Clive Staples Lewis, known to his family and friends as Jack, was an Irish-born scholar of medieval and Renaissance literature, a Christian apologist, a novelist and a poet, Fellow and Tutor in English at Magdalen College, Oxford, from 1925 to 1954 and the first Professor of Medieval and Renaissance English at Cambridge from 1954 to 1963. His forty-odd books fall into four kinds: the literary scholarship on which his academic reputation rested (The Allegory of Love, 1936; A Preface to Paradise Lost, 1942; English Literature in the Sixteenth Century, 1954; The Discarded Image, 1964); the apologetics that made him, from the wartime broadcasts and The Screwtape Letters (1942) onward, the best-known lay defender of Christianity in the English-speaking world (The Problem of Pain, 1940; Mere Christianity, 1952; Miracles, 1947; The Abolition of Man, 1943); the fiction, from the allegory of his own conversion, The Pilgrim’s Regress (1933), through the planetary romances of the Ransom trilogy (1938–45), The Great Divorce (1945) and Till We Have Faces (1956), to the seven Chronicles of Narnia (1950–56); and the poetry he wrote all his life and published first, under the name Clive Hamilton, in Spirits in Bondage (1919) and Dymer (1926). What unifies the work is a single imaginative possession, the pre-Copernican cosmos of the Middle Ages — the “Model”, as he called it, of nested spheres, planetary intelligences, angelic hierarchies and a world of daemons and longaevi — the long-lived fairies — between heaven and earth, inherited from Plato’s Timaeus through Chalcidius, Apuleius, Macrobius, Boethius and pseudo-Dionysius — which he expounded as a historian, inhabited as a novelist, and treated, in his own phrase, as having “a permanent value as spiritual symbols”. Around that Model he built a Christian Platonism of his own: the doctrine that the longing he called Joy is a desire for a country we have never seen; that the pagan myths were good dreams sent to the human race and the Gospel “a true myth” which “really happened”; that the higher is always present in the lower by “transposition”; that there is an objective moral law, the Tao, which men can obey or abolish but not invent; and that every human being is a possible god or goddess.
His relation to the esoteric currents of his age is the reverse of a convert’s. He met them early and from the inside: the matron at his preparatory school who floundered “in the mazes of Theosophy, Rosicrucianism, Spiritualism” and woke in him “the passion for the Occult”, which he called “a spiritual lust” and judged “probably this passion, more even than the desire for power, which makes magicians”; the evenings of 1921 in W. B. Yeats’s candlelit rooms where the talk was “all of magic and cabalism and ‘the Hermetic knowledge’”; the madness of a spiritualist doctor he helped to hold down in 1923; the Anthroposophy of his closest friend Owen Barfield, against which he fought a years-long private “Great War”; the Rosicrucian past of Charles Williams; a reading of Jacob Boehme in 1930 that shook him. From these he drew, on his own testimony, a lifelong aversion to occult practice, a diagnosis of its psychology, and the materials of his fiction, in which magicians, spiritualists and planners of the “Materialist Magician” kind are the villains and the planets, angels and Platonic forms the furniture of reality. He is at once the most widely read twentieth-century expositor of the cosmology that Renaissance magic took for granted, the first English critic to state, before the historians D. P. Walker and Frances Yates, that the magia of Ficino, Pico and Agrippa was the twin and not the enemy of the new science, and a determined adversary of every attempt to make that cosmology a technique. His life, the system of thought that his books share, the books in turn, and his reception are treated below.
Life#
Belfast, Bereavement and the Matron, 1898–1913#
Lewis was born on 29 November 1898 at Dundela Villas, Strandtown, Belfast, the second son of Albert James Lewis, a police-court solicitor, and Florence Augusta Hamilton, the daughter of the rector of St Mark’s, Dundela, where the child was baptised by his grandfather in January 1899. His brother Warren (“Warnie”), three years older, was his companion for life and, from 1932, his housemate. At about four he announced that he was to be called Jacksie, later Jack, and the name stuck. In 1905 the family moved to “Little Lea”, a large new house on the edge of the city whose attics, long corridors and shelves of books furnish the first chapter of his autobiography, Surprised by Joy (1955); there the brothers invented and wrote up, between about 1906 and 1913, the chronicles of Animal-Land and India that were published as Boxen in 1985. On 23 August 1908, Albert’s forty-fifth birthday, Flora Lewis died of cancer at Little Lea; the family calendar for that day carried the line from King Lear, “Men must endure their going hence, even as their coming hither; Ripeness is all”, which is now cut on the brothers’ gravestone.1
Within a month of his mother’s death Lewis was sent to Wynyard School at Watford, the “Belsen” of Surprised by Joy, under a headmaster later certified insane; the school closed in 1910. After a single term at Campbell College in Belfast he went in January 1911 to Cherbourg House, a preparatory school at Malvern (the “Chartres” of the autobiography), and stayed until July 1913. It was there, he records, that he lost his childhood faith, and the chapter in which he tells the story, “I Broaden My Mind”, is also his account of his first meeting with the occult. The matron, “dear Miss C.”, a kindly woman still in search of a religion, “was (as I should now put it) floundering in the mazes of Theosophy, Rosicrucianism, Spiritualism; the whole Anglo-American Occultist tradition”. She intended no harm — “she could not tell that the room into which she brought this candle was full of gunpowder” — but “for the first time, there burst upon me the idea that there might be real marvels all about us, that the visible world might be only a curtain to conceal huge realms uncharted by my very simple theology”. The effect was double. It “loosened the whole framework, blunted all the sharp edges, of my belief”, so that “little by little, with fluctuations which I cannot now trace, I became an apostate, dropping my faith with no sense of loss but with the greatest relief”; and it “started in me something with which, on and off, I have had plenty of trouble since — the desire for the preternatural, simply as such, the passion for the Occult”. His analysis of that desire, written forty years later, is the most considered statement of his life on the subject: “It is a spiritual lust; and like the lust of the body it has the fatal power of making everything else in the world seem uninteresting while it lasts. It is probably this passion, more even than the desire for power, which makes magicians.” He adds that he “once tried to describe it in a novel” — the novel is not named, and is usually taken to be That Hideous Strength — and that the occultist fancies and the atheism he was reaching at the same time by way of Lucretius “had only this in common, that both made against Christianity”. He is scrupulous to add that Miss C. “had been the occasion of much good to me as well as of evil”, and that in her “Higher Thought” there were “elements of real and disinterested spirituality by which I benefited”.2
Malvern, the Great Knock and Phantastes, 1913–1917#
A scholarship took him to Malvern College in September 1913, the “Wyvern” whose athleticism and hierarchy of “Bloods” he hated and described at length; he left after a year. In April 1914 he met Arthur Greeves, a neighbour at Strandtown, over a shared love of Myths of the Norsemen, and began the correspondence, nearly three hundred letters, that is the fullest record of his inner life; the first surviving letter announces a discovery, “an author exactly after my own heart, whom I am sure you would delight in, W. B. Yeats”, whose works “have all got that strange, eerie feeling about them, of which we are both professed admirers”. From September 1914 to the spring of 1917 he was taught privately at Great Bookham in Surrey by William T. Kirkpatrick, his father’s old headmaster, the “Great Knock” of the autobiography, a rationalist and atheist who trained him in dialectic and classics and confirmed the atheism he had already reached. On Saturday 4 March 1916, at the station bookstall at Leatherhead, he bought the Everyman edition of George MacDonald’s Phantastes and wrote to Greeves three days later that he had “had a great literary experience this week”; he had “picked up by hazard in a rather tired Everyman copy … on our station bookstall last Saturday” a book such that “never since I first read ‘The well at the world’s end’ have I enjoyed a book so much”, and Greeves “simply MUST get this at once”. Thirty years later, introducing his MacDonald anthology, he described the same evening as the crossing of “a great frontier”: he “had already been waist-deep in Romanticism; and likely enough, at any moment, to flounder into its darker and more evil forms, slithering down the steep descent that leads from the love of strangeness to that of eccentricity and thence to that of perversity”, and what the book did “was to convert, even to baptize (that was where the Death came in) my imagination”. In Surprised by Joy the sentence became “That night my imagination was, in a certain sense, baptized; the rest of me, not unnaturally, took longer.” The autobiography places the purchase in October; the letter fixes it in March.3
War, Mrs Moore and the Occult “Perhaps”, 1917–1924#
In December 1916 Lewis won a scholarship to University College, Oxford, and came into residence in April 1917; within weeks he had joined the Officers’ Training Corps, where he shared a room with Edward “Paddy” Moore and was drawn into the household of Paddy’s mother, Janie King Moore, who had separated from her husband and was living with her daughter Maureen. Commissioned in the Somerset Light Infantry, he reached the front line near Arras on his nineteenth birthday, 29 November 1917, had trench fever in February 1918, and on 15 April 1918 was wounded at Riez du Vinage by a British shell that fell short and killed the sergeant beside him. Paddy Moore had been killed in March. Whatever the two cadets had promised one another — the pact to care for the survivor’s parent is reported only at second hand — Lewis kept faith with Mrs Moore for the rest of her life: from 1920 or 1921 he lived in her household, at a succession of Oxford addresses and from 1930 at The Kilns, called her “mother”, concealed the arrangement from his father and nursed her through her last years until her death in January 1951. Whether the relationship was, in the early 1920s, a sexual one has been argued since his biographers first raised it (George Sayer and A. N. Wilson thought it likely; others doubt it); Lewis destroyed his diary for 1919–21 and never discussed it, and the question is not decidable. In March 1919 Heinemann published Spirits in Bondage: A Cycle of Lyrics under the name Clive Hamilton, his own first name and his mother’s maiden name. He took Firsts in Classical Moderations (1920), Literae Humaniores (1922) and, after a single year’s work, English (1923), and won the Chancellor’s English Essay Prize in 1921 with an essay, “Optimism”, of which no copy survives.4
These were also the years in which the occult came back. In 1920 his friend Leo Baker, later an anthroposophist, told him “how he had seen things ever since he was a child, and had played about with hypnotism and automatic writing” and “stated confidently that anyone could compel a ghost to appear”, which produced in Lewis “such a fit of superstitious terror as I have never known since childhood” and, for the present, “a violent distaste for mysteries and all that kind of business”. In March 1921 Baker took him twice to Yeats’s house in Broad Street. “I have been taken recently to see the mighty Yeats,” he told his father on 19 March; “It was the weirdest show you ever saw, and I fear he is a Kod [a humbug] … You sit on hard antique chairs by candlelight in an oriental looking room … listen in silence while the great man talks about magic and ghosts and mystics … What fluttering of the dovecote!” To Warnie, two days later, he was fuller: the stairway “lined with rather wicked pictures by Blake”, the room “lit by tall candles, with orange coloured curtains and full of things which I can’t describe”, the company (“the poet’s wife, a little man who never spoke all evening, and Father Martindale”), and the talk — “It was all of magic and cabalism and ‘the Hermetic knowledge.’ … The great man talked while the priest and Mrs Yeats fed him with judicious questions … I could never have believed that he was so exactly like his own poetry.” Of the second evening: “Of course we got on to magic in the end — that was only to be expected.” The autobiography draws the moral. “Here once more was a responsible adult (and not a Christian) who believed in a world behind, or around, the material world”; Lewis “did not give my assent categorically. But a drop of disturbing doubt fell into my Materialism. It was merely a ‘Perhaps.’” And “as soon as I paused on that ‘Perhaps’, inevitably all the old Occultist lore, and all the old excitement which the Matron of Chartres had innocently aroused in me, rose out of the past”. What ended the Perhaps was a horror. In February and March 1923 Mrs Moore’s brother, Dr John Askins, “the Doc”, a physician who had dabbled in spiritualism and psychical research, went violently mad in the house; Lewis helped to hold him through fits in which he screamed that devils were tearing him, and he died in an asylum in April. The diary records the doctors’ diagnosis, the tertiary stage of syphilis; Surprised by Joy, which does not, presents the episode as the lesson that cured him of “dabbling”, and both are Lewis’s own accounts.5
Magdalen, the Great War with Barfield and the Two Conversions, 1925–1931#
After a year’s lecturing in philosophy at University College, Lewis was elected Fellow and Tutor in English of Magdalen College on 20 May 1925 (“Elected fellow Magdalen. Jack.”, he wired his father), a post he held for twenty-nine years. Dent published Dymer, his narrative poem of 2,065 lines begun in 1916, in September 1926, again as Clive Hamilton; it was well reviewed and did not sell. On 11 May 1926 he met J. R. R. Tolkien at an English Faculty tea and noted in his diary, “No harm in him: only needs a smack or two”; Tolkien’s Icelandic reading club, the Coalbiters, followed, and from about 1933 the circle of friends that took over the name of a defunct undergraduate society, the Inklings, met on Thursday evenings in Lewis’s rooms and on Tuesday mornings at the Eagle and Child until the Thursday meetings lapsed in 1949.6
The decisive friendship of the decade, however, was with Owen Barfield, whom he had known since 1919 and later called “the wisest and best of my unofficial teachers”. Barfield heard Rudolf Steiner lecture in 1924 and became an anthroposophist, as did their mutual friend Cecil Harwood, who went on to found the first Steiner school in England; Lewis’s diary for late 1923 already notes that Barfield “has completely lost his materialism and ‘the night sky is no longer horrible’”. Between about 1925 and 1930 the two conducted what they called the “Great War”, a private campaign of conversation, letters and formal treatises — Lewis’s Summa Metaphysices contra Anthroposophos and Barfield’s De toto et parte among them — over whether imagination can be an organ of knowledge, as Barfield (and Steiner) held, or must be governed by reason and authority. The surviving documents of 1927–30 were published in 2015. Lewis’s verdict, in Surprised by Joy, is exact about what he took and what he refused: “Barfield never made me an Anthroposophist, but his counterattacks destroyed forever two elements in my own thought”, the first being “what I have called my ‘chronological snobbery,’ the uncritical acceptance of the intellectual climate common to our own age and the assumption that whatever has gone out of date is on that account discredited”. Barfield, for his part, insisted in 1976 that Lewis’s attitude to Anthroposophy had been “explicitly detached and indeed hostile”, and, against the suggestion that he had merely heard vaguely of Steiner, “He had heard, and he did think.”7
The conversion followed in two stages and is told in the autobiography’s last two chapters. “You must picture me alone in that room in Magdalen, night after night, feeling, whenever my mind lifted even for a second from my work, the steady, unrelenting approach of Him whom I so earnestly desired not to meet … In the Trinity Term of 1929 I gave in, and admitted that God was God, and knelt and prayed: perhaps, that night, the most dejected and reluctant convert in all England.” The year is a slip of memory. The letters of 1929 show no belief, those of early 1930 do (“Things are going very, very well with me (spiritually)”, to Greeves on 30 January 1930; “Terrible things are happening to me”, to Barfield a few days later), and the manuscript draft of the autobiography ties the event to the month in which he learned to dive, which was June 1930; Alister McGrath and Andrew Lazo, working independently in 2012, redated the surrender to Trinity Term 1930, and the correction is now accepted. It followed, rather than preceded, the death of his father, whom he had nursed through the late summer of 1929 and who died at Little Lea on 25 September. In 1930, with Warnie home from China, the brothers and Mrs Moore bought The Kilns at Headington Quarry, and in the same year Lewis read, among much devotional literature — Traherne, William Law, the Theologia Germanica, MacDonald’s sermons — Jacob Boehme’s Signatura Rerum (The Signature of All Things, in the Everyman edition) and told Greeves that it had shaken him as nothing had since Phantastes. The second stage came in the autumn of 1931. On the night of 19–20 September he walked on Addison’s Walk with Tolkien and Hugo Dyson until the small hours; the argument, as he summarised it to Greeves on 18 October, was that the pagan stories of dying gods were God’s myth told through the poets, and that “The story of Christ is simply a true myth: a myth working on us in the same way as the others … but with this tremendous difference that it really happened”. On 28 September, driven to Whipsnade Zoo in the sidecar of Warnie’s motorcycle, he crossed the line: “When we set out I did not believe that Jesus Christ is the Son of God, and when we reached the zoo I did. Yet I had not exactly spent the journey in thought … It was more like when a man, after a long sleep, still lying motionless in bed, becomes aware that he is now awake.” He resumed communion at Holy Trinity, Headington Quarry, on Christmas Day 1931. The next August, in a fortnight at Greeves’s house in Belfast, he wrote the allegory of the whole journey, The Pilgrim’s Regress (1933).8
The Oxford Don: Scholarship, Williams and the Inklings, 1932–1939#
The Allegory of Love: A Study in Medieval Tradition, published by the Clarendon Press in May 1936 and dedicated to Barfield, made his academic name and won the British Academy’s Sir Israel Gollancz Memorial Prize in 1937 (the Hawthornden Prize sometimes credited to it went to Evelyn Waugh in 1936 and to Ruth Pitter in 1937; Lewis never won it). In February 1936 he read Charles Williams’s novel The Place of the Lion and wrote to its author on 11 March that “A book sometimes crosses ones path which is so like the sound of ones native language in a strange country”, that it had been “one of the major literary events of my life”, and that he should come and stay in College; Williams, who was at that moment reading the proofs of The Allegory of Love for the Oxford University Press, wrote the same day, and the letters crossed. When the Press moved to Oxford in September 1939 Williams joined the Inklings and lectured for the English Faculty; his sudden death on 15 May 1945 had, Lewis said, “Greatly reduced my feeling about ghosts” — “I think (but who knows?) that I should be, tho afraid, more pleased than afraid, if his turned up.” Williams had been initiated in 1917 into the Salvator Mundi Temple of A. E. Waite’s Fellowship of the Rosy Cross, an offshoot of the Golden Dawn, and had remained active in it through the 1920s; Grevel Lindop’s biography (2015) judges that his magical experiment was “probably considerable” and that he “hid all of this from his wife and from the Inklings”. No statement by Lewis about Williams’s Rosicrucian past survives; what he wrote about was the novels, in which the marvellous breaks into the ordinary world, and the Arthurian poems, whose unfinished commentary he completed in Arthurian Torso (1948). The years before the war also produced the first of the planetary romances, Out of the Silent Planet (1938), and Rehabilitations (1939), the essays that include “The Alliterative Metre” with its poem “The Planets”.9
The War, the Broadcasts and Fame, 1939–1949#
In September 1939 evacuee children were lodged at The Kilns; Lewis, at forty, tried to re-enlist, declined to write for the Ministry of Information, and served in the Home Guard. The Problem of Pain appeared in October 1940, and from 1941 he spent weekends and vacations speaking at RAF stations. On 6 August 1941 he gave the first of four Wednesday-evening talks on the BBC; three further series followed, the last on seven Tuesdays in February–April 1944, and the four printed booklets were gathered as Mere Christianity in 1952. The thirty-one letters of Screwtape ran in the Anglican weekly The Guardian from May to November 1941 and appeared as a book in February 1942; Time, putting him on its cover on 8 September 1947 under the heading “Don v. Devil”, reported that the book had “gone through 20 British and 14 U.S. printings” and had made its author a celebrity. From January 1942 he presided over the Oxford University Socratic Club, founded to debate the case for and against Christianity, and did so until he left for Cambridge. At its meeting of 2 February 1948 Elizabeth Anscombe read a paper against chapter 3 of Miracles (1947), arguing that his case against naturalism confused “irrational” with “non-rational” causes; Lewis conceded the terminological point, rewrote the chapter for the 1960 edition, and told Stella Aldwinckle in 1950 that Anscombe had “obliterated me as an Apologist”. The legend that he was humiliated into abandoning apologetics for children’s stories, built up by his biographers Humphrey Carpenter, George Sayer and A. N. Wilson, does not survive the evidence: Anscombe herself described a sober exchange and called his revisions a sign of “honesty and seriousness”, and he went on writing apologetic essays for the rest of his life; but he wrote no further book-length apologetics, and the debate shook him. He collapsed from overwork in June 1949, and the last Thursday evening of the Inklings was held that October.10
Cambridge, Honours and Joy Davidman, 1946–1960#
The honours came from outside Oxford: an honorary Doctorate of Divinity from St Andrews in June 1946, whose Dean of Divinity said that he had “arranged a new kind of marriage between theological reflection and poetic imagination”; doctorates from Laval (1952), Manchester (1959), Dijon (1962) and Lyon (1963); election to the Royal Society of Literature (1948) and the British Academy (1955). Oxford passed him over for the Merton and Goldsmiths’ chairs and, in 1951, elected C. Day-Lewis Professor of Poetry against him. In December 1951 he declined a CBE in Churchill’s New Year Honours, telling the Prime Minister’s secretary that “there are … knaves who say, and fools who believe, that my religious writings are all covert anti-Leftist propaganda, and my appearance in the Honours List would of course strengthen their hands”. In June 1954 Cambridge elected him to its new Chair of Medieval and Renaissance English, with a Professorial Fellowship at Magdalene; he gave his inaugural lecture, “De Descriptione Temporum”, on his fifty-sixth birthday, 29 November 1954, and from January 1955 divided his weeks between Cambridge and The Kilns. The seven Chronicles of Narnia were published between 1950 and 1956, the last winning the Carnegie Medal; Surprised by Joy appeared in 1955 and Till We Have Faces in 1956.11
The first letter from Helen Joy Davidman, an American poet and novelist, a former Communist whose conversion owed something to his books, reached The Kilns in January 1950; they met in Oxford in September 1952, and in 1953 she settled in England with her two sons. On 23 April 1956, so that she could remain in the country when her permit lapsed, Lewis married her at the Oxford register office in what he described to a friend as “a pure matter of friendship and expediency”; in October her cancer was diagnosed, and on 21 March 1957 they were married by a priest, Peter Bide, at her bedside in the Wingfield-Morris Hospital, Bide praying for her healing. She recovered enough to come home, and the remission lasted through 1958; in April 1960 they travelled to Greece with Roger Lancelyn Green and his wife; she died at the Radcliffe Infirmary on 13 July 1960. The notebooks he kept in the months after were published in 1961 as A Grief Observed under the name N. W. Clerk.12
Last Years, 1961–1963#
Lewis’s own health had been failing since 1957, when osteoporosis was diagnosed; from June 1961 he suffered from prostate and kidney disease. On 16 July 1963, in the Acland Nursing Home, he had a heart attack and lapsed into a coma, was given the last rites, and woke the next afternoon; in August he resigned the Cambridge chair, and Magdalene elected him an Honorary Fellow. At 5.30 in the afternoon of Friday 22 November 1963 — the day of President Kennedy’s assassination and of Aldous Huxley’s death — he collapsed in his bedroom at The Kilns and died within minutes, a week short of his sixty-fifth birthday. He was buried on 26 November at Holy Trinity, Headington Quarry, at a funeral that Tolkien described to his daughter as “quiet and attended only by intimates and some Magdalen people including the President”, and that Warnie, prostrated by grief, did not attend. Warnie died in 1973 and lies in the same grave. Lewis’s American correspondent Walter Hooper, who had acted as his secretary in the summer of 1963, became literary adviser to the Estate and edited the posthumous volumes for the next half-century, from Poems (1964) to the Collected Letters (2000–06); the charge brought by Kathryn Lindskoog from 1978 onward that Hooper had forged the fragment The Dark Tower (1977) and inflated his intimacy with Lewis has not been accepted by scholars, though the fragment’s provenance still rests on Hooper’s word and the stylometric anomalies have not been explained away. A memorial stone to Lewis was dedicated in Poets’ Corner, Westminster Abbey, on 22 November 2013, the fiftieth anniversary of his death, with a sentence from “Is Theology Poetry?” cut into it: “I believe in Christianity as I believe that the Sun has risen, not only because I see it but because by it I see everything else.”13
Thought#
The System in Outline#
Lewis never wrote a summa, and he disclaimed the title of philosopher; but the books share a single structure, and a reader who holds it in mind will find that the apologetics, the fiction, the criticism and the autobiography are statements of the same thing in different registers. The structure has four members.
The first is a fact about human beings: they carry an unsatisfied longing, which he called Joy and defined as “an unsatisfied desire which is itself more desirable than any other satisfaction”, and which nothing in the world answers. Followed faithfully — by what he called “the dialectic of Desire” — it is evidence that we were made for something beyond the world, and it is the engine of his autobiography, of the allegory of his conversion, of the sermons and of the argument from desire in the apologetics.
The second is a fact about reality: it is layered, and the layers are objective. Above the shadow-world of ordinary experience stands a more solid world, the “further up and further in” of The Last Battle and the diamond-hard grass of The Great Divorce; values are as objective as things, the Tao of The Abolition of Man being “the doctrine of objective value”; and the higher reproduces itself in the lower in a manner that the lower cannot by itself detect, which is the law he called transposition. The great picture of this layered order is the cosmos of the Middle Ages that he spent his professional life expounding: the nine spheres, the Intelligences that move them, the hierarchies of angels, the daemons and longaevi of the middle air, man as the “little world” in whom every mode of being meets, and the beasts below him.
The third is a doctrine of knowledge: myth and imagination are organs of meaning, not of falsehood. The pagan myths are God “expressing Himself through the minds of poets”; the Gospel is “a true myth” which “really happened”; reason is the organ of truth, but imagination the organ of meaning, and a truth that cannot be imagined cannot be lived. He learned this from George MacDonald, Chesterton, Barfield and Tolkien, and it is the reason he wrote fiction at all.
The fourth is a doctrine of the self: it is to be remade, not improved. The aim of the religion he defended is not nice people but new men, “little Christs”, and finally creatures that the sermon “The Weight of Glory” calls “possible gods and goddesses”. The obstacles are pride, the craving to be inside the “Inner Ring”, and the twin modern temptations of scientism and magic, which seek alike to subdue reality to the will instead of conforming the soul to reality.
What he rejected follows from the same map, and he rejected it with the authority of one who had been tempted: occultism and spiritualism, which put power and curiosity in the place of worship; Theosophy and Anthroposophy, which mistake imagination for a source of knowledge about the supra-sensible; pantheism and the “Life-Force”, a “tame God” who makes no demands; dualism and Manichaeism, which give evil an independent standing; “Christianity-and-water”, in which a good God in heaven leaves everything as it is; and the scientism that treats the conquest of nature as the end of man. The sections that follow take the members in turn.
