Renaissance

Where It Hung, What It’s Made Of, How the Light Falls

Three glossary terms help us see how Luca della Robbia’s reliefs were made and viewed.

Cantoria names a place, terracotta names a material, and chiaroscuro names an effect. The three terms restore details of setting and craft that are easy to miss in Pater’s account of Luca della Robbia.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • Three kinds of informationThe glossary distinguishes where a work belongs, what it is made of, and how light makes its forms visible.
  • A gallery made for musicLuca’s marble singers’ gallery placed figures illustrating Psalm 150 high inside Florence Cathedral.
  • The uses of fired clayGlazed terracotta let the workshop carry the effects of relief into new settings, including homes and exterior walls.
  • The conditions of lookingPater’s delicate shadows depend on light and angle, two conditions that a photograph fixes in place.

Here’s something you’d only notice by going looking through the essay itself. Of the three words, Pater uses exactly one, “terra cotta,” and he uses it once. “Cantoria” appears only in the edition’s notes and glossary, and “chiaroscuro” appears nowhere in Pater’s text at all. So the glossary isn’t simply decoding Pater’s vocabulary, it’s supplying names for things he describes in other words, and the three names it chooses belong to three different departments of knowledge. A cantoria is a place, terracotta is a material, and chiaroscuro is a visual effect, and each one sends a reader off toward a different question about an object made by human hands. That’s a quiet service to the reader, since a lyrical writer tends to dissolve technical facts into atmosphere, and a good glossary hands some of them back.

Start with the place, which is where the glossary adds the most. The glossary defines a cantoria as “A singers’ gallery” and adds that Luca’s marble gallery for Florence Cathedral “shows children singing, playing, and dancing.” That tells you something Pater’s essay barely mentions, which is where the work was meant to be and what it was for. The cathedral museum dates Luca’s work on the marble gallery to 1432–1438. It stood above a sacristy entrance, with musicians above the floor and Psalm 150 carved around children singing, playing and dancing. The original arrangement was dismantled in the late seventeenth century. The cathedral museum now displays a reconstruction with original panels, casts and additions, so the visitor sees the carving under different conditions.

That matters more than it sounds, because place changes what a sculpture is. A relief made to be seen from the floor of a dim cathedral, several yards up, with singers standing behind it, is a different visual event from the same relief at eye level under gallery lights. Pater himself insists on this point in another context, saying that Luca’s work is like Tuscan wine, which “loses its savour when moved from its birthplace.” The place word asks the questions of use and setting, who stood there, what was sung, where the viewer’s eye was, and it’s the category of information a museum label most easily loses.

The material word asks a different set of questions, closer to the workshop than to the cathedral. The glossary calls terracotta “Fired clay” and adds that in Luca’s workshop “a glaze gives the surface its colour and gloss.” Pater supplies the story of the invention, Luca first making “a mere rough imitation” of marble in plain white earthenware, “finished in a few hours,” and then adding color. A material term opens questions of making, how a thing was modeled and fired, how long it took, what it cost, how many could be produced, and how well it would survive rain and sun on an outside wall. Those are a craftsman’s and an economist’s questions, and they explain things the work’s beauty alone can’t, such as how a single family workshop could scatter blue and white Madonnas across Tuscany. The material term also explains the oddity at the center of Pater’s story, that a master of marble should turn to pottery at all, since glazed clay brought colored relief to settings such as outdoor walls and ordinary homes, alongside the places where Florentines already used marble.

Chiaroscuro asks a third kind of question, and here the glossary works best by contrast. The glossary defines it as “The use of light and dark to give form, volume, or dramatic emphasis,” and the word joins the Italian for “light” and “dark.” That contrast matters, because Pater says the Tuscan relief sculptors were “haters of all heaviness and emphasis, of strongly-opposed light and shade,” and that they worked instead with “those last refinements of shadow, which are almost invisible except in a strong light.” So the term names the dramatic tradition that Luca’s art declines, and that refusal is exactly its character, a chiaroscuro of whispers rather than spotlights, where a smile can pass over a face like a ripple of air.

The effect word sends you to the moment of viewing. The note on low relief explains that the strength of a shadow on carving this shallow depends on how deep the cut is and where the light comes from, so the same panel can look flat in frontal light and alive when the light strikes across it. Questions of effect are questions about the viewer’s circumstances, the hour, the weather through the windows, the angle of approach, and they’re the questions Pater’s prose answers most fully, since his whole method begins with the impression a work makes on someone standing in front of it. It’s also the category where a modern reader is most easily misled, since a photograph fixes one lighting for good and makes the shallow carving look flatter or crisper than it ever looked in the church.

Put the three together and they explain each other in a way none of them does alone. Luca’s delicate shadows depended on the light and height of the place the gallery was built for, while his later glazed work, shining and colored, could carry its effects into dim churches and bright streets without any help from raking light, because the glaze does with color what the marble relief did with shadow. Place, material and effect form a single system, and a reader who only has Pater’s language of impression, however beautiful, will miss how the system works.

So a short glossary does its best work by supplying categories that a lyrical writer blends together. Cantoria asks where and for whom, terracotta asks how and at what cost, and chiaroscuro asks how and when the thing is seen. Pater mostly answers the third question and lets the other two dissolve into atmosphere, and the glossary quietly restores them, which gives a reader of his essay on Luca the tools to see the sculptures as objects that were made, placed and lit, as well as felt.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

Why does the article argue that displaying Luca’s cantoria at eye level in a museum changes the work’s visual effect?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.