Renaissance
Venus Clocks In at Dawn
Botticelli gives the goddess of pleasure a cold morning. Pater wonders whether it comes from the paint, the painter, or the work that awaits her.
The Renaissance (1893)Tempera, a familiar melancholy expression and a borrowed Psalm all shape Pater’s encounter with Venus. His strongest idea is that pleasure can be a responsibility for the one who provides it.
Orientation
At a Glance
- The morning has a chillPater notices grey water, a pale dawn and a face that seems sad. He asks what makes a picture of Venus feel so cold.
- Paint and habit explain part of itBotticelli’s tempera looks different from the warm oils of Titian’s Venus. Botticelli also gives a similarly withdrawn expression to figures in other paintings.
- A psalm makes Venus the first workerPater recasts a verse about people leaving for work. His goddess is awake before them and faces a long day of love.
- Pleasure has a providerThe interpretation gives the familiar expression a purpose in this painting. Pater imagines the power to stir desire as a burden Venus has to carry.
The Renaissance · Sandro Botticelli, Venus at a sunless dawn · Note 103, Venus arriving on shore · Sandro Botticelli, the expressions of the Madonnas · Botticelli’s Birth of Venus, Uffizi · Titian’s Venus Rising from the Sea, National Galleries of Scotland · Cabanel’s Birth of Venus, Musée d’Orsay · Psalm 104:23, King James Version
You’d expect the goddess of pleasure to arrive at noon in a heat wave, with the sea glittering and somebody already passing drinks around on the beach, but Botticelli brings her in at first light under a washed-out sky, and Pater clocks the temperature right away. The light, he says, is “mere sunless dawn,” the water is grey, the color can strike you as “cadaverous or at least cold,” and the goddess’s face carries a sorrow you’d never predict from her job description. The question worth asking is what kind of pleasure shows up on a morning like that, and Pater, unusually for a critic so fond of mood, gives us his own list of possible answers before he picks the one he believes, which makes it easy to check his work.
The list comes at the end of his paragraph, and it reads like a detective ruling out suspects one at a time. “Botticelli meant all this imagery to be altogether pleasurable,” he says, and then it was “partly an incompleteness of resources, inseparable from the art of that time, that subdued and chilled it,” though “his predilection for minor tones counts also,” and finally “what is unmistakable is the sadness with which he has conceived the goddess of pleasure, as the depository of a great power over the lives of men.” That gives us three candidates for the cold, which are the paint and its limits, the painter’s personal taste, and the meaning of being Venus, and the fair question is how much of the chill belongs to each of them.
Botticelli painted in tempera on canvas, a support the Uffizi notes was used for decorative pictures in noble houses. The pale surface looks quite different from the warm flesh in Titian’s Venus rising from the sea, painted in oils around 1520 and now in Edinburgh. The comparison shows what each painting does with its materials. It leaves open how much of the chill Pater saw can be explained by the medium or by the picture’s age.
Pater doesn’t wish the cold away, though, and that’s the interesting turn, because he says “a later painter would have cloyed you with sunshine,” and that the quiet morning air lets you see “each long promontory, as it slopes down to the water’s edge.” Alexandre Cabanel’s creamy Birth of Venus, bought by Napoleon III at the Paris Salon of 1863, gives us a near-contemporary example of the effect Pater has in mind. Next to that sugar rush, Botticelli’s dawn looks like clarity, so the resources Pater calls incomplete also give him the thing he values most, a light that lets you see edges instead of drowning them.
The second suspect, “his predilection for minor tones,” is a musical metaphor for a personal habit, and here the case against Pater’s big reading gets strong. Botticelli gives the same wistful, slightly withdrawn face to his Madonnas, to the women of the Primavera, and to women elsewhere in his work, and Pater himself calls the Madonnas “peevish-looking,” so the sorrow on Venus might be nothing more than house style, the face this painter put on everybody, the way some singers can’t help sounding sad on a happy song. If that’s right, then reading a theory of pleasure off her expression is like reading a breakup into every track by an artist with a melancholy voice, and Pater’s grand claim about the goddess shrinks to a remark about Botticelli’s habits.
Pater’s answer to that objection is tucked inside a borrowed Bible verse. “Men go forth to their labours until the evening; but she is awake before them,” he writes, rewriting Psalm 104, where in the King James wording “Man goeth forth unto his work and to his labour until the evening,” and with that one swap Venus becomes the first worker of the day, up before the farmers, looking at a shift that won’t end. He follows it with the thought that her sorrow might be “at the thought of the whole long day of love yet to come,” which recasts love as labor and pleasure as something she supplies to other people rather than something she gets to enjoy herself, and that’s a reading the house face can’t explain away.
That reading earns its keep because it explains why the house face fits this subject so well, instead of merely showing up on it. Pater opens the whole passage by saying Botticelli “carries this sentiment into classical subjects,” so he knows perfectly well the sadness is a habit, and his claim is that the habit finds its truest object in a goddess who serves as the “depository” of power over other people’s lives, a word that sounds like a bank vault and means someone holding in trust what belongs to everyone. Pleasure seen from the provider’s side is a responsibility rather than a treat, and responsibility at six in the morning tends to wear exactly the face Botticelli gave her.
My verdict is that the cold belongs to all three suspects, though not equally, and Pater ranks them in the right order. The pale surface and the familiar wistful expression both matter to what we see. Pater’s third explanation does the most to explain the role he gives Venus. The pleasure that arrives at a cold dawn is pleasure on the clock, a goddess facing a whole day of other people’s desire, and it’s Pater’s best call in the passage because it takes a painter’s limits and a painter’s habits and shows that together they make an idea about love that a sunnier picture would have melted clean away.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
What is the article’s main reason for comparing Botticelli’s dawn with Cabanel’s sunnier treatment of Venus?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- When does a recurring artistic habit become meaningful to a particular subject rather than merely repeating itself? How would you decide in the case of Botticelli’s Venus?→
- Does interpreting pleasure from the provider’s perspective change what pleasure means? What features of the article’s reading support your answer?→
- If Botticelli’s technical limitations help produce the clarity Pater values, should they still be called limitations? Why or why not?→