Philosophy

Finding Yourself or Making Yourself?

A doctor who doubts his own results and a boy who asks for a daily charm put self-knowledge to different tests.

Finding out what you’re like is one way to know yourself. Plato’s dialogues also ask what happens when the search changes how you live.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • Finding out what happenedSocrates’ doctor may help a patient without knowing how the treatment turned out.
  • Recognizing a limitIn the Apology, Socrates counts it as a small advantage that he can admit when he doesn’t know something.
  • Learning what to cultivatePindar’s line about learning and becoming gives the essay a way to connect discovery with the work of shaping a life.
  • A practice for tomorrowCharmides asks Socrates for a daily charm while he is still unsure whether he has temperance.

Charmides 164b–d, 164d–165b, 165c–166a, 175e–176a, 176a–c · Phaedrus 229d–e, 229e–230a · Apology 21d, 38a · Pindar, Pythian 2.72 · Nietzsche, Ecce Homo subtitle

The definition Critias lands on has a strange grammar. The inscription he quotes is an imperative, “Know thyself,” something the god tells you to do. His definition makes temperance a kind of knowing, which sounds like something you have once you’ve found it out. And the case that set it all off was the doctor who “does not know himself — how he has acted.” What he lacks is knowledge of whether he’s helped or harmed his patient. How does a gap like that turn into the demand the god makes of a visitor?

The discovery reading is an easy one to recognize today. On this view, knowing yourself means finding out the truth about your temperament, your strengths and weaknesses, and what makes you tick, the way a conversation with a good friend might help you find out. The doctor’s problem fits this reading. He needs to find out whether his treatment helped. If self-knowledge is discovery, the aim is to get a more accurate picture of ourselves. You can see the appeal of that idea every time a personality quiz promises to tell you who you really are.

A second reading starts with a small advantage Socrates claims at his trial. The man he questioned thought he knew things he didn’t know. Socrates could at least get that much right about himself. At Delphi, the same sort of question might ask you to remember the limits of a human being in a god’s house. This is still a discovery of a sort, but what it finds is a boundary, and finding it can make you more careful about claims you can’t back up. Sometimes the most useful thing you know is where you should stop trusting your own judgment.

A third reading takes the imperative as a call to become a certain kind of person. Pindar has a famous line in an ode for Hieron. “Learn and become who you are.” Nietzsche echoes it in the subtitle of Ecce Homo, his late self-portrait, which can be translated as “How One Becomes What One Is.” On this reading, learning something about yourself can help you decide what to cultivate. The command at the temple door is an invitation to grow into the person it addresses.

The Socrates of the Phaedrus gives us a way to put these readings beside each other. He has no time to explain away stories about mythical creatures, since he still can’t follow the Delphic injunction and know himself. He’d rather find out whether he’s a beast more tangled and fuming than Typhon or a gentler, simpler creature with a share in something divine. He’s trying to discover what kind of creature he is and admitting a limit to his knowledge. There’s a question about becoming in the scene as well, if you ask what a person might cultivate after getting a good look at the sort of creature he is.

That helps explain why Socrates in the Apology says the unexamined life isn’t worth living. He talks about examining himself and others every day. The emphasis is on something he does repeatedly, more like exercise than like a diagnosis. The choices we make in light of one examination will give us more to examine the next time. Nobody goes to the gym once and considers the matter settled.

Critias starts by calling temperance knowledge of oneself. Socrates asks what this knowledge is of and what it produces, the way medicine produces health or building produces houses. Critias pushes back. This knowledge, he says, differs from the other kinds, and even calculation and geometry have no product like a house. We could follow his example and ask a different question. What would temperance look like as the practice of examining yourself and letting what you find change how you act?

My verdict is that self-knowledge has something to do with temperance when it changes what you do. An accurate inventory of your traits can leave you doing all the same things. The discipline of examining yourself gives what you discover a chance to make a difference. The boy at the end of the Charmides gets that far. He can’t tell whether he has temperance, so he asks to be charmed every day until Socrates says it’s enough. He’s found something to do tomorrow, even with the question still open.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

How does the article distinguish Socrates’ daily self-examination from a one-time diagnosis?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.