Philosophy

The Entourage Walks In First

The young man everyone follows ends up promising to follow Socrates, at his guardian’s urging.

Before Charmides says a word, the room already knows how famous he is, because his fans come through the door ahead of him, arguing with each other. Plato shows you what that kind of fame is made of, and then flips it on the last page.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • An entrance in stagesRival admirers arrive first, so the gym learns Charmides’ reputation before it hears him speak.
  • Reputation under pressureWhen asked whether he is temperate, Charmides weighs his own answer against what Critias and the others already believe.
  • From spectacle to conversationSocrates offers to examine temperance with him, giving Charmides a way to begin without having to praise or disparage himself.
  • Who follows whomThe boy who arrived with followers promises to follow Socrates. His promise is also an act of obedience to Critias.

Charmides makes the kind of entrance you only get when you’re the hottest name in town, which is to say that he doesn’t make it himself. First a group of young men comes through the door “trading insults with one another,” then another crowd follows on behind, and only after that, with the room already buzzing, does the boy himself appear, with “many other lovers” trailing along at the back. Critias reads the whole thing like a forecast and tells Socrates that these are the admirers of the one who is “thought the most beautiful,” so before anybody has heard Charmides say a word, everybody knows exactly where he ranks.

Anyone who has spent five minutes online knows this move, because it’s the way you can tell someone is blowing up before you’ve ever heard them, by the size of the crowd at the stage door or the follower count under their name. It works because a crowd is a kind of argument, since if this many people are following him, he must be something, and Plato’s wording leans on that logic by introducing the boy as the one “thought” most beautiful, so that his beauty is a matter of what people think. The procession turns reputation into something you can see, and the room reads it before it has any other information to go on.

The funny part is what the fans are actually doing. They aren’t cheering for Charmides or even looking at him, since he hasn’t arrived yet, and what they’re doing instead is insulting each other. These are his “lovers,” young men a bit older than the boy who were courting him in the way Athenian custom allowed, and the first thing Plato shows us about their love is that it’s a competition. Whatever they feel about Charmides, the energy in that doorway is all rivalry, who’s closest and who’s winning, so the crowd that looks like it’s all about him is mostly about itself.

The same thing happens a few minutes later on the bench, when the boy sits down and every man shoves his neighbor to get the seat beside him, which is the same rivalry with even less dignity. Even the boys in the room, the ones too young to be rivals, are gazing at him in silence as if he were a statue, so the whole gym has organized itself around Charmides without his having done anything at all. Everything we know about him at this point comes from the people around him, which means the procession tells you a great deal about Athens and almost nothing about the boy.

That’s exactly why Socrates wants him to sit down and talk, because a fan base can’t tell you whether someone is any good, it can only tell you how many people think so, and Socrates’ whole approach is to swap the procession for a conversation. The first real test comes when Socrates asks him straight out whether he agrees with Critias that he already has enough temperance, and the answer shows that Charmides has been living inside the crowd’s opinion of him. He blushes, and then he lays out the bind he’s in. If he says he isn’t temperate, it’s an odd thing to say against himself, and he’ll be showing up “Critias here as a liar, and many others too who think I am temperate,” but if he says he is, he’ll be praising himself, which “will probably seem obnoxious.”

Plenty of readers see the blush and the refusal to boast as temperance in its everyday form, modesty, on display before anyone has tried to define it, and I think they’re right. But look at what the bind is made of, because Charmides can’t answer a question about himself without reckoning with what his admirers think, since their opinion has hardened into a fact about him that he’d have to contradict. The entourage that walked in ahead of him is now sitting inside his head. Socrates’ way out is gentle and smart, to look into the question together “so that you won’t be forced to say what you don’t want to,” which takes it out of the crowd’s hands and puts it into a conversation between two people.

Now jump to the last page, because Plato flips the procession. Critias tells his ward that it will be proof he’s temperate “if you let Socrates charm you and don’t desert him, great or small,” and Charmides answers, “I’ll follow him and not desert him.” The boy who walked into the gym with a crowd following him walks out promising to be somebody’s follower, which is about as complete a reversal of status as you can pull off in a single afternoon, and for the moment the celebrity has become the student and the fan base has nothing left to do.

There’s a catch, though, and Plato doesn’t hide it, because Charmides says he’ll follow Socrates on his guardian’s orders, adding that he’d be “doing something terrible” if he didn’t obey Critias. Even his decision to become Socrates’ follower is an act of following Critias, and Plato’s readers knew which of those two men the boy really ended up following. That’s what makes the entourage scene more than color, since it’s the “before” picture of a young man whose life is shaped by the people walking ahead of him and behind him, and the dialogue’s hope, fragile as it turns out to be, is that a conversation could teach him to walk on his own.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

What is the article’s main point about the crowd accompanying Charmides?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.