Philosophy

The Adults Were the Ones Being Tested

The Charmides and the Laches both begin with concern for young people. The adults soon find that their own judgment is the thing under examination.

Two fathers ask for help with their sons, and a guardian vouches for his ward. In both dialogues, Socrates ends up questioning the adults.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The fathers want to do betterLysimachus and Melesias ask two generals about their sons’ education. They recall how little attention their own distinguished fathers could give them.
  • Nicias knows how this goesHe says a conversation with Socrates can lead anyone to give an account of his life. The generals then find their own understanding of courage under examination.
  • Critias takes overCritias first assures Socrates that his ward is temperate. When the boy cannot explain a definition, the guardian steps in and has to defend it himself.
  • The endings part companyIn the Laches, Lysimachus agrees that the adults need lessons too. In the Charmides, Critias orders his ward to keep going to Socrates.

The Laches opens with two fathers, Lysimachus and Melesias, who are worried about their sons. Each had a famous father of his own, Aristides the Just and the statesman Thucydides son of Melesias, and each admits with real candor that their fathers, busy with public affairs, neglected their upbringing, so that they have achieved nothing worth mentioning. Determined not to repeat the mistake, they ask two generals, Nicias and Laches, how their boys should be educated. It’s a touching scene, two obscure sons of great men trying to do better by their own children. Lysimachus is old by now, and his willingness to admit his failings at that age is the first sign of the humility that will set him apart later.

The conversation doesn’t stay on the boys for long. Nicias, who knows Socrates well, warns the fathers what will happen. Anyone who comes close to Socrates and enters into conversation with him, he says, even if the talk begins on another subject, is led round by the argument until he has to give an account of himself, of how he lives now and how he has lived, and Socrates won’t let him go until he has examined all of it. Nicias says he enjoys this, and the rest of the dialogue proves him right, as the generals, not the boys, are the ones whose understanding of courage is tested and found wanting. Laches says he likes a speaker whose deeds match his words. His respect for Socrates’ conduct gives him a reason to agree to the examination.

The Charmides follows the same arc with a different cast. It begins with a boy and his guardian, and Critias presents his ward as a finished product, assuring Socrates that Charmides is “thought far and away the most temperate of anyone nowadays.” For the first part of the dialogue Charmides is the one examined, but at 162c Critias, “eager to shine before Charmides and the company,” can’t contain himself any longer and takes over the defense of the definition his ward had borrowed from him. For most of the remaining discussion the boy is quiet, and it is the adult who ends up perplexed.

The contrast between the two sets of adults is telling. Lysimachus and Melesias begin humble, openly admitting that they were badly educated and don’t know how to educate their sons, and they ask for help. Critias begins proud, presenting his ward as already excellent and himself, by implication, as the author of that excellence. Yet both conversations end in the same place, with the responsible adults unable to say what the virtue in question is, and with Socrates candid about what he still doesn’t know. In the Laches he says he has had no teacher in how to make a person good and has never been able to pay the sophists.

The point is that responsibility for education doesn’t establish understanding of virtue. A father can love his sons and want the best for them, and a guardian can be proud of his ward and genuinely devoted to his success, and neither fact means they know what courage or temperance is. Both dialogues make the point by moving the examination upstream, from the child who is supposed to acquire the virtue to the adults who are supposed to know what it is and how it is acquired. Parents still learn the lesson, often when a child’s question about why something is right exposes how little they have thought about it themselves.

The Laches even ends with a proposal that makes the point explicit. Since none of them has turned out to know what courage is, Socrates suggests that they should all, old as they are, look for the best teacher they can find, first for themselves and then for the boys, and he adds that if anyone laughs at men their age going back to school, they should quote Homer, that shame is no good companion for a man in need. Lysimachus, the oldest, cheerfully agrees, and asks Socrates to come to his house the next morning to begin.

Critias never reaches that point, and that’s the sharpest difference between the two endings. In the Charmides, the guardian who has just been shown not to know what temperance is responds by ordering his ward to keep going to Socrates and declaring that doing so will prove the boy temperate. He sends the child back to school without going back himself, which is exactly the move the Laches warns against. The responsibility for education stays with the adult, but the need for education is placed entirely on the child. It’s a quiet echo of the self-knowledge theme, since the man who most needed to examine himself is the one who arranges for someone else to be examined.

The two conversations turn concern for the young into a test for the adults. Lysimachus welcomes the chance to learn alongside the boys. Critias uses his authority to send Charmides back to Socrates. Both men want something good for a child in their care, and the endings show two different ways to respond when the adult’s own judgment has been called into question.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

According to the article, what central lesson emerges when the dialogues shift their attention from children to adults?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.