Joy and the Dialectic of Desire#
The first chapter of Surprised by Joy describes three episodes of early childhood — a toy garden made by his brother in the lid of a biscuit tin, which Lewis compares to “Milton’s ‘enormous bliss’ of Eden”; the Idea of Autumn that rose from Beatrix Potter’s Squirrel Nutkin; and the lines of Longfellow’s Tegnér on the death of Balder — and warns the reader that if he finds them uninteresting he need read no further, “for in a sense the central story of my life is about nothing else”. What the episodes share “is that of an unsatisfied desire which is itself more desirable than any other satisfaction. I call it Joy, which is here a technical term and must be sharply distinguished both from Happiness and from Pleasure.” It shares with them only “the fact that anyone who has experienced it will want it again”; in its quality “it might almost equally well be called a particular kind of unhappiness or grief. But then it is a kind we want”; and “Joy is never in our power and pleasure often is”. The German word Sehnsucht, which he used for it, has given its name to a journal.14
The preface to the third edition of The Pilgrim’s Regress (1943) gives the method. The “Romanticism” of the allegory’s subtitle had meant this experience, which he there calls sweet Desire: “This sweet Desire cuts across our ordinary distinctions between wanting and having.” It attaches itself in turn to objects — a landscape, the past, the planets, the erotic, knowledge — and “Every one of these supposed objects for the Desire is inadequate to it”; magic is explicitly on the list of false candidates, and “With Magic in the darker sense (as it has been and is actually practised) we should fare even worse.” Hence “The dialectic of Desire, faithfully followed, would retrieve all mistakes, head you off from all false paths” and force the recognition that the object is not in the world at all. The sermon “The Weight of Glory”, preached in the University Church at Oxford on 8 June 1941, is the same argument addressed to a congregation. “I am trying to rip open the inconsolable secret in each one of you”, a secret so tender that we take revenge on it “by calling it names like Nostalgia and Romanticism and Adolescence”; the beauty of books and music, if “mistaken for the thing itself”, turns into “dumb idols, breaking the hearts of their worshippers”, for “they are only the scent of a flower we have not found”; we remain “conscious of a desire which no natural happiness will satisfy”, with “the sense that in this universe we are treated as strangers”. The desire is not to see beauty but to enter it: “We do not want merely to see beauty, though, God knows, even that is bounty enough. We want something else which can hardly be put into words — to be united with the beauty we see … to pass into it, to receive it into ourselves, to bathe in it, to become part of it.” And “That is why we have peopled air and earth and water with gods and goddesses and nymphs and elves” — the pagan pantheon as the projection of the longing. The promise is that “The door on which we have been knocking all our lives will open at last.” In Mere Christianity the argument is put as an inference: “If I find in myself a desire which no experience in this world can satisfy, the most probable explanation is that I was made for another world”; and in The Problem of Pain the soul is “a hollow made to fit a particular swelling in the infinite contours” of God, each soul bearing its own “signature”.15
The autobiography’s fourteenth chapter records the correction that the doctrine needed. From Samuel Alexander’s Space, Time and Deity (1920) Lewis took the distinction between “enjoyment” (the act of mind) and “contemplation” (its object) and saw that “the enjoyment and the contemplation of our inner activities are incompatible”: “all my waitings and watchings for Joy … had been a futile attempt to contemplate the enjoyed”. The consequence was decisive for everything he wrote afterwards about mysticism and inner states. “Joy itself, considered simply as an event in my own mind, turned out to be of no value at all. All the value lay in that of which Joy was the desiring.” Joy “proclaimed” something other: “You want — I myself am your want of — something other, outside, not you nor any state of you”, and its object is “the naked Other, imageless (though our imagination salutes it with a hundred images) … unknown, undefined, desired”. After the conversion the longing lost its interest for him; it had been a signpost, and one does not stop to admire signposts once the road is found.16
Myth, Imagination and the Fact#
The second member of the system was fixed in a single night. On 19 September 1931 Lewis walked with Tolkien and Hugo Dyson on Addison’s Walk and talked, as he told Greeves three days later, first “on metaphor and myth” and then, in his rooms, “on Christianity: a good long satisfying talk in which I learned a lot”. The letter of 18 October states what he had learned. He had always been moved by the idea of sacrifice and of a dying and reviving god when he met it in pagan story and repelled by it in the Gospels; “Now what Dyson and Tolkien showed me was this”, that “the story of Christ is simply a true myth: a myth working on us in the same way as the others, but with this tremendous difference that it really happened”; “the Pagan stories are God expressing Himself through the minds of poets”, “using such images as He found there”, “while Christianity is God expressing Himself through what we call ‘real things.’” The doctrines “we get out of the true myth are of course less true”: “they are translations into our concepts and ideas of that which God has already expressed in a language more adequate”, “namely the actual incarnation, crucifixion, and resurrection”. The essay “Myth Became Fact” (1944) made it a thesis — “The heart of Christianity is a myth which is also a fact” — and Till We Have Faces made it a novel. The position has an ancestry: Lewis’s “good dreams” are the Christian Platonists’ praeparatio evangelica, and his insistence that the Incarnation does not cease to be myth by becoming fact is what separates him from the demythologising theology of his day, which he attacked in “Fern-seed and Elephants” (1959).17
What imagination is, and what it is not, he worked out against Barfield. Poetic Diction (1928) had argued that early language was an “ancient semantic unity” in which the literal and the figurative had not yet divided, and Lewis acknowledged that “Much of the thought which he afterward put into Poetic Diction had already become mine”; in That Hideous Strength Ransom cites “one of Barfield’s ‘ancient unities.’” Barfield’s “counterattacks”, he says, destroyed two things in him, his “chronological snobbery” and his belief that the world disclosed by the senses is rock-bottom reality; “But I think he changed me a good deal more than I him.” What Lewis would not grant was the Anthroposophical corollary, that imagination trained in Steiner’s manner becomes an organ of knowledge about the supra-sensible. His essay “Bluspels and Flalansferes” (1939) ends with the formula that governed his practice: reason is the organ of truth, imagination the organ of meaning; a metaphor, a myth, a picture of the cosmos tells us what a truth would mean if it were true, and leaves to reason and to revelation the question whether it is. It is why he could spend his life inside a cosmology he did not believe to be physically true, and why he insisted that Narnia was not an allegory. In the preface to The Great Divorce he puts the rule for his fiction: “the transmortal conditions are solely an imaginative supposal”, and “I beg readers to remember that this is a fantasy”. Tolkien’s lecture “On Fairy-Stories” (1939), with its doctrine of sub-creation and of the “eucatastrophe” that “denies universal final defeat and in so far is evangelium”, and his statement that “The Birth of Christ is the eucatastrophe of man’s history”, is the companion text; the sentence from “Is Theology Poetry?” (1944) that is now cut in Westminster Abbey gives the epistemology in a line: “I believe in Christianity as I believe that the Sun has risen, not only because I see it but because by it I see everything else.”18
The Model: The Medieval Cosmos and the Planets#
The picture of the universe that Lewis taught for thirty years and described in The Discarded Image (1964) is the one that Western esotericism also inherited, and he knew it. The medieval mind, he writes, had an “intense love of system”; “All the apparent contradictions must be harmonised. A Model must be built which will get everything in without a clash”; and yet “On the highest level, then, the Model was recognised as provisional.” The Model’s materials are Platonic and late-antique. The Timaeus in Chalcidius’s Latin and commentary; Apuleius’s De deo Socratis with its daemons, the intermediaries between gods and men who inhabit the air; Cicero’s Somnium Scipionis and Macrobius’s commentary on it; the Celestial Hierarchy of pseudo-Dionysius with its nine orders of angels; Boethius’s Consolation — these are the classical and “seminal” authors of his third and fourth chapters, and the chapter on the heavens then builds the cosmos they imply. “Fixed in each of the first seven spheres is one luminous body. Starting from Earth, the order is the Moon, Mercury, Venus, the Sun, Mars, Jupiter and Saturn; the ‘seven planets’. Beyond the sphere of Saturn is the Stellatum”; “Beyond the Stellatum there is a sphere called the First Moveable or Primum Mobile”. Each sphere is moved by an Intelligence; each planet has a character and an influence; the elements seek their “kindly stede”, for “Everything has its right place” and “moves thither by a sort of homing instinct”; Fortune “fulfills the office of an Intelligence in the mode proper for a stationary globe”. Looking up, the medieval man did not feel what we feel: “the spheres of the old present us with an object in which the mind can rest … overwhelming in its greatness but satisfying in its harmony”. Between the planets and ourselves lies the realm of the Longaevi, the fairies, whose “place of residence is ambiguous between air and Earth”; Lewis reviews the medieval attempts to find them a place in the scheme — a third rank of rational creatures, the dead, fallen angels, demons — and concludes, “Such were the efforts to find a socket into which the Fairies would fit. No agreement was achieved … As long as the Fairies remained at all they remained evasive.” Man, in the seventh chapter, “is a rational animal, and therefore a composite being”, which “gives us one of the senses in which he is the ‘little world’ or microcosm”: “Every mode of being in the whole universe contributes to him; he is a cross-section of being.” His soul has the vegetable, sensitive and rational powers, and in the rational “We are enjoying intellectus when we ‘just see’ a self-evident truth”, “we are exercising ratio when we proceed step by step to prove a truth which is not self-evident”; the “spirits” that mediate between soul and body Lewis calls “the least reputable feature in the Medieval Model”. The whole has a direction: “Historically as well as cosmically, medieval man stood at the foot of a stairway”. And the Model’s power was its imaginability: “Other ages have not had a Model so universally accepted as theirs, so imaginable and so satisfying to the imagination.”19
Lewis’s own attitude to the Model is stated twice, in the book’s epilogue and, thirty years earlier, in the essay in which he published the poem “The Planets”. The epilogue holds that no model, medieval or modern, is a catalogue of ultimate realities; each answers to the evidence of its age and to the taste of its age, and each is “provisional”. The essay, “The Alliterative Metre” (1935; collected in Rehabilitations, 1939), prints the poem as a specimen of the metre and explains the choice of subject: it “was not chosen under the influence of any antiquarian fancy that a medieval metre demanded medieval matter”, “but because the characters of the planets, as conceived by medieval astrology”, “seem to me to have a permanent value as spiritual symbols — to provide a Phänomenologie des Geistes which is specially worth while in our own generation. Of Saturn we know more than enough. But who does not need to be reminded of Jove?” The poem’s Jupiter brings “guilt forgiven, and good fortune”, “Jove is master; and of jocund revel”. That is the whole of his astrology: not prediction, which he never credited, but a psychology and a theology of the seven planetary characters — Saturn’s melancholy, Jupiter’s kingly festivity, Mars’s valour, the Sun’s gold and wisdom, Venus’s fertility, Mercury’s quickness of meaning, the Moon’s wandering — held as “spiritual symbols”. The Church, he noted, had never denied the general theory of planetary influence on plants, minerals and temperament; what it fought were lucrative prediction, determinism and planet-worship. From the symbols he built his fiction. The eldila (angelic beings) and Oyéresu (plural of Oyarsa, the ruling intelligence of a planet) of the Ransom trilogy are the Intelligences of the spheres; in That Hideous Strength the Director’s “Masters are the Oyéresu”, “Malacandra and Perelandra have spoken to me”, and in the chapter called “The Descent of the Gods” the five come down in their old characters — Mercury “the lord of Meaning himself, the herald, the messenger, the slayer of Argus”; Venus, “triumphant among planets, whom men call Venus”; “vigilant Malacandra, captain of a cold orb, whom men call Mars and Mavors”; “Saturn, whose name in the heavens is Lurga”; and Jupiter the “King of Kings” — “ancient eldils, steersmen of giant worlds”. Michael Ward’s Planet Narnia (2008) argued that each of the seven Chronicles is secretly governed by one planet in the same seven characters, and whatever is made of the thesis, it rests on Lewis’s own statement that the planets are symbols of permanent value. Ramandu, the retired star of The Voyage of the Dawn Treader, gives the children the rule for the whole: “Even in your world, my son, that is not what a star is but only what it is made of.”20
Christian Platonism: Shadows, Substance and Transposition#
“It’s all in Plato, all in Plato”, says the Professor at the end of The Last Battle, when the children find that the Narnia they knew was a shadow of the real one and that England too was only the “Shadowlands”. The line is Lewis’s confession. His Platonism was Christian, of the Boethian and Augustinian kind, and it had three articles. The first is the solidity of the higher world. In The Great Divorce the narrator, arriving from the Grey Town, has “the sense of being in a larger space, perhaps even a larger sort of space”; “It was the light, the grass, the trees that were different, made of some different substance, so much solider than things in our country, that men were ghosts by comparison”; “The grass, hard as diamonds to my unsubstantial feet”; the visitors “were in fact ghosts: man-shaped stains on the brightness of that air”, and “Reality is harsh to the feet of shadows.” George MacDonald, the narrator’s guide, gives the doctrine: “Hell is a state of mind — ye never said a truer word”, but “Heaven is reality itself. All that is fully real is Heavenly.” The second article is objective hierarchy. A Preface to Paradise Lost names it “the Hierarchical conception”, the “ancient orthodox tradition of European ethics from Aristotle to Johnson himself”: “According to this conception degrees of value are objectively present in the universe. Everything except God has some natural superior; everything except unformed matter has some natural inferior. The goodness, happiness, and dignity of every being consists in obeying its natural superior” and ruling its natural inferiors; Satan’s sin, in the chapter on Satan, is to have “wished to ‘be himself’”, and “The Hell he carries with him is, in one sense, a Hell of infinite boredom.” The third article is transposition. The sermon of that name (1944) begins from translation — “If you are to translate from a language which has a large vocabulary into a language that has a small vocabulary”, the poorer language must make one word do for several meanings — and from drawing, where three dimensions are rendered in two, and lays down the law of “this kind of transposition or adaptation from a richer to a poorer medium”: “The transposition of the richer into the poorer must, so to speak, be algebraical, not arithmetical.” The sign “can be understood only if we know the higher medium”; from below it cannot be read — “The brutal man never can by analysis find anything but lust in love”; “Spiritual things are spiritually discerned.” He ends by asking whether the principle “may help us to conceive the Incarnation” and “the doctrine of the resurrection of the body”. This is Lewis’s general theory of symbol and sacrament, and it is the bridge between his Platonism and his refusal of the Platonists’ contempt for the body: the lower is not an illusion but a transposition, and glorified flesh is the richer medium reached at last. The Neoplatonic authorities he worked with were Boethius (seventh on the list of the ten books that most shaped him, which he gave to The Christian Century in 1962: Phantastes, The Everlasting Man, the Aeneid, Herbert’s Temple, The Prelude, Otto’s Idea of the Holy, Boethius’s Consolation, Boswell’s Johnson, Williams’s Descent into Hell and Balfour’s Theism and Humanism), Macrobius, Chalcidius, Apuleius and pseudo-Dionysius; Plotinus he knew and cited, among the authorities the Florentines harmonised and in Letters to Malcolm, but there is no evidence that the Enneads shaped him as Boethius did.21
The Tao: Objective Value and the Abolition of Man#
The Riddell Memorial Lectures that Lewis gave for the University of Durham, at King’s College, Newcastle, in February 1943, published as The Abolition of Man, state the ethics of the system. “The Chinese also speak of a great thing (the greatest thing) called the Tao. It is Nature, it is the Way, the Road. It is the Way in which the universe goes on”; under that name he groups the Platonic, Aristotelian, “Stoic, Christian, and Oriental alike” conceptions of an objective order, “the doctrine of objective value, the belief that certain attitudes are really true, and others really false, to the kind of thing the universe is and the kind of things we are”. The psychology is Plato’s: “As the king governs by his executive, so Reason in man must rule the mere appetites by means of the ‘spirited element’. The head rules the belly through the chest — the seat, as Alanus tells us, of Magnanimity, of emotions organized by trained habit into stable sentiments.” A schooling that debunks the sentiments produces “Men without Chests”: “We make men without chests and expect of them virtue and enterprise. We laugh at honour and are shocked to find traitors in our midst.” The second lecture argues that the Tao “is not one among a series of possible systems of value. It is the sole source of all value judgements”, so that every attempt to build a new ethic from outside it borrows its authority from it; “Only those who are practising the Tao will understand it.” The third follows the logic of “Man’s conquest of Nature” to its end. Each generation’s power over nature is a power over later generations; when human nature itself is conquered, the “Conditioners” who do the conquering, having stepped outside the Tao, have nothing left to guide them but impulse; “what we call Man’s power over Nature turns out to be a power exercised by some men over other men with Nature as its instrument”; “Man’s conquest of Nature turns out, in the moment of its consummation, to be Nature’s conquest of Man”, and “Man’s final conquest has proved to be the abolition of Man.” He hopes instead for “The regenerate science which I have in mind”, which “would not do even to minerals and vegetables what modern science threatens to do to man himself”. The appendix, “Illustrations of the Tao”, sets out passages from the Egyptian Book of the Dead and the Precepts of Ptah-hetep, the Laws of Manu, the Analects, the Völuspá, Babylonian hymns, the Old and New Testaments, Cicero, Locke and Hooker under eight heads of natural law. The word Tao itself he may have taken from Charles Gore’s The Philosophy of the Good Life, read in January 1940. The political corollary was stated in “Equality” (1943): “I am a democrat because I believe in the Fall of Man. Mankind is so fallen that no man can be trusted with unchecked power over his fellows”; but “There is no spiritual sustenance in flat equality”, and “Let us wear equality; but let us undress every night.” In the novels Ransom puts it shortly: “Equality guards life; it doesn’t make it. It is medicine, not food.”22
Angels, Daemons and Devils#
Lewis’s angelology is the Model’s, and he states it plainly in the two prefaces to The Screwtape Letters. In 1941, in the sentences quoted under Screwtape below, there are “two equal and opposite errors” about the devils, disbelief and an unhealthy interest, and the devils “hail a materialist or a magician with the same delight”. In 1960, asked whether he believed in the Devil, he answered that if by the Devil “you mean a power opposite to God, and, like God, self-existent from all eternity”, “the answer is certainly No. God has no opposite.” “The proper question is whether I believe in devils. I do. That is to say, I believe in angels, and I believe that some of these, by the abuse of their free will, have become enemies to God and, as a corollary, to us. They do not differ in nature from good angels, but their nature is depraved. Devil is the opposite of angel only as Bad Man is the opposite of Good Man. Satan, the leader or dictator of devils, is the opposite, not of God, but of Michael.” The same preface explains why his hell is a bureaucracy: “I live in the Managerial Age, in a world of ‘Admin.’”, and the greatest evil is now done by quiet men in offices, in the sentence quoted under Screwtape below; “I like bats much better than bureaucrats.” Mere Christianity supplies the doctrine behind the fiction: “Christianity thinks this Dark Power was created by God”, “was good when he was created, and went wrong”, which is “why Christianity has always said that the devil is a fallen angel”. The good angels of the fiction are the eldila, bodiless, swift, barely visible beings of Deep Heaven, and their lords the Oyéresu, one to each planet; the devils are the “terrestrial eldils” of the “silent planet”, and, in That Hideous Strength, the “macrobes” with whom Frost of the N.I.C.E., the novel’s National Institute of Co-ordinated Experiments, believes himself in scientific contact — “You have probably not heard of macrobes … I did not say microbes, I said macrobes” — and who speak through the severed Head. Lewis knew the lineage. In English Literature in the Sixteenth Century he notes of Ficino that “Platonism, in fact, is for him a system of daemonology”, that Agrippa holds that “by proper means the mundana numina can be called” (the numina being the powers of the world) “or at the very least the daemons (not demons) who are their attendants”, and that the Apuleian daemons had “trickled down from Apuleius into Bernardus Sylvestris and Geoffrey of Monmouth”. His own daemons are these, baptised: the neutral intermediaries of Apuleius sorted into the obedient and the bent.23
Magic and Science: The Twins#
The thesis for which historians of esotericism might have claimed Lewis, had they read him, is stated in the third lecture of The Abolition of Man and worked out in the introduction to his Oxford History volume of 1954. “There was very little magic in the Middle Ages: the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries are the high noon of magic”, he writes against the habit of treating “Magic” as “a medieval survival and Science the new thing that came in to sweep it away”. “The serious magical endeavour and the serious scientific endeavour are twins: one was sickly and died, the other strong and throve. They were born of the same impulse.” He allows that “some (certainly not all) of the early scientists were actuated by a pure love of knowledge”, but “if we consider the temper of that age as a whole we can discern the impulse of which I speak. For the wise men of old the cardinal problem had been how to conform the soul to reality, and the solution had been knowledge, self-discipline, and virtue. For magic and applied science alike the problem is how to subdue reality to the wishes of men: the solution is a technique”. “If we compare the chief trumpeter of the new era (Bacon) with Marlowe’s Faustus, the similarity is striking”; “In Paracelsus the characters of magician and scientist are combined.” The process by which man “surrenders object after object, and finally himself, to Nature in return for power” he calls “a ‘magician’s bargain’”: “give up our soul, get power in return”.24
The 1954 introduction, “New Learning and New Ignorance”, gives the history. “By magic I do not here mean mere witchcraft — traditional, perhaps Satanistic, rites practised by the poor”; “My concern is with high magic: not concealed but avowed and vindicated by eloquent scholars” who draw their strength from the New Learning, and “in this high magic there is no Satanism and no Faustian compact”. “This high magic can be studied in Pico, Ficino (1433–99), Paracelsus (1493–1541), Agrippa (1486–1535), or our own Dr. Dee.” Pico “attacked astrology” but “also defends both the reality and the lawfulness of magic” and “will distinguish magia from goeteia”; in his Conclusiones magicae “you will find the magical ideal expressed in its sharpest contrast to the scientific”, for “Magic and astrology, though of course often mixed in practice, are in tendency opposed. The magician asserts human omnipotence; the astrologer, human impotence.” The decisive sentence is against the historians: the example of a “new empiricism leading to a new conception of magic” should make it clear “how inadequate the term ‘medieval survival’ is for all that we count superstitious in the sixteenth century. We might reasonably call eighteenth-century magic, if there is any, a ‘survival’ from the seventeenth century, but to talk in that way about the sixteenth is to antedate the real change and to misconceive the period we are studying.” The new magic reached the public as the old had not: “The medieval author seems to write for a public to whom magic, like knight-errantry, is part of the furniture of romance: the Elizabethan, for a public who feel that it might be going on in the next street.” Agrippa is quoted — “‘Once,’ says Agrippa, ‘by the iudgment of all olde philosophers Magick held the hyest place of honour’” — with his authorities (“Pliny, the Hermetica, the Orphic books, and ‘the Platonists’”; “Trismegistus is quoted in support”). And Lewis connects the magic with what he calls, “as Ficino himself calls it, ‘Platonic theology’”, “to distinguish it from the Platonism on which lectures are given in a modern university”: “If Plato alone had been in question the Florentines would in fact have been attempting to ‘baptise’ him”, but “since Pythagoras, the Hermetic Books, the Sibylline Books, the Orphic” books, Apuleius, “Plotinus, Psellus”, Iamblichus “and the Cabbala all meant the same, their task was hardly distinguishable from that of reconciling paganism, Judaism, and Christianity in general”; hence, “paradoxically, it comes about that though the Florentine Platonists were wholly pious in intention”, their work is the most pagan movement of its age; “The title of Pico’s De Dignitate Hominis would really have served as the title for all their works”; “Yet the actual trend of Ficino’s thought is always away from the centre of Christianity”; “In a passage that oddly anticipates Sartre, Pico suggests that Man has no specific nature” at all; “Pico even allows the use of evil spirits when enslaved by magia and not given dominion over us by goeteia.” The psychology beneath it all he names “the megalomania or (to revive a word) anthropolatry which lies at the back of the whole movement”. Finally the junction with science: “the new magia, far from being an anomaly in that age, falls into its place among the other dreams of power which then haunted the European mind. Most obviously it falls into place beside the thought of Bacon. His endeavour is no doubt contrasted in our minds with that of the magicians: but contrasted only in the light of the event, only because we know that science succeeded and magic failed. Both seek knowledge for the sake of power (in Bacon’s words, as ‘a spouse for fruit’ not a ‘curtesan for pleasure’), both move in a grandiose dream of days when Man shall have been raised to the performance of ‘all things possible’. Nor would Bacon himself deny the affinity: he thought the aim of the magicians was ‘noble’.”25
Set beside the historiography, the statement is early. That Renaissance “high magic” was a new thing and not a medieval survival; that it rested on the Florentine Platonic theology with its Hermetic, Orphic, Chaldaean and Cabbalistic authorities; that it was continuous in aim with Bacon’s programme; and that magic and the new science were born together — this is the substance of what became known, after D. P. Walker’s Spiritual and Demonic Magic (1958) and Frances Yates’s Giordano Bruno and the Hermetic Tradition (1964), as the Yates thesis, and Lewis had it in print in 1943 and 1954. His version is moral and psychological where theirs is historical; he drew on his own reading of the Renaissance Platonists — Ficino, Pico, Agrippa and Paracelsus are named in the Oxford History — rather than on the Warburg Institute’s; and where Yates was sympathetic to the Hermetic magus Lewis was not. None of the historians cites him, and he has no place in the historiography of the subject. The fiction carries the same thesis. In That Hideous Strength the N.I.C.E., the scientific institute of the novel, means to effect “A junction … between two kinds of power which between them would determine the fate of our planet”, the technique of the laboratory and the dark eldils; Merlin, dug up to supply the old power, is “not evil; yet he’s a magician”, and Ransom judges that “Merlin’s art was the last survival of something older and different — something brought to Western Europe after the fall of Numinor and going back to an era in which the general relations of mind and matter on this planet had been other than those we know. It had probably differed from Renaissance Magic profoundly.” “Merlin is the reverse of Belbury”, says Dimble, the novel’s Christian don, Belbury being the Institute’s seat; but his art, lawful or half-lawful in its own day, “cannot be done any longer”, and the planetary powers come down not through his spells but through the obedient man who “became a bridge”.26
The Occult: Temptation, Diagnosis and Refusal#
Lewis’s hostility to occultism is the hostility of a man who knew the appetite from within and had watched it destroy a friend. The autobiography’s account of the matron who woke in him “the passion for the Occult” has been given in the Life; its diagnosis — “It is a spiritual lust; and like the lust of the body it has the fatal power of making everything else in the world seem uninteresting while it lasts. It is probably this passion, more even than the desire for power, which makes magicians” — is the premise of everything he wrote on the subject. The “Perhaps” that Yeats’s talk of “magic and cabalism and ‘the Hermetic knowledge’” let fall into his materialism in 1921 brought “all the old Occultist lore, and all the old excitement” back; the madness and death of Dr Askins in 1923 ended the Perhaps. The doctrine that resulted is Screwtape’s. The devils’ “perfect work” would be “the Materialist Magician, the man, not using, but veritably worshipping, what he vaguely calls ‘Forces’ while denying the existence of ‘spirits’”: the occultist and the materialist are, from hell’s point of view, the same client. Spiritualism he refused even in grief. “At any rate I must keep clear of the spiritualists. I promised H. I would”, he wrote after his wife’s death; and, of the séance-room’s consolations, “How well the Spiritualists bait their hook!” — things on the other side are not so different after all, “There are cigars in Heaven. For that is what we should all like.” Theosophy he had met in the matron and listed, in Miracles, among the pantheisms that the mind slides into when left to itself. Anthroposophy he fought for five years in the Great War and never accepted; the preface to The Pilgrim’s Regress describes the “Southerners” whose “boneless souls” keep doors “open day and night” to “some sort of intoxication”, and the map of the allegory places “Occultica”, “Theosophica”, “Anthroposophia” and “Behmenheim” in their country, in the warm south of the soul where the “Northerners”, the “men of rigid systems whether sceptical or dogmatic”, never go. Ghosts he came to think probable and not frightening: Williams’s death “Greatly reduced my feeling about ghosts”, and to a correspondent who had seen one he wrote that “the absence of fear is, as far as it goes, probable evidence that the experience was not merely imaginary”, so that “apparently ghosts are the least alarming kind of spirit”.27
Mysticism he treated with the same discrimination. In Letters to Malcolm he disclaims the title — “So now, I do not attempt the precipices of mysticism” — and argues that the experience of the mystics proves nothing by itself, since diabolical mysticism or a drug might produce states indistinguishable from theirs; what matters is not the departure but the lawfulness of the voyage and the landfall, and the true religion validates its mysticism rather than being validated by it. The judgement follows from Alexander’s distinction: an inner state, “considered simply as an event in my own mind”, is “of no value at all”. Secret societies and initiations he analysed in “The Inner Ring” (1944), where “the desire to be inside the local Ring and the terror of being left outside” is named as one of the dominant elements of every life, and “the passion for the Inner Ring is most skillful in making a man who is not yet a very bad man do very bad things”; the alternative is the open fellowship of the craft — “You will be one of the sound craftsmen, and other sound craftsmen will know it” — and the “mere” Christianity of the hall with many rooms. Astrology, as the section on the Model showed, he kept as symbol and refused as prediction. What he never did was to claim esoteric knowledge, a lineage or a technique; the ladder of his Platonism is climbed by obedience and the dialectic of desire, in daylight.28
Sources, Synthesis and Gnosticism#
The synthesis was acquired in an order that can be dated. Romantic longing and “Northernness” (Wagner, Morris, the Norse myths) gave him the experience of Joy in boyhood; MacDonald’s Phantastes in 1916 baptised the imagination and showed him holiness and fairy-tale as one thing; Chesterton’s The Everlasting Man, read about 1926, gave “the whole Christian outline of history set out in a form that seemed to me to make sense”, from a man he “already thought … the most sensible man alive ‘apart from his Christianity’”; Barfield gave the doctrine of imagination, the critique of chronological snobbery and the ancient unities; Alexander’s Space, Time and Deity (1920) dissolved the cult of inner states; Bergson, Berkeley and the Hegelian idealists carried him from materialism to an Absolute that, as he found, “cannot be made clear” — “Idealism can be talked, and even felt; it cannot be lived” — and thence, in 1930, to theism. Otto’s Idea of the Holy, with its account of the Numinous, gave the opening chapter of The Problem of Pain its structure (the Numinous “is not the same as the morally good”, and “a man overwhelmed with awe is likely, if left to himself, to think the numinous object ‘beyond good and evil’”; the Jews were the people who fully identified the awful Presence with the righteous God); Tolkien and Dyson gave myth become fact; the professional study of Boethius, Chalcidius, Macrobius, Dionysius, Dante, Spenser, Milton and the Florentine Platonists gave the Model, the Hierarchical conception and the thesis of the twins. Williams gave romantic theology, Descent into Hell and the Arthurian and Atlantean furniture of That Hideous Strength; and the Christian mystics and devotional writers read in 1929–31 — MacDonald’s Diary of an Old Soul, Bunyan’s Grace Abounding, Dante’s Paradiso, Boehme’s Signature of All Things, Brother Lawrence, Traherne’s Centuries, William Law, à Kempis, with the Gospel of John in Greek — gave the devotional register of the later books. Boehme is the one figure of the esoteric canon proper on the list, and the exception is instructive: the book shook him, and he scarcely mentions it again.29
The result is best described as a Christian Platonism of the Augustinian and Boethian kind, with a Romantic doctrine of longing and a medieval cosmology held as symbol, and it is defined as much by what it excludes as by what it contains. It is not Gnostic. Lewis’s theology is deliberately anti-dualist: Mere Christianity takes dualism seriously — next to Christianity “the manliest and most sensible creed on the market” — and rejects it on the ground that “All the things which enable a bad man to be effectively bad are in themselves good things”, so that “Dualism, in a strict sense, will not work”; the universe is at war, but the Dark Power is a creature, not a rival principle, and “God has no opposite.” The world is a good creation, not a prison; the body is to be raised, not escaped; the way up is not knowledge reserved to the few but obedience open to all; and the “Pale Men” of the north in The Pilgrim’s Regress, who starve the body and despise the earth, are among the pilgrim’s enemies. Nor is it pantheist: the Pantheist, “Confronted with a cancer or a slum”, can say that from the divine point of view this too is God, whereas for Christians God “invented and made the universe — like a man making a picture or composing a tune”. The “Life-Force philosophy” of Bergson and Shaw is “a sort of tame God”, and “Christianity-and-water”, “the view which simply says there is a good God in Heaven and everything is all right”, is no better; the argument of Mere Christianity is given in full below. What remains, when all this is set aside, is a Christian Platonist who kept the planets, the daemons and the ladder of desire, and who defended the medieval Model, the Hermetic magus’s own cosmos, against the magus.30
Spiritual Ethics: New Men, the Inner Ring and the Weight of Glory#
The goal of the system is stated in the last book of Mere Christianity, which began as the broadcast talks of 1944 called Beyond Personality. There are two kinds of life, “The Biological sort which comes to us through Nature”, which “is Bios”, and “The Spiritual life which is in God from all eternity”, which “is Zoe”; “Every Christian is to become a little Christ”; “The Son of God became a man to enable men to become sons of God.” The demand is total: “The command Be ye perfect is not idealistic gas”; “He said (in the Bible) that we were ‘gods’ and He is going to make good His words. He will make the feeblest and filthiest of us into a god or goddess, a dazzling, radiant, immortal creature.” Hence the title of the penultimate chapter, “Nice People or New Men”: “God became man to turn creatures into sons: not simply to produce better men of the old kind but to produce a new kind of man. For mere improvement is not redemption”; and the image of the sculptor’s shop — “This world is a great sculptor’s shop”, with “a rumour going round the shop that some of us” are some day going to come to life. “The Weight of Glory” gives the same doctrine its social form. “There are no ordinary people”; each person we meet is on the way to becoming one of two things, “immortal horrors or everlasting splendours”; “Nations, cultures, arts, civilization — these are mortal”, but the person is not; “It is a serious thing to live in a society of possible gods and goddesses”, and “The load, or weight, or burden of my neighbour’s glory should be laid daily on my back, a load so heavy that only humility can carry it, and the backs of the proud will be broken.” The glory itself he defines, against the suspicion of vanity, as “good report with God”: to be known and approved. The Four Loves (1960) supplies the ethics of affection: Need-love, Gift-love and Appreciative love — “Need-love cries to God from our poverty; Gift-love longs to serve, or even to suffer for, God; Appreciative love says: ‘We give thanks to thee for thy great glory.’” — and the rule, taken from Denis de Rougemont, that love “begins to be a demon the moment he begins to be a god”, for the natural loves turned gods “become in fact complicated forms of hatred”. “Friendship is unnecessary, like philosophy, like art, like the universe itself (for God did not need to create)”; “To love at all is to be vulnerable”; and “All that is not eternal is eternally out of date.” The vocabulary of deification — “little Christs”, “gods and goddesses”, the statues that come to life — is Athanasian and Pauline rather than Orthodox, and he does not use the word theosis; but the thing is there, and it is reached, as everything in Lewis is reached, by the surrender of the self rather than by its cultivation.31
Works#
Lewis published some forty books in his lifetime and his literary executors nearly as many after it. They are treated here by kind — the poetry, the fiction for adults, the seven Chronicles of Narnia, the apologetics and theology with the autobiographical books, the scholarship and criticism, and the letters, diaries and posthumous collections — and in order of publication within each kind (the three Ransom novels being kept together), since the books of each kind answer one another and the reader who wants the trilogy or the Narnian sequence whole should find it so. Each is given its publication data, its argument or plot (with the ending), its characters where it has them, its themes, the layer of its thought that bears on esotericism, and a closing estimate.
