Renaissance
Hometown, Fortress and Family Tree
Pater finds a contradiction in Michelangelo’s defense of a republic and his pride in his ancestry. The sonnet he quotes carries a different tension, between Florence and a poet it sent away.
The Renaissance (1893)Michelangelo helped fortify Florence and called it his nest in a poem about Dante. Restoring the words around that phrase brings the city’s ingratitude into the picture.
Orientation
At a Glance
- A sculptor defended the republicMichelangelo took responsibility for Florence’s fortifications in 1529. His designs and the defenses of San Miniato give the episode a physical record.
- Family pride could coexist with civic servicePater sets the Canossa claim against republican politics. In Florence, a tradition of public office could itself be a source of family pride.
- The nest appears in a poem about DanteMichelangelo calls Florence the nest where he was born. The neighboring words say Dante made it shine more brightly than it deserved.
- Love gives the grievance its forceThe poem calls Dante’s fellow citizens ungrateful. Pater hears affection for Florence, and the full sonnet makes us hear disappointment in the same phrase.
The Renaissance · The Poetry of Michelangelo, the republican and the Canossa claim · Note 146, Florence as Michelangelo’s nest · The Poetry of Michelangelo, the place of his birth and family story · The Poetry of Michelangelo, Dante and political poetry · Michelangelo’s fortifications and the siege of Florence, Casa Buonarroti · Condivi’s Life of Michelangelo, Florence and the family story · Michelangelo’s sonnet to Dante, Italian text and English translation · Michelangelo’s Dante sonnet and Giannotti’s dialogues, University of Pisa
In the spring of 1529 the most famous sculptor in Europe became a military engineer, because Florence had thrown out the Medici two years earlier and now a Medici pope and the emperor’s army were coming to put them back. Michelangelo sat on the city’s nine-man militia board, was named governor and procurator general of the fortifications that April, and helped defend the heights at San Miniato, on the south side of the Arno. Condivi says that when enemy guns went to work on the church’s bell tower, he protected it with mattresses and other soft material to soften the blows, which is about the most Michelangelo solution imaginable, practical and theatrical and a little bit crazy all at once.
Pater puts this moment into a sentence that’s built to feel like a contradiction. Michelangelo was “a republican superintending the fortification of Florence,” he writes, the city he calls “the nest where he was born, il nido ove naqqu’io, as he calls it once, in a sudden throb of affection,” and then comes the turn, since the same man “believed always that he had imperial blood in his veins and was of the kindred of the great Matilda.” Two pages earlier Pater has told us the family claimed “kinship with the family of Canossa,” and Condivi spells the story out, with an ancestor named Simone arriving from the counts of Canossa to serve as Florence’s chief magistrate in 1250. A letter from Count Alessandro da Canossa greeted Michelangelo as a relative. The courtesy shows that the claim circulated and leaves the lineage itself open.
Matilda is the funny part, because the great Countess Matilda of Tuscany is famous for supporting Pope Gregory VII and hosting his encounter with Henry IV at Canossa in 1077. Her example makes an easy equation of aristocratic ancestry with imperial politics harder to sustain. Still, the case for Pater’s split is a strong one, and it deserves a fair hearing. Here’s a man who fought for a republic against a Medici pope, bolted to Venice in September 1529 when he became convinced the city was being betrayed, was declared a rebel, came back in November, hid when the city fell in August 1530, and eventually returned to work on the Medici tombs.
The other side has a good answer, though, because in Florence pride of lineage and republican service weren’t enemies at all. The republic was run by old families who kept their genealogies the way people now keep their credit scores, and Pater himself notes that Michelangelo’s people had “generation after generation, received honourable employment under the government of Florence,” which makes the pedigree and the civic duty two halves of one family brand. Michelangelo put both into a single sentence when he urged his nephew Leonardo to buy a handsome house in the city, telling him a good house shows more than land does, and that it suits them “because we are, after all, citizens descended from a most noble line.” He puts citizen first and noble line second, and nothing in the letter suggests he felt the two pulling against each other.
The bigger surprise is the nest itself, because Pater lifts that phrase out of a sonnet about Dante, written in the 1540s while Michelangelo was living in Rome. The poem calls Dante a “lucente stella” (shining star) whose rays “fe’ chiaro a torto el nido ove nacqu’io,” which means they lit up, undeservedly, the nest where I was born. That little “a torto” (wrongly, without its deserving it) changes everything, and the poem goes on to say Dante’s works were badly understood “da quel popolo ingrato” (by that ungrateful people) and ends with Michelangelo wishing he were Dante, since for that harsh exile and that virtue he’d give up the happiest state in the world, so the nest turns up right in the middle of an accusation against the city that owned it.
So the “sudden throb of affection” is really affection with a bruise in it. By the time he wrote the sonnet Michelangelo had walked away from Florence for good, leaving in 1534 and never returning while the Medici ran it as a duchy, which makes his envy of Dante’s exile pretty pointed. There’s also a quieter twist that Pater should have caught, since two pages earlier he tells us Michelangelo was born “at a place in the neighbourhood of Arezzo,” the village of Caprese, where his father was serving a term as the local magistrate. Florence was home in the poem’s sense of the word, even though his birthplace was Caprese. Dante gives him a way to describe a city he chose to belong to.
Weigh it all and Pater is right about the coexistence and right that there’s bitterness in the mix, his “secret spring of indignation or sorrow,” but he puts the fault line in the wrong place. Republic and pedigree sat together comfortably in a Florentine of Michelangelo’s class, and the history of his family’s public office helps explain why. What didn’t sit comfortably was love for a city that kept failing its best people, the city that exiled Dante, left its own defender hiding in a friend’s house, and under the dukes became a place he’d only visit in poems. That’s the tension the nest phrase actually carries, and it cuts a lot deeper than anything about imperial blood.
So can Florence be a nest and a republic at once? For Michelangelo it plainly could, since the republic was the nest in its best clothes, the city run by the kind of old families he insisted he came from. What it couldn’t be was a nest under the Medici dukes, and the Dante sonnet is how an old man in Rome said so without saying it outright. Pater was reaching for a man torn between republic and aristocracy, which is a very nineteenth-century way of slicing things, when the real split ran between a hometown he chose and a hometown that kept letting him down. I’d keep his phrase and change one word, because what Michelangelo felt for his nest was less a throb of affection than a throb of grievance that only someone who loved the place could feel.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
Where does the article locate the deepest conflict in Michelangelo’s relationship with Florence?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- What assumptions about politics and social class lead Pater to treat republican service and noble ancestry as opposing forces, and how does the article challenge those assumptions?→
- How does the Dante sonnet transform the image of a “nest” from a symbol of uncomplicated belonging into one of grievance as well as love?→
- If Michelangelo could regard republican Florence as home but not Florence under the Medici dukes, what does that suggest about the relationship between a place, its government, and personal identity?→