Renaissance

It Takes a Temperament to Spot One

The capacity to be moved helps a critic recognize what a painter keeps returning to.

Pater calls temperament a critic’s capacity to be moved and looks for an artist’s temperament in recurrent details. The article asks how much a critic can infer from those details and where self-recognition can get in the way.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • A capacity for being movedIn the Preface, temperament is what lets the critic respond strongly to beauty. A theory of beauty cannot do that work by itself.
  • An artist gives a mood formPater says the world awakens a distinctive mood in Botticelli. Painting gives that private experience a visible form other people can encounter.
  • A recurring detail becomes evidenceA kind of face or light can suggest a painter’s temperament when it appears across works. That inference weakens when the paintings are by other hands.
  • The critic’s range mattersThe artist’s temperament gives the work a distinctive signature. The critic needs enough range to recognize signatures unlike their own and to say what in the work moved them.

Pater’s Preface reads in places like a job ad for critics, and the one hard requirement isn’t a theory. “What is important, then,” he says, “is not that the critic should possess a correct abstract definition of beauty for the intellect, but a certain kind of temperament, the power of being deeply moved by the presence of beautiful objects.” So far that’s clear enough, since a temperament here is a capacity you’ve got and can use, like a good ear. But the Diotimos Key Words entry points out that Pater uses the same word for artists, whose temperament he reads “through recurrent faces, gestures, and kinds of beauty,” so in one chapter temperament is something you exercise, and in the next it’s something you detect in somebody else from the way he keeps painting mouths.

Look closely at how Pater describes the artist’s side, though, and the two meanings start to slide together. Botticelli, he says, gets the same outward scene as everybody else, but it “awakes in him, moreover, by some subtle law of his own structure, a mood which it awakes in no one else, of which it is the double or repetition.” That’s a description of someone receiving a one-of-a-kind impression from the world, which is very nearly the Preface’s account of what beautiful things do to a sensitive critic, producing sensations “each of a more or less peculiar or unique kind.” The difference lies only in what happens next, since Botticelli takes his private mood and “clothes” it, “that all may share it, with visible circumstance,” while the critic writes his up.

Leonardo gets the same treatment, only turned up louder. “Out of the secret places of a unique temperament he brought strange blossoms and fruits hitherto unknown,” Pater writes, and he adds that for Leonardo “the novel impression conveyed, the exquisite effect woven, counted as an end in itself.” That’s the Conclusion’s creed showing up in a painter’s biography seventy pages early, and it makes Leonardo sound less like a man with a fixed character and more like the ideal reader of Pater’s own book. Even the women in Leonardo’s drawings are built this way, because Pater calls them “clairvoyants” who “become, as it were, the receptacle” of nature’s subtler forces “and pass them on to us in a chain of secret influences.”

That word “receptacle” is the key, because the Preface uses it too, and at both ends. Works of art “are indeed receptacles of so many powers or forces,” and when the critic looks at a period he asks, “In whom did the stir, the genius, the sentiment of the period find itself? where was the receptacle of its refinement, its elevation, its taste?” Put those uses together and you get a relay in which an age’s spirit collects in a person, that person’s temperament gives it a shape, the shape goes into a work, the work holds it as a power, and a critic with the right temperament picks it up and passes it on. Temperament on both sides of a painting is the same capacity, taking in and handing on, working at two different links of one chain.

It’s still fair to say the word slides from a capacity you exercise to a character you infer, but Pater shows you how the slide happens. A capacity used again and again in one direction starts to leave tracks, and tracks are what a character is made of. Botticelli’s Madonna is Pater’s example, a “distinct and peculiar type” that he says the painter returned to “over and over again, sometimes one might think almost mechanically,” which is uncomfortably close to the habit the Conclusion warns against. Winckelmann shows the change happening in real time, because the Greek world, Pater says, “penetrates him, and becomes part of his temperament,” so that a sensitivity turns into a signature right in front of us.

Reading temperament backward from tracks has its risks, and the introduction names one when it says Pater “sometimes reads an artist’s temperament out of paintings once assigned to that artist,” which is a polite way of saying some of his tracks were left by other people. Pater half admits this himself when he says Leonardo’s pupils caught his manner so well that we see the master through “a multitude of other men’s pictures.” The deeper risk is a cheekier one, because the artists Pater finds most moving, Botticelli with his wistful exiles and Leonardo with his hunger for novel impressions, look suspiciously like the reader the Preface was hoping for, and you have to ask whether the critic is detecting a painter’s temperament or recognizing his own in a mirror.

What keeps this from turning into mere projection is the Preface’s demand that the critic say where an effect comes from and under what conditions it’s felt. When Pater reads Botticelli’s sadness he points at visible things, the wan color and the light on the Madonna’s face, “cast up hard and cheerless from below, as when snow lies upon the ground,” and if that light isn’t there when you go and look, his reading of the temperament falls with it. The lopsidedness between the two sides also turns out to be deliberate, since the artist is prized for one note, like the “unique, incommunicable faculty” Pater finds in Wordsworth, while the critic has to remember “that beauty exists in many forms” and hold every period and school to be “in themselves equal.”

So temperament on both sides of a painting is one capacity, the power to be moved in a way nobody else is, showing up in two different conditions. In the artist it has narrowed into a signature you can spot across a room, and in the critic it has to stay wide, growing “in depth and variety,” so he can take in many signatures without melting them into his own. The critic’s real job, in Pater’s terms, is to take an artist’s “incommunicable” faculty and make it communicable, noting it “for himself and others,” and The Renaissance is that relay running for a whole book. I think the parallel is the book’s quietest good idea, and the risk of the mirror is simply the price of a criticism built on being moved, which is a price worth paying.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

According to the article, what most clearly distinguishes the artist’s use of temperament from the critic’s?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.