Renaissance

Does Della Robbia Travel?

Pater compares a glazed relief to Tuscan wine that loses its flavor away from home. The museum brings the work closer to the eye and farther from the setting that shaped it.

A Madonna in New York, ceiling roundels in London, and a sculpture lent from Pistoia show what a move can take away and what it can make easier to see.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The first setting shaped the workPater remembers white and blue reliefs against stone, seen from below or glimpsed in a dim church. A museum changes the light and the distance.
  • A move can make the craft clearerAt eye level, the surface can show details of modeling and glaze that are hard to make out above a doorway.
  • The roundels preserve clues to their settingThe curved terracottas in London are thought to come from Piero de’ Medici’s study. Their shapes helped conservators understand how they might have fit a vaulted ceiling.
  • The object and the encounter travel differentlyLuca’s Visitation was seen in Boston and Washington. A loan can give viewers a new encounter with the sculpture while its relationship to Pistoia remains distinct.

Pater’s best-known line about Luca della Robbia is a love letter to a place. “I suppose nothing brings the real air of a Tuscan town so vividly to mind as those pieces of pale blue and white earthenware,” he writes, “like fragments of the milky sky itself, fallen into the cool streets, and breaking into the darkened churches.” Then comes the warning that no work is less imitable, since “like Tuscan wine, it loses its savour when moved from its birthplace, from the crumbling walls where it was first placed,” which is the old traveler’s complaint that the bottle you loved on vacation tastes flat when you open it back home.

The edition sets that line beside its illustration, Luca’s Madonna and Child with Scroll in the Metropolitan Museum, and the relief makes a perfect test case. Made around 1455 and about three and a half feet tall, it shows a white Virgin holding a white Child who raises his hand in blessing, with a scroll reading Ego sum lux mundi (I am the light of the world), and its scale makes a high position on a Florentine building easy to imagine. It reached New York in 1913 in the bequest of the department-store magnate Benjamin Altman, so it’s exactly the bottle Pater warned about, uncorked a long way from its cellar.

Pater’s side of the argument is strong, because a lot of what these reliefs did depended on where they hung. A white-and-blue Madonna over a doorway on a narrow street was seen from below, in passing, in shifting daylight, against grey stone, and its job was to make a patch of sky and a piece of heaven appear in the middle of ordinary traffic, which is precisely what “fallen into the cool streets” describes. Glaze throws back whatever light it gets, so a relief in a dim church really does seem to break into the gloom, while the same surface under a museum’s even lighting reads as a handsome object rather than a sudden opening in the wall.

Some of the loss concerns a whole room rather than a single panel. Twelve glazed roundels of the Labours of the Months are thought to come from the vaulted ceiling of Piero de’ Medici’s study in the family palace. The room was destroyed after the Riccardi family bought the palace in 1659. The roundels were bought for the South Kensington Museum, now the V&A, in 1861, and no museum case can give back the effect of sitting under a ceiling of months, each marked with its hours of daylight, while you read your books or counted your money underneath.

Relocation gives things back, though, and sometimes the gift is a surprise. The London roundels carry a clue to their lost room. Each is slightly curved, and historical records and plans suggest the study was about ten by sixteen feet with a vaulted ceiling. At the museum, the fit between their curves and the room becomes something you can inspect. The move also exposes the craft, since a relief at eye level shows the modelling of a cheek, the pooling of glaze in a fold and the small accidents of firing, all of which vanish when the thing sits twenty feet up under a church window.

The most striking recent case came when Luca’s Visitation, the freestanding glazed group of Mary and Elizabeth meeting, from the church of San Giovanni Fuorcivitas in Pistoia, was shown in the United States for the first time at a 2016 exhibition in Boston that traveled to Washington. The museum setting brought the figures into a different relationship with the viewer. It also gave visitors a chance to look at a work they would otherwise have needed to travel to Pistoia to see. Pater couldn’t have imagined a trip like that, but it shows that removal can clarify as well as diminish.

There’s also an irony buried in Pater’s wine comparison. Glazed terracotta can keep much of its color and gloss for centuries, a quality Vasari recognized when he praised Luca’s invention for its durability. The roundels show that even a durable surface can suffer damage when its surroundings change. What doesn’t travel is the situation rather than the object, the street, the height, the church gloom and the habit of glancing up on the way to market, and that’s a loss of meaning rather than of material, more like a joke that dies when you have to explain the context than a wine that spoils in the hold of a ship.

My verdict is that Pater is right that the air of a Tuscan town doesn’t make the trip, because that air was a relation between an object and a street, and relations stay where they were formed. He’s wrong to say the work itself loses its savour, since much of the glaze can survive and the move often makes the modelling, the craft and even the lost settings more visible than they ever were in place. The best answer splits his metaphor in two, so that the wine travels perfectly and the trattoria stays behind, and a museum visitor who knows that can taste what’s in the glass while picturing the street it was first poured in.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

What does the author’s final revision of Pater’s wine metaphor suggest about relocating della Robbia’s works?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.