Renaissance
From the Cathedral to the Bedroom Wall
Glazed clay took skills Luca learned on public commissions into private rooms. Molds and a family workshop helped those objects travel.
The Renaissance (1893)Pater sees an affinity between church and household art in Luca della Robbia. Domestic reliefs and their workshop variations show how devotional use and repeat production could support each other.
Orientation
At a Glance
- Cathedral work gave Luca a starting pointLuca had carved for Florence’s cathedral and bell tower. Glazed terracotta gave him a different material for carrying those skills into more settings.
- A sacred picture belonged at homeHousehold images could mark a marriage or encourage devotion. One relief attributed to Andrea was probably commissioned for a wedding in 1483.
- Molds made room for variationsThe workshop could repeat a design and alter details such as its framing, colors and figures. Andrea expanded that practice.
- Domestic art took an organized workshopPater stresses the closeness of household and church art. Kilns, recipes and repeated designs help explain how that closeness took material form.
The Renaissance · Luca della Robbia, pale blue and white earthenware · Luca della Robbia, cathedral work and daily household life · Note 126, Luca’s cathedral and bell tower commissions · Note 127, terracotta and its uses · Conclusion, the hard, gem-like flame · Serial sculpture and workshop variants, National Gallery of Art · Andrea’s Virgin Adoring the Christ Child, Walters Art Museum · Vasari, Life of Luca della Robbia · Pater’s 1868 review of William Morris, University of Wuppertal
Pater tells the second half of Luca’s career as a story of generosity. After producing many works in marble for the cathedral and its bell tower, he says, Luca wanted to realize the spirit of that sculpture “in a humbler material,” to join its science to the homely art of pottery, “to introduce those high qualities into common things, to adorn and cultivate daily household life.” In this, Pater adds, Luca was “profoundly characteristic of the Florence of that century,” of its “old-world modesty and seriousness and simplicity,” and he notes that people “had not yet begun to think that what was good art for churches was not so good, or less fitted, for their own houses.”
The starting point is worth remembering, because the edition’s note points to the cathedral and its bell tower, where Luca carved the singing gallery and a set of marble reliefs for the campanile, public works in the most prestigious material for the city’s most important building. The note on the next step adds the practical side, that terracotta was cheaper than marble and so opened a wider range of uses, but that forming, firing and glazing it called for real technical control, which gently corrects Pater’s own remark elsewhere that the first glazed pieces were finished in a few hours.
Florentine houses were ready for these objects, and the reasons were religious as much as decorative. The Dominican preacher Giovanni Dominici, writing a rule for family life early in the century, advised parents to keep images of the Christ Child and other holy children at home so their own children could see themselves in them, and reliefs of the Madonna and Child could mark a marriage or a hoped-for birth. The Walters Art Museum identifies one relief attributed to Luca’s nephew Andrea as a probable commission for the 1483 wedding of Alessandra Pazzi and Bartolomeo di Rosso Buondelmonti.
What made this possible on a large scale was the mold. Luca pioneered glazed Madonna reliefs that were both modeled by hand and reproduced by piece-molding, and Andrea, who inherited the workshop, exploited the technique to turn out Madonnas in large editions, combining different sections and then customizing each one with its own frame, glaze colors and family coat of arms. It worked something like ordering a car with options, a standard design given a personal finish, and it let more households acquire work from the same family of sculptors. The workshop could make variants in higher and lower relief, depending on the design.
The range of uses grew with the technique, from heraldry to architecture. Luca made guild arms in glazed roundels for the outside of Orsanmichele, armorial pieces, reliefs for churches, and the glazed ceiling of Piero de’ Medici’s study, the most luxurious household version of all. Vasari praised the medium as especially useful per i luoghi dove sono acque (for places where there is water), where damp leaves no room for paintings, so the same material that decorated a bedroom could also face rain on a public wall, and that durability was part of what made it suitable for ordinary lives as well as grand ones.
Pater’s picture has a Victorian background worth noticing, since he was writing in 1872, in a Britain arguing about the gap between fine art and decorative art, where William Morris had founded his design firm in 1861 and would later tell audiences to “Have nothing in your houses that you do not know to be useful, or believe to be beautiful.” Pater’s own Conclusion began life in an 1868 review of Morris’s poems, and the South Kensington Museum, founded to improve British design, had been buying della Robbia works since the 1850s, so his Luca is partly a design reformer’s dream, a Renaissance artist who never accepted the split the Victorians were trying to heal.
The romance needs some correcting, though, because the household art Pater admires was a business, run by a family workshop that expanded its production under Andrea and later worked beyond Florence. Later workshop pieces grew formulaic, other shops copied the style from the same kinds of molds, and the move into common things brought repetition along with access, which is the usual price of making beautiful objects affordable, whether the objects are Madonnas, prints or furniture.
My verdict is that the social change Pater describes was real and that he describes its spirit well. Glazed clay really did carry the intelligence of cathedral sculpture into bedrooms, guild halls and wedding chests, and the surviving reliefs show what household and church art could share. But the engine of that change was technical and commercial as much as moral, built on molds, kilns and a family firm, and the best way to honor Pater’s insight is to see that the old-world modesty he admired came packaged with a very modern ability to make good things in quantity.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
How did piece-molding help the della Robbia workshop balance wider access with personal distinction?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- When art becomes affordable through repetition, what standards should we use to decide whether increased access outweighs the risk of formulaic production?→
- How does recognizing the workshop’s molds, kilns, and commercial organization change the meaning of Pater’s claim that Luca acted from generosity?→
- Why might the same religious image function differently in a cathedral, on a public wall, and inside a family home?→