Renaissance

Check Your Feelings Before You Check the Painting

Pater makes knowing your own impression the first step toward seeing what is in front of you.

Matthew Arnold, Walter Pater, and Oscar Wilde give the critic’s feelings different jobs. Botticelli’s Madonnas let the feature test when a personal reaction can lead to a claim someone else can check.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • Pater adds a first stepMatthew Arnold asks the critic to see the object as it really is. Pater begins by asking the critic to examine the impression that the object produces.
  • Wilde gives the critic a different jobIn Wilde’s dialogue, Gilbert treats a work of art as a starting point for the critic’s own creation. Ernest gives that view its sharpest formulation, and Gilbert agrees.
  • Botticelli’s faces offer a testPater traces his first response to the Madonnas back to the wan color and the shape of their faces. Another viewer can look for those same details.
  • Follow the feeling back to its causeA critic can describe which features of a work provoke a response and which circumstances intensify it. That distinction gives others something they can return to and examine.

Pater opens his second paragraph by borrowing a line from Matthew Arnold, whose 1864 essay “The Function of Criticism at the Present Time” described the critic’s job as the effort “to see the object as in itself it really is.” Pater agrees that this “has been justly said to be the aim of all true criticism whatever,” and then he adds a step of his own. In aesthetic criticism, he says, “the first step towards seeing one’s object as it really is, is to know one’s own impression as it really is.” The edition’s note puts the shift plainly, since Arnold called for a disinterested study of the object and Pater makes a close description of the observer’s own impression the way in, and the question is whether that detour helps you see the thing or just helps you see yourself.

The case for worry comes from Pater’s most famous admirer. In the 1891 version of Oscar Wilde’s The Critic as Artist, Ernest sums up Gilbert’s theory. The primary aim of the critic is to see the object as in itself it really is not. Gilbert agrees and treats the artwork as a starting point for a new work of the critic’s own. The joke gives the inward turn a different destination. If attention to your own response leads there, then Pater’s step doesn’t correct projection at all, it turns projection into a style and hands it a license.

The case for Pater starts with an ordinary experience. Say you hear a song the week after a breakup and it absolutely wrecks you. If you just report that the song is devastating, you’re projecting, because half of what you felt was the breakup. But if you examine the response, you can start pulling it apart, the part that’s your week, the part that’s the line about leaving, the part that’s the chord change in the bridge, and you can test the pieces, asking whether it still lands a month later on a good day. That sorting is exactly what Pater asks of the critic when he says the job is “to distinguish, to analyse, and separate from its adjuncts, the virtue” of a work, and some of those adjuncts are you.

Pater shows the sorting at work in his chapter on Botticelli, where he takes a first reaction seriously instead of either trusting it or throwing it away. He admits that the painter’s “peevish-looking Madonnas” don’t fit any obvious type of beauty, and that at first “you may have thought that there was something in them mean or abject even.” Then he finds the reason in the paint, telling you that “the abstract lines of the face have little nobleness, and the colour is wan,” and once the first reaction has a cause you can check, he can go on to explain why the same faces “attract you more and more.” The inward look ends in claims about lines and color that anybody can take back to the picture.

So the same act can go two ways, and the difference lies in what you do with the impression once you’ve got hold of it. If you savor it, polish it and write it up as though the feeling were the finding, you end up where Wilde’s Gilbert ends up, and your examination has only made your projection more articulate. If you sort it, asking which parts come from the object and under what conditions, then the examination works like cleaning a lens you were always going to look through anyway, and you come out seeing more of the painting rather than more of yourself.

What evidence lets the rest of us tell which one a critic is doing? The first test is whether the response ends in a feature somebody else can find, such as wan color or lines with little nobleness, rather than a mood with nowhere to go. The second is whether it survives repetition, coming back on another day and in another frame of mind. The third is whether the critic owns up to the adjuncts, naming the parts of the effect that belong to him or to his moment. Pater doesn’t pass all three tests every time, and the Mona Lisa page shows him happily flying past the second and third, but his method has the tests built in, which Gilbert’s theory gives less reason to use.

It helps to notice the word Pater chose, because he calls knowing your impression the “first step,” and a first step only makes sense if there’s a second one, which in this case is the object itself, still standing there to be seen as it really is. Arnold’s formulation keeps the object in view without making the critic’s temperament the starting point. Pater’s version admits there’s a viewer and asks him to account for himself before he talks about the picture, which is less grand than Arnold and much more honest about how looking actually works.

So can you see an object clearly by examining your response to it? I think you can, and that you have no better option, because you always see through a response whether you inspect it or not. Pater’s step gives Arnold’s ideal a practical starting point. Wilde asks what the critic can make from an encounter. Close attention to your own impression corrects projection when it’s done as sorting and entrenches it when it’s done as savoring, and a critic shows which he’s doing by what he hands you at the end, a feeling to admire or a feature you can walk up to and check, which is why Pater’s sentence holds up as long as you take the word “first” literally.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

According to the article, what most clearly separates useful self-examination from licensed projection in criticism?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.