Philosophy
Reading With the Ending in Mind
Plato’s readers could know what became of Critias and Charmides. The two men in the wrestling school still had choices to make, and the dialogue lets us read with both times in view.
The Platonic Dialogues: CharmidesThe future careers of Critias and Charmides give the last joke a darker sound. Reading from inside the encounter leaves room for the choices that lay ahead of them.
Orientation
At a Glance
- Readers know the outcomeCritias went on to lead the Thirty, and Charmides served in Piraeus. Both died fighting the democratic exiles at Munychia.
- Praise sounds differentCritias vouches for his ward’s temperance, and Socrates praises the family. The later careers give those compliments an irony the speakers cannot yet hear.
- Other futures were possibleMorson calls it sideshadowing when a reader remembers the alternatives open at the time. Charmides’ blush and interest in further discussion can still be taken seriously.
- Two times stay in viewThe later history sharpens the joke about force. What the characters intended and whether their arguments hold remain questions for the dialogue itself.
Charmides 154e–155a, 157c–e, 157e–158b, 176b–d · Xenophon, Hellenica 2.4.19 · Gary Saul Morson Narrative and Freedom
Read the Charmides with its ending in mind, and there are two endings to choose from. One is in Xenophon. Critias will lead the Thirty, Charmides will serve among the Ten in the Piraeus, and both will die fighting the democratic exiles at Munychia in 403. The other is in the wrestling school a generation earlier, among people who still have choices to make. Readers who know the history bring both endings to the room. How much weight should each carry?
The case for the historical reading is strong, because the dialogue seems to invite it. When Socrates says a boy so beautiful should also have a well-made soul, “coming from your family,” Critias assures him the boy is “thoroughly beautiful and good,” using the standard aristocratic phrase for a gentleman. Critias tells Socrates that Charmides “is thought far and away the most temperate of anyone nowadays,” and Socrates lavishes praise on the family’s beauty and virtue. Every one of those lines lands differently when you know what became of these men, and the ending, with its plotting, its orders and its talk of force, reads almost like a sketch of oligarchy in miniature. Even Socrates’ teasing about the family’s distinction sounds different once you know that its most powerful member would later decide which Athenians deserved to live.
History gives the praise and the joke about force a sharper sound. It gives the argument higher stakes too. A reader can see that the men will one day have occasion to exercise the judgment they’re trying to understand. The conversation about temperance still belongs to this afternoon, when a promise of more lessons can end in an affectionate joke.
The case for reading the encounter on its own terms is also strong. The literary critic Gary Saul Morson has warned against what he calls backshadowing, the habit of reading the past as if it pointed only toward what actually happened and judging people as if they should have seen it coming. Against it he recommends sideshadowing, keeping alive the other possibilities that were open at the time. In the wrestling school, Charmides is a teenager who blushes, hesitates and gives a modest answer, and nothing in the scene requires him to become a henchman of tyranny. Even the closing talk of force is spoken in fun, and a reader who hears only menace in it has stopped listening to the tone.
There are also things history plainly can’t establish, since it can’t tell us that Critias, around thirty and talking philosophy with a friend, already harbored the ambitions he acted on in his late fifties, or that every boast he makes is a symptom of future cruelty. It can’t tell us that Charmides’ modesty was false, or that his wish to be charmed every day was insincere. And it can’t tell us anything about whether the arguments are good, since a definition of temperance doesn’t become worse because its author later behaved intemperately.
Try rereading the end after learning who will give orders under the Thirty. It’s easy to hear the language of force as the moment that was always leading to Munychia. Then read Charmides’ request to be charmed every day once more. He’s just admitted that he can’t tell whether he has temperance. How far that moment might have taken him is a question that remains open to the people in the room.
The best practice holds both readings at once and lets each check the other. The historical reading supplies irony and stakes, and the encounter reading supplies fairness, a refusal to convict characters of crimes they haven’t yet committed. Where the later history can be heard, as in the closing talk of force, it deserves a place in the reading, and where a line makes perfect sense as ordinary conversation, as most of Charmides’ answers do, it should be allowed to mean what it means in the scene. Morson’s aim is a reading that lets the past be as open as the present feels to us, and the Charmides, with its open questions and its undecided young man, rewards exactly that kind of reading.
The later careers of Critias and Charmides give the talk of orders and force real weight. Keeping the encounter in view lets Charmides’ hesitation, his interest in the charm, and the humor of the last lines have weight too. A reader can hear the irony and still leave the boy’s next choice open.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
What does the article identify as the main danger of “backshadowing”?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- How can a reader decide when later historical knowledge genuinely illuminates an earlier scene and when it unfairly makes the outcome seem inevitable?→
- What would be lost if the closing talk of force were read only as playful conversation? What would be lost if it were read only as a warning of future tyranny?→
- If a person’s later conduct does not determine whether that person’s earlier argument was sound, what role—if any—should character and biography play in interpreting philosophical dialogue?→