Philosophy
Tying Himself to the Mast
Odysseus uses ropes to hear the Sirens without following them. At the wrestling school, a promise gives Socrates a way to admire Charmides without making an exception for him.
The Platonic Dialogues: CharmidesSocrates says he swore on campaign to let neither wealth, birth nor beauty persuade him to give the remedy without first caring for the soul. Back in Athens, the boy beside him is just the sort of person who could make an exception tempting.
Orientation
At a Glance
- A promise made on campaignSocrates says he swore to follow the doctor’s instructions. Wealth, family and beauty must never talk him into treating a person’s head at the expense of the soul.
- Odysseus gives the order in advanceOdysseus tells his crew to bind him to the mast and tighten the ropes if he asks to be released. The plan lets him hear the Sirens without acting on their song.
- Persuading and obeyingThe Greek uses forms of the same verb for someone persuading Socrates and for Socrates obeying the doctor. The echo makes the two kinds of influence audible.
- Praise without a free passSocrates praises Charmides’ looks and family. He still makes the remedy depend on whether the boy has temperance and asks Charmides to answer for himself.
Socrates explains the oath right after laying out the Thracian’s medicine. The Thracian, he says, charged him “very strictly to let no one be so rich, or so wellborn, or so beautiful, as to persuade me to do otherwise,” meaning to give the remedy without treating the soul, and Socrates adds that he has sworn an oath and must obey. It sounds like a professional rule, the kind of thing a doctor might be bound by, but look at who’s sitting next to him when he says it, because Charmides has the looks and the family connections that could make the promise hard to keep. He already fits two of the three temptations the doctor names.
The oath works like a famous piece of self-binding in Greek literature. In the Odyssey, Circe tells Odysseus how to hear the Sirens’ song and survive. Following her advice, he plugs his crew’s ears with wax and has them tie him to the mast, with orders to bind him tighter if he begs to be let go. He doesn’t trust himself in the moment, so he makes the decision in advance, while his head is clear, and lets the ropes do the deciding when the beautiful song begins. The genius of the plan is that Odysseus still gets to hear the song. What he can’t do is act on it. That’s the sort of arrangement Socrates needs on this bench.
Socrates has every reason to want ropes of his own. He has already told us that where the beautiful are concerned he’s “a white measuring-line on white stone,” a judge whose eye finds nearly every young man gorgeous, and earlier he caught fire and lost possession of himself on this very bench. A man who knows that about himself is exactly the man who should not be making exceptions on the spot, and an oath sworn on campaign to a foreign doctor is the perfect way to take the decision out of the hands of the flustered man on the bench. The flustered man is real, and so is the clear-headed one who made the promise, and the oath lets the second overrule the first.
The Greek makes the binding even tighter with a verbal echo that English has trouble keeping. The verb peithō means to persuade, and in its middle form it can mean to heed or obey. Nobody is to persuade Socrates to make an exception. Socrates must heed the doctor’s instructions, and he says he will. The oath is a kind of persuasion fixed in advance, so that any later persuasion, however charming, has to get past the earlier one, and the earlier one wins, the way Odysseus’ standing orders outrank the signal he gives once the music starts. It’s persuasion turned into a commitment, the way a signed contract is an old agreement that outvotes a new mood.
Modern life is full of the same trick, because people have always known that good intentions melt under pressure. A musician auditioning behind a screen gives judges a chance to listen without seeing who’s playing. The oath gives Socrates a rule for the moment when everyone can see who’s sitting next to him. You set the rule when you’re calm, because you know you won’t be calm later. The trick makes room for a fact about any judge. Everyone has weak spots, and it’s easier to plan around them in advance.
And the oath gets tested almost immediately, when Critias tells him what a reputation the boy has for temperance. Socrates answers with lavish praise of the boy’s family. He mentions the poets who celebrated his father’s house, his uncle Pyrilampes, whose looks and stature were famous abroad, and the boy’s own looks, which Socrates says fall short of none of his ancestors. It’s exactly the kind of talk that could slide into an exception, the moment where a man might say that surely a boy like this doesn’t need any treatment for his soul. It’s the Sirens’ song in prose, sung by Socrates himself, and the test is whether the ropes hold.
But the praise ends in a condition. That’s the oath doing its job. Socrates says that if the boy is temperate, as Critias claims, he can have the remedy straightaway, and if not, the charm must come first, and then he hands the question to the boy himself. The beauty and the birth get their full due as compliments. Neither settles the question of the boy’s temperance, whatever Critias has heard. The boy gets every compliment and no free pass, which may be the most respectful thing anyone does for him all afternoon.
My verdict is that the oath is self-knowledge put to work. Socrates knows what beauty can do to his judgment. Because he arrives already tied to the mast, he can admire Charmides openly without letting that admiration decide what treatment to offer. In a dialogue that will struggle to define temperance, the oath shows one of its most practical forms, knowing your weak spots well enough to make your rules before you need them, and then keeping them when the song begins.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
What is the central similarity between Socrates’ oath and Odysseus’ order to be tied to the mast?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- Does making rules in advance demonstrate temperance, or does it reveal that a person lacks enough temperance to face temptation directly?→
- In what sense might refusing to give Charmides a “free pass” be more respectful than accepting Critias’ praise of him?→
- How does Socrates’ ability to praise Charmides openly while following his oath complicate the difference between experiencing desire and acting on it?→