Poetry#
Spirits in Bondage: A Cycle of Lyrics (1919)#
At a glance. London: William Heinemann, 20 March 1919, as by “Clive Hamilton”, Lewis’s first name joined to his mother’s maiden name; the author was twenty and just demobilised, and his old tutor Kirkpatrick had encouraged him to publish. Forty poems, written mostly between 1915 and 1918 at Bookham, in the trenches and in hospital, in three parts headed “The Prison House” (twenty-one poems), “Hesitation” (three) and “The Escape” (sixteen), with a Prologue; the title is from Paradise Lost (I.658) and the epigraph reads “The land where I shall never be / The love that I shall never see”. It sold almost nothing.32
The poems. The Prologue sets the argument in a few lines: the poet, “As of old Phoenician men, to the Tin Isles sailing”, will sing “Flying from the scarlet city where a Lord that knows no pity, / Mocks the broken people praying round his iron throne”, and “Sing about the Hidden Country fresh and full of quiet green. / Sailing over seas uncharted to a port that none has seen.” The Prison House opens with “Satan Speaks”, in which Nature herself is the devil — “I am Nature, the Mighty Mother, / I am the law: ye have none other”, “I am the flower and the dewdrop fresh, / I am the lust in your itching flesh” — and proceeds through the war poems (“French Nocturne”, “Ode for New Year’s Day”, written under shellfire: “Woe unto you, ye sons of pain that are this day in earth, / Now cry for all your torment: now curse your hour of birth”, and of the god who made the world, “He cares not for our virtues, our little hopes and fears, / And how could it all go on, love, if he knew of laughter and tears?”) to the book’s blasphemy and its defiance, “De Profundis”: “Come let us curse our Master ere we die, / For all our hopes in endless ruin lie. / The good is dead. Let us curse God most High”, and yet “Yet I will not bow down to thee nor love thee, / For looking in my own heart I can prove thee, / And know this frail, bruised being is above thee.” A second “Satan Speaks” makes the maker of matter the demiurge of the Gnostic myths: “I am the Lord your God: even he that made / Material things, and all these signs arrayed”. “The Witch” takes the side of the enchantress whom her Christian persecutors have “led … bound in fetters vile”. The hinge of the book is “Dungeon Grates”: the lonely soul of man “Shudders before this universal plan”, but a moment “Of unsought Beauty in some casual hour / Can build a bridge of light or sound or form”, so that “When of some beauty we are grown a part / And for one little moment we are one”, and “we can bear all trials that come after”, “For we have seen the Glory — we have seen.” The Escape is sung to the powers of MacDonald’s north: “O Dwellers at the back of the North Wind, / What have we done to you? How have we sinned / Wandering the Earth from Orkney unto Ind?” (“Song of the Pilgrims”); “Faeries must be in the woods / Or the satyrs’ laughing broods” (“Song”); “Oxford” makes the university a sanctuary of “palaces of peace / And discipline and dreaming and desire”, lest men cease “The Spirit’s work — to hunger and aspire”; “World’s Desire” sets a castle “On a rock above a forest where the trees are grim and great”; and the last poem, “Death in Battle”, first printed in Reveille beside Sassoon and Graves, is a soldier’s prayer for Avalon: “Open the gates for me, / Open the gates of the peaceful castle, rosy in the West, / In the sweet dim Isle of Apples over the wide sea’s breast, / Open the gates for me!”33
Major themes. A dualist cosmos. Lewis told Greeves in 1918 that the book’s thesis was that nature was wholly diabolical and that God, if he existed, stood outside and against the cosmic arrangement; Part I is that thesis, the world as a prison under a cruel or indifferent maker. Beauty as evidence. Against it stands the glimpse — the moment of beauty in which “we are one” — which proves that the spirit is not of this world; this is Joy, twenty years before the name. The hidden country. The Isle of Apples, the castle in the west, Hesperus and the country at the back of the North Wind are the first forms of the Island of The Pilgrim’s Regress.
Esoteric symbolism. The young atheist’s cosmos has the shape of the Gnostic and Manichaean myths he would later argue against: a demiurge who made matter and is the enemy, a true good elsewhere, a spirit imprisoned and escaping. The apparatus of the escape is Celtic and Pre-Raphaelite (Avalon, the god Angus, the faeries, the persecuted witch), filtered through Yeats, whom he had loved since 1914, and MacDonald. The Promethean refusal of “De Profundis” — the creature proving by its own heart that it is above its maker — is exactly the attitude the mature Lewis would diagnose, in Milton’s Satan, as the wish “to ‘be himself’”.
Relation to other works. The autobiography’s chapters on Bookham gloss the atheism; Dymer narrates the same dualism; the Landlord and the Island of The Pilgrim’s Regress are its tyrant god and hidden country seen from the far side of conversion.
Takeaway. The earliest Lewis in print: a soldier’s dualism in which the maker of the world is the enemy and only the glimpse of beauty and the longing for a far country redeem the prison — the raw material of everything he later built, and the position he spent his life refuting.
Dymer (1926)#
At a glance. London: J. M. Dent, 20 September 1926 (New York: Dutton, the same year), again as by Clive Hamilton: a narrative poem of 2,065 lines in nine cantos of rhyme royal, begun in prose in 1916–17, taken up in verse in 1922 and finished in 1925. Its epigraph is Odin’s from the Hávamál: “Nine nights I hung upon the Tree, wounded with the spear, as an offering to Odin, myself sacrificed to myself.” Reissued under Lewis’s own name with a new preface on 19 October 1950, and reprinted with that preface in Narrative Poems (1969). It had a good notice in the Sunday Times a year after publication and sold poorly.34
Plot. Dymer is born in the Perfect City, a planned state that regulates marriage, schooling and leisure (“That in the city which men called in scorn / The Perfect City, Dymer could be born?”). At nineteen, when a bird’s song and a spring wind come through a lecture-room window, he laughs, strikes the aged lecturer — “Yet lazily — he struck the lecturer’s head. / The old man tittered, lurched and dropt down dead” — walks out of the city, strips off his uniform and follows music and light through a forest to a great lit house with open doors (I). In its hall he finds a mirror, rich clothes, a laden table and wine; he dresses and feasts and boasts that he will bring the City down; beyond a curtained door, in a dark fragrant grove, he hears “A low grave laugh and rounded like a pearl, / Mysterious, filled with home”, and lies with an unseen woman (II). He wakes at dawn beside his sleeping bride, goes out into the morning, and on his return finds every door barred by a huge shapeless old woman, who strikes him senseless when he attacks her (III). In a thunderstorm he finds a dying man, a survivor of the City, who tells him that a youth named Dymer killed their master, that a hunchback named Bran used the deed to raise a mob, that the rebels burned and killed and turned on one another, and that his own hands and feet were cut off (IV). Dymer climbs into barren mountains in despair (V) and, descending for food, hears a shot and comes to an old house whose clock has no hands: its master, an aged learned magician, has just shot a lark. Over supper “all his talk was tales of magic words” — “Thus the Hermetics tell” — and he offers Dymer the way back to his beloved through dreams: “Wake into dreams, into the larger light / That quenches these frail stars. They will not know / Earth’s bye-laws in the land to which you go”, “And you will drink my cup and go your way / Into the valley of dreams.” Dymer resists (“Oh lies, all lies…. Why did you kill the lark?”) and, dazed, drinks (VI). While he sleeps the Magician, tormented, fingers the legs of his chair and turns to his books; Dymer wakes and tells his dream — a forest, a bear, a woman who tells him that the wild world “every part / Was what I made it — all that I had dreamed”, beneath which lies lust, then satyrs and witches — and accuses his host, “You did me wrong to send me to that wood. / I sought a living spirit and found instead” a phantom; the Magician fires at him as he runs (VII). He wakes wounded in a lane beside a woman who says she belongs to a new life; when he accuses her of deceiving him she answers that the gods take whatever form suits those who call them — “For our kind must come to all / If bidden, but in the shape for which they call” — and he drags himself to a churchyard and sinks down at the lych-gate (VIII). A great wind carries him through empty regions where his hopes and his self dissolve; a sentinel tells him that a monster born of a divine lady and a mortal — his own son — haunts the border, arms him and leaves him. At dawn he charges the beast and is killed: “Under its feet, broken and bent and white, / The ruined limbs of Dymer, killed outright / All in a moment, all his story done.” The land flowers; where the brute stood stands a god, “A wing’d and sworded shape, through whom the air / Poured as through glass”, and the poem ends with trumpets and bells, “And such a music as the dumb would sing / If Balder had led back the blameless spring / With victory, with the voice of charging spears, / And in white lands long-lost Saturnian years” (IX).35
Characters. Dymer is the rebel against the totalitarian city and the seeker of the spirit behind his longing, who begets a monster on his dream and is redeemed only by dying to it; the unseen bride is the dream-image of desire that proves, in the end, to be a goddess in the shape he called for; the old woman at the doors is the guardian who bars the return to the moment of bliss; the wounded man and Bran are the revolution that a single romantic gesture unleashes, the horror of mobs and causes that Lewis’s 1950 preface traces to the Russian Revolution and to Ulster; the Magician, a Hermetic adept with a handless clock who shoots larks and sells dreams, is the figure of occult wish-fulfilment, and is usually taken to owe something to the Yeats whose candlelit talk of magic Lewis had heard five years before; the woman of the eighth canto is the goddess as she really is; the beast that becomes a god is Dymer’s own offspring transfigured.
Major themes. The Christina Dream. The 1950 preface names the poem’s enemy after Christina Pontifex in Butler’s The Way of All Flesh: the dream of wish-fulfilment in which the self is the hero, “the hidden enemy whom we were all determined to unmask and defeat”. The counterfeit of desire. The Magician’s cup is the offer to have the longing’s object by technique and in dream, and the dream breeds a monster. Idolatry and its cure. “Instead of repenting my idolatry,” Lewis wrote in 1950, “I spat upon the images which only my own understanding greed had made into idols”; the true longing “is in itself the very reverse of wishful thinking: it is more like thoughtful wishing.” Self-sacrifice. Odin on the tree, “myself sacrificed to myself”, is the key to the ending: the hero dies to his dream-born monster and the death makes a god.
Esoteric symbolism. The poem is Lewis’s first portrait of the magician, and it is already the mature portrait: learned, Hermetic (“Thus the Hermetics tell”), a dealer in drugged dreams and the “larger light” that quenches the stars, compulsive, tormented, and a killer of larks. The dream-world the cup opens is the world of the Southern regions of The Pilgrim’s Regress, where every feeling is justified by being felt; the goddess who comes “in the shape for which they call” states, in 1926, the doctrine later given to the Oyarsa of Perelandra, the planetary intelligence of the trilogy, that the gods of myth are real powers seen through the forms our minds supply; and the Saturnian spring of the close is the first appearance of the planetary mythology of the later work.
Relation to other works. The escape from the planned city, the counterfeit of desire sold by a magician, the dream that breeds a monster and the death that redeems it are the Regress in embryo; the Perfect City returns as the N.I.C.E.; the preface of 1950 is the bridge to Surprised by Joy.
Takeaway. Lewis’s one published long poem found few readers as poetry and succeeded as diagnosis: the Magician who sells dreams, and the self that must die to the monster its dreams have bred, are the figures he would spend thirty years refining.
The Later Poems: Poems (1964), Narrative Poems (1969) and the Collected Poems (1994, 2015)#
Lewis went on writing verse all his life, much of it published in Punch over the initials N.W. (for Nat Whilk, Old English for “I know not who”), in The Spectator, The Oxford Magazine and Time and Tide, and Walter Hooper gathered it in Poems (London: Bles, 1964); Narrative Poems (Bles, 1969) printed Dymer with its preface, the unfinished Arthurian “Launcelot”, “The Nameless Isle” (1930), an alliterative romance of a shipwrecked mariner on an island ruled by a wizard whose flute turns men to stone and a lady who holds the counter-magic, after The Magic Flute, and “The Queen of Drum” (1930), in which a young queen who walks by night and has been to Elfland, confronted with the choice between the Archbishop’s Christian submission and the fairy road, chooses Elfland. The Collected Poems (Fount, 1994) added Spirits in Bondage, and Don W. King’s critical edition (Kent State University Press, 2015) is the standard text. The poems that matter here are those that state the cosmology — “The Planets” (1935), which runs through the seven planets from the Moon to Saturn in Old English alliterative metre, giving each its character, so that Jupiter brings “guilt forgiven, and good fortune”, “Jove is master; and of jocund revel”, and the lion-hearted “are Jove’s children”; “The Turn of the Tide” (1948), in which the whole cosmos freezes into Saturnine silence at the Nativity until the tide of life turns outward from Bethlehem, where “Nothing greater could be heard”; “The Birth of Language”, on the descent of meaning through the spheres. Others state the epistemology: “Reason”, with Reason as the maiden on the soul’s acropolis and Imagination as the dark earth-mother who must be reconciled; “The Country of the Blind”, after Wells, on a people who treat the seer’s talk of light as metaphor gone mad; “Footnote to All Prayers”, in which every image we pray by is an idol that God must translate; “The Apologist’s Evening Prayer”, asking to be delivered from his own clever arguments. The late poems of the Joy Davidman years are “Love’s as Warm as Tears”, “Joys That Sting” and “As the Ruin Falls”. King’s judgement is that Lewis’s poetic impulse, frustrated in verse, became the energy of his prose.36
Fiction for Adults#
The Pilgrim’s Regress: An Allegorical Apology for Christianity, Reason and Romanticism (1933)#
At a glance. London: J. M. Dent, 25 May 1933, Lewis’s first prose book and the first under his own name, written in a fortnight at Arthur Greeves’s house in Belfast in August 1932, eleven months after the ride to Whipsnade, and dedicated to Greeves. A second edition (Sheed & Ward, 1935) added the double-page “Mappa Mundi” endpapers and, without consulting the author, short “Arguments” at the head of each Book; the third (Geoffrey Bles, 1943) added the long preface in which Lewis explained his terms, running headlines that gloss the allegory, and footnotes to the sources. The title-page epigraph is “As cold waters to a thirsty soul, so is good news from a far country” (Proverbs 25:25), and two passages of Pascal precede the contents, one holding that “Without amusement there is no joy; with amusement there is no sadness”, the other beginning “Atheism shows strength of mind, but only to a certain degree”. Each of the ten Books carries its own epigraphs — Plato (“This every soul seeketh and for the sake of this doth all her actions, having an inkling that it is”), Boethius (“Whose souls, albeit in a cloudy memory, yet seek back their good, but, like drunk men, know not the road home”) and Hooker before Book One; Exodus before Book Two; Thucydides before Book Three; Bacon before Book Four; and, before the last Book, Plato, Bernardus Silvestris and William Law. Ten Books and seventy-nine chapters; the 1943 preface appears as an afterword in some later editions.37
Plot. “I dreamed of a boy who was born in the land of Puritania and his name was John.” In Puritania, the country of the Landlord’s tenants, the masked Steward gives the child a card of rules — “Here is a list of all the things the Landlord says you must not do” — and teaches that the Landlord “owns all the country, and it is very, very kind of him to allow us to live on it at all — very, very kind”, and that the disobedient go to a black hole “full of snakes and scorpions”. Then, through a window in a stone wall, John sees a wood of primroses and beyond it an island in the sea, with “the pale, small-breasted Oreads, wise like gods” peeping from the thickets, and hears a voice: “The voice said, Come.” “There came to him from beyond the wood a sweetness and a pang so piercing that instantly he forgot his father’s house”, and “All the furniture of his mind was taken away.” Going back for the Island he finds instead a brown girl — “‘It was me you wanted,’ said the brown girl. ‘I am better than your silly Islands’” — whose children multiply around him; the chapter-titles “Leah for Rachel”, “Ichabod” and “Non est hic” name the pattern of substitution, lost glory and empty tomb that every false object of the Desire will repeat. When an uncle dies and the Steward’s religion fails to console, John leaves home westward to find the Island (Book One, “The Data”). On the road Mr Enlightenment of Claptrap disposes of the Landlord by incantation — “There is absolutely no such thing — I might even say no such entity — in existence”, “Christopher Columbus, Galileo, the earth is round, invention of printing, gunpowder!!” — and in the city of Thrill old Mr Halfways’s songs seem to give the Island, his daughter Media offers it as romantic love, in whose arms John finds the brown girl again, and his son Gus, a modern young man with a machine, carries John off to Eschropolis (Book Two, “Thrill”). Eschropolis, the ugly city, is the city of the Clevers, the young modernist artists kept by Mr Mammon; when John objects to their performances he is thrown out and arrested by the men of the giant Spirit of the Age, whose eyes make men transparent to themselves — “whatever they looked on became transparent” — and whose jailor, Sigismund Enlightenment, son of the old rationalist, teaches the prisoners that “‘Argument,’ said Master Parrot, ‘is the attempted rationalization of the arguer’s desires’” and that the Island is wish-fulfilment: “‘Have you never before imagined anything to be true because you greatly wished for it?’” Reason, a woman in armour on horseback, kills the giant with three riddles — “What is the colour of things in dark places, of fish in the depth of the sea, or of the entrails in the body of man?”; the parable of the man, his enemy and the bridge; and “By what rule do you tell a copy from an original?” — and “Then there was a noise and a crumbling like a landslide and the huge carcass settled down” (Book Three, “Through Darkest Zeitgeistheim”). Riding with Reason, John learns to live with an unanswered question — “out here in the country you can walk all day and all the next day with an unanswered question in your head: … you need never speak until you have made up your mind” — hears that “Some have thought that all these loves were copies of our love for the Landlord”, and, frightened of where she leads, escapes from her (Book Four, “Back to the Road”).38
The road is cut by the Grand Canyon, the chasm of the Fall, whose story Mother Kirk tells as a tenant’s wife eating the mountain-apple and an earthquake; she offers to carry John across and he will not trust her. He is joined by Vertue, a young man of iron self-discipline who walks for the sake of walking and refuses to want anything; they lodge with Mr Sensible, the cultured worldling who lives on quotations and good wine — “The great art of life is to moderate our passions”; “Objects of affection are like other belongings. We must love them enough to enrich our lives while we have them, not enough to impoverish our lives when they are gone” — and whose comfort depends entirely on his servant Drudge, who leaves to join the northern revolutionaries, whereupon the house falls apart (Book Five, “The Grand Canyon”). Northward along the canyon they meet the Three Pale Men, Mr Neo-Angular, Mr Humanist and Mr Neo-Classical, who have fled from humanism into thin rigid systems, Neo-Angular being a convert to Mother Kirk’s dogma without her charity who despises the Island as Romanticism; further north the country turns to the arctic pass of Savage, the heroic nihilist, and his dwarfs the Marxomanni, Mussolimini, Swastici and Gangomanni (Book Six, “Northward along the Canyon”). Vertue falls sick — his self-sufficiency gives no reason for walking anywhere — and John must lead: “‘Vertue,’ said John, ‘give in. For once yield to desire. Have done with your choosing. Want something.’” They turn south past Mr Broad, the latitudinarian clergyman at ease with the world, to the House of Wisdom in the valley, where Mr Wisdom teaches that the Landlord and the Island are the Absolute, that “What does not satisfy when we find it, was not the thing we were desiring”, and, in the chapter “Wisdom — Esoteric”, that the Absolute is not a person and that Mother Kirk’s picture-language is for the many; Wisdom’s children, who cannot live on the valley’s food, secretly eat the Landlord’s bread (Book Seven, “Southward along the Canyon”). John’s attempt to cross the canyon by the “Inner Light” of the esoteric teaching fails; he is led by a Man who feeds him at a cost, and in the chapter “Caught” discovers that the philosophical Absolute has become a person who sees him: “In one night the Landlord — call him by what name you would — had come back to the world, and filled the world, quite full without a cranny. … All things were indeed one — more truly one than Mr. Wisdom dreamed — and all things said one word: CAUGHT — Caught into slavery again, … never the master of his own soul, to have no privacy, no corner whereof you could say to the whole universe: This is my own, here I can do as I please. Under that universal and inspecting gaze, John cowered like some small animal caught up in a giant’s hands and held beneath a magnifying-glass.” He takes refuge with the hermit History, who explains that the Landlord gave the Shepherd People the Rules and sent the Pagans pictures, of which the Island is one, and who tells “the legend of the Landlord’s Son”: “after the eating of the mountain-apple and the earthquake, when things in our country had gone all awry, the Landlord’s Son himself became one of his Father’s tenants and lived among us, for no other purpose than that he should be killed” (Book Eight, “At Bay”). Two more attempts to go round the chasm by his own light and by the lightning fail; in darkness John comes back to Mother Kirk at the bottom of the canyon, who tells him, in a chapter named with Augustine’s words “Securus te projice” (throw yourself in without fear), to dive; the art of diving is not to do a new thing but to stop doing one, to let go. He strips off his rags, Vertue goes first, and under the water they pass the drowned pictures and come up on the far side, where, in a chapter named from Dante, “Nella sua Voluntade” (in His will), John finds that the Island he sought in the west is the far side of the Eastern Mountains he had feared since childhood (Book Nine, “Across the Canyon”). The way to the Mountains runs back along the same road, and the Guide, the angel Slikisteinsauga (“whetstone-eye”, Lewis’s coinage), shows what the places were — “security is mortals’ greatest enemy” — Mr Sensible’s house a hovel, Wisdom’s valley Limbo, the black hole explained: the Landlord “cannot do what is contradictory: or, in other words, a meaningless sentence will not gain meaning simply because someone chooses to prefix to it the words ‘the Landlord can.’ And it is meaningless to talk of forcing a man to do freely what a man has freely made impossible for himself.” Past Superbia, Ignorantia — the Clevers’ machine civilisation, whose “labour-saving devices multiply drudgery; their aphrodisiacs make them impotent: their amusements bore them”, and whose “iron cities will break most suddenly” — and Luxuria, the witch whose cup turns men to fungus, each pilgrim must kill a dragon: Vertue goes north to fight the cold hoarding Northern Dragon, John south to fight the hot Southern one, and each gains the virtue of his opposite. At “The Brook”, the stream that is death, they cross towards the Mountains, and a last lyric closes the dream: “Passing to-day by a cottage, I shed tears / When I remembered how once I had dwelled there / With my mortal friends who are dead” (Book Ten, “The Regress”).39
Characters and places. John is Everyman and the author, whose road from Ulster Protestant childhood through atheism, aestheticism, psychoanalysis, idealism and theism to Christianity the book follows (“I still think this a very natural road,” says the preface, “but I now know that it is a road very rarely trodden”). Puritania is the Ulster Protestantism of Lewis’s childhood; the Landlord is God as Puritania imagined him and then God as he is; the Steward the clergy; the Island the sweet Desire, finally identified with the Mountains, which are death and heaven; the brown girls lust; Mr Enlightenment nineteenth-century rationalism; the Halfways family Romantic art, erotic love and the machine; the Clevers the avant-garde of the 1920s and Mr Mammon their patron; the Giant the Spirit of the Age and Sigismund its Freudian jailor; Reason, with her younger sisters Philosophy and Theology; the Grand Canyon the Fall; Mother Kirk traditional Christianity, not the Roman Church only; Vertue the natural moral conscience, the Stoic will that must learn to desire as John must learn discipline; Mr Sensible and Drudge cultured worldliness and the labour it lives on; the Pale Men the rigid intellectual reactions of the decade (the neo-scholastic Anglo-Catholic, Babbitt’s humanist, the classicist); Savage and his dwarfs heroic nihilism and the totalitarian movements; Mr Broad modernist religion; Mr Wisdom Absolute Idealism, exoteric and esoteric, which had been Lewis’s own last station; the Man Christ; History the historical understanding of revelation; the Guide an angel; Superbia, Ignorantia and Luxuria pride, ignorance and lust as regions of the return; the two Dragons the two opposite errors of the book’s whole geography.
The Mappa Mundi. The map that Lewis drew for the 1935 edition, with its “Military Railway” and numbered shires, is the one place in his work where the esoteric currents of his youth are literally put on a map. Its labels include, besides Puritania, Claptrap, Thrill, Eschropolis, Zeitgeistheim, the Pale Men, Wisdom and the Tableland, a set of paired regions: Ceremonia and Orgiastica, Dialectica and Aphroditopolis, Cruelsland and Pagus, Heliana and Anthroposophia, Zeitgeistheim and Theosophica, Occultica and Golnesshire, with Behmenheim (the old English spelling of Boehme’s name), Quietismus, Glamaria, Sodom, Mania, Wanhope and Naughtstow. The preface explains the scheme: the pilgrim’s road runs between a North and a South. “Northerners” are “men of rigid systems whether sceptical or dogmatic”; “Southerners” are “boneless souls whose doors stand open day and night” to anyone who can “offer some sort of intoxication”; for a Southerner “every feeling is justified by the mere fact that it is felt”, for a Northerner “every feeling on the same ground is suspect”. Occultica, Theosophica, Anthroposophia and Behmenheim lie in the South, among the intoxications; the hard dialectical and cruel countries in the North; and the one explicit reference to an occultist in the apparatus is the footnote to “Wisdom — Esoteric”, which names Marx, Spencer, Spinoza, Steiner, Kant and Bosanquet as cases of the same move, the turning of the personal God into an impersonal Absolute and of the popular picture into an esoteric truth.40
Major themes. The dialectic of Desire. The preface’s definition — the sweet Desire that “cuts across our ordinary distinctions between wanting and having”, for which “Every one of these supposed objects … is inadequate”, and which, “faithfully followed, would retrieve all mistakes” — makes the whole allegory a lived ontological proof: “This Desire was, in the soul, as the Siege Perilous in Arthur’s castle — the chair in which only one could sit”, and “the human soul was made to enjoy some object that is never fully given”. Reason against the Spirit of the Age. The Giant’s transparency and Sigismund’s rationalisations are the reductive habit of “seeing through” everything, answered by Reason’s distinction of copy from original and by the point that the inside of a man looks ghastly only because insides are not meant to be seen. North and South. The two errors, the bloodless system and the intoxication, are the book’s most durable contribution, and each pilgrim must swallow the other’s fire. The Regress. Conversion does not shorten the road; it changes its direction and reveals what the places were.
Esoteric symbolism. The preface places the occult among the counterfeits of the Desire in so many words: “With Magic in the darker sense (as it has been and is actually practised) we should fare even worse”, and, with Novalis’s flower of Romantic longing, “It is not at Black Mass or seance that the Blue Flower grows.” The allegory’s structure is Platonic — the Island as a picture sent to the pagans, the copy-and-original riddle, the chapters called “Archtype and Ectype” (Locke’s words for a Platonic scheme), the Boethius epigraph on souls that “seek back their good, but, like drunk men, know not the road home” — and it is a scheme of anamnesis in which the copies, followed faithfully, lead to the original. The valley of Wisdom is the subtlest counterfeit, and its division of an exoteric picture-language for the many from an esoteric truth for the few is the structure of every gnosis; Lewis’s verdict is that the esoteric reading is the error and the popular picture the truth. The dive is baptism; Augustine’s “Securus te projice” and Dante’s “Nella sua voluntade” name the chapters; Limbo holds the virtuous unbelievers; the world between two mountain ranges is the medieval allegory Lewis was then studying for The Allegory of Love; and Bernardus Silvestris, cited before the last Book, is the Platonist whose word “Oyarses” would give the trilogy its planetary rulers.
Relation to other works. Surprised by Joy retells the journey as autobiography; the 1943 preface is the bridge; The Allegory of Love supplies the theory of allegory that the preface defends (“all good allegory exists not to hide but to reveal”); The Abolition of Man restates Reason’s case against seeing through; The Great Divorce reuses the dream-journey and the Guide’s explanation of Hell; and the poems embedded in the Books — the Northern Dragon’s lament and “Footnote to All Prayers” among them — were gathered in Poems (1964).
