Renaissance

Pater’s Rule Against Color Meets Its Exception

Pater calls color an awkward borrowing in sculpture and loves the blues and whites Luca fires onto clay. Ancient sculpture gives us another reason to test his rule.

Glaze gives Luca’s reliefs a kind of brightness that white stone cannot produce. The essay’s praise of that brightness sits beside a rule that gives color very little credit.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • Pater sets a high bar for sculptureHe wants carved form to suggest the play of life through its own means. In his rule, color looks like something borrowed from painting.
  • Glaze changes how a relief meets the lightThe kiln makes color part of the fired surface. A white figure against blue gains an outline and luminosity that matter at a distance.
  • Ancient sculpture complicates the ruleEvidence of painted and gilded surfaces shows how often ancient sculpture used color. Surviving white marble tells only part of that history.
  • Luca gives color a purpose of its ownThe pale fruit and flat blue belong to the relief’s design. Their effect helps explain why Pater responds to the work even when his rule gives him little room to praise it.

Pater lays down a rule in the middle of the Luca essay that sounds final. “The use of colour in sculpture is but an unskilful contrivance to effect, by borrowing from another art, what the nobler sculpture effects by strictly appropriate means,” he writes, and the real goal, he says, is “to get not colour, but the equivalent of colour.” Yet the same essay opens with Luca’s “pale blue and white earthenware” falling like fragments of sky into Tuscan streets, and it later praises the colored glaze as “colours of art, colours not to be attained in the natural stone,” and the fruit garlands colored “a little paler than nature,” so the man who banned color from noble sculpture is plainly in love with a colored sculptor.

The first way out is to say the glaze isn’t paint at all. Luca’s color is fused onto the clay in the kiln, so it becomes part of the surface rather than a coat laid over it, and it lasts, which is why Vasari called the invention almost eternal. The workshop’s glazes relied on colorants that could withstand firing. White and blue became especially recognizable, and surviving reliefs also use greens, yellows and other colors. On this reading the color belongs to the material the way grain belongs to wood, and Pater’s objection to borrowing doesn’t apply, since nothing has been borrowed from painting and the potter’s color is as native to fired clay as the white is to Carrara marble.

The second way out is that the color does exactly the job Pater set for sculpture. He wants every great style to relieve form of “its stiffness, its heaviness, and death,” and a white figure against a blue ground does that brilliantly, lifting a Madonna off the wall and opening a patch of sky in a dark street, which is the effect he describes so vividly on his first page. On this reading Luca’s color succeeds because it enlivens the form, and the distinction between color and its equivalent stops mattering once both produce the same result, the play of life in a hard material.

The third answer is the uncomfortable one, which is that the rule needs revising. As the edition’s note points out, ancient sculpture was painted, gilded and inlaid, and the evidence has been piling up for two centuries, from traces of pigment on Greek marbles to the experimental reconstructions in the Metropolitan Museum’s Chroma exhibition. Pater’s “nobler sculpture,” pure and uncolored, is partly an invention of eighteenth-century taste, the dream of white antiquity that Winckelmann helped spread, and the rule rests on a past that never existed.

Victorian Britain shows how strong that dream was, and how badly it could mislead careful people. John Gibson exhibited his Tinted Venus at the London International Exhibition of 1862. The tinted marble figure, now in the Walker Art Gallery, put the question of sculptural color in front of Victorian viewers. The dream lasted well into the next century. A later British Museum account submitted to Parliament records that copper tools and abrasives were used without authorization on some of the Parthenon sculptures as they were prepared for the Duveen Gallery in the late 1930s.

The other side deserves its due, because Pater’s suspicion of color has a sound instinct inside it. Much painted sculpture of his day looked like Gibson’s Venus did to her critics, a marble woman made up to look real, and that’s just the hard realism he warns against a few lines earlier, color used to compete with living flesh and losing. Luca’s color makes the convention easy to see. Flesh is white, the background is flat enamel blue, and even the fruit comes out “a little paler than nature.”

That points to what really decides the case, because the line that matters isn’t between fired color and painted color, or between color and its equivalent, but between color that imitates nature and color that works as a convention, and Pater’s own words of praise sort neatly onto the right side of it, “colours of art,” colors “subdued a little,” colors no stone could supply. His taste was always sounder than his rule, and his rule was simply drawn in the wrong place, around color itself rather than around realism.

My verdict is that all three answers hold some truth, but the third one wins. The glaze is integral and it does enliven the form, but Pater’s rule fails on its own premise, since noble ancient sculpture was colored, and his admiration for Luca contradicts it on every page where it appears. What survives is a narrower and better principle, that color belongs to sculpture on its own terms when it’s conventional, built into the surface and kept below nature, and on those terms Luca isn’t the exception to the rule but the best argument for rewriting it.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

Why does the article's first proposed defense of Luca claim that Pater's objection to sculptural color may not apply to his work?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.