Renaissance

Finished Within Their Own Walls

Pater asks what it means for a sculpture to be complete. Luca della Robbia and the Pazzi Chapel show how much can happen inside a narrow frame.

The opening and close of Pater’s Luca della Robbia essay connect artistic restraint with expression. The scale of a relief or chapel can make a small gesture carry further.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • Earlier sculptors had goals of their ownPater resists a history that treats early Renaissance artists as preparation for Michelangelo. They can perfect the kind of work they choose to do.
  • The chapel gives restraint a scaleIn the Pazzi Chapel, the glazed figures of the Apostles sit within an orderly architectural frame. The small reliefs and the structure give each other room.
  • A larger ambition can remain unfinishedMichelangelo drew up a marble façade for San Lorenzo, but it was never built. The project brings out the difference between ambition and a completed effect.
  • Limits can make expression visiblePater ends by praising the impression a sculptor leaves on the work. In a quiet setting, a small change in a face can carry that impression.

Pater starts his Luca della Robbia essay by picking a fight with the way art history usually tells the Renaissance. “The Italian sculptors of the earlier half of the fifteenth century are more than mere forerunners of the great masters of its close,” he writes, “and often reach perfection, within the narrow limits which they chose to impose on their work.” The story he’s arguing against goes back to Vasari, whose Lives arranged Italian art into three ages climbing toward Michelangelo, with the fifteenth century as the middle stretch that had the rules and the proportions but not yet the final freedom, and that story turns Luca and his generation into an opening act, the band you sit through politely while you wait for the headliner.

The key word in his sentence is “chose,” because the label can make a finished work sound as if it needed something more, a draft waiting for its final version, while an artist working inside limits he picked is doing exactly what he means to do, and the standard of success changes with that. Wordsworth made the same case for the sonnet in a poem of 1807 that opens “Nuns fret not at their convent’s narrow room,” arguing that a prison we sentence ourselves to is no prison at all, and Pater, who wrote on Wordsworth in 1874, makes a comparable case for marble and clay, where a fourteen-line poem isn’t a failed epic and a shallow relief isn’t a failed statue.

His next move widens the claim from sculpture to the taste of a whole city, since this work “shares with the paintings of Botticelli and the churches of Brunelleschi that profound expressiveness, that intimate impress of an indwelling soul, which is the peculiar fascination of the art of Italy in that century.” Brunelleschi’s churches, San Lorenzo and Santo Spirito, are about the purest restraint you could ask for, with columns and arches of grey sandstone drawn like clean lines against white plaster, no gold and no clutter, an interior that feels like a diagram of calm. It’s an odd thing to call that architecture expressive of a soul, until you stand inside it and notice how much feeling comes from what’s been left out.

The best place to test Pater’s grouping is a single room where two of his three names actually meet. In the Pazzi Chapel at Santa Croce, a building traditionally credited to Brunelleschi, twelve glazed roundels of the seated Apostles made by Luca and Andrea della Robbia sit in walls marked out in the same grey stone, white figures on blue grounds, so the sculptor’s restraint and the architect’s restraint share a single surface. The room feels complete in its proportions and ornament. It gives a visitor a concrete example of what Pater means when he says these artists reached perfection inside a narrow frame.

The point gets sharper if you remember what happened when the High Renaissance tried to finish one of Brunelleschi’s buildings. San Lorenzo never received a proper façade, so in 1516 Pope Leo X, himself a Medici, put Michelangelo in charge of the design. Michelangelo planned a marble front with statues and spent years securing the stone. The marble contract was cancelled in 1520 and the front was never built. The church still faces its square with a bare, rough brick front, which makes a neat parable for Pater’s argument, since the restrained interior by the so-called forerunner is complete, while the great master’s completion is the part that never happened.

Pater adds that these artists have been neglected, their works “often almost hidden away amid the frippery of modern decoration,” though “we come with some surprise on the places where their fire still smoulders.” That complaint had real targets in his Florence, which had just given Santa Croce a busy neo-Gothic marble façade, completed in 1865, and was debating a new front for the cathedral that went up in the following decades, so part of what Pater defends is a quiet art against a loud century. The modest sculptors suffer twice, first by being ranked as preludes and then by being buried under decoration with none of their reserve, and his defense is aesthetic and practical at once, a plea to go and find them.

The end of the essay tells you what the restraint is for. Pater closes by naming the quality he values most in Luca and his school, “what we call expression, carried to its highest intensity of degree,” which he calls “rare in poetry, rarer still in art, rarest of all in the abstract art of sculpture,” and suggests it may be “the quality which alone makes work in the imaginative order really worth having at all.” Set that beside his opening and the argument snaps shut, since the narrow limits turn out to be the condition of expression rather than its sacrifice, the way a whisper in a quiet room carries further than a shout in a crowded one, and the century’s restraint is what lets a small change in a face register as an event.

My verdict is that Pater’s defense works because he changes what counts as completion. If perfection means doing everything, then the early sculptors are forerunners by definition and Michelangelo wins every argument, but if perfection means doing fully what you set out to do, then a relief, a chapel or a small glazed Madonna can be finished in a way the grand projects often weren’t, and the limits become the frame that makes the achievement visible. I’d only add that the word “chose” carries more weight than Pater admits, since money, materials and patrons imposed plenty of limits nobody chose, but the best of these artists turned even those into a style, which is the surest sign that the narrowness had become their own.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

How does the article say Pater challenges Vasari’s account of fifteenth-century sculptors?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.