Philosophy
Homer Takes the Stand
A line from the Odyssey serves as a famous witness, a concrete example, and a verbal echo in Socrates’ argument.
The Platonic Dialogues: CharmidesCharmides takes Homer’s word for it. Picture the hungry man in the poem and you can decide for yourself why the line matters.
Orientation
At a Glance
- The famous witnessSocrates asks whether Homer is right, and Charmides immediately agrees. In the Republic, Socrates refers to admirers who call Homer the educator of Greece.
- A case you can pictureTelemachus tells his disguised father to ask the suitors for food. A hungry person who goes without because he’s too shy to ask gives Socrates a case anyone can weigh.
- Words that carry overTelemachus’ line speaks of modesty being present with someone in need. After quoting it, Socrates asks what temperance does for the people it is present with.
- How to test a sayingA few lines later Socrates tells Charmides to examine whether a saying is true. The hungry man lets us apply that test to Homer himself.
Charmides 160d–e, 160e–161c · Odyssey 17.345–352, 17.578 · Hesiod, Works and Days 317–318 · Protagoras 347c–e, 348a · Hippias Minor 365d · Republic 606e · Laches 201b
Socrates calls a witness. “Well then,” he asks, “don’t you believe that Homer is right when he says,” and he quotes the line “Modesty is no good thing to be present with a man in need,” to which Charmides answers at once, “I do.” The speed of that answer makes sense. In the Republic, Socrates mentions admirers who call Homer the educator of Greece. The first job the line does is to bring that authority into the room. Charmides is ready to take Homer’s word for it.
That’s strange coming from Socrates, who elsewhere sets poetry aside when a live person can answer a question. In the Protagoras, he compares talk about poets to a drinking party where people hire flute girls because they can’t make conversation themselves. A poet can’t answer for what he meant, so Socrates wants the people in the room to test each other directly. In the Hippias Minor, he asks Hippias to answer for himself and Homer, since they can’t question the poet. Why put Homer on the stand here? One answer is that Socrates needs a premise Charmides will accept, and the boy gives him one without hesitation.
The second job the line does is to give an example, and here it’s worth looking at where it comes from. In the Odyssey, the hero has finally made it home, disguised as a beggar in his own palace while the suitors who are courting his wife eat him out of house and home. His son Telemachus, who knows who he is, sends him bread and meat with the swineherd and tells him to go around the suitors asking for food. Modesty does a hungry man no good. Penelope says much the same thing later in the book. When Socrates says Homer is speaking, the voice in the poem is a son coaching his disguised father.
The example works whether or not the poet endorses it. You can picture a starving man too shy to ask for food and see what his modesty is costing him. That gives Charmides a case he can check against his own sense of things, a concrete situation where a definition can visibly fail in front of you. Socrates could have described the hungry man and invited the boy to make up his own mind.
The third job is a verbal link, and it’s the sliest of the three. In Telemachus’ line, the Greek word pareinai means to be present. The swineherd puts the advice differently when he relays it, speaking of a beggar. Socrates quotes Telemachus’ wording and then says temperance is good “if it makes good those it is present with.” The same verb connects the two cases. The line fits the argument like a key in a lock. In the Laches, Socrates quotes the advice again when he and his companions are in need of a teacher.
The thought behind the line turns up in Hesiod, too. In Works and Days, he says shame can be a bad companion to a man in need and adds that it can both harm and help people. That comes close to what Socrates says after Charmides accepts the quotation. “So it seems modesty is both not good and good.” An old warning about shame gives him a way to test a definition that leaves no room for its harm.
So how much weight should the line carry once you pull its three jobs apart? A famous name can get Charmides to listen, and the repeated verb helps him follow the comparison. The example gives him a reason to agree. A hungry man’s reluctance to ask for bread can hurt him, and the boy can see that once he pictures him. The line is a solid piece of evidence dressed up in the borrowed robes of an authority.
My verdict is that the hungry man can stand on his own as a witness. There’s a lovely irony in what happens next. Charmides offers a saying he heard from someone, and when he asks what difference it makes who said it, Socrates replies that “what we have to look into is not who said it, but whether what is said is true or not.” That’s exactly the test the Homer line should face. Once you picture the hungry man, you can judge the testimony for yourself.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
Why does the article find Socrates’ appeal to Homer initially surprising?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- If the hungry-man example can be judged independently, what—if anything—does attributing it to Homer add to Socrates’ argument?→
- How should we distinguish between using an authority to persuade someone and using an example to give that person a reason to agree?→
- What does the claim that modesty can be both good and harmful suggest about definitions that treat a quality as unconditionally good?→