Philosophy

Wisdom From the Edge of the Map

An oath makes the healer’s rule apply even to the most admired boy in the gym.

Socrates says he learned his charm from a Thracian doctor he met on campaign, a foreigner who told him what Greek doctors had overlooked. Plato often gives a stranger the lesson the Greeks need to hear, and this stranger does two jobs at once.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • A lesson learned abroadSocrates says a Thracian doctor taught him the charm during a campaign. The doctor attributes the principle behind it to Zalmoxis, whom he calls both king and god.
  • What the doctors missedThe Thracian agrees that doctors should treat sore eyes with the head and the head with the body. He goes a step further and says that caring for the body starts with the soul.
  • Another outsider corrects the GreeksIn the Timaeus, an Egyptian priest tells Solon that the Greeks have little knowledge of their own distant past. Both stories give a stranger the authority to point out what Greeks overlook.
  • An oath that applies to CharmidesSocrates has sworn to treat the soul before applying the remedy to the head. The doctor expressly forbids an exception for anyone rich, wellborn or beautiful.

Charmides 153a–c, 156d–157b, 157b–e, 157e–158c · Herodotus 4.93–96, 5.6 · Thucydides 2.29 · Symposium 201d–e · Sophist 216a · Statesman 257a · Laws 624a · Timaeus 20e, 22b · Apology 21d

When Socrates finally explains his charm, he doesn’t claim it as his own idea. He says, “I learned it out there on campaign from one of the Thracian doctors of Zalmoxis,” and everything that follows, the principle about the soul, the charm made of beautiful words, the strict rules about who may be treated, comes to us as what the Thracian told him. For an Athenian audience that’s a surprising choice of authority. Herodotus, writing about the peoples north of Greece, reports that some Thracians counted tattoos a mark of noble birth. His account makes a point of how differently familiar things could be understood across the border.

The particular Thracians Socrates names make the choice even more pointed. The doctor calls Zalmoxis his king and a god. Herodotus associates Zalmoxis with the Getae, a people near the lower Danube whom he describes as the bravest and most just of the Thracians. He says they believed that people who died went to Zalmoxis. The campaign had taken Socrates to Potidaea in the north, and Athens made an alliance with the Thracian king Sitalces early in the war. A doctor encountered on campaign is a plausible enough figure. The claim that his teaching goes back to a god gives the story a stranger turn.

Then the foreigner corrects the Greeks, and his correction has a sting to it. The Thracian, Socrates reports, said the Greeks were right about treating the eyes with the head and the head with the body, but that “this is the very reason why most diseases elude the Greek doctors,” since they neglect the whole person, soul included. It’s as if a visiting physician from somewhere you’d been taught to look down on walked into your country’s best hospital and calmly explained that your doctors were missing the most important thing, and then turned out to be right. Notice how much of Greek medicine he keeps. He accepts the comparisons Socrates has just made, then adds the one thing he thinks the Greek doctors have left out.

Plato does this kind of thing again and again. The deepest teaching about love in the Symposium comes from Diotima, a woman from Mantinea whom Socrates names as his teacher, two of his late dialogues are led by an unnamed visitor from Elea, and the Laws is run by a stranger from Athens talking to a Spartan and a Cretan. The closest parallel comes in the Timaeus. There the story of Atlantis passes from Solon through Dropides and an older Critias to the Critias who tells it. It begins with an Egyptian priest telling Solon that the Greeks are always children, with no truly ancient learning of their own. Once again, an outsider tells a Greek what his own tradition has overlooked.

The stranger does a second job for Socrates, which is just as important. In the Apology, Socrates says he has the small advantage of recognizing his own ignorance. That’s hardly the posture of someone who can march into a gym and lay down the law about how to treat a soul on his own authority. He can report what a foreign doctor taught him and what he swore to do. That’s exactly how he frames it, saying that he has sworn the Thracian an oath “and I must obey,” so the demanding conditions of the treatment arrive as instructions he received rather than rules he made up, and Socrates gets to be the messenger instead of the boss. Anyone who objects has to contend with the Thracian’s rule as well as with Socrates.

The oath matters most because of exactly what it forbids. The Thracian charged him “to let no one be so rich, or so wellborn, or so beautiful, as to persuade me to do otherwise,” and that description fits Charmides to a tee, since the boy’s looks and celebrated family are already the talk of the room. If Socrates had said on his own that the boy’s money and family and face would earn him no special treatment, he would have sounded rude, but the rule sounds like professional ethics once Socrates says he has sworn to follow it. Socrates’ oath to the stranger does some of the awkward work for him.

There’s a nice irony in where the correction lands, too. The people hearing that Greek medicine has missed something are about as aristocratic as Athenians get. Socrates is about to praise the beauty and virtue of Charmides’ family, and he names Solon among the poets who celebrated it. Yet the man with the lesson is a doctor from somewhere else. Wisdom doesn’t check your pedigree before it shows up.

My verdict is that the Thracian stranger is one of Plato’s smartest devices. He gives Socrates an authority that isn’t his own, which fits a philosopher who makes a point of admitting what he doesn’t know, and he lets an outsider tell the most privileged people in Athens that their best experts are missing the point. Whether or not Socrates ever met such a doctor, the choice to make the teacher a foreigner from the edge of the map makes us consider where hard truths can come from, and how much easier they are to hear when someone else is delivering them. A Greek reader has to swallow a little pride to take the lesson, and that may be part of the lesson too.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

Why does the author think Socrates’ oath is especially effective in his treatment of Charmides?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.