Philosophy

Who Has to Prove What?

Socrates tells Critias he can’t decide whether knowledge of knowledge is possible, then asks Critias to show that it is. What does each man owe the inquiry?

Critias puts forward the definition. Socrates asks him to support it, grants a disputed point so the test can continue, and takes responsibility when the inquiry comes up short.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • Socrates owns his uncertaintyAt 169a Socrates says he can’t decide which things can relate to themselves. He asks Critias to show that the capacity in his definition is possible and beneficial.
  • The claim needs supportCritias has proposed a kind of knowledge that is directed at other kinds of knowledge and at itself. Asking him to explain how it could exist is a way of taking the claim seriously.
  • Criticism can come firstA critic may identify a gap in a proposal before being ready to offer a better one. Socrates can press a question about Critias’ definition while leaving his own answer open.
  • Socrates shares the workWhen Critias has no clear answer, Socrates grants the disputed possibility for the time being. In the closing review, he takes some of the blame for how little the inquiry has achieved.

Charmides 164d–165b, 166a–d, 168d–169a, 169a–d, 175a–b · Justinian’s Digest 22.3.2 (Paulus)

Socrates’ demand comes right after a confession, which is what makes it look odd. He says it would take “a great man” to decide whether anything can relate to itself, and adds, “I, for my part, don’t trust myself to be capable of making these distinctions.” Then he turns to Critias and says, “So you, son of Callaeschrus, since you lay it down that temperance is this, knowledge of knowledge and indeed of the lack of knowledge,” and asks him to show first that it’s possible and then, “besides its being possible, that it is beneficial too.”

On the face of it, that looks like an uneven demand. Socrates has just admitted he can’t answer the question himself, yet he asks Critias to answer it and offers no rival account that Critias could examine in turn. A questioner can take advantage of that position. It’s fair to ask why Critias should have to meet a demand Socrates says he can’t meet himself.

The Roman jurist Paulus gives a useful comparison in a maxim preserved in the Digest. The person who asserts a fact is the one called on to establish it. That’s a principle about proof, and here we can hear an everyday version of it in Socrates’ words “since you lay it down.” Critias proposed the definition, connected self-knowledge with Apollo’s greeting at Delphi, and argued that temperance differs from other kinds of knowledge. It makes sense to ask him what supports that account. If I say a restaurant is the best in town, you can ask me why before naming a better one.

The demand also fits the size of the claim. Critias says there is a knowledge unlike every other kind, one that has itself as its object. Before we can put this proposed capacity to work, we need to understand what it would mean for knowledge to turn on itself. Socrates gives Critias a specific question to answer. Asking for support here is different from demanding that he prove everything about temperance at once.

Fair scrutiny can start before the critic has a better answer. A reviewer can find a gap in a scientific paper without writing a replacement. A juror can find a case unproven without being able to say who committed the crime. Socrates can put pressure on the point where Critias’ account needs support. If Socrates goes on to advance an account of his own, it will be his turn to show what it can explain.

The burden can still be abused. When Critias has no clear answer, Socrates could have left him there. Instead he says, “let us grant for now that it is possible for there to be knowledge of knowledge,” and carries on with what such knowledge could do. A critic can use a demand for proof to stop a conversation. Here, asking Critias to show his work and making a concession when he can’t are two ways of keeping the question alive.

Socrates also carries part of the load in a less obvious way. He states his “prophetic hunch that temperance is something beneficial and good.” Critias can see that usefulness is a test Socrates himself has brought to the discussion. Socrates later blames himself for how little the inquiry has achieved. He can ask Critias to defend the definition and still accept some responsibility for what the conversation has become.

My verdict is that the demand is fair because Critias has laid down a claim and Socrates has asked him to show what supports it. Much depends on what Socrates does next. He grants what Critias can’t establish, continues the test, and takes part of the responsibility when the inquiry falls short. He asks Critias for reasons while sharing the work of finding out where those reasons lead.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

How does the comparison with Paulus’s maxim answer the objection that Socrates offers no alternative definition?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.