Reception. The book sold slowly and was little noticed; the encouragement of Martyn Lloyd-Jones meant much to Lewis when the first edition was not selling, and the 1935 blurb, which implied that the author had been a Catholic, annoyed him. His own second thoughts are in the preface, where he compares himself to “one who should narrate his travels through the Gobi Desert” without explaining that the route is unknown to the reader. Kathryn Lindskoog’s Finding the Landlord (1995) was the first full key; David C. Downing’s annotated edition (Eerdmans, 2014) reproduces the map and glosses the figures.41
Takeaway. Lewis’s map of the modern soul’s errors, drawn within a year of his conversion: the one book in which occultism, Theosophy, Anthroposophy and Boehmism stand on an actual map, in the warm South of intoxication opposite the cold North of reductive systems, with the road of the Church running between; and an allegory whose Platonic method — the copies followed to the original — turns against the esoteric reading that would make the original impersonal.
Out of the Silent Planet (1938)#
At a glance. London: John Lane The Bodley Head, 23 September 1938, after Dent and Allen & Unwin had refused it and Stanley Unwin, on Tolkien’s recommendation, had passed it to The Bodley Head; first American edition New York: Macmillan, 1943. Dedicated to Lewis’s brother, W. H. L., a lifelong critic of the space-and-time story; a prefatory note disclaims any ingratitude to H. G. Wells for the slighting references to earlier interplanetary romances; twenty-two chapters and a Postscript of “extracts from a letter written by the original of ‘Dr. Ransom’ to the author”. The book grew from an agreement with Tolkien in 1936 or 1937 that Lewis would write a space-travel story and Tolkien a time-travel one, and from a provocation Lewis described to Roger Lancelyn Green on 28 December 1938: “What immediately spurred me to write was Olaf Stapledon’s Last and First Men (Penguin Libr.) … and an essay in J. B. S. Haldane’s Possible Worlds … both of wh. seemed to take the idea of such travel seriously … and to have the desperately immoral outlook wh. I try to pillory in Weston.” He added that he liked “the whole interplanetary idea as a mythology … and simply wished to conquer for my own (Christian) pt. of view … what has always hitherto been used by the opposite side”. David Lindsay’s A Voyage to Arcturus (1920) he called the real father of his planet books.42
Plot. Elwin Ransom, “a philologist, and fellow of a Cambridge college”, on a walking tour, is asked by a frightened woman to see her simple son Harry home from a house called The Rise, and forcing his way in finds two men struggling with the boy: Devine, a contemptible old schoolfellow (“‘I thought I knew you as soon as you spoke,’ said the slender man. ‘I’m Devine. Don’t you remember me?’”), and Weston, a great physicist. They drug him, and he wakes in a spherical ship already in space, bound, he learns, for Malacandra. He had expected the horror of “Space”: “at the back of his thinking for years had lurked the dismal fancy of the black, cold vacuity, … the utter deadness, which was supposed to separate the worlds”, and he finds instead that “the very name ‘Space’ seemed a blasphemous libel … for this empyrean ocean of radiance in which they swam. Older thinkers had been wiser when they named it simply the heavens — the heavens which declared the glory”; Milton’s “happy climes that ly / Where day never shuts his eye / Up in the broad fields of the sky” come back to him. Overhearing that he is to be handed to the “sorns” — “‘Human sacrifice, I suppose. At least it wouldn’t be human from their point of view; you know what I mean’” — he steals a knife and, when they land on a world of pink vegetation, thin towering mountains and warm valleys and the tall pale sorns appear at the water’s edge, runs for his life. Alone in the low country he meets Hyoi, a hross, a tall furred seal-like creature with speech, and lives for weeks among the hrossa, poets and hunters, monogamous and unafraid of death, learning the language he will later recognise as Old Solar. Hyoi teaches him that “A pleasure is full grown only when it is remembered”, that of the water-monster they hunt “The hnakra is our enemy, but he is also our beloved”, that death is a thing he will drink “in the day I drink it and go to Maleldil”, and that “It is a bent hnau that would blacken the world” — the hrossa have no word for evil but “bent”, and all three rational species of the planet, hrossa, sorns and pfifltriggi, are hnau, none ruling the others; above them is Oyarsa, and above Oyarsa Maleldil the Young, who made the worlds. An eldil, a being of light scarcely visible, sends Ransom to Oyarsa at Meldilorn; the hnakra hunt succeeds, but Hyoi is shot dead by Weston and Devine, who have been hunting Ransom. Crossing the high cold plateau Ransom is taken in by the sorn Augray, who explains the eldila as a physicist might: “Body is movement”; “The swiftest thing that touches our senses is light”; “the body of an eldil is a movement swift as light”, so that “what we call light is for him a thing like water, a visible thing, a thing he can touch and bathe in”, while “what we call firm things — flesh and earth — seem to him thinner, and harder to see, than our light”; “Oyarsa does not die”, “His body is not like ours, nor yours; it is hard to see and the light goes through it”. Augray has guessed Ransom’s origin, “that you come from Thulcandra, the silent planet”, and through his telescope Ransom sees Earth: “It was the bleakest moment in all his travels.” At Meldilorn, the island sanctuary, a frog-like pfifltrigg carves Ransom’s portrait among stone pictures of the solar system’s history, in which Thulcandra alone is a blank where its Oyarsa has been cut away.43
Oyarsa receives him among the assembled hnau and invisible eldila — “What are you so afraid of, Ransom of Thulcandra? … You began to be afraid of me before you set foot in my world” — and tells the history of Earth as the heavens know it. “Thulcandra is the world we do not know. It alone is outside the heaven, and no message comes from it. … Once we knew the Oyarsa of your world — he was brighter and greater than I — and then we did not call it Thulcandra. … He became bent. … There was great war, and we drove him back out of the heavens … and bound him in the air of his own world as Maleldil taught us. … There doubtless he lies to this hour, and we know no more of that planet: it is silent.” Of the Incarnation the eldila have only rumours: “We think that Maleldil would not give it up utterly to the Bent One, and there are stories among us … that He has taken strange counsel and dared terrible things, wrestling with the Bent One in Thulcandra. … But of this we know less than you; it is a thing we desire to look into.” Weston and Devine are brought in with three dead hrossa; Weston, taking the Malacandrians for savages, tries beads and threats and is dipped in the lake to cool his head; then Ransom is made to translate his speech to Oyarsa into Old Solar, and the translation strips the creed of its rhetoric. “To you I may seem a vulgar robber, but I bear on my shoulders the destiny of the human race”; “Life is greater than any system of morality; her claims are absolute”; “It is in her right, the right, or, if you will, the might of Life herself, … that I am prepared without flinching to plant the flag of man on the soil of Malacandra: … to march on, step by step, superseding, where necessary, the lower forms of life that we find, … claiming planet after planet, system after system, … till our posterity — whatever strange form and yet unguessed mentality they have assumed — … dwell in the universe wherever the universe is habitable.” Oyarsa’s judgement: “I see now how the lord of the silent world has bent you”; “There are laws that all hnau know, of pity and straight dealing and shame and the like, … and one of these is the love of kindred”; of Weston’s one surviving virtue, “He has left you this one because a bent hnau can do more evil than a broken one.” The three men are given ninety days to reach Earth; the voyage home, close to the sun and short of air, is made in terror, and the ship dissolves as they step out into an English field. Then the narrator removes the mask. “At this point, if I were guided by purely literary considerations, my story would end, but it is time to remove the mask … and to acquaint the reader with the real and practical purpose for which this book has been written.” “Dr. Ransom — and at this stage it will become obvious that that is not his real name” — had abandoned his Malacandrian dictionary and all thought of telling his story, until the narrator, a medievalist, wrote to him about a word in a twelfth-century Platonist: “In one of them, Bernardus Silvestris, there is a word I should particularly like your views on — the word Oyarses”, which “C. J.” says “ought to be Ousiarches”. Together they have gathered “facts about planets in general and about Mars in particular, facts about mediæval Platonists, … and (not least in importance) facts about the Professor to whom I am giving the fictitious name of Weston”; a factual report “would almost certainly result in universal incredulity and in a libel action from ‘Weston’”, and since “‘Weston,’ or the force or forces behind ‘Weston,’ … will play a very important part in the events of the next few centuries, … and, unless we prevent them, a very disastrous one”, “It was Dr. Ransom who first saw that our only chance was to publish in the form of fiction … what would certainly not be listened to as fact.” The Postscript, from Ransom’s letter, complains of what has been left out — the smells of Malacandra, the philology, how the eldila speak (“He thought it probable that they directly manipulated the ears of those they were ‘speaking’ to”), the hrossa’s refusal to give Maleldil “a local habitation” — and records the Malacandrian reverence for Jupiter, “Glundandra”, “‘the centre,’ ‘great Meldilorn,’ ‘throne’ and ‘feast’”, before ending: “Now that ‘Weston’ has shut the door, the way to the planets lies through the past; … if there is to be any more space-travelling, it will have to be time-travelling as well . . .!”44
Characters. Ransom, the Cambridge philologist whose Christian name Elwin is the Old English Ælfwine, elf-friend, is the trilogy’s hero and, in the frame, the source of its “facts”; Weston, inventor of the ship and spokesman of what the trilogy calls Westonism, the creed that the survival and spread of the species justifies every crime; Devine, in it for the gold of Malacandra, who returns as Lord Feverstone; Hyoi the poet-hunter; Hnohra the language-teacher; Augray the sorn of the high plateau; Kanakaberaka the craftsman; Oyarsa, the Intelligence of Mars, visible as a faint light; the eldila; Maleldil the Young and the Old One his father; the Bent One, Oyarsa of Thulcandra, bound in the air of his own world; and “C. J.”, the Oxford philosopher Clement Webb, who proposed the emendation.
Major themes. The heavens against “space”. The substitution of the medieval heavens, full of light and life, for the modern void is, Lewis told Evelyn Underhill, “my favourite idea in the book”. Westonism. The evolutionary and imperial creed of Stapledon and Haldane is refuted by translation into a language without abstractions, in which “the right of Life” becomes a demand to kill. The unfallen world as a mirror. Three rational species, none ruling, and a people that welcomes death, show Earth as bent. Theology smuggled in. “Any amount of theology can now be smuggled into people’s minds under cover of romance without their knowing it,” Lewis told Sister Penelope, the Anglican nun of Wantage who became his correspondent, in 1939, having found that of some sixty reviewers only two had seen “that my idea of a fall of the bent One was anything but a private invention of my own”; a pupil’s “dream of interplanetary colonization” taken seriously had shown him “that a ‘scientific’ hope of defeating death is a real rival to Christianity”.45
Esoteric symbolism. The Oyarsa is the Intelligence or archon of a planet, the being that the medieval Platonists, following the Hermetic Asclepius and Bernardus Silvestris’s Cosmographia, set over each sphere; the name is Bernardus’s, probably a corruption of the Greek ousiarches, “lord of being”, that the Asclepius uses, and the novel’s frame makes the emendation a plot-point. Deep Heaven is the medieval heavens of The Discarded Image; the eldila are the angels of Dionysius and Aquinas described in the language of physics; the “silent planet” is the sublunary world quarantined, its Oyarsa the prince of the power of the air of Ephesians 2:2, and the blank among the pictures at Meldilorn makes the fall of the angels a cosmological fact. The scheme is the Gnostic cosmos inverted: the archons are good, the heavens are home, and the prison is Earth; the one archon who withholds his world from the dance is ours. The reverence for Jupiter as “the centre” is the first appearance of the Jovial theology that governs the third book.
Relation to other works. The eldil-physics of Augray is expounded again in Perelandra’s first chapter; the heavens of the fifth chapter are the subject of The Discarded Image; the argument with Westonism continues in The Abolition of Man and in the unfinished reply to Haldane; the Postscript’s last sentence announces the “time-travelling” of the third book, in which Merlin is the past brought forward.
Reception. Evelyn Underhill, the historian of mysticism, wrote to thank Lewis for “the very great pleasure which your remarkable book ‘Out of the Silent Planet’ has given me”, confessing “a decided prejudice against ‘voyages to Mars’”, wishing he had reported “the conversation in which Ransom explained the Christian mysteries to the eldil”, and concluding, “We should be content with the fact that you have turned ‘empty space’ into heaven!”; Lewis replied on 29 October 1938 that hers was “one of the most surprising and, in a way, alarming honours I have ever had”, that he had “not been for very long a believer and have hitherto regarded the great mystical writers … as a man in the foothills regards the glaciers and precipices”, and that he was “glad you mentioned the substitution of heaven for space as that is my favourite idea in the book”. Haldane’s attack of 1946 and Marjorie Nicolson’s praise in Voyages to the Moon (1948) are the two poles of its early reception; David C. Downing’s Planets in Peril (1992) and Sanford Schwartz’s C. S. Lewis on the Final Frontier (2009), which reads the trilogy as an engagement with rather than a rejection of the evolutionary thought of its day, are the standard studies.46
Takeaway. The medieval cosmos rebuilt as science fiction: the heavens alive and bright, each planet with its Intelligence, Earth alone quarantined under a fallen archon, and Bernardus Silvestris’s Oyarses resurrected as an angel — the Gnostic map turned inside out, and presented as fact disguised as fiction.
Perelandra (1943)#
At a glance. London: John Lane The Bodley Head, 20 April 1943, “A Novel”; New York: Macmillan, 1944; reissued in paperback as Voyage to Venus (Pan, 1953). Dedicated “To Some Ladies at Wantage”, the Anglican sisters of the Community of St Mary the Virgin, Sister Penelope’s convent, to whom Lewis had lectured. An author’s note states that “All the human characters in this book are purely fictitious and none of them is allegorical.” Seventeen chapters. Lewis named it more than once among the favourites of his own books.47
Plot. The narrator, “Lewis”, walking from a country station to Ransom’s cottage, is assailed on the way by a mounting dread that he later understands to be the work of the dark eldila of Earth — “We had eldila of our own, he said, Tellurian eldils, but they were of a different kind and mostly hostile to man”; “Oh, they’ll put all sorts of things into your head if you let them” — and arrives afraid “that I might get ‘drawn in.’” The first chapter expounds the eldila: “very different from any planetary creatures”, their “physical organism, if organism it can be called, … quite unlike either the human or the Martian”; “They themselves regard space (or ‘Deep Heaven’) as their true habitat”, and “the planets are to them not closed worlds but merely moving points”. In the dark cottage the narrator finds the Oyarsa of Malacandra, “the archon of Mars”, present as “simply a very faint rod or pillar of light”, and learns that Ransom is being sent to Perelandra, Venus, because “The black archon — our own bent Oyarsa — is meditating some sort of attack on Perelandra”; he is to travel naked in a coffin-shaped casket of which the Oyarsa “himself will be the motive power”, with “No idea at all what I’m to do.” The narrator and Humphrey the doctor seal him in at dawn; more than a year later they receive him back, golden-bearded, with a bleeding heel and red flowers on him, and “all that day and far into the night he told us the story that follows.” Ransom falls into a warm ocean under a golden sky and climbs onto one of the floating islands on which the planet’s life lives; the fruit and the bubble-trees give pleasures so intense that he learns he must not repeat them for their own sake. Across the water he sees a green human figure with a dragon: the Green Lady, Queen and Mother of this world, who laughs at his piebald sunburn, who has never known anything but Maleldil’s company and that of her King, from whom she is separated, and who grows “older” as she learns — “Maleldil has made me older to that amount since we began speaking”; “You make me grow older more quickly than I can bear.” The heart of their talk is her discovery of freedom. When Ransom asks whether she could have wished a different outcome she sees that “One joy was expected and another is given”, and that “it is I, I myself, who turn from the good expected to the given good”; “You could send your soul after the good you had expected, instead of turning it to the good you had got”; “The wave you plunge into may be very swift and great”, but “it is I who plunge into them with my own legs and arms, as when we go swimming”; “I thought,” she said, “that I was carried in the will of Him I love, but now I see that I walk with it.” Riding a great fish they visit the Fixed Land, the one solid continent, on which Maleldil has forbidden them to dwell or sleep, the planet’s single prohibition; from its mountain they see a sphere fall from Deep Heaven. It is Weston, who lands and asks, “May I ask you, Dr. Ransom, what is the meaning of this?”48
Weston, now fluent in Old Solar, has a new religion. He renounces the humanism of the first book — “I say to you quite freely, Ransom, that I should have been wrong in liquidating the Malacandrians”; “To spread spirituality, not to spread the human race, is henceforth my mission”; “Man in himself is nothing. The forward movement of Life — the growing spirituality — is everything” — has become “a convinced believer in emergent evolution” in which “The stuff of mind, the unconsciously purposive dynamism, is present from the very beginning”, and serves an impersonal Force beyond good and evil: “Your Devil and your God,” he says, “are both pictures of the same Force.” Ransom objects that “There’s nothing specially fine about simply being a spirit. The Devil is a spirit”, that “There are spirits and spirits you know”, that “a thing might be a spirit and not good for you”. Weston answers that he is the Force’s vessel — “There is no possible distinction in concrete thought between me and the universe”; “I am the Universe”; “I, Weston, am your God and your Devil. I call that Force into me completely. . . .” — and the invocation is answered: “A spasm like that preceding a deadly vomit twisted Weston’s face out of recognition”, and he is “rolling at Ransom’s feet, slavering and chattering and tearing up the moss by handfuls”, crying “Ransom, Ransom! For Christ’s sake don’t let them——”. What follows is possession. Ransom finds a trail of mutilated frogs and then the thing that was Weston, sitting still, tearing a frog: “Weston himself was gone”, and what remains he names “the managed corpse, the bogey, the Un-man”. The Un-man lays siege to the Lady with argument — that the one command given without a reason is given “In order that you may break it”, that “A real disobeying, a real branching out, this is what He secretly longs for”, that in his world women became great through suffering and disobedience, “Hardness came out of it but also splendour”, and that he has come “that you may have Death in abundance” — and then with self-consciousness: tragic tales of noble women, a robe of feathers torn from the planet’s birds, and a mirror. “Look in it,” said the Un-man. “That is what it means to be a man or a woman — to walk alongside oneself … as if one were a second person and to delight in one’s own beauty. … Mirrors were made to teach this art.” She answers, “I am walking alongside myself already”, and refuses; Ransom sees that “The external and, as it were, dramatic conception of the self was the enemy’s true aim.” Between the debates the Un-man torments him with obscenity, with the repetition of his name, and with a pettiness that is worse than majesty: “It was not like dealing with a wicked politician at all: … it was much more like being set to guard an imbecile or a monkey or a very nasty child.”49
On the night of decision Ransom becomes aware of Maleldil’s presence in the darkness and of the demand that he, not argument, must end the contest. He learns that “The whole distinction between things accidental and things designed, like the distinction between fact and myth, was purely terrestrial”; that the enemy can be fought because it is embodied — “It had entered that body at Weston’s own invitation, and without such invitation could enter no other”, so that “Weston’s body could be destroyed; and presumably that body was the Enemy’s only foothold in Perelandra” — and that what is asked “was an action, by ordinary standards, neither impossible nor hopeless”. Then the Voice: “It is not for nothing that you are named Ransom,” said the Voice; and “My name also is Ransom,” said the Voice. If he fails, “Maleldil Himself would do some greater thing instead.” At dawn he attacks the Un-man with his fists; the fight runs across the islands and into the sea, the two riding fish, Ransom’s heel bitten. In the open ocean the thing speaks in Weston’s own frightened voice of death and the dead: “I mean that child knows something about the universe which all science and all religion is trying to hide”; “It knows — Homer knew — that all the dead have sunk down into the inner darkness: under the rind”; “Every savage knows that all ghosts hate the living who are still enjoying the rind”; “That is the real universe, always has been, always will be”; “Then there’s Spiritualism,” said Weston, with its “Ectoplasm — slimy films coming out of a medium’s belly and making great, chaotic, tumbledown faces”. Ransom tells it, “Say a child’s prayer if you can’t say a man’s”, asks “Are you Weston?”, is answered “Who else should I be?”, and is dragged under. They surface in a cave beneath the Fixed Land, and in the dark the philosophy of the Rind seizes Ransom’s own mind — “What he had called the worlds were but the skins of the worlds”; “The ghosts, the damned ghosts, were right”; “Reality lived — the meaningless, the un-made, the omnipotent idiocy” — until he knows the thought as sent from outside and his anger returns. By the light of an underground fire the Un-man climbs the shaft followed by a huge many-legged beast; Ransom, with “In the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Ghost, here goes — I mean Amen”, “hurled the stone as hard as he could into the Un-man’s face”, sees that the beast “intended him no harm — had indeed no intentions at all”, and drags the body to the cliff: “He took it by its ankles and lugged it up to the edge of the cliff: … he shoved it over” into the fire, “and then that was the end of it.” Through galleries, a hall of thrones, a swathed figure in a chariot drawn by giant beetles (“no doubt his fellow creature”) and an underground river he comes out on a high mountain, recovers for weeks beside a crystal stream, finds that the heel “was not bleeding at all fast, but nothing he could do would stop it”, carves an epitaph for Weston in Old Solar, and climbs to a rose-red valley with a pool where a casket waits and two eldila are present.50
The Oyéresu of Malacandra and Perelandra converse over his head about the transfer of the world to its King and Queen, and when asked to show themselves try three forms: “A tornado of sheer monstrosities”, “Darting pillars filled with eyes, lightning pulsations of flame”; then “concentric wheels moving with a rather sickening slowness one inside the other”; and at last two tall white human-like figures, sexless but gendered. “The Oyarsa of Mars shone with cold and morning colours, a little metallic — pure, hard, and bracing. The Oyarsa of Venus glowed with a warm splendour, full of the suggestion of teeming vegetable life. … Malacandra was like rhythm and Perelandra like melody”; Mars “seemed to him to have the look of one standing armed … at the ramparts of his own remote archaic world, in ceaseless vigilance … his eyes ever roaming the earth-ward horizon whence his danger came long ago” — “‘A sailor’s look,’ Ransom once said to me; ‘you know . . . eyes that are impregnated with distance’” — while “the eyes of Perelandra opened, as it were, inward, … as if they were the curtained gateway to a world of waves and murmurings and wandering airs”. Both faces show one expression: “Pure, spiritual, intellectual love shot from their faces like barbed lightning.” “Gender is a reality, and a more fundamental reality than sex”; “Masculine is not attenuated male, nor feminine attenuated female.” Ransom’s conclusion is “I have seen Ares and Aphrodite”, and “Our mythology is based on a solider reality than we dream”; the Oyarsa explains that “In the mind of the fallen Archon under whom our planet groans, the memory of Deep Heaven” survives, and “Memory passes through the womb and hovers in the air”, so that the gods of Earth’s myth are faint true memories of the real powers. The animals come in pairs, the King and Queen descend, “And the gods kneeled and bowed their huge bodies before the small forms of that young King and Queen.” Perelandra hails them — “Hail and be glad, oh man and woman, Oyarsa-Perelendri, the Adam, the Crown, Tor and Tinidril, … Baru and Baru’ah, Ask and Embla, Yatsur and Yatsurah, dear to Maleldil. Blessed be He!” — and Tor explains that they had wanted the Fixed Land in order to command their own future, that there is no security and one must always throw oneself into the wave, and that in ten thousand circlings of Arbol their descendants will reach Deep Heaven. Of Earth he prophesies: “It is but the wiping out of a false start in order that the world may then begin”; “The siege of your world shall be raised, the black spot cleared away, before the real beginning”; “In those days Maleldil will go to war — in us, and in many who once were hnau on your world, … and in many from far off and in many eldila, and, last of all, in Himself unveiled, He will go down to Thulcandra”; and of the Moon, “wherein there is a secret evil, and which is as the shield of the Dark Lord … of Thulcandra — scarred with many a blow”, “We shall break her. Her light shall be put out.” Then the voices speak the Great Dance in turn. “The Great Dance does not wait to be perfect until the peoples of the Low Worlds are gathered into it. We speak not of when it will begin. The dance which we dance is at the centre and for the dance all things were made. Blessed be He!” “Each thing was made for Him. He is the centre. Because we are with Him, each of us is at the centre. … Where Maleldil is, there is the centre.” “All is righteousness and there is no equality. Not as when stones lie side by side, but as when stones support and are supported in an arch, such is His order”; “In the plan of the Great Dance plans without number interlock”; “He has no need at all of anything that is made. … He has immeasurable use for each thing that is made, that His love and splendour may flow forth like a strong river … which has need of a great watercourse and fills alike the deep pools and the little crannies, … that are filled equally and remain unequal; and when it has filled them brim full it flows over and makes new channels”; “It is loaded with justice as a tree bows down with fruit.” Ransom sees the Dance itself, “woven out of the intertwining undulation of many cords or bands of light, … leaping over and under one another and mutually embraced in arabesques and flower-like subtleties”, until “the whole solid figure of these enamoured and inter-inanimated circlings was suddenly revealed … as the mere superficies of a far vaster pattern in four dimensions, … and that figure as the boundary of yet others in other worlds”. A year has passed; Tor washes the bleeding heel; the eldila lay him in the casket among lilies: “Then his consciousness was engulfed.”51
Characters. The narrator “Lewis” and Humphrey the doctor (R. E. Havard); Ransom, now middle-aged and piebald; Weston, converted from biological imperialism to the religion of the Life-Force and then possessed, thereafter the Un-man; the Green Lady, Tinidril, the Eve of Perelandra; the King, Tor, absent on another island through the temptation and instructed meanwhile by Maleldil; the Oyéresu of Mars and Venus; Maleldil, the Voice, who has himself been a man on Thulcandra; the dark eldila of Earth; the dragon, the singing beast, the water-people, the beetles, the swathed figure of the underworld.
Major themes. An unfallen Eve and a temptation resisted. The Fixed Land is the one command without a given reason, obedience to which is the only way of obeying for obedience’s sake. Freedom and providence. The Lady’s discovery that she walks with Maleldil’s will rather than being carried in it, and her turning from the expected good to the given, state Lewis’s doctrine of freedom. The invention of the self. The Un-man’s progress from argument to the mirror is Lewis’s anatomy of temptation as the creation of a self-regarding self. Incarnation. The spiritual battle must be fought bodily; the “spiritual” of Weston’s creed is the Devil’s element. Gender as a cosmic reality more fundamental than sex, embodied in the two gods. The Great Dance, Lewis’s fullest statement of a cosmos that is hierarchy without equality and in which every point is the centre.
Esoteric symbolism. The Oyéresu are the planetary intelligences of the medieval Model and of Neoplatonism; their first attempts at visibility are Ezekiel’s wheels and many-eyed living creatures, and their final forms are the tutelary planetary gods of Renaissance Platonism purified of magic. The Oyarsa’s doctrine that the memory of the gods “passes through the womb and hovers in the air” is Lewis’s theory of pagan myth as a distorted memory of true cosmic beings, the counterpart of “Myth Became Fact”. The Great Dance comes from Plotinus’s chorus around its leader, from the dance of the blessed in the Paradiso, from Sir John Davies’s Orchestra and from the cosmic dance of the medieval Platonists, and combines Neoplatonic hierarchy (stones in an arch) with the Christian paradox of every creature at the centre; the four-dimensional figure that is the boundary of others is an attempt to render the “all in each”. Weston’s invocation of the Force into himself is a possession, written to show that the “Spirit” of the Life-Force philosophies carries no guarantee of goodness — “The Devil is a spirit” — and the Un-man is Lewis’s most considered demon, not Satan in majesty but a managed corpse, idiot, obscene and repetitive. The chapter on the Rind gives the demonic cosmology complete: reality is the inner darkness under the skin of the worlds, and ghosts, Spiritualism and ectoplasm are its truth; it is the trilogy’s most direct engagement with occult practice, and it places necromancy on the side of the Un-man. The descent under the Fixed Land, the fire, the river and the return to a mountain paradise follow the Inferno and the Purgatorio; the subterranean dwellers who are not evil answer Dante’s demons with Lewis’s insistence that the alien is not the hostile; the Moon as the shield of the Dark Lord is the sublunary boundary of the Model; and the naming of the pair with the Norse Ask and Embla and with Hebrew-sounding doublets makes them the Adam and Eve of all mythologies.
Relation to other works. The eldil-theology of the first chapter continues Out of the Silent Planet; the prophecy of the Moon’s breaking and the raising of Thulcandra’s siege is taken up in That Hideous Strength, where the Oyéresu of chapter 15 descend on St Anne’s and Ransom’s heel is explained; A Preface to Paradise Lost, written at the same time, supplies the reading of Milton’s Eve and of the hierarchical cosmos the Dance dramatises; The Problem of Pain had already imagined unfallen humanity; Weston’s “emergent evolution” is the target of “The Funeral of a Great Myth”.
Reception. Kate O’Brien in The Spectator (14 May 1943) thought the subject “only for verse, and verse at its most immense”, so that “passages in this book which tremble near the absurd … because they have to be so much explained, might well have been majestic and beyond question … in the simple, inevitable dress of poetry”; Schwartz’s chapter reads the novel against Bergson and Nicholas of Cusa; the Wantage sisters, the dedicatees, had been its first audience.52
Takeaway. The trilogy’s theological centre, and the book in which Lewis’s Platonism, his medieval cosmology and his doctrine of freedom meet: the planetary gods are real and the pagan myths their memory, the Fall is a choice that can be refused, the Devil is a possessing spirit who speaks the language of the Life-Force and of the séance, and the cosmos is a Dance in which hierarchy and the centrality of every creature coincide.
