Philosophy

Not Persuaded, Still Coming Back

Charmides questions Socrates’ closing judgment and still asks to see him again. Critias then gives the same commitment a different meaning.

Charmides wants the charm even after the inquiry stalls. His willingness to disagree with Socrates looks different from the obedience he promises his guardian.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • Charmides asks to returnAfter Socrates calls his own inquiry a failure, Charmides says he’s unconvinced and asks for the charm. The failure leaves him willing to continue.
  • What the examiner offeredAt the beginning Socrates proposed that they look into temperance together and gave Charmides the choice to leave it. That invitation gives him a reason to take further conversation seriously.
  • One Greek verb, two relationsCharmides uses forms of the same Greek verb when he speaks of being persuaded by Socrates and obeying Critias. The change of setting helps explain the difference in sense.
  • The guardian sets a testCritias says that continuing with Socrates will prove Charmides is temperate to him. A request for help becomes something Charmides’ guardian can order.

Charmides 158d–e, 169a–d, 175d–176a, 176a–c · Phaedo 91c

Socrates closes his last speech with advice that sounds like a resignation letter. Charmides, he says, should “regard me as a babbler, unable to inquire into anything whatever by argument,” and count himself happier the more temperate he is. If the boy took that at face value, the natural thing would be to thank Socrates politely and never see him again. Instead, after admitting he doesn’t know whether he has temperance, Charmides says, “I’m not altogether persuaded by you, though, Socrates, and I think I very much need the charm,” and he offers to be charmed every day.

The exact scope of his refusal is worth leaving open. Socrates has doubted his own ability and suggested that a temperate Charmides would have no need of the charm. Charmides has just said he doesn’t know whether he has temperance. What’s clear is that he has heard enough to question the advice and still wants Socrates’ help. His trust can survive disagreement because he’s asking Socrates to keep looking with him.

What might make someone want to return after the inquiry has stalled? Charmides has had a front-row seat. At the start Socrates proposed that they “look into it together” so that he “won’t be forced to say what you don’t want to.” He gave him the option of leaving it. Later Charmides heard Socrates admit his own perplexity and say he was “less aggrieved” on his own account than on Charmides’. Plato leaves the boy’s motives unstated and gives us these things he has seen and heard.

Think of a climbing guide who turns a party around below the summit because the weather looks wrong. A climber can be disappointed and find the guide easier to trust the next time. The decision showed that the guide could stop and explain what she was seeing. Socrates has just admitted that his inquiry came up short. Charmides may have more reason to continue with someone willing to admit that than with someone who could always give him a confident answer.

Trusting a person’s assistance can mean trusting that she’ll keep looking and take you seriously when you think she’s made a mistake. That leaves her conclusions open to scrutiny. In the Phaedo, Socrates tells his friends to give little thought to Socrates and much more to the truth. If they think he is wrong, he asks them to argue against him. Charmides’ last exchange shows what it can look like when someone keeps company with Socrates and reserves the right to question him.

There’s a turn in the Greek that sharpens the point. Charmides uses one form of a verb when he says he’s unconvinced by Socrates and another form of the same verb when he says he would be doing something terrible if he disobeyed Critias. In the first case, he can tell Socrates that the argument hasn’t persuaded him. In the second, he tells his guardian that he’ll do what he’s told. The same family of words brings the two relationships very close together.

Critias makes the change visible. “If you do this,” he tells Charmides, “it will be proof to me that you are temperate.” Charmides had wanted the charm because he was unsure whether he had temperance. Critias offers to treat his showing up as evidence that he does. When Charmides says he’ll obey his guardian, Critias makes it an order. An invitation to keep looking has become a condition the guardian can use to judge him.

My verdict is that Charmides’ disagreement tells us something about the help he wants. He can ask Socrates to continue without treating Socrates’ verdict as the last word. Then Critias offers another way to understand the same promise, as obedience that can be certified. The last few lines give both meanings to the act of coming back, and we have to listen for who gets to decide what it means.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

What does the article identify as the clearest significance of Charmides’ response to Socrates?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.