Renaissance
The Mona Lisa’s Familiar Face
Pater recognizes a sitter and a familiar Leonardo expression in the same portrait. An October 1503 note helps separate the historical record from the stories told about the smile.
The Renaissance (1893)Vespucci names Lisa del Giocondo while the portrait is underway. Vasari and Pater offer later accounts of the smile, which looks back toward the workshop and across Leonardo’s other work.
Orientation
At a Glance
- A name in the marginAgostino Vespucci names Lisa del Giocondo in an October 1503 annotation to Cicero.
- Two heads and an old painterVespucci mentions Lisa and Saint Anne while comparing Leonardo’s practice to Apelles’ habit of bringing one part of a picture further than the rest.
- A story about the sittingsVasari says music and jesters kept Lisa merry. Pater uses that story to imagine the sitter’s contribution to the expression.
- A portrait kept by the painterThe Louvre dates the panel to 1503–19 and records that Leonardo kept it to continue working on it.
The Renaissance · Leonardo da Vinci, pp. 82–83, portraiture and the recurring face · Leonardo da Vinci, note 198 · Leonardo da Vinci, note 199
Pater starts where everyone starts, with the things you’d recognize from across a crowded gallery. “We all know the face and hands of the figure, set in its marble chair, in that circle of fantastic rocks, as in some faint light under sea.” Then he says something that sounds like an aside and is really the whole problem, “Besides, the picture is a portrait,” and soon he’s arguing that “from childhood we see this image defining itself on the fabric of his dreams,” so that we “might fancy that this was but his ideal lady, embodied and beheld at last.” Those claims describe two things Pater sees at once, a likeness of a woman and an expression he recognizes from other work by the same painter. The question is whether the evidence lets us say which parts of the panel belong to which claim.
The record side is now very solid, starting with the Louvre’s own title, given in the edition’s note. The Louvre identifies Lisa Gherardini as the sitter, and Vasari says her husband, the silk merchant Francesco del Giocondo, asked Leonardo to paint her. The clinching evidence turned up in 2005 at Heidelberg, in the margin of an old printed Cicero, in a note transcribed by Heidelberg University, where Agostino Vespucci, a clerk in the Florentine chancery, noted in October 1503 that Leonardo was then working on the head of Lisa del Giocondo. That’s a contemporary naming the sitter at the time, which is about as good as Renaissance evidence gets.
But the whole note complicates the record in the very act of confirming it. Vespucci wrote it beside Cicero’s remark that the Greek painter Apelles perfected the head and bust of his Venus and left the rest only begun, and comments that Leonardo does the same in all his pictures, giving as examples the head of Lisa del Giocondo and that of Anne, the mother of the Virgin. So the first witness to the portrait files it next to the Saint Anne Leonardo was designing in the same years and treats both heads as products of one method, a face brought to a high finish while everything else waited. A contemporary already put the two faces side by side as examples of Leonardo’s way of working.
For the origin of that face Pater points to an inherited type. In the folio of drawings Vasari owned, he says, were designs by Verrocchio, “faces of such impressive beauty that Leonardo in his boyhood copied them many times,” and he finds there the “germinal principle” of “the unfathomable smile, always with a touch of something sinister in it, which plays over all Leonardo’s work.” In his life of Verrocchio, Vasari praises the women’s expressions and hair and says that Leonardo imitated the drawings for their beauty. Pater goes further, picking out one expression as the ancestor of the smile. The idea of a family resemblance isn’t silly, though, since Verrocchio’s bronze David in Florence wears a small, pleased smile of its own, and the same tilted head and curling mouth keep turning up in Leonardo’s angels, Madonnas and saints.
The third layer is the stories about the sittings, and Pater uses one of them as proof of portraiture. “That there is much of mere portraiture in the picture,” he says, “is attested by the legend that by artificial means, the presence of mimes and flute-players, that subtle expression was protracted on the face.” The legend is Vasari’s, who says Leonardo kept musicians, singers and jesters around her to keep her merry. It’s a delightful image, the first celebrity photo shoot with a live band, but the account does not establish that Vasari witnessed a sitting. He also describes eyebrows and color in the lips and cheeks that Pater found harder to see, calling the crimson “lost for us.” A story like that is good evidence of how people explained the smile, and it tells us very little about how the smile was made.
Time is what settles the balance, and Pater half sees it when he asks whether the image came “in four years and by renewed labour never really completed, or in four months and as by stroke of magic.” The Louvre dates the panel to 1503–19 and concludes that Leonardo kept it to continue working on it. That long history gives us no stopwatch for the initial likeness. A visitor to Leonardo’s home in France in 1517 describes seeing a portrait of a Florentine lady painted from life, though he names Giuliano de’ Medici as the patron. The Louvre discusses whether that account refers to the same panel. What the painting’s long stay with Leonardo makes possible is a likeness that absorbed years of his thinking about faces.
The case for a plain portrait still has real weight, and it lives in the very places Pater named first. The bare hands, one resting on the other at the arm of the chair, and the dark dress give the figure the ordinary physical presence of someone sitting in a room. The case for the repeated face is strongest in the face itself, in the smile and eyes that come back in the Saint Anne, the Louvre’s Saint John and the drawings, the part a painter who kept the panel for fifteen years had the most time to refine.
My verdict is that the Mona Lisa is both, in layers you can roughly map onto the panel. Vespucci’s note records Lisa under her married name, while the hands and clothes give the portrait some of its particularity. The repeated face lives in the smile and the modeling around the eyes, the parts Leonardo treated, in Vespucci’s own comparison, like Apelles finishing the head of a goddess, and could keep refining as long as the panel stayed with him. The sitting story belongs to Vasari’s account of how a likeness could hold such an expression. Vespucci records the portrait as a work in progress, and Pater asks what it means to see an individual through a look that feels familiar from other pictures. That question takes me back to the hands and mouth he asked us to look at in the first place.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
Why does Vespucci’s note both strengthen and complicate the case that the painting is a portrait of Lisa del Giocondo?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- If the face resembles expressions in Leonardo’s other works, how should that affect our understanding of the painting as a likeness of one particular woman?→
- Why might Vespucci’s comparison between Lisa’s head and Saint Anne’s head be more significant than a simple identification of the sitter?→
- How does the painting’s long period in Leonardo’s possession complicate any attempt to separate what came from the original sitting from what came from his continuing artistic reflection?→