That Hideous Strength: A Modern Fairy-Tale for Grown-Ups (1945)#
At a glance. London: John Lane The Bodley Head, 16 August 1945 — the day Orwell’s review appeared and the day before Animal Farm; New York: Macmillan, 1946; abridged by the author for Pan Books in 1955 with a note that “In reducing the original story to a length suitable for this edition, I believe I have altered nothing” but pace and manner, the abridgement appearing in America as The Tortured Planet (1958). Dedicated “to J. McNeill”, Jane McNeill, the Belfast friend of both brothers, who disliked the book. The epigraph is Sir David Lyndsay’s on the Tower of Babel: “The shadow of that hyddeous strength, sax myle and more it is of length”, “strength” in the old sense of stronghold. The preface, dated from Magdalen on Christmas Eve 1943, calls the book “a ‘tall story’ about devilry, though it has behind it a serious ‘point’ … which I have tried to make in my ‘Abolition of Man’”, explains that “the outer rim of that devilry had to be shown … touching the life of some ordinary and respectable profession”, traces one of its central ideas to “conversations … I had with a scientific colleague, some time before I met a rather similar suggestion … in the works of Mr. Olaf Stapledon”, and tells those “who would like to learn further about Numinor and the True West” that they “must (alas!) await … the publication of much that still exists only in the MSS. of my friend, Professor J. R. R. Tolkien” — “Numinor” being Lewis’s spelling, from hearing Tolkien read aloud, of a name that would not appear in print until The Lord of the Rings (1954–55). Seventeen chapters, the last three titled “The Descent of the Gods”, “Banquet at Belbury” and “Venus at St Anne’s”.53
Plot. “MATRIMONY was ordained, thirdly,” said Jane Studdock to herself, “for the mutual society, help, and comfort that the one ought to have of the other.” Jane, six months married and bored, is frightened by a dream of a prisoner with “a foreign-looking face, bearded and rather yellow, with a hooked nose”, whose visitor “unscrewed the prisoner’s head and took it away”, and of an old man dug up in a churchyard, “a sort of ancient British, druidical kind of man, in a long mantle”. Her husband Mark, a young sociologist and Fellow of Bracton College in the university town of Edgestow, is being drawn into the college’s Progressive Element and flattered by Lord Feverstone into carrying the sale of Bragdon Wood — the ancient grove, “older than the Bractons”, in which lies Merlin’s Well — to the N.I.C.E., “the National Institute of Co-ordinated Experiments”, the fruit of “that constructive fusion between the state and the laboratory”. At lunch with the Dimbles Jane hears Dr Dimble wonder “whether Merlin doesn’t represent the last trace of something the later tradition has quite forgotten about … something that became impossible when the only people in touch with the supernatural were either white or black … either priests or sorcerers”: “He’s not evil; yet he’s a magician. He is obviously a druid; yet he knows all about the Grail.” Her dream proves to match the newspaper: the beheaded man is Alcasan, a French radiologist guillotined for murder. Feverstone — Dick Devine of the first book — tells Mark what the Institute is for: “Man has got to take charge of Man. … You and I want to be the people who do the taking charge, not the ones who are taken charge of”; “sterilisation of the unfit, liquidation of backward races (we don’t want any dead weights), selective breeding”; “A new type of man: and it’s people like you who’ve got to begin to make him.” At Belbury, the Institute’s headquarters, Mark is neither appointed nor dismissed, and dares not ask what he is for, “partly because he began to be afraid that he was supposed to know this already”; he meets the Deputy Director Wither, whose speech never says anything, Miss Hardcastle, “the Fairy”, head of the Institute’s police, Filostrato the physiologist, the Reverend Straik, and the chemist Hingest, who resigns and is murdered on the road; he is set to write the newspaper articles that will justify the seizure of a village and, later, the riots the Institute itself stages. Jane, sent to St Anne’s on the Hill, learns from Grace Ironwood that her dreams are true seeing and that she is wanted by the household of a Mr Fisher-King; she refuses, goes home, and comes back through a fog out of which she rises into sunlight to meet the Director — Ransom, golden-bearded and ageless, with his wounded heel on a couch — to whom she gives her obedience though she cannot yet give it to Maleldil. “You do not fail in obedience through lack of love,” he tells her, “but have lost love because you never attempted obedience”; “Equality guards life; it doesn’t make it. It is medicine, not food”; “No one has ever told you that obedience — humility — is an erotic necessity.” He is, Camilla Denniston tells her, the Pendragon of Logres — Arthur’s secret successor in the hidden Britain within Britain.54
At Belbury Filostrato and Straik take Mark, drunk, to the Head. Filostrato’s gospel is the abolition of organic life — “In us organic life has produced Mind. It has done its work. After that we want no more of it”; “We do not want the world any longer furred over with organic life, like what you call the blue mould — … all sprouting and budding and breeding and decaying”; “Learn to make our brains live with less and less body: learn to build our bodies directly with chemicals”; the Moon, “Thousands of square miles of polished rock with not one blade of grass”, is his ideal — and the Head is its first fruit: “Our Head is the first of the New Men — the first that lives beyond animal life”; “The Head himself has already survived death, and you shall speak to him this night”; “It is François Alcasan,” said Filostrato. Straik’s gospel is the same thing as fulfilled religion: “The resurrection of Jesus in the Bible was a symbol: to-night you shall see what it symbolised”; “This is real Man at last, and it claims all our allegiance”; “It is the beginning of Man Immortal and Man Ubiquitous”; “A king cometh,” said Straik, “who shall rule the universe with righteousness and the heavens with judgement.” Mark is washed, dressed in white and masked like a surgeon and led towards the room where, among pulsing tubes and dials, the severed head is kept alive, speaking “In starts — like a man who’s out of breath”. At St Anne’s the Company — Ransom, the Dimbles, the Dennistons, the Ulster sceptic MacPhee, Grace Ironwood, Ivy Maggs and the bear Mr Bultitude — understand what Belbury wants in Bragdon: Merlin, who “had not died” but whose “life had been hidden, side-tracked, moved out of our one-dimensioned time, for fifteen centuries”. Ransom’s theory of his art, quoted in the Thought section — the last survival of something older than Renaissance magic, from an era in which the relations of mind and matter were other than they are — adds that it was “possibly (though this was doubtful) … less guilty” and “certainly … more effective”. Behind Belbury’s interest in “the last vestiges of Atlantean magic” he sees “Eldilic energy and Eldilic knowledge”: “Our own crew, the terrestrial eldils, are at the back of the whole conspiracy”, and “A junction would be effected between two kinds of power which between them would determine the fate of our planet.” The Institute takes over Edgestow under martial law; Jane is arrested and tortured by the Fairy with cigarette burns and freed by the rioters; Mark, escaping, is arrested by the Institute’s own police. Jane, now committed, is asked “Do you place yourself in the obedience … in obedience to Maleldil?” and answers, “Sir,” said Jane, “I know nothing of Maleldil. But I place myself in obedience to you”, which is accepted: “This is the courtesy of Deep Heaven: that when you mean well, He always takes you to have meant better than you knew”; “He is very jealous. He will have you for no one but Himself in the end.”55
Frost, the Institute’s psychologist, offers Mark initiation and tells him the truth. “You have probably not heard of macrobes. … I did not say microbes, I said macrobes. … Below the level of animal life we have long known that there are microscopic organisms. … I have now to inform you that there are similar organisms above the level of animal life.” “Filostrato and Wilkins are quite deceived about the Head. … But Alcasan’s mind is not the mind we are in contact with when the Head speaks”; “The vocal organs and brain taken from Alcasan … have become the conductors of a regular intercourse … between the macrobes and our own species”; “I do not say that we have discovered this technique; the discovery was theirs, not ours”; “neither the Deputy Director, nor I, are responsible for shaping … the policy of the Institute”. The first step towards intercourse with the macrobes “is the realisation that one must go outside … the whole world of our subjective emotions”; “The change, you will see, is far greater than that which turned the sub-man into the man. It is more comparable to the first appearance of organic life”; “The individual is to become all head. The human race is to become all Technocracy.” That same wild night Merlin wakes in Bragdon, takes a tramp’s clothes, rides through the storm to St Anne’s and is admitted, while Belbury captures the tramp and takes him for Merlin. Merlin tests the Director with three questions in Latin — on the Moon, “Who is called Sulva? What road does she walk? Why is the womb barren on one side? Where are the cold marriages?”; on Arthur’s ring; on the Pendragon — and Ransom answers: “Half of her orb is turned towards us and shares our curse. Her other half looks to Deep Heaven. … On this side the womb is barren and the marriages cold”; “The ring of the King is on Arthur’s finger where he sits in the House of Kings … in the cup-shaped land of Abhalljin, beyond the seas of Lur in Perelandra”; “My Masters are the Oyéresu.” Merlin kneels, and judges Jane: “Sir, you have in your house the falsest lady of any at this time alive”, because she and Mark have refused the child who might have freed Logres. Dimble gives the schema to his wife: “Merlin is the reverse of Belbury. He is the last vestige of an old order in which matter and spirit were, from our modern point of view, confused. For him every operation on Nature is a kind of personal contact, like coaxing a child or stroking one’s horse. After him came the modern man to whom Nature is something dead — a machine to be worked, … and taken to bits if it won’t work the way he pleases. Finally, come the Belbury people, who take over that view from the modern man unaltered … and simply want to increase their power by tacking on to it the aid of spirits. … In a sense, Merlin represents what we’ve got to get back to in some different way.” In the Blue Room Merlin offers to heal the heel and to raise the old earth-magic, and the Director forbids both: “that cannot be done any longer. The soul has gone out of the wood and water. Oh, I dare say you could awake them — a little”; “It never was very lawful, even in your day. It is in this age utterly unlawful. … If it were possible, it would be unlawful.” Merlin asks whether God has not “made it a law for Himself that He will not send down the Powers … to mend or mar in this earth until the end of all things?”, and is answered that “Our enemies had taken away from themselves the protection of the Seventh Law” by going into the heavens and calling the macrobes down, so that the Oyéresu may now descend, but only through a man whose mind was opened to them in a lawful age and who is now a Christian — through Merlin himself. “I have become a bridge,” said Ransom; “Malacandra and Perelandra have spoken to me”; “They have gone to the gods who would not have come to them, and pulled down Deep Heaven on their heads.” Mark, in the Objective Room with its crooked pictures and the crucifix he is told to trample, finds that he is on a side — “He was choosing a side: the Normal. If the scientific point of view led away from ‘all that,’ then be damned to the scientific point of view!” — and, looking at the figure on the cross, that “Christianity was nonsense, but one did not doubt that the man had lived … and had been executed thus by the Belbury of those days. It was a picture of what happened when the Straight met the Crooked”; he refuses.56
In the Blue Room the five come down. “For the lord of Meaning himself, the herald, the messenger, the slayer of Argus, was with them: the angel that spins nearest the sun, Viritrilbia, whom men call Mercury and Thoth”, while the household below falls to puns. “So Perelandra, triumphant among planets, whom men call Venus, came and was with them in the room”, and her charity “was fiery, sharp, bright, and ruthless, ready to kill, ready to die, outspeeding light”. “Ransom knew, as a man knows when he touches iron, the clear, taut splendour of that celestial spirit … who now flashed between them: vigilant Malacandra, captain of a cold orb, whom men call Mars and Mavors, … and Tyr who put his hand in the wolf-mouth.” “Saturn, whose name in the heavens is Lurga, stood in the Blue Room. His spirit lay upon the house, or even on the whole earth, with a cold pressure such as might flatten … the very orb of Tellus to a wafer. Matched against the lead-like burden of his antiquity, the other gods themselves perhaps felt young and ephemeral”; “all that was strength in Lurga became sorrow as it entered them”. And last, “great Glund-Oyarsa, King of Kings, through whom the joy of creation principally blows … across these fields of Arbol, known to men in old times as Jove and under that name, … by fatal but not inexplicable misprision, confused with his Maker — so little did they dream … by how many degrees the stair even of created being rises above him”; “Kingship and power and festal pomp and courtesy shot from him as sparks fly from an anvil”, and below they put the kettle on and dance. “Then they proceeded to operation. Merlin received the powers into him”; shaven and disguised as a Basque priest, “no longer his own man”, he is driven to Belbury, which has advertised for an interpreter for its captive tramp. At the Institute’s banquet the figurehead Director Horace Jules rises to speak and his speech dissolves into gibberish — “The madrigore of verjuice must be talthibianised” — and so does Wither’s, and everyone’s; Frost’s note to the Fairy reads “Blunt frippers intantly to pointed bdeluroid”; Merlin, going out, pronounces the sentence, “Qui Verbum Dei contempserunt, eis auferetur etiam Verbum hominis” — they that have despised the Word of God, from them shall the word of man also be taken. The Fairy shoots Jules; the animals of the vivisection laboratories, loosed by Merlin, break into the hall; Mark, bruised among the dead, is sent to St Anne’s. Wither, who left early, understands that the macrobes have miscalculated, and “It is incredible how little this knowledge moved him. It could not, because he had long ceased to believe in knowledge itself. He had willed with his whole heart that there should be no reality and no truth, … and now even the imminence of his own ruin could not wake him. The last scene of Dr. Faustus where the man raves and implores on the edge of Hell is, perhaps, stage fire. The last moments before damnation are not often so dramatic.” Drawn into the Head’s room, Wither, Straik and Filostrato hear it cry “Adore!” and then “Another,” said the voice, “give me another head”; Filostrato is beheaded on his own guillotine (“His last thought was that he had underestimated the terror”); Straik “slipped in Filostrato’s blood” and is killed by Wither; Wither, carrying the head inward, meets the bear in the doorway. Frost, finding the Head gone, locks himself into the Objective Room, “poured out the petrol and threw a lighted match into the pile”, glimpses in the fire “that he had been wrong from the beginning, that souls and personal responsibility existed”, refuses the knowledge, and “In that attitude eternity overtook him as sunrise in old tales overtakes trolls and turns them into unchangeable stone.” Feverstone’s car is driven by an unseen power into the earthquake that swallows Edgestow. At St Anne’s Dimble explains Logres — “Haven’t you noticed that we are two countries? After every Arthur, a Mordred; behind every Milton, a Cromwell: a nation of poets, a nation of shopkeepers”; “How something we may call Britain is always haunted by something we may call Logres”; “Every people has its own haunter”; “Those who have forgotten Logres sink into Britain” — and Ransom, who has “not grown a day or an hour older since I came back from Perelandra” and whose wound “will only be healed in the world where it was got”, is to go where Arthur is, “In the Third Heaven, in Perelandra. In Aphallin, the distant island which the descendants of Tor and Tinidril will not find for a hundred centuries” (the island is spelt both Aphallin and Abhalljin in the book); Venus “comes more near the Earth than she was wont to — to make Earth sane”, “Perelandra is all about us and Man is no longer isolated”, and “when she returns to her sphere I will ride with her”. The animals pair in the garden (“Look! The elephants are dancing”; “They will be as private as human lovers,” said the Director. “They are not common beasts”); Mark, coming through the light, meets a towering woman who opens the lodge door for him; Ransom’s last words to Jane are “Your husband is waiting for you in the lodge. … Go in obedience and you will find love. You will have no more dreams. Have children instead.” She finds Mark’s shirt hanging from the window — “How exactly like Mark!” — and “Obviously it was high time she went in.”57
Characters. Mark Studdock, “a man of straw, a glib examinee in subjects that require no exact knowledge”, whose “education had been neither scientific nor classical — merely ‘Modern’”, and whose life is governed by the craving for the inner ring; Jane, his wife, a doctoral student working on Donne and a seer, “a good sensitive” in Belbury’s terms; Ransom, now Mr Fisher-King and the Director, the Pendragon of Logres, unaged since Venus; Merlinus Ambrosius, neither priest nor sorcerer, last of the Atlantean order, who becomes the vessel of the gods and dies at Belbury; the Head; Wither, who has willed that nothing be real; Frost, the believer in objectivity; the Fairy; Filostrato, who hates organic life; Straik, the preacher of the kingdom as power; Feverstone; Horace Jules, the popular scientist (a caricature of Wells); Hingest; the Progressive Element of Bracton; the Dimbles, the Dennistons, MacPhee (modelled on Kirkpatrick), Grace Ironwood, the Maggses, Mr Bultitude; and the five Oyéresu, Viritrilbia, Perelandra, Malacandra, Lurga and Glund.
Major themes. Scientism as devilry. The Institute’s programme, from eugenics through the abolition of organic life to the macrobes, is the practical outcome of the philosophy attacked in The Abolition of Man; Wither and Frost are its Conditioners. The Inner Ring. Mark’s whole history dramatises the lecture of 1944, until the choice of “the Normal”. Obedience and marriage. Jane’s story, the refused child, the lodge. Logres and Britain, the remnant at St Anne’s. The limits of magic: Merlin’s art lawful in its day and unlawful now, the Seventh Law, and the gods descending only because the enemy has broken the quarantine.
Esoteric symbolism. The novel contains Lewis’s most explicit theory of magic, and it has three terms. Merlin’s art is “the last survival of something older and different”, Atlantean, belonging to an age when “the general relations of mind and matter on this planet had been other than those we know”, differing “from Renaissance Magic profoundly” — Lewis’s own distinction, from the Oxford History, between the old magic of the romances and the new high magia that was the twin of science — and forbidden now because “The soul has gone out of the wood and water” and “It is in this age utterly unlawful.” The modern man treats nature as a machine; Belbury keeps that view “and simply want[s] to increase their power by tacking on to it the aid of spirits”: it is Screwtape’s Materialist Magician in power, men who deny spirit and worship the Forces they call macrobes. The Head is a necromantic oracle, a dead man’s organs kept alive as a channel and approached by washed and masked initiates as by a medium’s sitters, speaking in gasps and demanding adoration; Frost’s disclosure that “Alcasan’s mind is not the mind we are in contact with when the Head speaks” is the classic warning of the anti-spiritualist literature that the communicating spirit is not the dead man, and “macrobe” is Lewis’s coinage for a devil as a scientist without the word would describe it. The Objective Room is an inverted via negativa, the systematic destruction of the affections by crooked pictures and the trampling of a crucifix, and Frost’s degrees are an initiation. Against all this stands the descent of the planets in their old characters — Mercury the lord of language, Venus charity, Mars iron and courage, Saturn cold, age and sorrow, Jupiter kingship and festival — which is Lewis’s most explicit use of the Model’s “influences” as persons, and the chapter from which Michael Ward’s reading of Narnia begins; the divided Moon, Sulva, with its barren womb and cold marriages on the near side, is the sublunary boundary. And the whole is set in Charles Williams’s Arthuriad: Logres haunting Britain, the Pendragon as a secret succession from Arthur, the Fisher-King, Merlin as the druid who knew the Grail, Arthur alive in Abhalljin on Venus, the Company at St Anne’s as a company of the Co-inherence (Williams’s doctrine that all persons live in and by one another), Jane’s bearing of burdens as Williams’s substitution (the deliberate taking on of another’s fear or pain) — all from Taliessin through Logres (1938), The Region of the Summer Stars (1944) and the prose Figure of Arthur that Lewis would complete in Arthurian Torso. The title is Babel, and the confusion of tongues at the banquet is its curse.
Relation to other works. The preface names The Abolition of Man as the book’s “point”; “The Inner Ring” is its moral and “Membership” its ecclesiology; The Screwtape Letters supplies the theory Belbury enacts, The Discarded Image the planets; Perelandra’s prophecy of the war against the Moon and Ransom’s heel are brought to their end; the unfinished Dark Tower, with MacPhee and Ransom in a Cambridge setting, has been read as an early draft of some of its material; and Tolkien’s Númenor, borrowed as “Numinor”, is the one explicit link between the two friends’ legendaria.
Reception. Orwell, reviewing it in the Manchester Evening News on the day of publication, laid down that “On the whole, novels are better when there are no miracles in them”, that the book “would probably have been a better book if the magical element had been left out”, since “in essence it is a crime story”, that “it rather resembles G. K. Chesterton’s ‘The Man Who Was Thursday’”, and that “When one is told that God and the Devil are in conflict one always knows which side is going to win. … The whole drama of the struggle against evil lies in the fact that one does not have supernatural aid”; but also that “Plenty of people in our age do entertain the monstrous dreams of power that Mr. Lewis attributes to his characters, … and we are within sight of the time when such dreams will be realisable”, and that “by the standard of the novels appearing nowadays this is a book worth reading”. John Hampson in The Spectator found “the structure of That Hideous Strength on the clumsy side”, “cluttered up and enfeebled by too many tame details and an over-boyish exuberance”, the killings at the climax “much too reminiscent of the twopence coloured dreadfuls”; Leonard Bacon in the Saturday Review called it “a ghastly but in many places a magnificent nightmare”; Haldane attacked it as the work of a man whose “contempt for science is constantly letting him down” and who was “a most useful prop to the existing social order”; and Tolkien, who held that the space and time stories had been agreed between Lewis and himself before Williams appeared, judged that Williams’s influence appeared only in the third book and that it spoiled it. Alister McGrath’s recent verdict is that the novel shows Lewis as “a prophetic voice, offering a radical challenge to the accepted social wisdom of his own generation”.58
Takeaway. The trilogy’s treatise on magic: the old Atlantean art of Merlin, personal and now wholly unlawful; the Renaissance magia that was the twin of science; and the Belbury synthesis of technocracy with the invocation of spirits, which is the Materialist Magician in power — its Head a laboratory séance, its Objective Room an initiation into inhumanity, and its answer the descent of the planetary gods of the medieval cosmos, lawful only because the enemy has broken the quarantine of the silent planet.
The Screwtape Letters (1942), with Screwtape Proposes a Toast (1959)#
At a glance. Thirty-one weekly instalments in The Guardian, the Anglican weekly, from 2 May to 28 November 1941; the book, London: Geoffrey Bles (The Centenary Press), February 1942, “Reprinted with some alterations by kind permission of ‘The Guardian’”, had reached its fourteenth printing by September 1944; New York: Macmillan, 1943. Dedicated to J. R. R. Tolkien, who did not like it and did not like the dedication; Lewis inscribed his copy “In token payment of a great debt”. Two epigraphs: “The best way to drive out the devil, if he will not yield to texts of Scripture, is to jeer and flout him,” for he cannot bear scorn, from Luther’s Table Talk, and “The devill . . the prowde spirite . . cannot endure to be mocked”, from More’s Dialogue of Comfort. A preface dated 5 July 1941; then the letters of Screwtape, a senior devil, to his nephew Wormwood, a junior tempter newly assigned to a young man in England, “the patient”, running from the summer of 1941 to the patient’s death in an air raid; each is signed “Your affectionate uncle Screwtape” except the twenty-second, which Screwtape’s secretary Toadpipe finishes. “Screwtape Proposes a Toast” appeared in The Saturday Evening Post on 19 December 1959 and was added, with a new preface dated 18 May 1960, to The Screwtape Letters and Screwtape Proposes a Toast (Bles, 1961). The book made Lewis’s name: Time’s cover story of 1947 reported it “an immediate and phenomenal success on both sides of the Atlantic”, and it brought the correspondence he answered for the rest of his life.59
The prefaces. The 1941 preface opens with a refusal — “I have no intention of explaining how the correspondence which I now offer to the public fell into my hands” — and states the position that governs everything Lewis wrote on the subject: “There are two equal and opposite errors into which our race can fall about the devils. One is to disbelieve in their existence. The other is to believe, and to feel an excessive and unhealthy interest in them. They themselves are equally pleased by both errors and hail a materialist or a magician with the same delight.” The reader is warned that “the devil is a liar”, that “There is wishful thinking in Hell as well as on Earth”, and that “the diabolical method of dating seems to bear no relation to terrestrial time”. The 1960 preface answers the commonest question, whether he “really believe[s] in the Devil”, with the demonology quoted in the Thought section — “God has no opposite”; devils are angels whose “nature is depraved”; “Satan, the leader or dictator of devils, is the opposite, not of God, but of Michael” — and explains the book’s imagery. “I like bats much better than bureaucrats. I live in the Managerial Age, in a world of ‘Admin.’ The greatest evil is not now done in those sordid ‘dens of crime’ that Dickens loved to paint. It is not done even in concentration camps and labour camps. In those we see its final result. But it is conceived and ordered (moved, seconded, carried, and minuted)” in clean, carpeted, warmed and well-lighted offices, “by quiet men with white collars and cut fingernails and smooth-shaven cheeks who do not need to raise their voice”; hence his symbol for Hell is “something like the bureaucracy of a police state” or “the offices of a thoroughly nasty business concern”, a state “where everyone is perpetually concerned about his own dignity and advancement” and “Everyone wishes everyone else’s discrediting, demotion, and ruin”. He disclaims the “undeserved compliment” of “supposing that my Letters were the ripe fruit of many years’ study in moral and ascetic theology”: “They forgot that there is an equally reliable, though less creditable, way of learning how temptation works.” And he records the cost: “Though I had never written anything more easily, I never wrote with less enjoyment. … Though it was easy to twist one’s mind into the diabolical attitude, it was not fun, or not for long. The strain produced a sort of spiritual cramp. The work into which I had to project myself while I spoke through Screwtape was all dust, grit, thirst, and itch. Every trace of beauty, freshness, and geniality had to be excluded. It almost smothered me before I was done. It would have smothered my readers if I had prolonged it.” A country clergyman, he adds, had cancelled his subscription to The Guardian because “much of the advice given in these letters seemed to him not only erroneous but positively diabolical”.60
Plot. The patient is a young Englishman living with his mother in the first summer of the war. Wormwood is told to keep him from argument — “Jargon, not argument, is your best ally in keeping him from the Church”; “Do remember you are there to fuddle him” (I) — and fails: “I note with grave displeasure that your patient has become a Christian” (II). The counter-attack is to be the disappointing parish church, which hides the real Church, “the Church as we see her spread out through all time and space and rooted in eternity, … terrible as an army with banners”, and the Enemy’s “curious fantasy of making all these disgusting little human vermin … into what He calls His ‘free’ lovers and servants — ‘sons’ is the word He uses”. The letters then work through the patient’s mother and the domestic irritations that the devil Glubose manages (III, XVII), prayer kept vague (IV), the war, which is bad for Hell because men die prepared — “How much better for us if all humans died in costly nursing homes … amid doctors who lie, nurses who lie, friends who lie, as we have trained them” (V) — fear of the future (VI), the policy on revealing devils and the use of extremes, “All extremes, except extreme devotion to the Enemy, are to be encouraged” (VII), and the law of Undulation (VIII), where Screwtape sets out the two war-aims: the Enemy “really does want to fill the universe with a lot of loathsome little replicas of Himself”; “We want cattle who can finally become food; He wants servants who can finally become sons. We want to suck in, He wants to give out. We are empty and would be filled; He is full and flows over. Our war aim is a world in which Our Father Below has drawn all other beings into himself: … the Enemy wants a world full of beings united to Him but still distinct”; “He cannot ravish. He can only woo”; and “Our cause is never more in danger than when a human, no longer desiring, but still intending, … to do our Enemy’s will, looks round upon a universe from which every trace of Him seems to have vanished, … and asks why he has been forsaken, and still obeys.” The trough is to be used for sensual temptation — “An ever increasing craving for an ever diminishing pleasure is the formula” — and for the word “phase”: “Keep his mind off the plain antithesis between True and False” (IX). New worldly friends are found him, for “All mortals tend to turn into the thing they are pretending to be” (X); the four causes of laughter are classified (XI); he lapses by idleness, since “the safest road to Hell is the gradual one — the gentle slope, soft underfoot, … without sudden turnings, without milestones, without signposts” (XII); he repents after a walk and a book he really enjoys, real pleasures being dangerous to Hell (XIII). Counterfeit humility (XIV); the Future, in which “nearly all vices are rooted”, whereas “Gratitude looks to the past and love to the present; fear, avarice, lust, and ambition look ahead” (XV); church-shopping and Fr Spike, the link in whose opinions “is Hatred” (XVI); sexual temptation and the philosophy of Hell — “one thing is not another thing, … and, specially, … one self is not another self. My good is my good and your good is yours. … What one gains another loses” (XVIII); Screwtape’s slip in admitting that the Enemy really loves the humans, with the account of the Fall as a withdrawal in disgust when “the Enemy freely confessed that he foresaw a certain episode about a cross” (XIX); the terrestrial Venus (XX); the claim to one’s own time — “Men are not angered by mere misfortune but by misfortune conceived as injury” (XXI). Then the patient falls in love with a Christian girl, “a vile, sneaking, simpering, demure, monosyllabic, mouse-like, … watery, insignificant, virginal, bread-and-butter miss” whose “whole house and garden is one vast obscenity”, and Screwtape discovers the Enemy’s vulgarity — “He’s a hedonist at heart”; “He has filled His world full of pleasures. … There are things for humans to do all day long without His minding in the least — sleeping, washing, eating, … drinking, making love, playing, praying, working” — and, in his rage, “inadvertently allowed myself to assume the form of a large centipede”, a change he presents, on the authority of “someone with a name like Pshaw”, as “a glorious manifestation of that Life Force … which Our Father would worship if he worshipped anything but himself”; the letter names “the Lowerarchy” and “the Miserific Vision” (XXII). The historical Jesus (XXIII); spiritual pride (XXIV); “Christianity And”, the horror of the Same Old Thing and the fashion for asking “Is it in accordance with the general movement of our time? … Is it progressive or reactionary? Is this the way that History is going?” (XXV); unselfishness (XXVI); prayer and the Historical Point of View, by which Hell cuts “every generation off from all others”, so that “great scholars are now as little nourished by the past as the most ignorant mechanic” (XXVII); the bombing, which Hell fears, since “seventy years is not a day too much for the difficult task of unravelling their souls from Heaven … and building up a firm attachment to the earth” (XXVIII); courage, the danger being “one of the Enemy’s motives for creating a dangerous world — … a world in which moral issues really come to the point” (XXIX); fatigue (XXX). In the last letter the patient is dead in a raid, has seen the devils and then seen Him, and Wormwood has lost him: “Rest assured, my love for you and your love for me are as like as two peas. I have always desired you, as you (pitiful fool) desired me. The difference is that I am the stronger. … As dainty a morsel as ever I grew fat on”; “If only we could find out what He is really up to! … All that sustains me is the conviction that our Realism, … our rejection (in the face of all temptations) of all silly nonsense and claptrap, must win in the end.”61
The Materialist Magician. The seventh letter contains a sentence much quoted by writers on the occult. Asked whether the patient should be kept ignorant of his tempter’s existence, Screwtape answers that “Our policy, for the moment, is to conceal ourselves. … We are really faced with a cruel dilemma. When the humans disbelieve in our existence we lose all the pleasing results of direct terrorism and we make no magicians.” But “I have great hopes that we shall learn in due time how to emotionalise and mythologise their science to such an extent” that “what is, in effect, a belief in us, (though not under that name) … will creep in while the human mind remains closed to belief in the Enemy. The ‘Life Force’, the worship of sex, and some aspects of Psychoanalysis, may here prove useful. If once we can produce our perfect work — the Materialist Magician, the man, not using, but veritably worshipping, … what he vaguely calls ‘Forces’ while denying the existence of ‘spirits’ — then the end of the war will be in sight.” Weston’s Life-Force religion in Perelandra and the macrobes of Belbury are this programme fulfilled.62
The Toast. Screwtape, guest of honour at the annual dinner of the Tempters’ Training College, apologises for the thinness of the wine, which is made of the souls of the damned — no great sinners, only “the sort of souls on whose despair and ruin we have — well, I won’t say feasted, but at any rate subsisted” — and reviews Hell’s strategy since the French Revolution. The freed poor, “Instead of using their new liberties — as we reasonably hoped and expected — for massacre, rape, and looting, … or even for perpetual intoxication, they were perversely engaged in becoming cleaner, more orderly, … more thrifty, better educated, and even more virtuous”, so that “the threat of something like a really healthy state of society … seemed then perfectly serious”. Hell’s remedy was to make them enthrone “a good, solid resounding lie”: the perversion of the word democracy into the feeling I’m as good as you, which is Envy made respectable — “Under the name of Envy it has been known to the humans for thousands of years”; “Under the influence of this incantation those who are in any or every way inferior … can labour more wholeheartedly and successfully than ever before to pull down everyone else to their own level.” The modern girl’s prayer, “Oh God, make me a normal twentieth-century girl!”, means “Make me a minx, a moron, and a parasite”; the new education’s principle is “that dunces and idlers must not be made to feel inferior … to intelligent and industrious pupils. That would be ‘undemocratic’”; and the end is “a nation without great men, … a nation mainly of subliterates, morally flaccid from lack of discipline in youth, … full of the cocksureness which flattery breeds on ignorance, and soft from lifelong pampering”. The deeper value of the lie is as “a state of mind, … which necessarily excluding humility, charity, contentment, and all the pleasures … of gratitude or admiration, turns a human being away from almost every road … which might finally lead him to Heaven.”63
Characters. Screwtape, “His Abysmal Sublimity Under Secretary”, a senior tempter writing from the bureaucracy of Hell; Wormwood, his nephew, fresh from the Training College under Slubgob, finally to be eaten; the unnamed patient, his mother, his materialist friend, the worldly couple, the Vicar and Fr Spike, the Christian girl and her family; Our Father Below, who withdrew from the Enemy’s presence in disgust; the Enemy, God; the lesser devils Glubose, Scabtree, Triptweeze, Slumtrimpet and Toadpipe; the Lowerarchy, the High Command, the Secret Police, the Miserific Vision.
