Philosophy

Same Command, Different Words?

Critias says the two commands at the heart of his argument amount to the same thing. That depends on what you know about yourself and whether the knowledge can guide you.

A horse buyer helps explain what knowing your limits looks like. Medea raises the harder question of what happens when you can see the better course and still leave it.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • What do you need to know?Knowing facts about yourself can leave your conduct untouched. Xenophon’s horse-buyer comparison points instead to a practical knowledge of what you can do and where your powers run out.
  • Can knowledge govern?In the Protagoras, Socrates asks whether knowing what is good can govern conduct when pleasure, anger or fear presses the other way. Critias’ equivalence needs knowledge with that sort of force.
  • Medea sees the dangerEuripides’ Medea understands the evil she is about to do, yet says her passion overcomes her plans. Her case puts pressure on the claim that understanding will reliably guide action.
  • The gap in the two commandsThe commands can converge if knowing yourself includes an understanding of your good that holds up under pressure. Critias asserts their equivalence and leaves the dialogue to test what such knowledge could be.

Charmides 164c–d, 164d–165a, 166a–c, 174d–175a · Plutarch, On the E at Delphi 394c · Xenophon, Memorabilia 4.2.24–29 · Protagoras 352b–d · Euripides, Medea 1078–1080 · Ovid, Metamorphoses 7.19–21

Critias makes his big claim in one breath and concedes the obvious objection in the next. He says that ‘Know thyself’ and ‘Be temperate’ “are the same, as the inscription says and as I say; but one might think them different.” It’s worth giving that other thought a hearing. The two commands can come to the same thing, but only if self-knowledge does two jobs. It has to tell you something that bears on how you live, and it has to make a difference when the time comes to act.

Start with what the knowledge is of. Knowing your height, blood type and birthday can come in handy without doing much for your temperance. A more promising way to hear the maxim is as a reminder of human limits. In Plutarch’s later dialogue on the letter E at Delphi, a speaker takes the phrase as a reminder of mortal nature and weakness. On that reading, you know something about yourself when you realize that some things are beyond your power. It’s the realization the victor needs just when the whole city is telling him he can do anything.

Xenophon gives a practical version in his Memorabilia. Socrates asks Euthydemus what a person would have to know to know himself. Imagine a horse buyer, he says. It takes more than learning the animal’s name. You look to see whether the horse is strong or weak, willing or stubborn, fast or slow. A person can learn something similar about his own powers and limits. Once he has, he can take on work he understands and think twice before trying what he has no idea how to do.

The second job is harder. Knowing your limits helps only if you give the knowledge some authority over what you do. In the Protagoras, Socrates asks whether knowledge can be dragged around like a slave by pleasure, anger or fear. He and Protagoras favor the stronger view. On that view, someone who genuinely knows what is good and bad will follow that knowledge even when other things pull at him. If that’s right, knowing what’s good for you might amount to having a grip on your conduct.

Medea makes you wonder. In Euripides’ play, before killing her children, she understands the evil she is about to do and says that her passion has the upper hand over her plans. Ovid gives the conflict to Medea at a different moment, when she’s trying to decide what to do about Jason. She sees and approves the better course and follows the worse. A defender of the Protagoras could say that seeing the wrong in a plan falls short of the kind of knowledge that can govern a choice. Medea forces that defender to explain what the difference amounts to.

The same question comes up in less terrible company. There’s the self-aware jerk who knows he’s selfish and announces that this is just who he is. There’s the manipulator who knows precisely how charming she can be and uses that knowledge to work on other people. There’s even the person who knows his faults in great detail and finds them fascinating. Their self-knowledge has a subject and can be accurate. You’d want to know more before saying it helps any of them live well.

So try hearing the two commands together. Know the things about yourself that bear on action, including your limits and what will do you good. Then ask whether that knowledge still guides you when something you want pulls the other way. If it does, you can see why Critias might call this kind of self-knowledge temperance. You can also see how much he has to show. The fact that somebody understands how vain he is gives us no reason by itself to expect him to stop showing off.

My verdict is that Critias has a philosophical position worth defending. His aside that people might think the commands different is an invitation to do the defending. The Charmides goes on to ask what self-knowledge is knowledge of and whether it can benefit us. That’s the work the inscription leaves for anyone who wants its words to guide a choice.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

According to the article, what must be true for “Know thyself” and “Be temperate” to amount to the same command?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.