Renaissance
Pater Takes the Long Way Round Through Como
A Florentine sculptor’s chapter opens with Tommaso Rodari at Como Cathedral. The detour shows how far Pater is willing to look for the restraint he prizes.
The Renaissance (1893)Pater finds quiet figures in places far from Florence and amid abundant ornament. Rodari and Mino show how sculptors’ careers complicate a style named for one region.
Orientation
At a Glance
- Rodari takes the essay outside TuscanyPater includes the sculptor of Como Cathedral beside Mino and Donatello. Rodari worked in Lombardy into the sixteenth century.
- A restrained figure can have a busy frameComo’s carved portals and the Colleoni Chapel carry abundant ornament. Pater attends to the quiet that can survive in the figures within such settings.
- Mino carried his practice between citiesMino made portraits and tombs in Florence and worked in Rome. His career gives a concrete example of a sculptor taking a manner with him.
- Vasari and Pater value imitation differentlyVasari thinks Mino followed Desiderio too closely. Pater’s praise invites us to see how an inherited way of carving can still be expressive.
The Renaissance · Luca della Robbia, p. 46, Mino and Maso del Rodario · Luca della Robbia, note 112 · Luca della Robbia, note 113 · Luca della Robbia, p. 47, Tuscan workmanship · Luca della Robbia, p. 48, restraint and the refinements of shadow · Luca della Robbia, pp. 50–51, tombs in Florence, Bergamo and Rome
Pater’s first paragraph on Luca della Robbia ends with a list of sculptors whose lives have vanished, and one name on it doesn’t belong to Florence at all. “Mino, the Raphael of sculpture, Maso del Rodario, whose works add a further grace to the church of Como, Donatello even,” he writes, before admitting that you ask in vain for their actual days. Mino and Donatello are Florentine stars, but Maso del Rodario, Tommaso Rodari in the modern spelling the edition’s note supplies, was a sculptor’s son from Maroggia on the shore of Lake Lugano who spent his working life in Lombardy, and his presence turns a list of Tuscan sculptors into a small map of northern and central Italy.
Rodari’s career makes the detour stranger the closer you look. Como Cathedral records that Rodari was commissioned in 1484 to complete statues on the façade and became engineer of the workshop in 1487. He worked with his brothers and apprentices on the church’s sculpture, including the north portal known as the Frog Door. He belongs, in other words, to the generation after Luca, working into the 1520s, so he doesn’t fit Pater’s “earlier half of the fifteenth century” at all, which tells you Pater is following a quality rather than a timeline.
It’s also an odd place to look for the restraint Pater prizes. Lombard sculpture of Rodari’s day was famous for abundance, and the Porta della Rana is a showpiece of it, a doorway framed by candelabra columns crawling with ornament, while the great Lombard project of the period, the façade of the Certosa di Pavia, buried its architecture under carved marble. The ornate Colleoni Chapel in Bergamo offers another example of that abundance, so if Pater wants artists who are “haters of all heaviness and emphasis,” the cathedral at Como is about the last building you’d expect him to send you to.
The answer has to be that the quality Pater means lives in figures rather than in frames, and that he was willing to find it inside busy settings. His own examples a few pages later confirm that he thinks this way, since his roll of noble tombs includes the effigy of Medea Colleoni, which Giovanni Antonio Amadeo carved and which now stands in her father’s chapel in Bergamo. Pater’s “Tuscan sculptors” turn out to name a temperament he recognizes wherever a carved face goes still, and his geography simply follows the temperament wherever it happens to lead, across the Apennines and up to the lakes.
Mino supplies the other half of the story, because his career shows how the quality actually moved. Mino worked in both Florence and Rome. In Florence he made the monument to Count Ugo that Pater admires in the Badia. In Rome he carved a bust of Cardinal Guillaume d’Estouteville. The Florentine manner rode along with him, and Pater’s remark that the finest effigies “abound in the churches of Rome” is partly a tribute to Tuscans like Mino who carried it south.
Vasari’s life of Mino makes a complaint of the same process. Vasari says Mino studied Desiderio da Settignano’s manner so closely that he neglected the study of nature. A pupil who always follows, in Vasari’s view, gives up the chance to go farther. Vasari meant it as a put-down, but it’s also a fair account of how a style crosses cities, because a manner is portable in a way that a city’s light and a patron’s taste aren’t, and an apprentice can carry a teacher’s way of softening a cheek from Settignano to Rome in his own two hands.
Pater’s nickname for Mino, “the Raphael of sculpture,” makes the same point from the friendlier side. Raphael was the great absorber, the painter who soaked up Perugino, Leonardo and Michelangelo and turned them into a sweetness that looked like his own, and calling Mino his sculptural twin praises exactly the gift Vasari distrusted, the knack of taking a manner from elsewhere and making it gentle and whole. Once you see that, the detour through Como stops looking like a slip, since Pater is tracing a family of sensibilities whose members trained each other, copied each other and moved for work, the way a sound passes between bands who share a rehearsal space and a few session players.
My verdict is that the Como detour shows the quality Pater calls Tuscan was really a portable way of carving, carried by apprentices, imitators and traveling masters, and finding it in Lombardy is a credit to his eye rather than a lapse in his geography. It crossed cities because workshops crossed cities, it crossed commissions because the same hands made altarpieces, busts and tombs, and it crossed kinds of work because the habit of a soft, still face doesn’t care whether it sits on a pope’s tomb or a cathedral door. The cost is that “Tuscan” becomes the name of a temperament rather than a place, and Pater, who was always more interested in temperaments than in maps, seems perfectly happy to pay it.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
What does Rodari’s later career most strongly suggest about why Pater includes him among artists associated with the earlier fifteenth century?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- When Pater uses “Tuscan” to describe a temperament rather than a geographic origin, what does that interpretation clarify, and what might it obscure?→
- How does the contrast between ornate settings and restrained figures complicate the way we assign a single style to an artwork or building?→
- If artistic imitation can be viewed as either a failure of originality or a means of carrying style across cities, what criteria should determine which interpretation is more persuasive?→