Philosophy

Be Men, and Feel Shame

What sounds like shyness in the wrestling school once helped Homer’s warriors stand their ground.

Socrates asks Charmides to answer like a man. The boy’s answer gives us a reason to ask what it takes to speak up when other people are watching.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • A manly answerSocrates asks Charmides to answer like a man, and the boy says temperance makes a person feel shame and become bashful.
  • Shame in battleAgamemnon and Ajax urge their men to feel shame before their comrades, while Hector imagines facing the people of Troy if he holds back.
  • Courage in inquiryIn the Laches, Socrates calls for the courage to keep examining a question when the argument has stalled.
  • A virtue in commonIn the Meno, Socrates argues that women and men both need temperance and justice, even in different roles.

Charmides 158c–e, 160d–e · Iliad 5.529–532, 6.441–443, 13.88–95, 15.561–564 · Aristotle, Politics 3.4, 1277b20–23 · Laches 194a · Meno 73a–c

Socrates’ request for the second definition comes with a challenge attached. He tells Charmides to look within himself and then answer “properly and like a man,” and the boy pauses and, after thinking it over “very much like a man,” says that temperance “makes a person feel shame and makes him bashful,” which makes it the same thing as modesty. The two Greek adverbs for answering and thinking like a man both come from the word for a man, and the first can also mean bravely, so on the surface the exchange looks like a mismatch, the coach’s pep talk followed by a confession of shyness. It sounds as though Socrates asked for something bold and got the virtue of a kid who stares at his shoes.

The mismatch looks sharper beside Aristotle’s account of how differently people judged men and women. He spells out the double standard bluntly in the Politics, saying that a man would seem a coward if he were only as brave as a brave woman, and a woman would seem a chatterbox if she were only as reserved as a good man. Restraint was graded on a curve, and the curve ran along the line between the sexes, so bashfulness can sound like an odd answer to a demand to speak like a man.

But go back to Homer, and the picture changes completely. In the Iliad, as Hector rallies the Trojans, Agamemnon shouts to his troops to be men, take up a fighting heart and feel shame before one another, and Ajax rallies them later with almost the same words, telling them to be men and put shame in their hearts. Poseidon even makes shame a battle cry when he calls out to the faltering Argives, much the way a coach yells at a team that’s falling apart in the fourth quarter. And Hector, explaining to his wife why he can’t stay safely inside the walls, says he would feel shame before the men and women of Troy if he hung back from the fighting like a coward. For these Homeric warriors, being a man and feeling shame can be part of a single command.

In these scenes, shame helps hold the line. A man is fighting beside people whose judgment matters to him, and both Agamemnon and Ajax count on that to make him stand firm. The feeling that makes a boy blush can also make a soldier think twice about running. Seen that way, Charmides’ answer is a lot manlier than it sounds, since Socrates asked for a manly answer and got an emotion Homer calls on to make warriors stand their ground.

The trouble is what that tradition reveals about the emotion. The warrior’s shame and the boy’s bashfulness both make sense in relation to an audience, the comrades in the line, the women on the walls, the admirers crowding the bench in the wrestling school, so courage of this kind is courage in front of people, and modesty of this kind is modesty in front of people, so both of them point outward, toward whoever happens to be looking. The courage Socrates cares about is different, and in the Laches he says they should keep going with the inquiry bravely so that courage herself won’t laugh at them for searching for her like cowards, which gives the joke a different point. Courage here is the nerve to keep thinking when thinking is getting you nowhere.

So “like a man” can have a different force in Socrates’ mouth. He asks the boy to say what he actually finds when he looks inside, even if it embarrasses him. The boy offers a definition that sounds a lot like his own blushing temperament. It takes some nerve for a teenager with a crowd of admirers to say out loud that the virtue he finds in himself is bashfulness, and the answer itself is the brave act Socrates asked for, whatever its merits as a definition.

In another dialogue, Socrates questions whether virtue itself varies with the person who has it. In the Meno, when Meno says a man’s virtue is running the city and a woman’s is running the house, Socrates asks whether anyone could run either one well without temperance and justice, and gets Meno to agree that men and women need the very same virtues to be good. The jobs stay different in that exchange, but the virtues needed to do them well are the same. The courage to answer honestly is something any thinker can show.

My verdict is that the language of manliness recalls an old Greek idea of modesty, shame as the soldier’s backbone. That tradition gives the boy’s answer more force than it first appears to have. It also invites us to ask how much courage and modesty depend on the thought of being watched. The bravery Socrates actually wants is the courage to look inward and report what you find, which Charmides shows in the act of answering, even while the answer he gives reminds us how much other people’s eyes can matter.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

Why does the author turn to Homer after presenting Charmides’ definition of temperance as bashfulness?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.