Philosophy
The Kid Who Walks Nicely
Charmides describes temperance as quiet, orderly conduct. Socrates tests the idea with examples from the writing lesson and the wrestling floor, where moving quickly can be the finer thing to do.
The Platonic Dialogues: CharmidesA well-behaved boy and a temperate person can look alike. Charmides’ first answer asks how much we can tell about character from the way someone carries himself.
Orientation
At a Glance
- Quietness as temperanceCharmides says temperance shows up in the way a person walks, talks and goes about things. In his first answer, those actions are orderly and quiet.
- Good conduct in publicAristophanes’ Clouds pictures boys marching quietly to a music lesson. Xenophon describes a Spartan ideal of young men walking silently with their eyes down.
- Quickness can be the finer thingSocrates gets Charmides to agree that quickness can be better in writing, wrestling and learning. If temperance is always admirable, it can’t just be a slow or quiet manner.
- From practice to characterAristotle says people become temperate through temperate acts. The question Charmides has to face is what would make his well-practiced manners an expression of temperance.
Charmides 154c–155a, 155c–e, 159a–b, 159b–d, 159d–160b, 160b–e · Aristophanes, Clouds 961–964 · Xenophon, Constitution of the Lacedaemonians 3.4, 3.5 · Aristotle, Nicomachean Ethics 2.1
When Charmides finally answers the question of what temperance is, he describes a way of moving through the world. After hanging back at first and not wanting to answer at all, he says temperance is “doing everything in an orderly way and quietly,” walking in the streets and talking and doing everything else in the same manner, and then he sums it up by saying, “I think what you are asking about is a kind of quietness.” It’s a picture rather than a definition, the picture of a boy who never runs, never shouts, never shoves his way to the front and never makes a scene in public, and you can almost hear the voice of every adult who ever told him to walk, not run, and to use his indoor voice.
That answer would have sounded familiar to some of his audience. In Aristophanes’ Clouds, a character nostalgic for the good old days of Athenian schooling describes how boys used to be raised, never heard to make a sound and walking in good order through the streets to the music teacher’s house. Xenophon describes young Spartans walking with their hands tucked inside their cloaks, eyes on the ground and mouths shut, so modest that you’d sooner hear a stone statue speak than one of them, and he says they’re more modest than brides in the bridal chamber. Aristophanes gives us a comic picture of what an older teacher wants to see. Xenophon is describing Sparta. Both help us picture how a well-raised boy might be expected to look in public.
The answer is plausible enough for Socrates to test. “People do say, you know, Charmides,” he replies, “that quiet people are temperate,” and how someone carries himself can tell you something. A person who doesn’t lunge after whatever catches his eye might be showing some self-control. The boy’s answer points to a possible connection between the inside and the outside of a person, the same connection his own appearance raised at the start of the dialogue, when Socrates asked whether a soul as fine as his body came with the package.
The trouble is that a manner is a sign, and signs mislead. A con man can walk as quietly as a saint, and the calmest person in the room is sometimes the one running the scheme, while a temperate surgeon may have to work fast in an emergency and a temperate soldier may have to sprint, so the sign can show up without the virtue and the virtue can show up without the sign. Even when the quietness is genuine, it can grow out of self-control but also out of fear, laziness, sulking or plain shyness, which is why nobody sensible treats a firm handshake as proof of honesty or a soft voice as proof of a gentle heart.
Socrates attacks the definition by showing that quickness is often finer than quietness, in writing, reading, music, wrestling, learning and thinking. The two have agreed that temperance is something fine. If a quick action can be finer than a quiet one, quietness won’t be enough to define it. The boy’s answer describes a surface where temperance might, on a good day, show up. It’s like defining a good driver as someone who drives slowly, which describes plenty of good drivers and also plenty of lost tourists and people texting at the wheel.
That’s why Charmides’ first definition is so revealing about him. It describes temperance from the outside, the way parents and teachers and the guys at the gym see a well-behaved boy, before asking what it feels like to make a temperate choice. Socrates seems to clock this, because when he asks for a second try, he tells the boy to “pay closer attention and look within yourself” and to think about what sort of person temperance makes you, which is an invitation to move from how virtue looks to what it is. Coming from a man who was knocked sideways by the boy’s looks when they sat together, it’s also a pointed reminder that appearances aren’t the whole story.
Good manners can have a part in learning how to behave, a bit like training wheels on a bike. Aristotle would later make habituation central to his account of virtue. He says we become temperate by doing temperate acts. A practiced manner might help to build the virtue. Treating it as the virtue itself is like mistaking the training wheels for the bike.
My verdict is that the well-behaved boy and the good person can look exactly alike for a long time, and that’s precisely why the first definition fails. Charmides has given a useful social sign, the calm bearing that often goes with self-control, but a sign can be faked, can be missing when the virtue is there, and can come from the wrong source, so it can’t tell you what makes conduct good. Socrates’ refutation pushes him to look past the quiet manners he’s described toward what those manners might express. It’s a question we can ask of our own good habits, especially the ones we keep when nobody’s watching.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
Why does Socrates’ comparison of quickness and quietness undermine Charmides’ first definition of temperance?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- If quiet conduct can arise from self-control, fear, laziness, or shyness, what would you need to know before judging whether someone’s behavior expresses virtue?→
- Can outward habits eventually shape inward character, or must a temperate action already come from the right motive to count as virtuous?→
- Which habits do you keep when nobody is watching, and what—if anything—do those habits reveal about your character?→