Philosophy
When “I Could Be Wrong” Is Just a Line
Critias says he would gladly take back a mistake. Then the conversation leaves him at a loss in front of the people he wants to impress.
The Platonic Dialogues: CharmidesSocrates tells us what Critias said about admitting error and what he did when the chance came. His own admissions give readers something else to compare.
Orientation
At a Glance
- Critias offers to take something backHe tells Socrates he would rather admit an earlier error than accept that a temperate person might lack self-knowledge. The claim he is defending stays in place.
- The company raises the stakesSocrates says Critias becomes perplexed and tries to cover it up in front of the group. Now an admission would cost him something.
- Socrates names his concessionsSocrates points out exactly what they granted without establishing it. He also holds himself responsible for the poor result of the inquiry.
- The revisions matterA general admission that one could be wrong is easy to make. The dialogue gives readers a way to watch what happens when a particular claim needs to change.
Imagine a popular commentator who has mastered the vocabulary of intellectual humility. Every talk begins with a reminder that he might be mistaken, every interview includes a line about following the evidence wherever it leads, and he often praises the virtue of changing one’s mind. Yet over ten years of public life, nobody can point to a single claim he has actually revised. His audience finds him reassuring and open-minded, and the question is what they should be looking at to tell whether the openness is real. None of this makes him dishonest, necessarily, since he may sincerely believe he is open-minded, but sincerity about one’s own openness is exactly the kind of self-knowledge the Charmides shows to be hard.
The Charmides contains a small version of this figure, and it isn’t the one you might expect. When Socrates’ argument suggests that a person might be temperate without knowing it, Critias makes a ringing declaration. If this follows from anything he agreed to earlier, he says, “I would sooner take back some of it, and not be ashamed to say I had spoken wrongly, than ever concede that a man who does not know himself is temperate.” It sounds like a model of intellectual courage, a man proclaiming that he would rather admit error than defend a bad conclusion. The image is of taking something back. What he is willing to take back is a previous concession.
Watch what happens a few pages later, when the moment for admitting error actually arrives. Socrates lays out his doubts about knowledge of knowledge and asks Critias to show that it is possible and beneficial, and Critias catches Socrates’ perplexity like a yawn. Then, Socrates reports, since he was used to being admired, he “was ashamed in front of the company,” wouldn’t concede that he couldn’t make the distinctions, and “said nothing clear, but kept covering up his perplexity.” Socrates describes him feeling the very shame he had said he would face.
His earlier speech had been humble in vocabulary and confident in substance. What Critias was really announcing was his certainty about one thing, that a temperate man must know himself, and his willingness to sacrifice other premises to protect it. That’s not the same as being willing to discover he was wrong about the thing he cared about. He has offered to retract his earlier agreements in order to protect the conclusion that matters to him. A modern equivalent is the speaker who will gladly drop any of his minor claims while treating his central thesis as beyond question.
Socrates offers a contrast, and it’s worth watching his conduct rather than his words. He says plainly that he examines arguments “for fear that I might ever, without noticing, think I know something when I don’t,” and many readers have suspected this kind of profession of being a pose. But in the dialogue, Socrates actually grants points he can’t refute, admits when he is stuck, says out loud that they “conceded many things that did not follow in the argument,” and blames the failure on his own poor inquiring. His humility comes with costs and with specific admissions, which is exactly what the commentator’s lacks. Even his self-deprecation is tested by what he does next, since Socrates calls himself a poor inquirer and still asks Charmides to consider what he needs.
That suggests what observers should look for, and the first sign is revision, actual claims withdrawn or changed, with the speaker able to say what changed his mind. The second is specificity, admissions of error about particular points rather than general disclaimers that cover everything and commit to nothing. The third is cost, humility that shows up when it’s inconvenient, in front of the people whose admiration the speaker values, rather than only when it flatters him. And the fourth is crediting critics, acknowledging by name when someone else turned out to be right. A speaker who scores well on all four has earned the vocabulary.
There’s an irony worth noticing in how the vocabulary works on audiences. A speaker who constantly says he might be wrong can actually become harder to challenge, since every objection seems already anticipated and absorbed, and the audience feels it would be churlish to press him. The disclaimer becomes a shield, and the more often it is used, the less it means. The Charmides shows the same mechanism in miniature, since Critias’ fine speech about retracting makes his later refusal to admit perplexity all the more striking. Socrates, by contrast, never asks the company to admire his openness, and the evidence for it is scattered through the argument rather than gathered into a speech.
Critias says he would sooner take something back than accept a conclusion he thinks absurd. Socrates describes him hiding his perplexity when the argument asks more of him. Then Socrates names the claims he himself was too quick to concede. Listen to a speaker’s assurances if you like. The moment a particular claim comes under pressure will tell you more.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
What does the article identify as the key limitation in Critias’ promise to retract earlier statements?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- How could you distinguish between someone who protects a central belief by revising minor claims and someone who is responsibly refining a complex position?→
- Why might admitting a specific error in front of an admiring audience reveal more about intellectual humility than repeatedly saying “I could be wrong”?→
- Can general disclaimers of uncertainty ever promote genuine inquiry, or do they become meaningful only when accompanied by revision, specificity, cost, and credit to critics?→