Renaissance
Meeting a Sculptor Who Left No Diary
Pater finds little record of Luca della Robbia’s inner life. The reliefs give him another kind of acquaintance with the sculptor.
The Renaissance (1893)The choir loft and the glazed Madonnas show what Luca paid attention to as a sculptor. They leave a different question open about what he felt on any particular day.
Orientation
At a Glance
- The chapter opens with an empty archivePater wants to know how the sculptors lived. He finds only a shadowy outline of their days.
- The reliefs preserve choicesThe placement of the singers and the tilt of a Madonna’s head show how Luca handled movement and stillness.
- Workshop practice complicates the signatureLuca’s nephew Andrea carried the family style forward. A familiar gesture in a relief may belong to habits shared by several hands.
- Intimacy has limitsA sculpture can make its maker’s habits of attention feel close. The mood in which the artist carved it remains a separate question.
The Renaissance · Luca della Robbia, p. 46, the sculptors’ missing lives · Luca della Robbia, pp. 51–52, labour and frugality · Luca della Robbia, p. 52, the seal of inwardness · Luca della Robbia, note 131
Pater begins his essay on Luca della Robbia with a frustration any biographer would recognize. “One longs to penetrate into the lives of the men who have given expression to so much power and sweetness,” he writes, but for Mino, for Maso del Rodario, for “Donatello even,” you ask in vain for more than “a shadowy outline of their actual days.” At the end of the essay he returns to the question by claiming that a certain quality in their work “seems to bring those workmen themselves very near to us,” a quality the French call intimité (intimacy or inwardness), and the whole chapter hangs between those two moments, the empty archive at the start and the close encounter at the finish.
Pater’s definition of the word is careful, and it’s worth reading slowly. Intimité, he says, means “some subtler sense of originality,” namely “the seal on a man’s work of what is most inward and peculiar in his moods, and manner of apprehension,” and the edition’s note adds that it names a work’s power to convey something inward and individual about its maker. Notice that he packs two different things into that phrase, moods and a manner of apprehension, and they make very different claims, because a mood is a fact about someone’s inner weather on particular days, while a manner of apprehension is a fact about how a person habitually takes hold of the world, what he notices, what he leaves out and what he lingers over.
The case for close looking is strong on the second claim. A relief records decisions, and decisions are evidence, so when Luca carves the cathedral’s singing children crowded together but never in chaos, or gives his glazed Madonnas the same calm, inward heads year after year, he’s telling you what he thought a face should do and how much movement a scene could hold before it tipped into noise. You can know a musician’s ear from the records alone, without a single interview, the way you can recognize a drummer who always sits a hair behind the beat, and a sculptor’s habits of attention are just as real and just as legible as that, which is what Pater means by apprehension.
The case gets shakier on the first claim, because moods are exactly what an archive would tell you and a relief wouldn’t, since a sculptor can carve a serene Madonna on the worst morning of his life, and workshop practice muddies things further, because Luca ran a family business with his nephew Andrea, who took over the shop and kept turning out its style for decades after Luca’s death in 1482. If specialists still argue over which glazed roundels are Luca’s and which are Andrea’s, a reader can’t hope to read Luca’s private moods off a surface two people may have shaped, and the seal Pater wants starts to look as much like a brand as a signature.
Pater’s own first page shows where the slide begins. Having lamented the lost lives, he decides that “it is part of the reserve, the austere dignity and simplicity of their existence” that so little is known, and he adds that “From their lives, as from their work, all tumult of sound and colour has passed away.” That’s a lovely sentence and a bad inference, because it turns missing records into evidence of quiet lives, as if people who left no gossip must have had no drama, when the silence of an archive mostly tells you who kept paperwork and what survived floods, fires and centuries of houses being cleared out by people who didn’t care about old receipts.
The few documents that do survive cut against the picture of a man without an outward life. The documentary record shows Luca carving marble for the cathedral, buying a house with a garden in Via Guelfa with his brother Marco in 1446, and declining a guild office in 1471 on grounds of age and ill health. Vasari adds a vivid anecdote, that as a young man he carved all day and drew at night, and when his feet froze he stuck them in a basket of wood shavings rather than stop, a good story about character that also happens to be the kind of story people love telling about artists.
The other side deserves its due, because the urge to meet the maker isn’t naive. A viewer standing before a della Robbia Madonna can feel the presence of a particular sensibility even with little evidence about the person who made it. The sense of gentleness and order comes from looking at the object. Pater even gets the outward facts roughly right when he calls Luca’s “a life of labour and frugality,” and his word intimité is a good one, provided you take it as a description of the encounter and not as a biography slipped in through the back door.
My verdict is that close looking can reasonably establish a manner of apprehension, how an artist sees and what he values, and that’s real knowledge, a kind of acquaintance as solid as knowing a friend’s handwriting. It can’t establish moods, and it certainly can’t prove a life was quiet because the records are, so the reader starts inventing at the moment the work is asked to supply facts it was never built to carry. Pater’s last paragraph stays on the right side of that line and his first paragraph wanders over it, and the fair way to read him is to trust the man who looks hard at the reliefs and to doubt the one who pictures the sculptor’s peaceful evenings at home.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
According to the article, what can close looking at Luca’s sculpture most reasonably reveal?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- Where should a viewer draw the boundary between recognizing an artist’s sensibility in a work and inventing a biography for its maker?→
- If an artistic style is sustained by a family workshop, in what sense—if any—can it still express an individual artist’s manner of apprehension?→
- Why might Pater’s unsupported picture of a quiet life remain persuasive even after the article exposes the weakness of his inference?→