Major themes. Temptation in ordinary life. Not spectacular sins but the gentle slope; the counterfeit of every virtue; the Historical Point of View; “Christianity And”. Hell as parasite. Pleasure is the Enemy’s invention; Hell can only distort it, by “the formula” of increasing craving. The two war-aims. To suck in or to give out; cattle that become food or servants that become sons. The policy of concealment and the two errors about devils. Death as victory.
Esoteric symbolism. The demonology is orthodox and anti-dualist, and the images are Lewis’s own: devils as a bureaucracy; the Miserific Vision as the inverted beatific vision; damnation as being eaten; and the devils’ metamorphosis as “a glorious manifestation of that Life Force”, which places Shaw’s and Bergson’s vitalism on the side of Hell. The Materialist Magician is Lewis’s prophecy of the occultism of his own century: not belief in spirits but the worship of Forces by men who deny spirits, nourished by the Life Force, the cult of sex and psychoanalysis. The preface’s “materialist or a magician” is the frame for everything he said of the occult: the magician’s error is real, and it is the materialist’s twin.
Relation to other works. Written beside The Problem of Pain and the first broadcast talks, whose doctrines the letters dramatise from below; the phrase “mere Christianity”, Baxter’s, first appears in the twenty-fifth letter; the Materialist Magician returns as Weston and as Belbury; The Great Divorce is the complement, Hell seen from the side of the lost; the Toast belongs with The Abolition of Man and the essays on education.
Reception. W. J. Turner in The Spectator (20 February 1942): “This is a witty and profound book. … Like all Mr. Lewis’s books, it is a delight to the intellect”, and “I do not hesitate to compare Mr. Lewis’s achievement with Pilgrim’s Progress.” Charles Williams reviewed it in Time and Tide as a letter from one devil to another: “Letters from devil to devil are not meant for earth. They give everything away. Do not ever let them be re-read”; “It is a dangerous book, heavenly-dangerous”; and its author “this unspeakable louse”. Tolkien thought it trite and hastily put together and held, more seriously, that one should not make light of real devils. Lewis himself resolved never to write another letter of the kind, and kept the resolution for eighteen years.64
Takeaway. The book in which Lewis defined, for a mass readership, the relation between materialism and magic: the devils are real, bureaucratic and bored, they conceal themselves by policy, and their masterpiece will be the man who worships Forces and denies spirits.
The Great Divorce: A Dream (1945)#
At a glance. Serialised in The Guardian from 10 November 1944 to 13 April 1945 under Lewis’s own title, Who Goes Home? (the doorkeepers’ cry when the House of Commons rises), which the publisher refused; the book, London: Geoffrey Bles, with the title-page date 1945 and publication in January 1946; New York: Macmillan, 1946. Dedicated to Barbara Wall, Lewis’s typist. Fourteen chapters and a preface dated April 1945. The preface begins with Blake. “Blake wrote the Marriage of Heaven and Hell. If I have written of their Divorce, this is not because I think myself a fit antagonist for so great a genius, … nor even because I feel at all sure that I know what he meant. But in some sense or other the attempt to make that marriage is perennial. The attempt is based on the belief that reality never presents us with an absolutely unavoidable ‘either-or’; … that, granted skill and patience and (above all) time enough, some way of embracing both alternatives … can always be found; that mere development or adjustment or refinement will somehow turn evil into good … without our being called on for a final and total rejection of anything we should like to retain.” Against it: “We are not living in a world where all roads are radii of a circle and where all, if followed long enough, … will therefore draw gradually nearer and finally meet at the centre: … rather in a world where every road, after a few miles, forks into two, and each of those into two again, … and at each fork you must make a decision”; “I do not think that all who choose wrong roads perish; but their rescue consists in being put back on the right road”; “Evil can be undone, but it cannot ‘develop’ into good. Time does not heal it.” He acknowledges “a writer whose name I have forgotten … whom I read several years ago in a highly colored American magazine of what they call ‘Scientifiction’”, whose time-traveller found “raindrops that would pierce him like bullets … and sandwiches that no strength could bite — because, of course, nothing in the past can be altered”, as the source of “The unbendable and unbreakable quality of my heavenly matter”; and he disclaims the thing his readers would most want: “I beg readers to remember that this is a fantasy. It has of course — or I intended it to have — a moral. But the transmortal conditions are solely an imaginative supposal: they are not even a guess … or a speculation at what may actually await us. The last thing I wish is to arouse factual curiosity about the details of the after-world.”65
Plot. “I seemed to be standing in a bus queue by the side of a long, mean street.” It is evening in the Grey Town, always drizzling and always twilight; the queue quarrels and dwindles, and a bus with a shining driver carries the narrator and a few others up into the air above streets that go on for ever. On the bus the Intelligent Man, Ikey, explains the town: people quarrel and move away from one another, so that the streets stretch for millions of miles and the oldest inhabitants, Napoleon among them, are too far off to visit — “I thought you’d meet interesting historical characters. But you don’t: they’re too far away” — and he means to fetch back real goods to start trade: “I’d start a little business. I’d have something to sell. You’d soon get people coming to live near — centralization.” The bus rises through cloud into a vast dawn country, and the passengers find themselves ghosts, smudges against the light; the grass will not bend under them and the leaves are too heavy to lift. “I had the sense of being in a larger place, perhaps even a larger sort of space, than I had ever known before”; “I had got out in some sense which made the Solar System itself seem an indoor affair.” Bright, solid People come down from the mountains, each known to one of the ghosts, and the episodes follow. The Big Ghost, a self-respecting man, is met by Len, his former employee, who murdered a man and is now solid — “What I’d like to understand,” said the Ghost, “is what you’re here for, as pleased as Punch, you, a bloody murderer, … while I’ve been walking the streets down there and living in a place like a pigsty all these years” — and, offered everything for the asking, insists on his rights and goes back to the bus. The Episcopal Ghost, a modernist bishop, boasts to his friend Dick of his doubts — “When the doctrine of the Resurrection ceased to commend itself to the critical faculties which God had given me, … I openly rejected it. I preached my famous sermon. I defied the whole chapter. I took every risk” — and is answered, “What risk? What was at all likely to come of it except what actually came — popularity, sales for your books, … invitations, and finally a bishopric?”; he prefers the theological society in the Grey Town, where he is to read a paper on what Jesus would have thought had he lived longer, and declines a God who can be known rather than discussed. Ikey tries to steal a golden apple from the heavenly orchard and sets out “on his via dolorosa to the bus, carrying his torture”, until the angel of the waterfall thunders: “Fool,” he said, “put it down. You cannot take it back. There is not room for it in Hell. … Stay here and learn to eat such apples. The very leaves and the blades of grass in the wood will delight to teach you.” The Hard-Bitten Ghost, who has seen through everything, explains that heaven and hell are the same racket under one management, and asks “if the official version were true” why “these chaps up here” do not “attack and sweep the Town out of existence”. A woman ashamed of her transparency is coaxed by a Spirit while a herd of unicorns thunders past to frighten her out of self-regard.66
Then the narrator meets his Teacher: “My name is George … George Macdonald”, to whom he confesses what Phantastes did for him, and who explains the country. “Is judgment not final? Is there really a way out of Hell into Heaven?” “It depends on the way ye’re using the words. If they leave that grey town behind it will not have been Hell. To any that leaves it, it is Purgatory.” The excursion is the Refrigerium: “A man with your advantages might have read of it in Prudentius, not to mention Jeremy Taylor. It means that the damned have holidays — excursions, ye understand.” “Hell is a state of mind — ye never said a truer word. And every state of mind, left to itself, every shutting up of the creature within the dungeon of its own mind — … is, in the end, Hell. But Heaven is not a state of mind. Heaven is reality itself. All that is fully real is Heavenly.” “There are only two kinds of people in the end: those who say to God, ‘Thy will be done,’ … and those to whom God says, in the end, ‘Thy will be done.’” MacDonald tells of Sir Archibald, who gave his life to psychical research into survival and found in heaven that “There was nothing more to prove. His occupation was clean gone”, and, refusing to laugh at himself, “cared nothing about joy. In the end he went away”; they watch the Artist, who cannot bear a country where his reputation is unknown (he has become “more and more interested in paint for its own sake”), and the Grumbling woman, of whom the question is whether she is still a grumbler or has become only a grumble. Robert’s wife, who made her husband her project and ruined him, demands him back to go on managing and dissolves into complaint. Pam, the mother, demands her son: “I want my boy, and I mean to have him. He is mine, do you understand? Mine, mine, mine, for ever and ever.” “He will be, Pam. Everything will be yours. God Himself will be yours. But not that way. … Nothing can be yours by nature”; and MacDonald on natural love gone wrong: “Brass is mistaken for gold more easily than clay is. … It is a stronger angel, and therefore, when it falls, a fiercer devil.” The one sin cured on the page is lust: the Ghost with the red Lizard whispering on his shoulder consents, through terror and pain, to let the burning Angel kill it, and the dead Lizard rises as a great stallion on which the new man rides to the mountains — “Ye must ask, if the risen body even of appetite is as grand a horse as ye saw, … what would the risen body of maternal love or friendship be?” Then a procession with music and flowers: Sarah Smith of Golders Green, unknown on earth and a great lady here, whose love made everyone she met her child, comes to meet her husband Frank, who has become two things, a Dwarf leading on a chain a tall Tragedian who speaks for him; she laughs at the Tragedian’s rhetoric — “Don’t you see what nonsense it’s talking” — and for a moment the Dwarf begins to grow, “Against his will, he was even growing a little bigger”, but he chooses the blackmail of pity, shrinks, vanishes into the Tragedian, and the Tragedian vanishes. When the narrator protests at the Lady’s untroubled joy, MacDonald names the alternative: “The demand of the loveless and the self-imprisoned that they should be allowed to blackmail the universe: … that till they consent to be happy (on their own terms) no one else shall taste joy: that theirs should be the final power; … that Hell should be able to veto Heaven.” He shows the crack in the soil through which the bus came: “All Hell is smaller than one pebble of your earthly world: but it is smaller than one atom of this world, the Real World. … Look at yon butterfly. … If it swallowed all Hell, Hell would not be big enough to do it any harm or to have any taste.” Asked about universal salvation he refuses the definition: “Ye can know nothing of the end of all things, or nothing expressible in those terms. … It may be, as the Lord said to the Lady Julian, that all will be well”; “But it’s ill talking of such questions. … Because all answers deceive. … Any man may choose eternal death”; “Time is the very lens through which ye see … small and clear”; “For every attempt to see the shape of eternity except through the lens of Time destroys your knowledge of Freedom. Witness the doctrine of Predestination which shows (truly enough) that eternal reality is not waiting for a future … in which to be real; but at the price of removing Freedom which is the deeper truth of the two.” “And wouldn’t Universalism do the same? … Ye cannot know eternal reality by a definition.” The vision ends on a silver table with “little figures like chessmen who went to and fro doing this and that”, each “the idolum or puppet representative of some one of the great presences” standing by, and MacDonald’s warning: “Ye saw the choices a bit more clearly than ye could see them on Earth: the lens was clearer. But it was still seen through the lens. … Do not ask of a vision in a dream more than a vision in a dream can give. … Ye are only dreaming. And if ye come to tell of what ye have seen, make it plain that it was but a dream. … Give no poor fool the pretext to think ye are claiming knowledge of what no mortal knows.” The sun rises over the mountains; “The morning! The morning!” I cried, “I am caught by the morning and I am a ghost”; and “I awoke in a cold room, hunched on the floor beside a black and empty grate, … the clock striking three, and the siren howling overhead.”67
Characters. The narrator; the shining driver; the Tousle-Headed Poet; Ikey; the Big Ghost and Len; the Episcopal Ghost and Dick; the Hard-Bitten Ghost; the ashamed woman; the Water-Giant; George MacDonald, the Teacher; Sir Archibald (reported); the Artist; the Grumbler; Robert’s wife; Pam and her brother Reginald; the Ghost with the Lizard and the Angel; Sarah Smith of Golders Green, Frank, the Dwarf and the Tragedian; Napoleon, pacing his palace for ever; the Bright People.
Major themes. Hell as self-chosen. The Grey Town grows by quarrel; every ghost refuses heaven for his rights, his reputation, his management of others, his possessive love, his self-pity. The refusal of Blake’s marriage. No synthesis of good and evil, only the fork in every road. The Refrigerium (Prudentius, Jeremy Taylor) as the fiction’s licence. Heaven as the Real, more solid than the solid; the ghosts are the shadows. Time as the lens: predestination and universalism as two attempts to see eternity without it, and the chessboard as Boethian eternity seen from outside. Pity’s two kinds, and the refusal to let Hell veto Heaven. MacDonald, the universalist, who in Lewis’s book declines to assert universalism.
Esoteric symbolism. The dream-vision with a dead master as guide is Dante’s; the mountains are Purgatory and the dawn is Judgement. The Platonic substance of heaven, where ghosts cannot bend the grass, literalises the doctrine that evil is privation and the real is the good, and the butterfly that could swallow Hell is Julian’s hazelnut turned inside out. The chessmen and the “great presences” give a theory of the relation between the empirical self in time and the eternal self that Lewis derives from Boethius and that resembles, without endorsing, the Neoplatonic doctrine of the undescended soul. Sir Archibald, whose life was psychical research and who in heaven had “nothing more to prove”, is Lewis’s judgement on the survival-research movement: to want to prove survival is to want the wrong thing, and the proof, when it comes, is unbearable to one who wanted only proof. The Episcopal Ghost’s theological society is modernism as damnation; the Dwarf and the Tragedian dramatise the splitting of a soul into the performed self and the real self that Perelandra’s mirror had foreseen; and MacDonald’s refusal to answer the universalist question with a definition is the book’s most careful theological act and the text for Lewis’s position on apokatastasis.
Relation to other works. The complement of Screwtape and the sequel in method of The Pilgrim’s Regress; the chapter on Hell in The Problem of Pain is its doctrine; the Lizard restates Perelandra’s teaching that spirit is not opposed to body; the Boethian eternity returns in Miracles and Letters to Malcolm; MacDonald’s role repays the debt acknowledged in the anthology of the same year. The book’s title answers Blake’s Marriage of Heaven and Hell.
Reception. A. C. Deane in The Spectator (25 January 1946), under the headline “A Nightmare”, found the satire brilliant and the tone intolerable: “it does not seem possible to doubt that writing of this type, however clever and even brilliant in itself, jars horribly when the theme is the doom of lost souls”, and “It would be tragic if gifts so remarkable as his were not reserved for purposes worthy of them.” The book has been much dramatised and has remained, with Screwtape, the most widely read of Lewis’s adult fiction.68
Takeaway. Lewis’s eschatological dream-vision, written against Blake’s marriage of contraries: Hell is the self shut in its own mind, Heaven is the Real, every road forks, and the saved and the lost are told apart by a single sentence about whose will is done.
Till We Have Faces: A Myth Retold (1956)#
At a glance. London: Geoffrey Bles, 1956; New York: Harcourt, Brace, 1957. The working title Bareface was refused by the publisher, and the title was fixed in February 1956 from Orual’s sentence, “How can they meet us face to face till we have faces?” Dedicated “To Joy Davidman”, who discussed each chapter with him and typed the book; the epigraph, unattributed, is the first line of Shakespeare’s Sonnet 151, “Love is too young to know what conscience is.” Part One has twenty-one chapters, Part Two four, followed by Lewis’s note on Apuleius. He had carried the subject since his undergraduate days and attempted it in several verse forms, so that he had been at work on Orual for thirty-five years; he called it “far and away my best book”.69
The note on Apuleius. The source is The Golden Ass (IV.28–VI.24), and Lewis treats Apuleius as “transmitter, not the inventor” of the myth, so that he “felt quite free to go behind Apuleius”: “Apuleius was of course a man of genius: but in relation to my work he is a ‘source,’ not an ‘influence’ nor a ‘model.’” The one decisive change: “The central alteration in my own version consists in making Psyche’s palace invisible to normal, mortal eyes … if ‘making’ is not the wrong word for something which forced itself upon me … almost at my first reading of the story, as the way the thing must have been.” “This change of course brings with it a more ambivalent motive and a different character for my heroine … and finally modifies the whole quality of the tale.” In Apuleius both sisters see the palace and act from envy; in Lewis, Orual sees only rock and heather, except once, and her motive is love. To a correspondent he described the book as “the story of every nice, affectionate agnostic whose dearest one suddenly ‘gets religion’ … or even every luke-warm Christian whose dearest gets Vocation”, “Never, I think, treated sympathetically by a Christian writer before”, told “all through the mouth of the elder sister”, whose question is “Is P(syche) mad or am I blind?”70
Plot. “I am old now and have not much to fear from the anger of gods.” Orual, Queen of Glome, a small barbarian kingdom north of the Greek world, writes her accusation against the gods in Greek for a Greek reader to judge. She is the ugly elder daughter of King Trom; her sister Redival is pretty and shallow; the King buys a Greek slave, the Fox, a Stoic rationalist, to teach his daughters; his second wife dies giving birth to Istra, whom the Fox names Psyche, and whom Orual loves as mother, sister and more. When the Fox sings over the child, “Prettier than Andromeda, prettier than Helen, prettier than Aphrodite herself”, Orual stops him — “Speak words of better omen, Grandfather” — knowing it is not good to talk that way about Ungit, the goddess of Glome, a faceless black stone in a dark house, served by a Priest and his temple girls. Psyche’s beauty makes the people worship her — “Her beauty, which most of them had never seen, worked on them as a terror might work”; “‘A goddess, a goddess’”; “‘It is Ungit herself in mortal shape’” — and she goes out to heal the plague-stricken. Drought and famine follow, and the Priest tells the King that the Accursed, who is Psyche, must be given to the Shadowbrute, the god of the Grey Mountain, who is Ungit’s son or Ungit herself: “And when the Brute is Ungit it lies with the man, and when it is her son it lies with the woman. And either way there is a devouring … many different things are said … many sacred stories … many great mysteries. Some say the loving and the devouring are all the same thing.” Against the Fox’s Greek objections the Priest answers: “I, King, have dealt with the gods for three generations of men, and I know that they dazzle our eyes … and flow in and out of one another like eddies on a river, and nothing that is said clearly can be said truly about them. … Holy places are dark places. It is life and strength, not knowledge and words, that we get in them. Holy wisdom is not clear and thin like water, but thick and dark like blood.” The King beats Orual senseless when she tries to intervene; on the night before the sacrifice Psyche tells her that she has always longed for the Mountain — “The sweetest thing in all my life has been the longing” — and Orual records the first of her sins: “Since I write this book against the gods, it is just that I should put into it whatever can be said against myself. So let me set this down: as she spoke I felt, amid all my love, a bitterness. … If this grudging is the sin for which the gods hate me, it is one I have committed.” Psyche is dressed as a bride and chained to the Tree on the Mountain, and the rains come.71
Orual goes with Bardia, captain of the guard, to bury Psyche’s bones, and receives on the way the nearest thing to a love-speech ever made her: “‘Why, yes, it’s a pity about her face. But she’s a brave girl and honest. … If a man was blind and she weren’t the King’s daughter, she’d make him a good wife.’” Beyond the Tree, in the god’s secret valley, they find Psyche alive, radiant, who says she is the bride of the god and lives in his palace, and tells of her rescue by the West-wind — “And he took me … and pulled me right out of the iron girdle … and carried me up into the air, far up above the ground, and whirled me away”; “Now I knew it was he, not it, I wasn’t in the least afraid of sailing along in the sky” — and of a husband who comes only in the dark and may not be seen. Orual sees only the valley. “For the world had broken in pieces and Psyche and I were not in the same piece. … Gods, and again gods, always gods … they had stolen her. They would leave us nothing.” A thought comes “like a crocus coming up in the early year” — “Was she not worthy of the gods? Ought they not to have her?” — and is drowned; Psyche will not come home — “Dear Maia, I am a wife now. It’s no longer you that I must obey” (Maia is her name for Orual) — and “I learned then how one can hate those one loves.” At dusk by the river Orual sees, for one moment, the palace, and then it is gone: “I was in great fear. Perhaps it was not real….” The Fox argues that the lover is an outlaw or that Psyche is mad; Bardia that it is the Brute and the dark hides a monster; Orual prays alone and without sacrifice — “I promised anything they might ask of me, if only they would send me a sign. They gave me none” — and goes back with a lamp and a dagger and compels Psyche, by stabbing her own arm and threatening to kill them both, to promise to look at her husband by lamplight. Psyche’s judgement: “You are indeed teaching me about kinds of love I did not know. It is like looking into a deep pit. I am not sure whether I like your kind better than hatred”; “Whatever comes after, something that was between us dies here.” That night the lamp is lit; light, a voice, thunder, the valley in ruin, Psyche weeping and driven into exile; the god appears to Orual, beautiful and terrible, and pronounces her sentence, that she also shall be Psyche. “You, who read my book, judge.” Orual veils her face for ever, becomes Queen on Trom’s death, kills Prince Argan of Phars in single combat, marries Redival away, reigns long and well, and buries Orual inside the Queen: “I locked Orual up or laid her asleep as best I could somewhere deep down inside me; she lay curled there. It was like being with child, but reversed; the thing I carried in me grew slowly smaller and less alive.” “My second strength lay in my veil”; “the wildest stories got about as to what that veil hid”; “The best story was that I had no face at all; if you stripped off my veil you’d find emptiness”; “The upshot of all this nonsense was that I became something very mysterious and awful.” At night she hears the chains of the well swinging and thinks it Psyche weeping, “terribly afraid of not hearing it … if for once — if possibly, at last, after ten thousand mockeries — it should be real, if Psyche had come back”. The old Priest dies and his successor Arnom, Hellenised by the Fox, sets a Greek Aphrodite beside the stone; the Fox dies; Bardia dies, worn out in her service. On a journey she finds a small temple of a goddess Istra whose priest tells the Cupid and Psyche story as the Greeks tell it: the sisters saw the palace and acted from envy. That is why she writes: “For if the true story had been like their story, no riddle would have been set me” — a world “in which the gods show themselves clearly and don’t torment men with glimpses, … nor unveil to one what they hide from another, nor ask you to believe what contradicts … your eyes and ears and nose and tongue and fingers”. Part One ends with her charge, and no answer.72
Part Two must be added, for the gods have answered by unmaking her. Bardia’s widow Ansit tells her what her love did to him: “Oh, Queen Orual, I begin to think you know nothing of love…. Perhaps you who spring from the gods love like the gods. Like the Shadowbrute. They say the loving and the devouring are all one, don’t they? … Gorged with other men’s lives, women’s too: Bardia’s, mine, the Fox’s, your sister’s — both your sisters’.” At the rite of the Year’s Birth she sees a peasant woman comforted by the faceless stone and understands that the old Ungit gave what the Greek statue cannot; in a vision her dead father drags her down to the Pillar Room’s mirror and she sees Ungit’s face as her own: “Lord, I am Ungit.” She goes to drown herself, and the god forbids it: “Do not do it,” said the god. “You cannot escape Ungit by going to the deadlands, for she is there also. … Die before you die. There is no chance after.” She tries to live by the Fox’s philosophy and fails. In visions she is set Psyche’s tasks — the sorting of seeds, the golden wool, the water of death — and is carried at last to a court of the dead where, unveiled, she reads her complaint, which is not the book she wrote but the thing under it: “Do you think that we mortals will find you gods easier to bear if you’re beautiful? I tell you that if that’s true we’ll find you a thousand times worse. … You’ll leave us nothing; nothing that’s worth our keeping or your taking. … It would be far better for us if you were foul and ravening. We’d rather you drank their blood than stole their hearts. We’d rather they were ours and dead than yours and made immortal.” “The complaint was the answer. To have heard myself making it was to be answered….” “When the time comes to you at which you will be forced at last to utter the speech … which has lain at the center of your soul for years, … which you have, all that time, idiot-like, been saying over and over, you’ll not talk about the joy of words. I saw well why the gods do not speak to us openly, nor let us answer. Till that word can be dug out of us, why should they hear the babble that we think we mean? How can they meet us face to face till we have faces?” The Fox, her guide now, confesses that he taught her to disbelieve the gods and gave her nothing in Ungit’s place, and shows her in living pictures that Psyche performed her tasks because Orual bore the anguish of them; Psyche returns from the deadlands with the casket of beauty, Orual kneels and is raised, and the god comes: “I was pierced through and through with the arrows of it. I was being unmade. I was no one. … The earth and stars and sun, all that was or will be, existed for his sake. … And he was coming. The most dreadful, the most beautiful, the only dread and beauty there is, was coming.” In the pool she sees two Psyches. She wakes in her garden, lives four days, and writes: “I ended my first book with the words ‘no answer.’ I know now, Lord, why you utter no answer. You are yourself the answer. Before your face questions die away. What other answer would suffice? … Only words, words; to be led out to battle against other words.” The sentence breaks off; a postscript by Arnom, priest of Aphrodite, records that the Queen’s head fell forward on the roll as she died, that she was the wisest, most just and most merciful of the princes of those parts, and asks any traveller to Greece to carry the book there.73
Characters. Orual, Maia to Psyche, the ugly veiled Queen of Glome, narrator and accuser, who is Ungit and becomes Psyche; Psyche, Istra, the soul and the god’s bride, whose tasks Orual unknowingly bears; Redival; King Trom, brutal and frightened; the Fox, Lysias, the Stoic tutor, reason and gentleness, who confesses that his wisdom was thin like water; Bardia, worn out in her service, and Ansit his wife, her accuser; the Priest of Ungit, blind, in his bird-mask, the voice of the holy darkness; Arnom, the Hellenising reformer, who writes the postscript; Ungit, the faceless stone, Aphrodite of Glome, the devouring mother; the god of the Grey Mountain, the Shadowbrute, “the most dreadful, the most beautiful”; the West-wind; Tarin the eunuch, Trunia, Argan, Ilerdia, Daaran, the nurse Batta, the maid Poobi, the priest of Istra, the peasant woman, the judge and the dead.
Major themes. The complaint and the answer. The gods do not answer because the accuser has no face until her own word is dug out of her. Love as devouring. Ungit, the Shadowbrute, and Orual’s love for Psyche, Bardia and the Fox against love as gift: the book is Lewis’s most searching treatment of what The Four Loves would call the jealousy of Affection. Reason and holiness. The Fox’s clear Greek rationalism against the Priest’s dark holiness, with the judgement that the Fox was wrong and the Priest half right, and Arnom’s Hellenised Ungit the loss of both. Seeing and not seeing: the invisible palace, the one glimpse, the veil, the mirror. Substitution: Orual bears Psyche’s tasks. The retelling of pagan myth as the vehicle of a Christian truth never named.
