Renaissance
The Circle Teaches the Angels to Bow
Botticelli uses a round frame to gather angels around Mary and her book. Pater reads her bowed head as dejection, where the Uffizi sees absorption.
The Renaissance (1893)The same tilt of a head can follow the curve of a panel and suggest more than one feeling. Botticelli’s round Madonnas give Pater’s reading of sorrow a visible test.
Orientation
At a Glance
- The round frame gives the figures a curve to followBotticelli fits inclined heads and shoulders inside the upper arc. Pater’s word depress means that the angels lower their heads.
- The book brings the group togetherIn the Magnificat, two angels hold the crown while others gather by the book. The Christ Child guides Mary’s hand as she writes.
- One bowed head suggests two moodsThe Uffizi calls Mary engrossed. Pater sees a woman whose pen nearly falls from her hand while she writes words of praise.
- The pomegranate changes what we noticeIn the other round painting, the fruit can suggest Christ’s future suffering. That symbol makes the figures’ sadness easier to read in the picture itself.
The Renaissance · Sandro Botticelli, pp. 41–42, the round Madonnas and Mary’s book · Sandro Botticelli, note 99 · Sandro Botticelli, note 101
Pater mentions the angels almost in passing, in a sentence about collections. “Hardly any collection of note is without one of these circular pictures, into which the attendant angels depress their heads so naïvely.” The edition’s note explains that depress simply means lower, and that in the round format, called a tondo, tilted heads and bent shoulders fit the upper arc and help make the figures’ inward attention visible. That small note contains a whole theory of composition, and it’s worth testing on the most famous of these pictures, since Pater himself goes on to describe the Madonna of the Magnificat, now in the Uffizi, in a way that turns its geometry into a story about the Virgin’s state of mind.
In Renaissance Florence, painted devotional tondi often hung in private homes. The format could also serve a civic setting. Botticelli’s Madonna of the Pomegranate still has its original frame of gold lilies on blue. The Uffizi links it tentatively to a 1487 payment for a round Madonna for a Florentine administrative body, whose location at the time is uncertain. A round frame gives the painter an arc along which to arrange the figures.
Botticelli turns that constraint into meaning, as the Madonna of the Magnificat shows, a picture painted in the early 1480s and nearly four feet across, in which five wingless angels in fashionable Florentine dress crowd around the Virgin. Two above hold a crown over her head, a small gold circle repeating the great circle of the frame, and three at the left gather around a book in which she is writing, while the Child on her lap rests his hand on a pomegranate and guides her writing hand. The heads near the edge bend inward along the curve, and the effect is that the whole circle leans toward one point, the place where the pen meets the page. Their posture helps lead the eye toward the writing, even as the two angels above draw attention to the crown.
The book is the test of what that attention is about. On the right page Mary writes the opening of the Magnificat, the song she sings in Luke’s Gospel, beginning “My soul doth magnify the Lord,” and the left page holds part of the Benedictus, the song of Zechariah. The edition’s note glosses Pater’s list of texts, the Ave, the Magnificat and the Gaude Maria, as Hail Mary, My soul magnifies the Lord, and Rejoice, Mary. These are words of exultation, and the circle concentrates all its bowing heads on the moment they’re being written, so the composition says, as plainly as geometry can, that this act matters more than anything else in the room.
Pater reads the same picture very differently, in a passage of real beauty. The Child guides her hand “to transcribe in a book the words of her exaltation,” and the young angels, “glad to rouse her for a moment from her dejection, are eager to hold the inkhorn and to support the book. But the pen almost drops from her hand, and the high cold words have no meaning for her.” He has already told us that these Madonnas are peevish-looking and that “her choice is on her face,” and he even makes the light an accomplice, “cast up hard and cheerless from below, as when snow lies upon the ground.” Where the composition shows concentration, Pater sees reluctance, and the head inclined along the curve becomes, in his reading, the posture of a woman burdened by an honor she never asked for.
The Uffizi’s own description calls her expression engrossed, and the gap between engrossed and dejected is exactly the gap the tondo opens. A lowered head can follow the curve and still leave the viewer to decide whether it means absorption, humility or sadness. Pater chooses sadness here, which fits his whole account of Botticelli’s figures as exiles from a fuller life. The circle doesn’t prove him wrong, but it shows that part of what he took for a mood is a shape the frame imposes, which a less committed viewer might read as simple attention.
The Madonna of the Pomegranate makes the same point from another angle. There six angels stand three to a side in strict symmetry, two of them carrying lilies and roses, and one wears a stole embroidered with the words of the angel’s greeting, Ave Maria gratia plena, Hail Mary, full of grace. The Uffizi describes the faces as thoughtful and touched with sadness, foreshadowing the Passion. Here the bowing heads frame the mother and the fruit, a traditional emblem of the suffering to come, so the circle’s inward lean and the picture’s sorrow work together, and Pater’s reading has more support in the subject itself.
My verdict is that the circle really does teach the angels to bow, and that Botticelli made the lesson expressive, using the curve to draw the figures into a scene of gathered attention. Pater was half right to call it naive, since the gesture looks artless, but the art lies precisely in making the constraint look like feeling. His reading of Mary’s bowed head belongs to the melancholy he finds elsewhere in Botticelli. The round frame makes room for that reading and for the simpler possibility that Mary is attending to the words she writes.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
How does the article argue that Botticelli turns the tondo's circular constraint into meaning in the Madonna of the Magnificat?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- How does recognizing the round frame as a compositional constraint change the way you interpret the figures' emotions?→
- What visual or thematic evidence would you weigh when deciding whether Mary appears engrossed, humble, or dejected?→
- If a formal constraint can be made to look like feeling, where should interpretation draw the line between artistic design and depicted psychology?→