Philosophy
Why Plato Slows Down
The Thracian doctor’s account of the soul offers a way to read the dialogue’s uneven pacing.
The Platonic Dialogues: CharmidesSocrates sums up his report from Potidaea in one sentence and then spends two pages on a teenager sitting down. That isn’t bad storytelling, because it’s Socrates’ own theory of medicine applied to the way he tells a story.
Orientation
At a Glance
- War news in briefSocrates sums up his account of the crowd’s questions about Potidaea in a sentence and narrates Charmides’ arrival in much greater detail.
- The doctor’s ruleThe Thracian doctor says that care for the body has to begin with care for the soul.
- What the narrator noticesThe story lingers over Socrates’ loss of composure, Charmides’ blush, and Critias’ embarrassment.
- Reading the facesThe essay connects the pacing to the doctor’s advice. Gestures and expressions help the reader follow the argument about temperance.
If you timed the opening of the Charmides with a stopwatch, the proportions would look crazy. Socrates sums up the crowd’s questions about Potidaea in a single sentence, while the next stretch, a boy walking into a gym and finding a seat, gets roughly two pages of play-by-play, down to who looked where, who ended up on the floor and what Socrates glimpsed inside a cloak. It’s as if a sports broadcast skipped the championship game and then ran a slow-motion replay of somebody finding his seat in the stands.
There are some easy explanations for the imbalance, and they deserve a hearing. War stories can be tedious, an erotic comedy in a gym is a lot more fun, and Plato was a dramatist who knew what holds an audience, so maybe he just cut the boring part. You could also say Socrates remembers the meeting in detail because it rattled him, since people tend to replay the moments when they lost their cool. Both of those are true as far as they go, but neither explains why the detail falls where it does.
The dialogue supplies a better explanation, and it comes from the Thracian doctor. When Socrates explains his charm, he passes on the teaching of Zalmoxis’ doctors that everything, good and bad, for the body and for the whole human being, “starts from the soul and flows from there, as it flows from the head into the eyes,” so the soul has to be treated first and foremost. The doctor even diagnoses why Greek physicians fail so often, saying “they neglect the whole, which is what they ought to be caring for,” and the narrator of the Charmides tells his story like a man determined not to make the same mistake. A battle is mostly about bodies, who lived and who died, and a narrator who believes that everything starts in the soul is going to move quickly through the war news and save the slow motion for the moments when a soul shows itself.
Look at which details get the slow-motion treatment, and you’ll find they’re nearly all moments when something inside a person breaks the surface. Socrates even holds himself to the same rule, since the fire, the loss of himself and the scramble for a line of poetry to steady his nerves all get the close-up too. The boys can’t take their eyes off Charmides, the men on the bench can’t keep their dignity, and Socrates’ own boldness gets knocked out of him the instant the boy sits down beside him. When the argument starts, the camera stays alert for the same kind of moment, so we get Charmides’ blush when Socrates asks whether he’s temperate, which Socrates calls “becoming at his age,” and later the sly laugh and the glance across at Critias that tell you more about the boy than any of his definitions.
That makes the detailed narration a kind of training for the reader. Socrates is teaching us to watch people the way his Thracian doctor watches patients, as wholes in which the body keeps giving away the state of the soul, the way a good poker player reads the tells at a table instead of listening to what everybody says about their cards. It’s a skill the dialogue clearly thinks matters, because a definition can be memorized and repeated by anyone, while a blush or a nervous laugh is much harder to fake. By the time the argument gets abstract, we’ve been taught to keep one eye on the faces, so we notice when Critias gets angry like a poet whose lines are being butchered, and when he blushes in his own way by covering up his confusion in front of the crowd.
Notice too that the detail comes back every time a soul flares up. The long middle of the dialogue, where Socrates and Critias work through definitions, has stretches of fairly bare question and answer, but the camera zooms right back in whenever someone’s character breaks through the argument, at the sly laugh, at Critias’ outburst, at the moment he catches Socrates’ perplexity “like people who catch a yawn.” That pattern would make no sense if Plato were simply padding the fun parts, but it makes perfect sense if the narration follows the doctor’s rule and lingers wherever the soul is at work.
So what does all this detail imply about an otherwise ordinary return to familiar company? It implies that Socrates thinks the ordinary afternoon was the real event, more important than the battle he survived, which is a strange news judgment for a man just back from a war, but a consistent one for a man who believes the soul is where everything begins. The city wanted the casualty list, and the narrator moves briskly past it, because for him the news that matters is what’s happening inside a young man whose life is about to be shaped by the people around him.
My verdict is that the uneven pacing is the argument, not a quirk of storytelling. Plato builds the narration on the same principle as the charm, so that a reader who pays attention learns to see souls in faces before the dialogue ever tries to define the virtue that is supposed to govern them. The war news goes by quickly because bodies are easy to count, and the gym gets two pages because what Socrates cares about is harder to see, and you only see it if somebody slows the tape down and shows you where to look.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
What is the article’s central claim about the uneven pacing in the opening of the Charmides?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- If bodily reactions can reveal the soul more reliably than memorized definitions, what limits should readers place on interpreting blushes, laughter, or anger?→
- How does the article’s interpretation change what it means to read a philosophical dialogue well: should readers judge arguments independently, or also judge the character and conduct of the speakers?→
- If pacing can function as an argument, what responsibilities does that create for readers when a narrative lingers over an apparently minor event or rushes past an apparently major one?→