Esoteric symbolism. The Apuleian tale had been read as an allegory of the soul’s union with divine Love since Fulgentius, and Lewis keeps the allegory while making the soul’s sister, the natural self, the narrator: Psyche is the soul that longs for the Mountain from childhood and is married to the god in the dark, her tasks are the Platonic ascent and her descent for beauty its last stage, and Orual is Ungit, the earth-mother and devourer, until she becomes Psyche too. Ungit, the shapeless stone sweating blood, is the Numinous as Otto described it, set against the Greek statue; the Priest’s speech on gods who “flow in and out of one another like eddies on a river”, on holy places that “are dark places” and on wisdom “thick and dark like blood”, is Lewis’s defence of the pre-philosophical sacred, and the peasant woman before the old stone is his acknowledgement that it mediated something real. The Priest’s “many sacred stories … many great mysteries”, the identity of loving and devouring, the Brute who is Ungit or her son and the rite of the Year’s Birth are the mythic substrate that “Myth Became Fact” treats as the pagan foreshadowing of the Incarnation, and the god who descends in the dark and whose face cannot be seen until the soul has a face is Eros and Christ at once. The veil is the mask of the self that cannot be seen; the title plays on “face to face” (1 Corinthians 13:12) and on the doctrine that the gods see the soul and not the mask; the mirror in which Orual sees Ungit is the self-knowledge that Perelandra’s mirror had perverted; and the trial, the reading of the complaint and the god as “the answer” reproduce the end of Job. The Fox’s Stoicism — “No man can be an exile if he remembers that all the world is one city” — is the Greek clarity Lewis admired and found insufficient, and the cosmology is kept pre-Christian, so that Christianity appears only as the shape of what the myth cannot say.
Relation to other works. “Myth Became Fact” and the chapter on myth in An Experiment in Criticism are the theory; The Four Loves the analysis of the loves Orual embodies; A Grief Observed, written after Joy Davidman’s death, continues the complaint against the silent God and its answer; Surprised by Joy, finished the same year, explains the longing for the Mountain; the Platonism is that of The Last Battle and of the Great Dance.
Reception. Robert Gorham Davis in The New York Times (1957) thought Lewis “still does not have all the equipment of a major novelist” but found the book “much more convincing” than his religious novels and “firmly grounded in actual primitive religious practice”; it sold slowly and puzzled the readers who missed the explicit Christianity, and has since been widely regarded as his finest novel. Peter Schakel’s Reason and Imagination in C. S. Lewis (1984), the first monograph, reads it as the dialectic of reason (the Fox) and the holy (the Priest) resolved in Part Two; Doris Myers’s Bareface (2004) is the fullest guide.74
Takeaway. Lewis’s late masterpiece and his most Platonic book: the soul’s marriage to a god who cannot be seen, the natural self’s complaint against the gods, the holy darkness of the mother-goddess against Greek clarity, and an answer that is not an answer but a face. It is the text in which he most fully honours the pagan mysteries and the Numinous, and in which the Christian meaning is withheld from the surface and left to the shape of the myth.
Short Fiction, Fragments and Juvenilia#
Lewis’s remaining fiction was collected by Walter Hooper. Of Other Worlds: Essays and Stories (London: Bles, 1966) prints, with the essays on story and on science fiction, three short stories and the opening of an unfinished novel; The Dark Tower and Other Stories (London: Collins, 1977) adds the fragment that gives it its title and “The Man Born Blind”. The Dark Tower, some sixty-four manuscript pages which Hooper reports having rescued from a bonfire of Lewis’s papers in January 1964 and which he dates to about 1939 (John Rateliff argues for about 1946), opens at a Cambridge college in the vacation, where the scientist Orfieu, with his assistant Scudamour, the Scots sceptic MacPhee, Ransom and the narrator, declares time travel impossible and unveils instead a chronoscope that shows scenes of an “Othertime”: a dark tower being built by men who move like automata, made so by the sting of the Stingingman or Unicorn, a man with a horn in his forehead who sits in the tower and stings those brought before him. The tower reproduces the new University Library, which suggests the future; Scudamour recognises the next Unicorn as his own double, flings himself at the screen when his fiancée’s double is to be stung, and finds himself in the Unicorn’s body in Othertime, where he reads in a library a theory of multiple time-lines and of the transfer of minds; the fragment breaks off there. Kathryn Lindskoog’s charge that the piece was forged has been discussed in the Life; Alastair Fowler’s recollection of being shown the Stingingman in 1952 has settled the authorship for most scholars, though the stylometric studies remain unexplained and the date uncertain. Its interest here is the chronoscope as a scientific crystal-gazing, the horned priest-king as Lewis’s most explicit image of a sexualised occult power, and the many-timelines theory that the Narnia books would use. “The Shoddy Lands” (The Magazine of Fantasy and Science Fiction, February 1956) carries an Oxford don into the mind of a young woman who attends to nothing but clothes, jewels and her own body, a world of green blobs and faceless sketches at whose walls two voices knock, her fiancé’s and a greater one: a picture of a mind without attention, treated as a horror, and Lewis’s one experiment in entering another consciousness. “Ministering Angels” (January 1958) answers a proposal in the Saturday Review that women be sent to comfort the crews of Mars stations with the arrival of two volunteers, a lecturer who argues the new sexual ethics in the jargon of psychology and an old prostitute who has come out of kindness, and with the meteorologist-monk who sees in the second something of Mary Magdalene. “Forms of Things Unknown” (first printed in 1966) sends a fourth expedition to the Moon after three have ended with the same broken message, and its lone astronaut finds the earlier crews standing as statues a moment before the shadow of a head with writhing hair falls across his own: the Moon is the Gorgon’s home, and the myths were memories of real things in other places, the thesis of the Oyarsa of Perelandra. “The Man Born Blind”, written in the late 1920s, is the parable of the sun told as tragedy: a man given sight keeps asking where the light is, since he sees only lit things, and, told by a painter that it is a shining mist in the valley, leaps into it from a quarry’s edge — the Great War with Barfield over knowledge of the light itself, in a page. After Ten Years (1959–60), abandoned in Joy’s last illness, puts Menelaus in the Wooden Horse on the last night of Troy and was to use the variant in which the real Helen waited in Egypt while an eidolon went to Troy, so that he must choose between the phantom beauty and the ageing woman — the subject of the Dwarf and the Tragedian and of Till We Have Faces. Boxen (London: Collins, 1985; enlarged 2008) prints the Animal-Land and Boxen chronicles the brothers wrote at Little Lea between about 1906 and 1913 — King Bunny, Sir Peter Mouse, Lord John Big of Bigham, the politics and bureaucracy of a state of dressed animals — of which Surprised by Joy says that they had nothing of romance and nothing of Joy in them: the training of a novelist, not of a romantic, and evidence that the longing came from elsewhere.75
The Chronicles of Narnia#
The seven Chronicles appeared at yearly intervals from 1950 to 1956, the first five from Geoffrey Bles and the last two from The Bodley Head, all illustrated by Pauline Baynes, with American editions from Macmillan in which Lewis made small changes; they have sold well over a hundred million copies in some forty-seven languages and are, by a long way, the most read books he wrote. The writing order differs from both the publication order and the internal chronology: The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe was finished by the end of March 1949, Prince Caspian after Christmas 1949, The Voyage of the Dawn Treader in February 1950, The Horse and His Boy by the end of July 1950, The Silver Chair in March 1951, The Last Battle in March 1953, and The Magician’s Nephew, begun in 1949 and twice abandoned, in February 1954. The dedications map the Inklings’ families and Lewis’s later household: Lucy Barfield, Mary Clare Havard, Geoffrey Barfield, Nicholas Hardie, David and Douglas Gresham, the Kilmer family. Lewis told the story of their genesis three times. In 1956 he denied that he had begun “by asking myself how I could say something about Christianity to children”, “then fixed on the fairy tale as an instrument, then collected information about child psychology”, “then drew up a list of basic Christian truths and hammered out ‘allegories’ to embody them” — “This is all pure moonshine. I couldn’t write in that way. It all began with images; a faun carrying an umbrella, a queen on a sledge, a magnificent lion. At first there wasn’t anything Christian about them; that element pushed itself in of its own accord.” The faun with the umbrella he had had in his head since he was sixteen; the lion came, he said, from dreams: “I’d been having strange dreams about lions when I began writing the work.” The whole scheme he set out for a child in 1961: “The Magician’s Nephew tells the Creation and how evil entered Narnia. The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe the Crucifixion and Resurrection. Prince Caspian restoration of the true religion after corruption. The Horse and His Boy the calling and conversion of a heathen. The Voyage of the ‘Dawn Treader’ the spiritual life (specially in Reepicheep). The Silver Chair the continuing war with the powers of darkness. The Last Battle the coming of the Antichrist (the Ape), the end of the world and the Last Judgement.” But the books are not allegory. “If Aslan represented the immaterial Deity in the same way in which Giant Despair … represents despair, he would be an allegorical figure. In reality, however, he is an invention giving an imaginary answer to the question, … ‘What might Christ become like if there really were a world like Narnia, and He chose to be incarnate … and die and rise again in that world as He actually has done in ours?’ This is not allegory at all.” The name Aslan is “the Turkish for Lion”.76
Two questions of reading hang over the series. The first is order: the books have been numbered since 1994 in the order of Narnian chronology, on the strength of a single letter to an American boy in 1957 — “I think I agree with your order for reading the books more than with your mother’s. The series was not planned beforehand as she thinks. When I wrote The Lion I did not know I was going to write any more. … So perhaps it does not matter very much in which order anyone read them” — against which Paul Ford writes that “Most scholars disagree with this decision and find it the least faithful to Lewis’s deepest intentions”, and almost all critics prefer the order of publication. The second is Michael Ward’s thesis, announced in 2003 and argued in Planet Narnia (2008), that Lewis “secretly constructed the Chronicles of Narnia out of the imagery associated with the seven heavens of the medieval cosmos”, one planet to a book: Jupiter for The Lion (kingship, the passing of winter, festivity), Mars for Prince Caspian (war, and Mars Silvanus of the woods), Sol for The Dawn Treader (gold, light, the dragon the sun’s influence kills), Luna for The Silver Chair (silver, water, wandering and lunacy), Mercury for The Horse and His Boy (speed, speech, twins), Venus for The Magician’s Nephew (fertility, the apple, the morning star) and Saturn for The Last Battle (age, cold, time, disaster). Ward’s evidence is the 1935 poem “The Planets”, whose Jupiter brings winter passed, “guilt forgiven, and good fortune” and “The lion-hearted”; The Discarded Image; the descent of the gods in That Hideous Strength; and Lewis’s own doctrine, in the paper on “the kappa element in romance” (1940, revised as “On Stories”), that what a story is about is a pervading atmosphere rather than its plot, which a reader enjoys without contemplating. The thesis won the Mythopoeic Scholarship Award in 2011; Ford found the claim that Lewis intended an embodiment of medieval astrology implausible, a quantitative study of the planetary vocabulary found support above chance for the four middle books and none for the first two and the last, and Ward has shown a real planetary colouring, strongest in the middle of the series, without proving that Lewis began with the scheme. What is beyond dispute is that Lewis treated the seven planets as “spiritual symbols” of “permanent value”, and that the Chronicles were written by the man who said so.77
Narnian magic is of the fairy-tale kind, and the books draw the line between it and the occult with some care. Good magic is either Aslan’s own — the song that makes a world, the Deeper Magic, the breath that unfreezes statues — or a craft exercised under his authority by beings who are not human, like Coriakin the star, who keeps a book of spells but has been set to rule the Duffers, the foolish dwarf-folk of his island, as a penance. Bad magic is human or demonic will seeking power: Uncle Andrew’s, learned from “some devilish queer people”; Jadis’s Deplorable Word, learned “in a secret place” at “a terrible price”; the Hag’s necromancy in Prince Caspian, “Black sorcery and the calling up of an accursed ghost”; the Green Witch’s enchantment by incense, music and suggestion; the Ape’s manufactured god. The rule is given in The Magician’s Nephew: “Uncle Andrew, you see, was working with things he did not really understand; most magicians are.”78
The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe (1950)#
At a glance. London: Geoffrey Bles, 16 October 1950; New York: Macmillan, 1950. Seventeen chapters. The dedication, adapted from a letter to his goddaughter, reads: “My Dear Lucy, I wrote this story for you, but when I began it I had not realized that girls grow quicker than books. As a result, you are already too old for fairy tales, and by the time it is printed and bound you will be older still. But some day you will be old enough to start reading fairy tales again. You can then take it down from some upper shelf, dust it, and tell me what you think of it. I shall probably be too deaf to hear, and too old to understand a word you say but I shall still be, your affectionate Godfather, C. S. Lewis.” The story grew from the evacuees of 1939 — a first attempt opened “This book is about four children whose names were Ann, Martin, Rose and Peter” and went no further — and was read in part to Roger Lancelyn Green on 10 March 1949, who approved it, suggested the collective title of the series, and recorded Tolkien’s verdict that it really would not do. Ninth in the BBC’s Big Read of 2003.79
Plot. Four children, Peter, Susan, Edmund and Lucy Pevensie, sent from wartime London to the country house of an old Professor, find in a wardrobe a door into a snowy wood by a lamp-post, where Lucy meets the Faun Mr Tumnus, who confesses, weeping, “I’m in the pay of the White Witch. … Why, it is she that has got all Narnia under her thumb. It’s she that makes it always winter. Always winter and never Christmas; think of that!” No time has passed when she returns, and nobody believes her. Edmund follows her on another day, meets the Witch on her sledge, eats her enchanted Turkish Delight, of which “anyone who had once tasted it would want more and more of it”, is promised a kingdom if he will bring the others to her house, and betrays Lucy by denying that Narnia exists: “Just for fun, of course. There’s nothing there really.” The Professor, consulted, astonishes Peter and Susan: “‘Logic!’ said the Professor half to himself. ‘Why don’t they teach logic at these schools? There are only three possibilities. Either your sister is telling lies, or she is mad, or she is telling the truth. You know she doesn’t tell lies and it is obvious she is not mad. For the moment then, and unless any further evidence turns up, we must assume she is telling the truth.’” All four enter Narnia, find Tumnus’s cave wrecked and a warrant for his arrest signed by Maugrim, captain of the Secret Police, in the name of Jadis, Queen of Narnia, and are led by a robin and Mr Beaver to the Beavers’ dam, where they hear that “They say Aslan is on the move — perhaps has already landed”, and “At the name of Aslan each one of the children felt something jump in its inside.” Mr Beaver gives the Witch’s descent — “She comes of your father Adam’s … first wife, her they called Lilith. And she was one of the Jinn. And on the other she comes of the giants. … No, no, there isn’t a drop of real Human blood in the Witch” — and the prophecy, “When Adam’s flesh and Adam’s bone / Sits at Cair Paravel in throne, / The evil time will be over and done”; and when Lucy asks whether Aslan is safe: “Safe? Who said anything about safe? ’Course he isn’t safe. But he’s good. He’s the King, I tell you.” Edmund has slipped away to the Witch’s house, where the courtyard is full of statues and he mocks a stone lion, “Yah! Silly old Aslan! How do you like being a stone?”, and is received with contempt. The Beavers and the three flee towards the Stone Table; the thaw begins; Father Christmas, kept out for a hundred years, arrives with gifts — “I’ve come at last. She has kept me out for a long time, but I have got in at last. … Aslan is on the move. The Witch’s magic is weakening” — a sword and shield for Peter, a bow and horn for Susan, a dagger and a healing cordial for Lucy. They meet Aslan at the Stone Table: “People who have not been in Narnia sometimes think that a thing cannot be good and terrible at the same time.” Peter kills the wolf and is knighted; Aslan’s forces rescue Edmund as the Witch is about to kill him.80
Edmund is forgiven. The Witch comes under safe-conduct to claim him by the Deep Magic, the law of the Emperor-beyond-the-Sea written on the Stone Table and engraved on his sceptre, by which “every traitor belongs to me as my lawful prey” and “for every treachery I have a right to a kill”, and without which “all Narnia will be overturned and perish in fire and water”. Aslan does not deny it — “It is very true; I do not deny it” — rebukes Susan for suggesting he “Work against the Emperor’s magic?”, talks alone with the Witch, and announces that she has renounced the claim. That night Susan and Lucy follow him to the Table and watch, hidden, as the Witch’s rabble bind, shave, muzzle and mock him and she kills him with the stone knife. At dawn the Table cracks and he stands before them alive. “But what does it all mean?” “It means that though the Witch knew the Deep Magic, there is a magic deeper still which she did not know. Her knowledge goes back only to the dawn of time.” Had she looked “into the stillness and the darkness before Time dawned”, “she would have read there a different incantation. She would have known that when a willing victim who had committed no treachery was killed in a traitor’s stead, the Table would crack and Death itself would start working backward.” After a romp he carries the girls to the Witch’s castle, breathes on the statues and restores them, and comes to the battle, where Edmund has broken the Witch’s wand at the cost of a near-mortal wound; Aslan kills the Witch, Lucy’s cordial heals her brother, and the four are crowned at Cair Paravel and reign through a Golden Age until, grown, hunting the White Stag, they come upon the lamp-post — “I know not how it is, but this lamp on the post worketh upon me strangely” — and tumble back through the wardrobe as children, no time having passed. “Once a King in Narnia, always a King in Narnia,” says the Professor. “But don’t go trying to use the same route twice. … It’ll happen when you’re not looking for it.”81
Characters. Aslan, the great Lion, son of the Emperor-beyond-the-Sea, the Christ of Narnia, whose death in a traitor’s stead and rising by the Deeper Magic are the Atonement in Narnian terms; the White Witch, Jadis, descended from Lilith and the Jinn and from the giants, not human, whose hundred-year winter is the reign of death, whose Turkish Delight is the sweetness of addiction and whose statues are a world without grace, and who is also Andersen’s Snow Queen; Peter the High King; Susan the practical and, later, the faithless; Edmund the traitor redeemed; Lucy the seer, whose faith is first and truest; the Professor, Digory Kirke, whose logic vindicates her, revealed in the sixth book as the boy who saw Narnia made; Mr Tumnus; the Beavers; Maugrim; Father Christmas, whose presence Tolkien deplored; the Witch’s Dwarf, Hag, ghouls and wraiths, and Aslan’s fauns, dryads, naiads, centaurs and talking beasts.
Major themes. The breaking of winter by the coming of the king. Betrayal, forgiveness and substitution. The goodness that is not safe. The law that cannot be set aside but can be fulfilled from a deeper law. Two worlds and two times.
Esoteric symbolism. The Stone Table is the altar of the old law, the tables of Moses and the sacrificial stone, which cracks when the sacrifice is complete; the Deep Magic is the law of the Emperor and the Deeper Magic the grace that precedes it “from before the dawn of time” — the two magics being the moral law written on stone and the love that was before it. The mocking and shaving of the lion, the two girls at dawn, the breath that gives life to the dead, the romp and the breakfast are the Passion and Easter. The Witch’s descent from Lilith, Adam’s apocryphal first wife, comes to Lewis by way of MacDonald’s Lilith (1895), and the Jinn are the fire-spirits of Islamic lore; the statues are souls under the dominion of death, the wardrobe the threshold between worlds, the lamp-post the light at the border; and the Professor’s “three possibilities” are the trilemma of Mere Christianity in miniature. In Ward’s scheme the book is Jovial: the king, the passing of winter, guilt forgiven, festivity, the red of Father Christmas, the crowns, the lion-hearted.
Relation to other works. The prequel The Magician’s Nephew explains the lamp-post, the wardrobe and the Witch; the Deeper Magic is the Grand Miracle of Miracles; Andersen, Nesbit, Spenser and Malory stand behind it, and Tolkien’s disapproval beside it.
Reception. Kirkus found “this wily symbolism-studded fantasy should appeal to children of an imaginative turn”, with a plot that “thickens to a pretty heavy pudding at the end”, and added “Not recommended for adults!”; the first critical response was muted, some reviewers finding the Christian machinery heavy and the violence frightening, and the publisher fearing it would not sell. Kathryn Lindskoog’s The Lion of Judah in Never-Never Land (1973) was the first Christian reading; Paul Ford’s Companion to Narnia (1980; 5th edn 2005), Peter Schakel’s Reading with the Heart (1979) and Hooper’s Past Watchful Dragons (1979) the standard guides; Philip Pullman and Polly Toynbee the standard hostile voices.82
Takeaway. The Atonement told as fairy tale: the law is real and the king submits to it, and a deeper law, older than the law, turns death backwards; its esoteric interest lies in the two magics and in the Witch’s non-human lineage from Lilith and the Jinn.
Prince Caspian: The Return to Narnia (1951)#
At a glance. London: Bles, 15 October 1951; fifteen chapters; dedicated to Mary Clare Havard; Lewis’s gloss, “the restoration of the true religion after a corruption”.83
Plot. A year later, waiting on a railway platform, the four are pulled into Narnia (“This is magic — I can tell by the feeling”) and find themselves on an overgrown island whose treasure chamber tells them it is Cair Paravel, centuries after their reign. They rescue a Dwarf, Trumpkin, from two soldiers about to drown him, and he tells the story. Narnia has been conquered by the Telmarines, men from Telmar, whose king Miraz has usurped the throne after murdering his brother; the Talking Beasts, dwarfs, fauns and tree-spirits of Old Narnia have been driven into hiding and their memory suppressed as nursery tales, and Miraz holds that “there’s no such person as Aslan. And there are no such things as lions.” His nephew Caspian, raised on his nurse’s stories, learns from his tutor, the half-dwarf Doctor Cornelius, that “All you have heard about Old Narnia is true. It is not the land of Men. … It is you Telmarines who silenced the beasts and the trees and the fountains … and who killed and drove away the Dwarfs and the Fauns, and are now trying to cover up even the memory of them.” When Miraz’s queen bears a son Caspian must flee with Queen Susan’s horn, which will bring help when blown; in the mountains the badger Trufflehunter and the dwarfs Trumpkin and Nikabrik take him in — “I tell you, we don’t change, we beasts. We don’t forget”; “But who believes in Aslan nowadays?”; “I do. And if I hadn’t believed in him before, I would now” — and he rallies the Old Narnians at the Dancing Lawn and, besieged at Aslan’s How, the mound raised over the Stone Table, blows the horn, which is what has summoned the children. Guided by Trumpkin, a sceptic converted by being beaten at archery and fencing, they make their way up the gorge; Lucy alone sees Aslan beckoning them another way — “Do you think I don’t know Aslan when I see him?” — is outvoted, and they lose a day. That night he calls her. “Aslan,” said Lucy, “you’re bigger.” “That is because you are older, little one,” answered he. “Not because you are?” … “But every year you grow, you will find me bigger.” Would things have gone right had she followed him alone? “To know what would have happened, child?” said Aslan. “No. Nobody is ever told that.” “If they will not, then you at least must follow me alone.” They follow, each coming to see him in turn, Susan last: “I see him now. I’m sorry.” Aslan wakes the trees and the river-god, and with him come Bacchus, Silenus on his donkey and the Maenads, and a wild dance of vines.84
In the How, Peter and Edmund overhear a council. Nikabrik, who has lost one dwarf in five and given up hope of Aslan — “You, you great clerk, you master magician, you know-all; are you still asking us to hang our hopes on Aslan” — has brought two guests, a Hag and a Wer-Wolf, and proposes to call up the one power that really ruled: “A King who has just won a great battle can usually establish himself without the help of a performing lion. … How if we could call them up? … We want power: and we want a power that will be on our side. … They say she ruled for a hundred years: a hundred years of winter. There’s power, if you like. There’s something practical.” “Yes,” said Nikabrik very slowly and distinctly, “I mean the Witch.” To Caspian’s “haven’t we always been told that she was the worst enemy of all?” he answers, “I’m a Dwarf and I stand by my own people. We’re not afraid of the Witch”; to Cornelius’s “The Witch is dead” the Hag replies, “Sweet Master Doctor, learned Master Doctor, who ever heard of a witch that really died? You can always get them back”, and the Wer-Wolf, “I’m hunger. I’m thirst. Where I bite, I hold till I die, … even after death they must cut out my mouthful from my enemy’s body and bury it with me. … I can fast a hundred years and not die.” Cornelius names it: “So that is your plan, Nikabrik! Black sorcery and the calling up of an accursed ghost.” The boys burst in — “Then the light was knocked over and it was all swords, teeth, claws, fists and boots for about sixty seconds. Then silence” — and Nikabrik, the Hag and the Wer-Wolf are dead. Peter challenges Miraz to single combat; Miraz’s lords goad him into accepting in order to betray him; when he trips they stab him and cry treachery, battle is joined, and the woken trees rout the Telmarines while Bacchus and the river-god pull down the bridge at Beruna and the Maenads’ romp frees the schoolchildren and the beasts. Caspian is crowned; Aslan tells the Telmarines’ descent — “Many years ago in that world a shipload of pirates was driven by storm on an island … And in Telmar their descendants lived and became a fierce and proud people” — and answers Caspian’s dismay at coming of pirates: “You come of the Lord Adam and the Lady Eve,” said Aslan. “And that is both honor enough to erect the head of the poorest beggar … and shame enough to bow the shoulders of the greatest emperor on earth.” He sets up three stakes as a doorway in the air, through which the Telmarines who wish return to their island and the children go home; Peter and Susan are told they will not come back.85
Characters. Caspian, the boy prince of the conquering race who restores the conquered; Miraz, the usurper who denies that lions ever existed, the modern unbeliever; Doctor Cornelius, the half-dwarf tutor and astronomer who reads the conjunction of Tarva and Alambil; Trufflehunter, the faithful who do not change; Trumpkin, the honest sceptic; Nikabrik, the embittered partisan for whom any power will do, with his Hag and Wer-Wolf, the book’s necromancers; Reepicheep the Mouse, first met here; Glenstorm the centaur; Bacchus, Silenus and the Maenads, admitted into Aslan’s train; the treacherous lords Glozelle and Sopespian; the four Pevensies, Lucy again the one who sees.
Major themes. Faith under suppression and the erasure of memory. The corruption and restoration of true religion. The hardening of the faithful into fanatics and the temptation to seek power from any source. Obedience to a vision one person has seen. The growth of the knower while the known is unchanged. The Telmarine fear of the sea and the woods, the modern fear of the wild and the sacred.
Esoteric symbolism. The necromancy scene is the Chronicles’ one explicit act of black magic, with its three classic figures — the Hag, the Wer-Wolf that cannot die, and the apostate who summons them — and its classic premise that a witch can always be called back; it is answered not by counter-magic but by swords and by the refusal of Cornelius, the white magician, to touch it. Bacchus, Silenus and the Maenads are the holy wildness of nature restored under Aslan — Lewis’s long argument that the pagan gods are true in so far as they serve the true God — and the river-god is freed from the chain of the bridge; Cornelius’s reading of the planetary conjunction is the one astrological sign in the series; and Lucy’s sight of Aslan against the others’ unbelief, the How raised over the Table, and the door in the air are the Christian layer. Ward’s planet is Mars, the book of war, single combat and sudden vengeance, and Mars Silvanus of the woods.
Relation to other works. The Bacchic dance recalls Perelandra; the necromancy recalls the N.I.C.E.’s plan to wake Merlin; the Lion who grows with the growing child restates “The Weight of Glory”.
Reception. Kirkus thought it “rich fairy-tale fare” and “More coordinated in construction, we think, than the preceding book.”86
Takeaway. A book about keeping faith when the faith has been suppressed and its believers have begun to despair, and about the difference between the true wildness of nature under God and the false power of the summoned dead.
