Philosophy

Temperate but Tongue-Tied?

Charmides is asked to put his own sense of temperance into words.

Recognizing a face, judging a foul, and finding the right words for courage all raise the same question. How much can you understand before you can explain it?

Orientation

At a Glance

  • From a sense to an answerSocrates expects Charmides to have some impression of temperance if the virtue is present in him.
  • What practice can showPolanyi’s familiar face and Ryle’s distinction between kinds of knowing make room for understanding that is hard to explain.
  • Courage slips away in wordsLaches feels that he understands courage but struggles to say what it is. Socrates urges him to keep looking.
  • An open verdictAt the end of the Charmides, Socrates leaves open whether the boy has temperance, and the boy asks for the charm.

Charmides 158e–159b, 175e–176a, 176a–b · Laches 181b, 194b · Aristotle, Nicomachean Ethics 1141b14–22, 1143b11–14 · Michael Polanyi, The Tacit Dimension opening claim · Gilbert Ryle, Knowing How and Knowing That p. 8

The examination of Charmides rests on a chain of assumptions that Socrates lays out in a few lines. “If temperance is present in you,” he says, “you have some opinion about it.” If it really is in him, “it must give rise to some sense, from which you would have some opinion about it.” Then, dryly, Socrates asks whether the boy, “since you know how to speak Greek,” can tell them what it seems to be. Possession leads to a sense of the virtue, the sense to an opinion, and the opinion to speech. On that last point Charmides answers, “Perhaps.”

The first step, from having a virtue to having some sense of it, sounds plausible enough. A temperate person might feel the pull of an appetite and notice the steadiness with which she handles it. The second step is also easy to imagine. Once you notice something about yourself, you’re likely to form some view of what it is, however vague. Someone who only half understands her own patience can still have a rough idea of what it feels like to wait without getting cross.

The third step, from opinion to speech, is where things get shaky. The philosopher Michael Polanyi starts from the thought that “we can know more than we can tell.” You can recognize a familiar face in a crowd and still struggle to say how you did it. Gilbert Ryle makes a related distinction between knowing how and knowing that. Someone can ride a bicycle without being able to explain the physics of balance. A native speaker can form a perfectly good sentence without being able to state the rule she just followed.

Plato brings a similar difficulty to the surface in the Laches. Laches speaks as someone who took part in the retreat from Delium. Later, when he tries to say what courage is, he gets vexed with himself. He feels he has a grasp of it, but somehow it’s given him the slip and he can’t catch it in words. Socrates invites him to keep up the chase. We have Laches’ sense that he understands courage and his honest difficulty explaining it. The scene leaves open how much he knows.

Aristotle gives experience a place in practical wisdom. General principles matter, but the person who has to act also needs to see what is happening in this particular case. Aristotle says the judgments of experienced people deserve attention even when they offer them without proof. Their experience helps them notice what others miss. A good referee can recognize a foul before she could write a definition that covers every case, and she’d be a worse referee if she waited for the definition.

That puts pressure on Socrates’ test before any of the boy’s answers has been tried. He asks for an opinion so they can make a guess about whether the boy has temperance. The wording matters. The way Charmides talks about the virtue may give them a clue. The remark about speaking Greek makes the step from an impression to an account sound easy, but it’s quite a lot to ask of a person who has just said he doesn’t know what to answer.

The examination can survive that difficulty. At the end Socrates can still imagine Charmides being “most temperate in soul.” He tells the boy that “if you have it you are blessed” and invites him to see for himself whether he needs the charm. The boy still doesn’t know, and asks to be charmed every day. Socrates leaves room for the possibility that Charmides has the virtue even though they haven’t managed to say what it is.

My verdict is that you can have more of a virtue than you can put into words, and that the step from opinion to speech is where Socrates’ test needs the most care. The conversation can still help the boy find words for what he’s noticed and discover where those words fail. The real risk would be to take a tongue-tied answer for proof of an empty soul. Charmides asks to go on while the question is still open.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

Which link in Socrates’ chain of assumptions does the article identify as the most doubtful?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.