Philosophy
The Playwright Storms the Stage
A borrowed definition sounds convincing until Socrates asks the person reciting it what it means.
The Platonic Dialogues: CharmidesSocrates compares Critias to a poet furious with an actor who is ruining his lines. The image fits a whole style of education, in which pupils perform their elders’ words, and it shows what happens when the performance turns into an examination.
Orientation
At a Glance
- A scene from the theaterSocrates likens Critias’ anger to that of a poet watching an actor mishandle his verses.
- Learning by heartIn the Protagoras, boys memorize poetry in the hope that they will imitate the people it praises.
- A performer under questioningIn the Ion, Socrates asks whether a performer’s command of Homer amounts to the knowledge he claims to have.
- The playwright answers backWhen Charmides cannot explain the borrowed definition, Critias takes over and must explain what doing one’s own business means.
Charmides 162b–e, 162e–163c, 163c–164a · Protagoras 325e–326a · Ion 530b–c, 535d–e, 541e–542b · Sisyphus fragment DK 88 B 25
Socrates reaches for a theater image to describe Critias’ outburst. When Charmides fumbles the saying about doing one’s own business and makes out that it has been refuted, Critias, Socrates tells us, “seemed to me as angry with Charmides as a poet is with an actor who makes a mess of the poet’s own verses.” It’s a vivid picture, a playwright sitting in the audience and watching a performer butcher his best lines until he can’t take it anymore and storms the stage himself. Plato chose the image carefully, and it repays a closer look, since it’s the sort of detail that tells you Socrates is enjoying himself even while he narrates a tense moment.
The simile fits Critias better than it might seem, given Critias’ association with dramatic verse. Sextus Empiricus quotes a speech about the invention of the gods and credits it to Critias. Another ancient source, Aëtius, associates its opening lines with Euripides’ Sisyphus. The authorship is uncertain, but the tradition makes it tempting to hear a small joke at Critias’ expense in the picture of a playwright listening to his own lines go wrong.
The simile also describes a whole model of education. In Plato’s Protagoras, Protagoras describes teachers setting the works of good poets before their pupils to read and learn by heart, in the hope that the boys would imitate the good men in the poems. The poets are a kind of moral textbook in that account. Charmides shows how easily the exercise can stop halfway. A boy can learn to deliver the lines and still be stumped when someone asks him what they mean.
Plato has a whole dialogue about where that model breaks down. In the Ion, Socrates meets a rhapsode, a professional performer of Homer, who can recite the poems beautifully and move an audience to tears, and Socrates says a good performer must understand the poet’s meaning. Ion claims he can explain Homer better than anyone, but under questioning he settles for being called divinely inspired. The comparison has its limits. Ion is proud of his ability to explain Homer, while Charmides admits when pressed that he can’t explain the line he’s borrowed.
Then the performance turns into an examination, and that’s the real disturbance in the scene. As long as the boy simply recites the saying, the author is safe, since a recited line never has to explain itself. But Socrates asks the actor what the line means, and the actor can’t say, so the play stops making sense in front of the audience, and the author is forced to come out of the wings and take responsibility for words he had been happy to let someone else deliver. Recitation hides the gap between words and their meaning, and questioning exposes it.
There’s a neat irony buried in the image, too. The phrase Socrates uses is “the poet’s own verses,” and the saying being mangled is about doing “one’s own business,” so you can see Critias rushing to protect what is his. It’s as if he acts out the definition in the very moment he comes to defend it. If protecting your own words means losing your composure over them, it’s hard to see how that could count as temperance. Plato was good at this kind of joke, where a character acts out the very definition he’s defending and shows its limits in the process.
The disturbance turns out to be good for the boy. Once the author is on stage and the actor is off the hook, Charmides gets to watch the playwright try to explain his own lines under questioning, which is a far better education than reciting them ever was. Critias draws distinctions between making, doing and working, and Socrates asks him to say more plainly what they amount to. Charmides gets to hear how much work it takes to turn a fine-sounding formula into an answer he can examine. That’s the real education going on in the scene, and it’s happening to the boy even though he’s no longer the one being asked.
My verdict is that the poet-and-actor simile captures the weakness of education built on performing elders’ words, and the Charmides shows the moment that weakness comes to light. A pupil who delivers his teacher’s lines can make the teacher look wise for as long as nobody asks questions, and the instant somebody does, the actor stumbles and the author has to step out from behind the curtain. Socrates turns the performance into a conversation. The boy gets to watch his guardian take responsibility for a line he was happy to let someone else deliver, and he gets to hear the questions that follow.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
According to the article, what does Socratic questioning reveal that recitation can conceal?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- If a student can accurately repeat a wise saying but cannot explain it, what—if anything—has the student learned?→
- How does Critias’s anger complicate his attempt to defend a definition of temperance?→
- When Socrates turns performance into conversation, what responsibilities shift from the pupil to the teacher or author?→