Philosophy
Showing Off for the Kid
The argument changes when Charmides’ guardian starts defending his own reputation.
The Platonic Dialogues: CharmidesBefore Critias jumps into the argument, Socrates says he was eager to shine in front of his ward and the crowd. When a teacher needs his pupil’s admiration, teaching and performing get tangled together, and the Charmides shows what that does to both of them.
Orientation
At a Glance
- An audience that mattersSocrates says Critias is eager to impress Charmides and the people watching before he takes over the argument.
- The first reactionCritias addresses his ward directly and defends the judgment of the man who supplied the definition.
- A change of responsibilitySocrates invites Critias to take over and examine whether doing one’s own business really is temperance.
- Two responses to doubtCritias covers up his perplexity before the crowd, while Charmides eventually says plainly that he cannot tell whether he has temperance.
Charmides 162b–e, 162e–163c, 163c–e, 169a–d, 176a–b · Hesiod, Works and Days 311 · Xenophon, Hellenica 2.4.19
Socrates gives us Critias’ state of mind just before he enters the argument, and it isn’t flattering. “Critias had plainly been on edge for some time,” he says, “and eager to shine before Charmides and the company,” holding himself back with difficulty until he couldn’t anymore. Notice who comes first in that sentence. It’s Charmides, the young man Critias is responsible for educating. Socrates’ wording invites us to wonder why his ward’s admiration matters so much to him.
That’s a common and slightly sad dynamic, and most of us have seen it. It’s the parent who has to win every argument with his teenager, the coach who can’t bear to be corrected in front of the team, or the professor who answers a student’s question in a way designed to show how much he knows rather than to help the student understand. In each case the adult’s authority has become tangled up with needing the young person’s admiration, and once that happens, every challenge from the young person feels like a threat instead of an opportunity. The young person picks up on it instantly, of course, which is why teenagers are so good at finding the sore spot.
Watch where Critias’ first words go when he finally speaks. He fixes his eyes on Charmides and says, “Do you really think, Charmides, that if you don’t know what the man meant who said that temperance was doing one’s own business, then he doesn’t know either?” The question defends the author’s competence. It’s aimed at the boy who just suggested, with a laugh, that the author might not understand his own words. Critias takes the challenge personally, and the meaning of the saying can wait.
Socrates steps in to redirect him, and the redirection is a lesson in itself. It’s no wonder the boy doesn’t know, at his age, Socrates says, but Critias can reasonably be expected to know, and if he agrees with the saying and takes the argument over, Socrates would much rather look into it with him to see whether it’s true. That moves the whole exchange from a contest between guardian and ward to an inquiry between two adults, and it puts the responsibility where it belongs, on the person who ought to understand the idea rather than on the person who repeated it. It’s a graceful way of telling Critias to stop arguing with the kid and start thinking with Socrates.
Critias accepts the invitation, but the performance doesn’t stop there. When Socrates presses him on a point, he answers with heavy sarcasm, “Oh yes,” and then, “I suppose I agreed that those who do other people’s business are temperate, just because I agreed that those who make other people’s things are!” before he launches into a learned display of distinctions between making, doing and working, complete with a quotation from Hesiod. It’s impressive in its way. The distinctions give Critias a way to defend his answer, and Socrates asks him to spell out what he means. Charmides, who started the exchange, is left to watch.
The difference between responsibility and performance comes down to whose understanding is the goal. A teacher who takes responsibility for his pupil’s understanding can say “Good question. I’m not sure. Let’s work it out,” because the point is that the pupil should end up knowing something. A teacher who is performing feels he has to look sure, because the point is that the audience, and especially the pupil, should go on admiring him, and those two aims pull in opposite directions the moment a hard question arrives. Most of us remember at least one teacher of each kind, and we remember what we learned from each.
The dialogue goes on to show exactly where that kind of performance leads. Later, when the argument corners him, Critias can’t admit that he’s stuck, and Socrates tells us that because he was used to being admired on every occasion, he was ashamed in front of the company and kept covering up his confusion. It’s a bad lesson to set before the boy. It makes knowledge look like a matter of never being caught at a loss. Charmides later served among the Ten in Piraeus while Critias was one of the Thirty in Athens, which gives their relationship a darker echo. Here, though, the boy can still say plainly when he’s unsure.
My verdict is that Critias’ need for his ward’s admiration quietly undermines his ability to teach him. Responsibility for a pupil’s understanding requires being willing to look uncertain in front of that pupil, and Critias, eager to shine, can’t afford that, so he defends his competence before he gets around to explaining the idea. Socrates can admit in the middle of an argument that he is at a loss. That gives the boy an example of someone who can keep thinking in front of an audience even after he’s lost his footing.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
What is the main effect of Socrates’ redirection after Critias challenges Charmides?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- When does a teacher’s desire to appear knowledgeable begin to interfere with a student’s understanding, and how might the teacher recognize that shift?→
- How does Socrates redirect the exchange without simply humiliating Critias, and what does that suggest about correcting someone who is acting defensively?→
- Can openly admitting uncertainty strengthen a teacher’s authority rather than weaken it? What conception of authority would make that possible?→