Philosophy
Cobblers, Fishmongers and Worse
Critias groups shoemaking, selling salt fish and prostitution as if their disgrace were obvious. What makes the first two belong on his list?
The Platonic Dialogues: CharmidesSocrates has just used cobbling as an example of useful craft. A few lines later, Critias puts it beside a brothel and expects the company to agree.
Orientation
At a Glance
- Three occupations in one breathCritias puts the cobbler, the salt-fish seller and the person in a brothel together. He expects his listeners to see at once why none counts as respectable work.
- Shoes and fishSocrates has already used shoemaking as an ordinary example of skilled work. Critias gives no account of what a cobbler or a fish seller does wrong.
- A different kind of stigmaAeschines cites a law that barred a male Athenian citizen who sold sex from addressing the Assembly. That legal disqualification is a separate issue from Critias’ judgment about cobbling and selling fish.
- Why Socrates likes cobblersIn the Symposium, Alcibiades says that Socrates’ homely examples conceal serious arguments. Xenophon later has Critias tell Socrates to give those examples up.
Charmides 161e–162a, 163b–c, 163c–d · Symposium 221e–222a · Xenophon, Oeconomicus 4.2, 4.3 · Aeschines, Against Timarchus 19, 20, 74 · Diogenes Laertius, Lives 2.122 · Xenophon, Memorabilia 1.2.31–34, 1.2.35–38
Critias’ examples arrive in a single indignant breath, as though anyone could see what they have in common. Could Hesiod really have said, he asks, that it was no disgrace “to cobble shoes, or to sell salt fish, or to sit in a brothel?” Critias expects that question to answer itself. The three are supposed to sound like the sort of thing nobody of sense would count as honest work. They make a strange list once you slow down and look at them one by one.
Take the cobbler first, since he’s the strangest choice. Shoemaking takes skill. In Xenophon’s Oeconomicus, Socrates gives voice to an objection people made against certain manual crafts. They keep workers indoors and leave little time for friends or the city. That helps explain how useful work can carry low status. In the Charmides, Socrates has just imagined a city where everybody has to cobble his own shoes. The city runs badly because everyone has to do everything. Critias takes the same occupation and drops it into a list of things a man should be ashamed to do.
The salt-fish seller adds a different sort of occupation. He makes his living at a stall, selling food people have a use for. You can imagine a seller cheating a customer, just as you can imagine a cobbler charging for a repair he never made. But Critias hasn’t mentioned cheating or poor workmanship. He has mentioned fish. The force of the example seems to come from what people think of the person behind the stall.
The third item changes the temperature of the list. Critias describes someone sitting in a brothel. Aeschines describes men sitting in brothels in his speech Against Timarchus, and he cites a law under which an Athenian citizen who had prostituted himself could be barred from addressing the Assembly. Whatever we make of that rule, it is a specific form of civic disqualification. Putting the cobbler next to the brothel lets that stigma color work that has no such restriction attached to it.
That’s the trouble with the list as an argument. Critias wants to show that making can be harmful or unworthy. He could point to something harmful that a person has made. Instead he runs together a craft, a trade and an occupation his audience may associate with a legal penalty. A restaurant review that complains about slow service, small portions and food poisoning in one sentence works the same way. By the end, the slow service has started to sound like a health hazard.
Cobbler talk sounds different when it comes from Socrates. In the Symposium, Alcibiades says Socrates’ speeches seem laughable at first, full of pack-asses, smiths, shoemakers and tanners. Open the speeches up, he says, and there’s something serious inside. Diogenes Laertius later tells of a cobbler named Simon who used to write down what he remembered after Socrates talked in his workshop. The story shows what later readers could imagine in a cobbler’s shop. Alcibiades gives us something firmer for the dialogue. The work Critias treats as beneath notice is precisely where Socrates finds examples worth thinking about.
There’s a darker echo in Xenophon. He says that Critias, while drafting laws with Charicles under the Thirty, inserted a ban on teaching the art of speech. Later the two summon Socrates and order him to stop talking to the young. Critias tells him to give up his favorite examples of cobblers, builders and metalworkers, which he says Socrates has worn out. Socrates asks whether that also means giving up the subjects those examples are meant to illuminate, such as justice. In the wrestling school, Critias wants to decide what counts as work. In Xenophon’s scene he can try to decide what Socrates is allowed to talk about.
My verdict is that Critias’ list gives a judgment about social rank the sound of a judgment about harm. If he wants us to call an action bad, there’s a question he has to answer about what the person did. It’s easy to miss the question when the brothel supplies all the heat. Put the cobbler back at his bench and ask what’s wrong with the work in front of him. Critias hasn’t said.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
According to the article, what is the central weakness in Critias’ list as an argument?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- What would Critias need to establish about cobbling or selling fish before their inclusion could support a claim about harmful or unworthy action?→
- How does placing a craft, a trade, and a legally stigmatized occupation in one list shape an audience’s judgment before any argument is made?→
- Why might Socrates’ use of humble occupations as philosophical examples challenge the social ranking that Critias’ list assumes?→