Philosophy
Knowing Yourself, Judging Yourself
You can keep an honest account of what you did and still misread the person who did it. It takes another kind of judgment to say whether the habits you discover are worth keeping.
The Platonic Dialogues: CharmidesCritias’ formula sounds as if it could settle three questions at once. A doctor, a man with a temper and Aristotle’s account of greatness of soul show why each question takes different evidence.
Orientation
At a Glance
- What did I do?Socrates’ doctor raises a question about one action and how it turned out. Evidence from the case can change the doctor’s assessment of what happened.
- What do I keep doing?Knowing your character means recognizing a pattern across actions. A person can remember each outburst accurately and explain away the pattern that others can see.
- What is the pattern worth?Judging a trait requires a standard of what is good or fitting. Aristotle’s great-souled person illustrates the difference between what someone deserves and what that person thinks they deserve.
- What makes knowledge beneficial?Critias agrees that self-knowledge would disclose what a person knows and doesn’t know. The later turn to good and bad raises a further question about what makes any of that knowledge worth having.
Charmides 164b–d, 164d–165b, 165c–e, 166d–167b, 174b–d, 174d–175a · Aristotle, Nicomachean Ethics 4.3 (1123b) · Kruger and Dunning, Unskilled and Unaware of It pp. 1121–1126
A man remembers every time he lost his temper last week. He can tell you who said what and what he said back. He still thinks of himself as a calm person, because each outburst had a good explanation. That’s one way of seeing how far the argument travels in a few lines of the Charmides. Socrates asks whether the doctor knows how he acted in a particular case. He goes on to ask whether someone might be temperate without knowing it. Critias then calls temperance “knowing oneself,” a phrase broad enough to make you wonder whether it includes knowing whether you’re any good.
The first achievement is practical self-assessment. A doctor can follow up with a patient, a teacher can look at the test scores, and an employee can read the client’s reply. Sometimes the relevant evidence is right there and people still misjudge it. In their 1999 studies, Justin Kruger and David Dunning found that Cornell undergraduates in the bottom quartile on their tasks in humor, grammar and logic substantially overestimated how they did relative to their peers. The researchers suggested that some of the skills involved in doing a task well also help you spot when you’ve done it badly. A good coach or editor can make that discrepancy easier to see.
The second achievement is knowing your character. You want to know whether you’re patient or quick-tempered, generous or tight-fisted, steady or easily swayed. No single scene tells you enough. The man who thinks he’s calm may have a perfectly good memory of every quarrel. It’s what he makes of the quarrels together that’s in doubt. A friend who was there for several of them may be better placed to point out what keeps happening.
The third achievement is a justified judgment about the pattern. Say the friend is right and the man does get angry easily. When his anger makes him listen less carefully to his children, there’s a reason to worry about it. When he gets angry at someone abusing a position of trust, you may be glad he did. To judge how he generally handles anger, you need some view of when anger is deserved and what it ought to accomplish. A detailed account of his habits will give you evidence for that judgment without settling it.
Aristotle makes room for the difference in his account of greatness of soul. The great-souled person claims great honors and deserves them. The vain person makes large claims he can’t justify, while the small-souled person claims less than he deserves. Aristotle is talking about a person’s estimate of what he merits, especially in matters of honor. His example makes a useful point for the broader inquiry. Someone can have qualities that make him worthy of something and still be badly mistaken about what those qualities entitle him to claim.
Critias’ definition leaves the three achievements tangled. Knowing how your work turned out helps with the next decision. Knowing your own character can give you a much wider view, and people of very different characters can have that kind of self-understanding. Judging what’s good in the character you find takes a standard the formula hasn’t yet supplied. At 167a, Critias agrees that the temperate person knows what he knows and what he doesn’t. That’s a further idea, an account of how you recognize the limits of your knowledge, and it still leaves the judgment of character open.
Near the end, Socrates asks which kind of knowledge would actually make us happy. Critias names knowledge of good and bad. Socrates points out that a doctor can still produce health and a cobbler can still make good shoes, while the question of what makes the work beneficial in a larger sense remains. The exchange gives us a way to see why a moral judgment needs more than an accurate account of oneself. Whether this anger, generosity or ambition is worth cultivating depends on knowing something about what is good.
My verdict is that Critias’ phrase sounds more settled than it is because it lets us glide among those questions. What happened? What do I do again and again? What’s good in that? The man who remembers his week has made a start. He may need his friend to recognize the pattern and still have to work out when he was right to get angry. The three jobs can belong to one inquiry without ever becoming the same job.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
Why might accurately remembering every quarrel still fail to establish that someone knows his own character?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- If a person explains each angry outburst convincingly but repeatedly becomes angry, what further questions should be asked before calling that person quick-tempered?→
- When should another person’s recognition of a pattern in your behavior outweigh your own interpretation, and what would justify trusting that person?→
- Can someone understand their character very well while remaining mistaken about whether that character is good? How would you distinguish those two kinds of judgment?→