

Citation convention

Spectres explained through fear’s effect upon imagination.

Context: The causal judgement is attributed to Lavater, with Weyer cited for fear’s imaginative power.

Source: original body

Source wording, Original wording: Lavater imputes the greatest cause of spectrums, and the like apparitions, to fear

Modern rendering: Lavater makes fear the chief cause of spectres and similar apparitions

Word and construction: The greatest cause is rendered the chief cause. Fear is the attributed cause, while spectrums and similar apparitions are what it chiefly causes; the comparative judgment belongs to Lavater.

Alignment convention

spectrum · spectra

Printed “spectra” (Latin; lemma). Attestation: word form.

Citation convention

Apparitions in the claim that brave people see them less often.

Context: Quoted Lavater claim; rarò means seldom, not never. The English is editorial translation within the note.

Source: original marginal quotation

Locator qualification: Do not remove bracketed or repeated-page qualifier.; This source group includes repeated printed 96–97 and supplied 98–99; see SUPPLIED_OPENING and SOURCE_DJR_040.

Source wording, Original wording: fortes rarò spectra vident, quia minus timent

Modern rendering: the brave seldom see apparitions because they fear less

Word and construction: Fortes is the brave as grammatical subject; spectra the apparitions seen. Rarò supplies seldom and minus supplies less; the causal clause quia minus timent explains the reported lower frequency, not impossibility.

Alignment convention

Edition note: checked against editorial translation within the Burton-labelled note; translation is not original evidence

spectrum · local use 2

Printed “spectrum” (English; lemma). Attestation: word form.

Citation convention

Ghost or apparition as a sudden frightening sight.

Context: Burton reports Lavater’s claim of lost reason and juxtaposes imitation devils.

Source: original body

Source wording: some spectrum or divil

spectrum · Spectrums

Printed “Spectrums” (English; lemma). Attestation: word form.

Citation convention

Meaning: Apparitions or spectres.

Here: Apparitions used as instruments of coercion in Burton’s account of superstition.

Context: Burton gives the Devil the principal agency, combining terror with rewards to secure worship; this is his theological account, not independent confirmation of those alleged phenomena.

Source: original body

Source wording: raising wars, seditions by Spectrums