Philosophy
Ask About Brains, Get an Answer About Looks
Charmides’ beauty puts Socrates’ own composure on the line before he can question the boy.
The Platonic Dialogues: CharmidesSocrates asks who’s outstanding in wisdom, beauty or both, and Critias only hears “beauty.” It looks like a shallow answer, but Plato ran the other version of this scene in another dialogue, and the comparison shows why the Charmides needed the shallow one.
Orientation
At a Glance
- The answer is beautySocrates asks who stands out in wisdom, beauty, or both. Critias answers by pointing to the celebrated Charmides.
- What looking can tell usThe gym can see why Charmides draws a crowd. Finding out how he thinks takes a conversation.
- A different kind of entranceIn the Euthydemus, two brothers arrive with reputations for winning arguments. They make a show of trapping young Cleinias with a question about learning.
- The examiner is testedCharmides’ beauty shakes Socrates’ composure. The inquiry into temperance begins with the examiner’s own self-control at stake.
Socrates’ question has three doors, wisdom, beauty or both, and Critias walks straight through the middle one. “As for the beautiful ones, Socrates,” he says, Socrates will know in a moment, and then the fans come through the door and the conversation is off and running about a face. Nobody circles back to wisdom until Socrates himself drags it in, asking whether this famous beauty has a well-made soul to go with the body, and even then the intellectual credentials arrive as add-ons, with Critias assuring him the kid is thoroughly beautiful and good, a philosopher, and quite the poet on top of it all.
The obvious way to read this is as a little indictment of Critias and of the city he stands for. Athens, on this reading, ranks its young men by their looks, the crowd has already made its choice, and Critias simply passes the verdict along, so Plato is showing us a culture that answers a question about minds by holding up a headshot. That reading has a lot going for it, and it fits everything we’re about to learn about Critias and his taste for appearances, from the staged entrance to the fake doctor’s visit.
There’s a plainer reason Critias answers the way he does, though, and it has to do with what can be pointed at. Beauty is the one kind of distinction you can confirm with a glance across a room, while wisdom can’t be confirmed that way at all, so Critias answers the half of the question that can be settled by looking and leaves the other half for later. The wisdom question needs a conversation, and in a sense the rest of the dialogue is that conversation, so Critias’ lopsided answer isn’t only shallow, it’s also an honest admission of what a crowd can and can’t know about a boy.
What would change if intellectual distinction had supplied the introduction? We don’t have to guess, because Plato ran that experiment. In the Euthydemus Socrates is again at a gym, the Lyceum, sitting in the changing room, when two famous visitors walk in, the brothers Euthydemus and Dionysodorus, and they’re introduced entirely by their wisdom, as all-round fighters who can beat anyone in an argument the way a champion beats anyone in the ring. They used to teach fighting in armor and then courtroom speaking, Socrates explains, and now they’ve moved into the business of winning arguments, which makes them the closest thing ancient Athens had to a pair of celebrity debate coaches. There’s a handsome boy in that dialogue too, with his own crowd of admirers, but the show belongs to the two visiting experts and their reputation for cleverness.
The result is a completely different kind of dialogue. Faced with men who claim to be wise, Socrates is cool, ironic and in total control, and the conversation turns into a demolition derby in which the brothers produce one absurd trick argument after another while Socrates plays the admiring student with a perfectly straight face. Their opening move is to ask a teenager whether it’s the wise or the ignorant who learn, and then to refute him whichever answer he gives, which is less a search for truth than a magic trick performed on a kid. Nobody gets knocked off a bench and Socrates certainly doesn’t lose his head over anyone, because a man advertising his own wisdom is exactly the kind of opponent Socrates knows how to handle.
Leading with beauty puts Socrates in a much less comfortable spot, and that turns out to be the point. When the introduction is a face rather than a claim, the person most at risk is Socrates, whose confidence gets knocked out of him before he’s asked a single question, so the dialogue about temperance starts with the examiner’s own temperance on the line. If Critias had led with wisdom we’d have gotten a match between Socrates and a reputation, and we know how those go, but because he led with beauty we get a test of the whole person, the one asking the questions included.
It also changes where wisdom has to be found. In the Euthydemus wisdom is advertised, loudly, by the people claiming it, and Socrates’ job is to show the advertisement is empty. In the Charmides the boy never advertises anything, and since he has never claimed a thing for himself Socrates can’t win simply by puncturing a boast. Charmides blushes and won’t even say whether he has temperance, so wisdom has to be looked for inside a body everybody is staring at, which is exactly the move the Thracian doctor makes when he insists you can’t treat the head without the soul. Socrates’ “or both” turns out to be the right question for a dialogue about a virtue of the whole person, since temperance is supposed to show in how someone carries himself as much as in what he knows.
So Critias’ answer is shallow, and the dialogue is better for it. Plato lets the city answer a question about minds with a report on looks, and then uses that bad answer to force a better question, whether this beautiful boy is also good inside and whether the man asking can keep his own head while he finds out. Had wisdom made the introduction, we’d have gotten another fun fight like the Euthydemus, and because beauty made it instead, we got a dialogue in which the philosopher has something to lose.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
Why does the article regard Critias’s focus on beauty as more than merely shallow?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- If beauty can be recognized at a glance but wisdom requires conversation, what kinds of judgments about a person can observation legitimately support?→
- Why might an inquiry into temperance be stronger when the questioner’s own temperance is also being tested?→
- Does Critias’s shallow answer ultimately hinder philosophical inquiry, or does it create the conditions for a deeper inquiry into the whole person?→