The Voyage of the Dawn Treader (1952)#
At a glance. London: Bles, 15 September 1952; sixteen chapters; dedicated to Geoffrey Barfield, Owen Barfield’s adopted son. Lewis rewrote the end of the Dark Island chapter for the American edition, so that the British and American texts differ until HarperCollins restored the British text in 1994. The form is the Irish immram, the voyage of St Brendan, sailing east instead of west; Lewis’s gloss, “the spiritual life (specially in Reepicheep)”.87
Plot. “There was a boy called Eustace Clarence Scrubb, and he almost deserved it.” Edmund and Lucy, lodged for the summer with their cousin, a priggish child of progressive parents, are drawn with him into a picture of a Narnian ship and hauled aboard the Dawn Treader by King Caspian, sailing east to find the seven lords whom Miraz sent away and, beyond them, Aslan’s country at the world’s end; with him are Drinian the captain and Reepicheep, who carries a Dryad’s prophecy from his cradle: “Where sky and water meet, / Where the waves grow sweet, / Doubt not, Reepicheep, / To find all you seek, / There is the utter East.” At the Lone Islands they are seized by slavers; Caspian, bought by the first of the lords, Bern, deposes the governor Gumpas, who has defended the slave trade as a necessity, and abolishes it. On a dragon’s island Eustace, slipping away from work, finds a dying dragon and its hoard, puts on a gold bracelet, sleeps, and wakes to find “He had turned into a dragon while he was asleep. Sleeping on a dragon’s hoard with greedy, dragonish thoughts in his heart, he had become a dragon himself.” As a dragon, made useful and lonely, he improves; one night “a huge lion coming slowly toward me” — “I wasn’t afraid of it eating me, I was just afraid of it — if you can understand” — leads him to a well and tells him, “You will have to let me undress you”: his own attempts to shed his skin only reveal another skin beneath, the lion’s claws go so deep he thinks they reach his heart, and after the skin is torn off he is thrown into the water and dressed in new clothes. Edmund tells him, “you were only an ass, but I was a traitor”; the bracelet had belonged to the second lord. The ship escapes a sea-serpent (“Don’t fight! Push!”) and comes to a pool that turns everything to gold, in which lies the third lord, and where Caspian and Edmund quarrel over the secret until a glimpse of Aslan recalls them and the place is named Deathwater. On the Island of the Voices invisible beings demand that Lucy go into the magician’s house and read the spell that will make them visible; in the Magician’s Book she is tempted by a spell for beauty beyond the lot of mortals, sees Aslan’s face on the page and turns it, says a spell to know what her friends think of her and hears a friend disparage her, reads a story for the refreshment of the spirit that she can never afterwards remember, and then the spell for making hidden things visible — “I will say the spell. I don’t care. I will” — and “she found the great face of a lion, of The Lion, Aslan himself, staring into hers”: “I have been here all the time, but you have just made me visible.” The magician is Coriakin, a star set to govern the foolish Duffers as a penance, who mends the ship. Into the Dark Island, “where dreams — dreams, do you understand — come to life, come real. Not daydreams: dreams”, the ship sails because Reepicheep insists — “we did not set sail to look for things useful but to seek honor and adventure” — and out of it an albatross leads them when Lucy prays, and “all at once everybody realized that there was nothing to be afraid of and never had been.”88
On the last island they find Aslan’s Table, laid each day by birds, where the remaining three lords sleep enchanted for having quarrelled and touched the Stone Knife with which the Witch killed Aslan, now lying on the table; the island’s lord is Ramandu, a retired star, with his daughter, who tells Caspian, “You can’t know. You can only believe — or not.” “I am a star at rest, my daughter,” answered Ramandu. “Every morning a bird brings me a fire-berry from the valleys in the Sun, and each fire-berry takes away a little of my age”, until he is young enough to rise again and tread the great dance. “In our world,” said Eustace, “a star is a huge ball of flaming gas.” “Even in your world, my son, that is not what a star is but only what it is made of.” The sleepers can be woken only by sailing to the world’s end and leaving one of the company there, and Reepicheep claims the place. In the last sea the water becomes sweet — “That’s real water, that. I’m not sure that it isn’t going to kill me. But it is the death I would have chosen — if I’d known about it till now. … It — it’s like light more than anything else.” “That is what it is. Drinkable light” — the sun grows huge, the Sea People are seen below, and the ship sails over a sea of lilies to a standing wave at the sky’s edge beyond which lies Aslan’s country. Reepicheep throws away his sword and paddles his coracle up the wave — “beautifully it rushed up the wave’s side” — and is never seen again in Narnia. The children walk ashore across the shallows and find a Lamb cooking fish: “Come and have breakfast,” said the Lamb in its sweet milky voice. The Lamb becomes Aslan. “Dearest,” said Aslan very gently, “you and your brother will never come back to Narnia. … You are too old, children, … and you must begin to come close to your own world now.” But he is there too: “But there I have another name. You must learn to know me by that name. This was the very reason why you were brought to Narnia, that by knowing me here for a little, you may know me better there.” The way into his country from their world lies across a river, “But do not fear that, for I am the great Bridge Builder.” Caspian marries Ramandu’s daughter; Eustace is found much improved by everyone but his mother.89
Characters. Eustace, the child of the modern world who is dragoned by greed and undragoned by Aslan, Lewis’s clearest image of conversion as death and rebirth; Reepicheep, whose whole life is a quest for Aslan’s country, chivalry become sanctity; Caspian, tempted by gold, by Deathwater and by the wish to go on; Lucy, tempted in the Book by vanity and curiosity; Drinian; the seven lords; Governor Gumpas and the slaver Pug; Coriakin, the star in penance, and the Dufflepuds; Ramandu and his daughter; the Sea People; the Lamb.
Major themes. The voyage as the spiritual life: greed, vanity, pride, dreaming and despair met one by one. Conversion as undragoning. The sweet water. The utter East. Aslan’s other name.
Esoteric symbolism. Ramandu’s sentence is the thesis of The Discarded Image in a line: a star is not what it is made of, and the retired star who grows young by fire from the sun is the Narnian form of the intelligences that move the spheres. The undragoning is baptism — the skin torn off, the plunge, the new clothes, the failure of self-reform before grace; the Lamb cooking fish on the shore is John 21; the sweet water is the water of life; the Stone Knife on Aslan’s Table is the instrument of the Passion laid on the altar; Reepicheep’s passage is the death of a saint. The Magician’s Book — spells for beauty, for knowing what others think, for refreshment, for making the hidden visible — is Lewis’s one sustained picture of a grimoire, and its lesson is that the user is watched; the Dark Island is the place where the lust of the dreaming mind becomes real, the nightmare side of the Christina Dream of Dymer; Deathwater is the alchemical temptation reversed, gold as death. Ward’s planet is Sol: gold, light, the dragon that the sun’s influence kills, the fire-berries, the stars who are persons.
Relation to other works. The Navigatio Brendani and the Odyssey; Spenser’s Phaedria; the living stars of the trilogy; The Silver Chair as sequel.
Reception. Boucher and McComas in The Magazine of Fantasy and Science Fiction found it “not quite up to the high level set by previous Narnian adventures” but called Reepicheep “one of Lewis’s finest imaginings”.90
Takeaway. The book that turns the Chronicles from war to pilgrimage: its villains are the voyagers’ own sins, its climax is a conversion, and its last page says what the series is for.
The Silver Chair (1953)#
At a glance. London: Bles, 7 September 1953; sixteen chapters; dedicated to Nicholas Hardie, son of the Inkling Colin Hardie; Lewis’s gloss, “the continuing war with the powers of darkness”.91
Plot. “This is not going to be a school story.” At Experiment House, a progressive co-educational school where bullies are “interesting psychological cases”, Jill Pole is found crying by Eustace Scrubb, who tells her of Narnia and proposes that they call on Aslan. Through a door in the wall they come not into Narnia but into Aslan’s country, a high mountain; Jill, showing off at a cliff’s edge, causes Eustace to fall, and a lion blows him away to Narnia. Left thirsty, she finds a stream guarded by the Lion. “Do you eat girls?” “I have swallowed up girls and boys, women and men, kings and emperors, cities and realms.” “Human Child. Where is the Boy?” “I was showing off, Sir.” “That is a very good answer, Human Child. Do so no more. … I have blown him to Narnia. But your task will be the harder because of what you have done.” The task is to find Prince Rilian, King Caspian’s lost son, by four Signs to be repeated morning and night: “The first step is to remember.” Blown to Narnia, she finds that the old man embarking at Cair Paravel to seek Aslan’s counsel is Caspian himself, seventy years older, whom Eustace has not recognised, and the first Sign is muffed. A parliament of owls tells the story — the queen killed by a great green serpent, Rilian bewitched by a lady in green while hunting it and vanished ten years since — and sends them to the Marsh-wiggle Puddleglum, whose gloom is the book’s comic engine: “I know these expeditions usually end that way: knifing one another, I shouldn’t wonder, before all’s done.” North across Ettinsmoor they meet a silent knight in black and a lady in green, “lovelier still”, who sends them to the giants of Harfang for the Autumn Feast, “two fair Southern children” from “She of the Green Kirtle”; lured by thoughts of baths and beds, “They never talked about Aslan, or even about the lost prince, now”, they struggle through a ruined city in a snowstorm, and only from Harfang’s window see that the trenches they crossed were letters, “the words UNDER ME”, the third Sign, which they have failed to obey. At Harfang they learn from the cookbook that they are to be eaten and that they have eaten a Talking Stag. They escape into a hole under the ruined city and fall into Underland, where an Earthman takes them across the Sunless Sea — “Many fall down, and few return to the sunlit lands. … Her will is not to be questioned but obeyed” — past the sleeping Father Time and the great beasts that “will all wake at the end of the world”. In the Queen’s city a young knight praises his Lady as “a nosegay of all virtues, as truth, mercy, constancy, gentleness, courage, and the rest”, explains that he must be bound each night in a silver chair during an hour of frenzy, and laughs at the plan by which she will make him king of a conquered Narnia. Bound, he begs them in the name of everything, and last in Aslan’s: “By all fears and all loves, by the bright skies of Overland, by the great Lion, by Aslan himself, I charge you —” “It’s the sign.” They cut his bonds; he destroys the chair and is Rilian, in his right mind.92
The Queen returns, throws a green powder on the fire, thrums a mandolin, and argues them out of the upper world: there is no sun, only a lamp they have enlarged in fancy; no Aslan, only a bigger cat; no Narnia; her pit is the only world. Puddleglum stamps out the fire with his bare webbed feet and answers her. “All you’ve been saying is quite right, I shouldn’t wonder. … Suppose we have only dreamed, or made up, all those things — trees and grass and sun and moon and stars and Aslan himself. Suppose we have. Then all I can say is that, in that case, the made-up things seem a good deal more important than the real ones. Suppose this black pit of a kingdom of yours is the only world. Well, it strikes me as a pretty poor one. … We’re just babies making up a game, if you’re right. But four babies playing a game can make a play-world which licks your real world hollow. That’s why I’m going to stand by the play-world. I’m on Aslan’s side even if there isn’t any Aslan to lead it. I’m going to live as like a Narnian as I can even if there isn’t any Narnia.” The Queen turns into the great green serpent and is killed; her enchantment broken, the Earthmen rejoice and return to their fiery country of Bism in the deeps; Rilian is tempted to see the bottom of the world and recalled to duty; the Underland floods, and they dig upward into a Narnian dance on a snowy night. At Cair Paravel the ship returns with the dying king, who embraces his son and dies: “Then suddenly the King’s head fell back upon his pillows, the musicians stopped and there was a dead silence.” Aslan takes Jill and Eustace back to his mountain, where the dead Caspian lies in the stream, and commands Eustace to drive a thorn into his paw: “And there came out a great drop of blood, redder than all redness that you have ever seen or imagined. And it splashed into the stream over the dead body of the King … and suddenly he leaped up and stood before them — a very young man, or a boy.” Caspian, in Aslan’s country, is allowed five minutes in the children’s world, where with the Lion’s roar and a few blows the bullies of Experiment House are routed.93
Characters. Jill Pole, whose failures to remember the Signs are the book’s spine; Eustace, reformed; Puddleglum the Marsh-wiggle, the book’s hero, pessimist and teetotaller, who makes the wager of faith, and whom Lewis is said to have modelled on his gardener Paxford; Rilian, the enchanted knight; the Lady of the Green Kirtle, the Queen of Underland, the serpent-witch, a northern witch like Jadis but not the same; Caspian, old, bereaved, dying and young again; Glimfeather and the owls; Trumpkin the regent; the giants of Harfang; the Warden of the Marches and the gloomy Earthmen; Father Time asleep.
Major themes. Obedience to remembered Signs against the pull of comfort and the fog of enchantment. The wager of faith when the arguments cannot be answered. Bondage and madness as the devil’s picture of sanity. Death and renewal.
Esoteric symbolism. The enchantment scene is Plato’s cave turned upside down: the Queen’s argument that sun and lion are only lamp and cat enlarged is the cave-dwellers’ account of the world above, and Puddleglum’s answer, that the shadows cannot have produced the thing they shadow and that he will live for the upper world whether or not it exists, is the philosopher’s refusal to go back to the shadows; her instruments — the sweet green incense, the thrumming, the soothing voice — are the classic apparatus of enchantment and of the reductive argument alike. The Signs are the commandments to be remembered morning and evening; the serpent is the old serpent; the king renewed by a drop of the Lion’s blood is the resurrection of the body shown plainly; the green witch is Lamia and Spenser’s enchantresses; the Underworld with its sleeping Time and its fiery deeps where gems are alive is a cosmology of layered worlds within the earth. Ward’s planet is Luna: the silver of the chair, the sunless water, wandering and forgetting, the lunacy of the nightly frenzy, and the moon as the boundary between the world of change and the changeless heavens.
Relation to other works. Republic VII; Spenser’s Duessa; Keats’s Lamia; MacDonald’s goblins underground; The Last Battle, where Jill, Eustace and Puddleglum return and Plato is named.
Reception. Kirkus: “English fantasy we hope some young Americans may fancy.” Puddleglum’s speech has been much discussed as a form of Pascal’s wager and of the argument from desire.94
Takeaway. The Chronicles’ most philosophical book: an enchantment by argument broken by a stamped-out fire and a confession of faith that does not depend on the argument’s outcome.
The Horse and His Boy (1954)#
At a glance. London: Bles, 6 September 1954; fifteen chapters; dedicated “To David and Douglas Gresham”; set in the Golden Age of the four Pevensie monarchs, inside the last chapter of the first book, and the only Chronicle in which no child from our world is a protagonist; Lewis’s gloss, “the calling and conversion of a heathen”.95
Plot. Shasta, a fair-haired boy raised by a fisherman on the shore of Calormen, the great southern empire, overhears a lord bargaining to buy him as a slave, learns that he was found as a baby in a boat, and hears the lord’s war-horse speak: “I wish you could talk, old fellow.” “But I can.” He is Bree, a Talking Horse of Narnia stolen as a foal, and the two flee north. Driven together by lions on the road, they fall in with Aravis, a Tarkheena fleeing a forced marriage to the aged Grand Vizier, and her mare Hwin (“And what business is it of yours if I am only a girl?”); Aravis, telling her story in the high Calormene manner, admits to having drugged a slave-girl to make her escape. At Tashbaan, the capital on its island between two streams, they are separated: Shasta is seized by visiting Narnians, King Edmund and Queen Susan among them, who take him for the Archenlandish prince Corin, and overhears their plan to flee the city because the Tisroc’s son Rabadash means to force Susan to marry him; the real Corin climbs in at the window and Shasta slips out to wait at the Tombs beyond the city, where a great cat keeps him company through a night of terror. Aravis, hidden in the palace, overhears the Tisroc, Rabadash and the Vizier plot a surprise attack on Archenland and Narnia. Reunited, the four cross the desert in a race against Rabadash’s cavalry; a lion chases them to the hermitage of the Hermit of the Southern March, wounding Aravis’s back, and Shasta runs on alone to warn King Lune — “If you run now, without a moment’s rest, you will still be in time to warn King Lune.” The Hermit, who sees the battle in his pool, tells the others, “I have now lived a hundred and nine winters in this world and have never yet met any such thing as Luck.” Shasta, having warned Lune, loses the party in fog and rides over the pass into Narnia alone, and in the dark finds something walking beside him; he pours out his sorrows, and the Voice, asked who it is, answers Myself, three times, deep and low so that the earth shakes, then loud and clear and gay, then in a whisper all round him. “I was the lion who forced you to join with Aravis. I was the cat who comforted you among the houses of the dead. I was the lion who drove the jackals from you while you slept. I was the lion who gave the horses the new strength of fear for the last mile so that you should reach King Lune in time. And I was the lion you do not remember who pushed the boat in which you lay, a child near death, … so that it came to shore where a man sat, wakeful at midnight, to receive you.” Why did he wound Aravis? He is being told his own story, and no one else’s. “Was it all a dream?” wondered Shasta — but the print of a huge paw is filling with water. In Narnia he raises the alarm; Rabadash’s assault on Anvard is broken; Shasta is revealed as Cor, elder twin of Corin, kidnapped in infancy because of a prophecy that “A day will come when that boy will save Archenland from the deadliest danger in which ever she lay”, and heir of King Lune. At the hermitage Aslan comes to Bree, who has been lecturing Aravis on the impossibility of Aslan’s being a real lion: “Aslan,” said Bree in a shaken voice, “I’m afraid I must be rather a fool.” “Touch me. Smell me. Here are my paws, here is my tail, these are my whiskers. I am a true Beast.” To Aravis: “Draw near, Aravis my daughter. See! My paws are velveted. You will not be torn this time”; the scratches on her back were “tear for tear, throb for throb, blood for blood” the stripes laid on the slave-girl she drugged; and when she asks what became of the girl, “No one is told any story but their own.” Rabadash, captured and refusing mercy, insults Aslan and is turned into a donkey, to be healed only in the temple of Tash, “if ever you go more than ten miles away from the great temple in Tashbaan you shall instantly become again as you now are”, so that Rabadash the Ridiculous reigns as the most peaceable of Tisrocs. Cor and Aravis quarrel, marry and reign; “Bree and Hwin lived happily to a great age in Narnia and both got married but not to one another.”96
Characters. Shasta, Cor of Archenland, the heathen called and converted, whose whole life has been steered by the Lion; Bree, vain of his Narnian breeding and afraid of lions, who learns humility by touching Aslan; Aravis, the proud Calormene girl who learns what her cruelty cost another; Hwin, the first to go to Aslan; Corin and King Lune; Rabadash; the Tisroc, the cynical autocrat, and his vizier; the Hermit, who denies Luck; Edmund, Susan, Lucy and Mr Tumnus as the Narnian embassy; Tash, the bird-headed god of Calormen, named but not seen.
Major themes. Providence: the clearest statement in Lewis’s fiction that what looks like a chain of misfortunes is one will at work from the beginning. The conversion of a heathen by a presence felt before it is known. Pride humbled in a horse and a girl. The equity of judgement, stripe for stripe. Calormen against the North: slavery, flattery, autocracy and Tash against freedom.
Esoteric symbolism. The Lion who was there all the time under other shapes is providence; the thrice-spoken Myself is the I AM of Exodus; the foundling in the boat is Moses; the hermit at his pool is a seer, and the ass who must be healed in the temple of his own god is Apuleius’s. Calormen is Lewis’s Arabian-Nights East, with its formulae of perpetual life, its viziers, its tales told in the high manner and its god Tash, and has drawn the charge of orientalism. Ward’s planet is Mercury: the messenger’s speed, the twins (Cor and Corin as Castor and Pollux), the word-play of Calormene speech, the separation and reunion of doubles.
Relation to other works. Set inside The Lion; Tash and Calormen return in The Last Battle; Apuleius; the Exodus.
Reception. The book’s reception has been dominated by the orientalism debate (Philip Hensher, Gregg Easterbrook, Laura Miller, with Devin Brown among the defenders), which belongs to the reception of the series as a whole.97
Takeaway. The Chronicle of providence: every lion in the story was the one Lion, and the boy who thought himself the unluckiest in the world was carried, pushed and chased all the way home.
The Magician’s Nephew (1955)#
At a glance. London: The Bodley Head, 2 May 1955; fifteen chapters; dedicated “To the Kilmer family”, the American children with whom Lewis corresponded. Begun in 1949 as the second book, after Green asked how a lamp-post came to be standing in a Narnian wood, abandoned after twenty-six pages (the “Lefay fragment”, in which Digory can talk to trees and animals and his godmother Mrs Lefay sends him to a furniture shop), resumed in 1950, stopped again, and finished in 1954; the sixth published and the first in internal chronology. Lewis’s gloss: “the Creation and how evil entered Narnia”.98
Plot. “This is a story about something that happened long ago when your grandfather was a child”, in the London of Sherlock Holmes and the Bastables. Polly Plummer meets Digory Kirke, brought to live with his Uncle Andrew and Aunt Letty because his father is in India and his mother is dying. Blundering into Uncle Andrew’s forbidden study, they are trapped; he tricks Polly into touching a yellow ring and she vanishes, and then he explains himself to Digory. His godmother, old Mrs Lefay, had been “one of the last mortals in this country who had fairy blood in her”, had been in prison, had “got to dislike ordinary, ignorant people, you understand. I do myself”, and on her deathbed gave him a box from a secret drawer and “made me promise that as soon as she was dead I would burn it, unopened, with certain ceremonies. That promise I did not keep.” His creed is the magician’s: “Men like me, who possess hidden wisdom, are freed from common rules just as we are cut off from common pleasures. Ours, my boy, is a high and lonely destiny” — which Digory translates as “that he thinks he can do anything he likes to get anything he wants”. “The box was Atlantean; it came from the lost island of Atlantis”, for “in the very dawn of time Atlantis was already a great city with palaces and temples and learned men”; Uncle Andrew had learned Magic in general from “some devilish queer people” — “One doesn’t become a magician for nothing” — and found that “The Atlantean box contained something that had been brought from another world when our world was only just beginning”: dust from a world “that could be reached only by Magic”, from which he made yellow rings that send and green rings that return, tried on guinea-pigs, some of which exploded, and, being “the great scholar, the magician, the adept, who is doing the experiment”, too valuable to risk (“No great wisdom can be reached without sacrifice”), has used Polly. Digory takes rings and follows her into the Wood between the Worlds, a warm green drowsy wood of shallow pools where “it seems to be always the same time” and where Polly has nearly forgotten who she is. The narrator corrects the magician: “Uncle Andrew, you see, was working with things he did not really understand; most magicians are” — the rings are not outward and homeward at all; “The stuff in the yellow rings had the power of drawing you into the wood; it was stuff that wanted to get back to its own place, the in-between place”, and the green rings take you out of the wood into any world. Marking their own pool, the children jump into another and come to Charn, a dead city under a dying red sun, “a dead, cold, empty silence”, and in a hall of enthroned figures whose faces grow crueller down the line find a bell and a hammer with a verse — “Make your choice, adventurous Stranger; Strike the bell and bide the danger, Or wonder, till it drives you mad, What would have followed if you had” — which Digory, over Polly’s protest, strikes. The last figure wakes: “I, Jadis, the last Queen, but the Queen of the World.” She tells how she ended her war with her sister by the Deplorable Word, “a word which, if spoken with the proper ceremonies, would destroy all living things except the one who spoke it”, which the ancient kings had sworn never to seek — “But I learned it in a secret place and paid a terrible price to learn it. … Then I spoke the Deplorable Word. A moment later I was the only living thing beneath the sun.” Her ethics are Uncle Andrew’s exactly: “You must learn, child, that what would be wrong for you or for any of the common people is not wrong in a great Queen such as I. The weight of the world is on our shoulders. We must be freed from all rules. Ours is a high and lonely destiny.”99
She seizes the children as they ring themselves home and comes with them to the Wood, where she weakens, and to London, where she does not: a seven-foot giantess who makes Uncle Andrew her slave and sets off in a hansom cab to conquer the world. In the riot at the front door, as she stands on the cab-roof with a wrenched-off lamp-post in her hand, Digory catches her ankle and Polly’s ring carries all of them — the Witch, Uncle Andrew, the cabby Frank and his horse Strawberry — into the Wood and out again into nothing. In the darkness a voice begins to sing, the stars come out singing, and a sun rises on a new world which a Lion is singing into being: grass, trees, flowers, and the beasts rising out of the ground. “Ever since the song began she had felt that this whole world was filled with a Magic different from hers and stronger. She hated it”; the Witch throws the iron bar at the Lion and flees, and where it falls a lamp-post grows. The Lion chooses pairs of beasts, breathes on them and speaks: “Narnia, Narnia, Narnia, awake. Love. Think. Speak. Be walking trees. Be talking beasts. Be divine waters.” A jackdaw makes the first joke — “You have not made the first joke; you have only been the first joke” — and Uncle Andrew, having decided that a lion cannot sing, hears only roaring: “Now the trouble about trying to make yourself stupider than you really are is that you very often succeed”; the beasts, unable to decide whether he is animal or vegetable, plant him and water him. Aslan, in council, declares: “Evil will come of that evil, but it is still a long way off, and I will see to it that the worst falls upon myself”, and sends Digory, who confesses that he woke the Witch, to undo the harm: to fetch from a garden on a green hill in the Western Wild the seed of a tree “that she will not dare to approach, and that tree will protect Narnia from her for many years”. The cab-horse, winged, carries Digory and Polly west. On the gates of the garden a verse reads: “Come in by the gold gates or not at all, / Take of my fruit for others or forbear, / For those who steal or those who climb my wall / Shall find their heart’s desire and find despair.” The garden is “a happy place but very serious”; as Digory pockets a silver apple he sees the Witch, who has climbed the wall and eaten one, her face deadly white — “It is the apple of youth, the apple of life” — urging him to eat and reign with her, and then to take the apple to his dying mother instead of to the Lion; he refuses, the second temptation nearly breaking him, and flies back. The apple thrown by the river springs up into a tree at once; Frank and his wife are crowned the first King and Queen of Narnia; Uncle Andrew, dug up, is given sleep, “the only gift he is still able to receive”; and Aslan explains the Witch’s whiteness: “That is what happens to those who pluck and eat fruits at the wrong time and in the wrong way. The fruit is good, but they loathe it ever after”; she has won endless life, “But length of days with an evil heart is only length of misery and already she begins to know it. All get what they want; they do not always like it”; a stolen apple would have protected Narnia too, “But it would have done so by making Narnia into another strong and cruel empire like Charn, not the kindly land I mean it to be”, and would have healed Digory’s mother, but not to her joy. “What I give you now will bring joy. It will not, in your world, give endless life, but it will heal. Go. Pluck her an apple from the Tree.” In the Wood he warns of our world: “It is not certain that some wicked one of your race will not find out a secret as evil as the Deplorable Word and use it to destroy all living things”, and “great nations in your world will be ruled by tyrants who care no more for joy and justice and mercy than the Empress Jadis”, and orders the rings buried. In London the apple is given — “And the smell of the Apple of Youth was as if there was a window in the room that opened on Heaven” — and the mother recovers; the core, planted in the garden with the rings buried round it, grows into a tree that moves when there is no wind because it remembers Narnia, and, blown down when Digory is a middle-aged professor, is made into a wardrobe: “That was the beginning of all the comings and goings between Narnia and our world, which you can read of in other books.”100
Characters. Digory Kirke, the magician’s nephew, who rings the bell, brings evil into a new world and is sent to undo it, and whose mother is healed — Lewis’s own childhood, the dying mother and the absent father, under the name of his tutor Kirkpatrick; Polly Plummer; Uncle Andrew Ketterley, the magician, vain, cowardly, a dabbler who thinks the rules are for others, experiments on guinea-pigs and children, and ends a nicer old man who remembers only “a dem fine woman”; Aunt Letty, who is not afraid of the Witch; Mrs Lefay, whose name is Morgan le Fay’s; Jadis, Queen of Charn, the future White Witch; the cabby Frank and his wife Nellie, the first King and Queen, chosen for humility; Strawberry, who becomes Fledge, father of all flying horses; the beasts of the first council; Aslan, creator by song.
Major themes. Creation by music. The entry of evil through curiosity and the temptation of knowledge (the bell, the apple). The ethics of the magician and the tyrant, shown to be identical in the Edwardian dabbler and the Empress of Charn. The Deplorable Word and the warning that our world may find it. The fruit taken rightly and wrongly. The mother’s healing, the one wish Lewis’s own childhood was denied.
Esoteric symbolism. The book is Lewis’s anatomy of the magician. Uncle Andrew has every mark of the late-Victorian occultist — a fairy godmother with a criminal past, a box of Atlantean dust, “certain ceremonies”, experiments on animals, a doctrine of the adept’s exemption from morality, and a complete inability to understand the forces he uses — and the narrator’s “most magicians are” is the series’ verdict on ceremonial magic; his counterpart is Jadis, whose Deplorable Word is the ultimate secret of a decadent magical royalty. Atlantis, “in the very dawn of time” already a city of palaces, temples and learned men, is the Platonic Atlantis of the Timaeus and Critias with its Theosophical afterlife, and the dust comes from another universe altogether. The Wood between the Worlds, a timeless forest of pools each giving on a universe, in which memory and identity fade, is Lewis’s image of the multiverse; Charn’s dying red sun is the entropic end of a world. The creation by song (the morning stars singing together), the beasts rising from the ground, the breath that gives speech and the first council are Genesis; the garden on the hill in the west with its golden gates and its tree, with Jadis climbing the wall as Satan leaps the wall of Eden in Paradise Lost, is Milton; the two temptations and the fruit that always works but not happily if stolen are the Fall refused; the apple is the Hesperidean apple of Venus, Ward’s planet for the book, with its fertility, its laughter and its morning star; and the English tree that remembers its Narnian original is the copy and the Form. The symmetry of Uncle Andrew’s and Jadis’s speeches on their “high and lonely destiny” — the Nietzschean exemption that Lewis saw in the mage and the dictator alike — and Aslan’s warning of tyrants and of “a secret as evil as the Deplorable Word”, read after 1945 as the Bomb, are the book’s politics.
Relation to other works. Prequel to the series, written last but one; the Atlantean box recalls the Atlantis of Merlin’s “Numinor”; Uncle Andrew is a comic Weston and a lesser Frost; Nesbit’s Story of the Amulet lies behind the Edwardian London and the magic that misbehaves; Surprised by Joy behind the dying mother.
Reception. Kirkus: “To all who have followed the adventures in C.S. Lewis’ marvelous land of Narnia, this is a treat … Couched in Lewis’ silvered prose, this is rich reading.” Hooper printed the Lefay fragment in Past Watchful Dragons (1979).101
Takeaway. Narnia’s Genesis and the Chronicles’ treatise on magic: the creator sings, the magician dabbles, the tyrant speaks the word of death, and the fruit is good or terrible according to the manner of its taking.
The Last Battle (1956)#
At a glance. London: The Bodley Head, 4 September 1956; sixteen chapters; no dedication; written in early 1953, before The Magician’s Nephew was finished; the Carnegie Medal for 1956, of which Lewis wrote to Pauline Baynes, “is it not rather ‘our’ medal? I’m sure the illustrations were taken into account as well as the text.” Lewis’s gloss: “the coming of the Antichrist (the Ape), the end of the world and the Last Judgement”.102
Plot. In the last days of Narnia an old clever Ape named Shift, living by Caldron Pool with his dupe the donkey Puzzle, who “never complained, because he knew that Shift was far cleverer than himself”, finds a lion-skin in the pool and dresses Puzzle in it: “If anyone saw you now, they’d think you were Aslan, the Great Lion, himself. … We would set everything right in Narnia.” Rumours reach Tirian, the last of the Kings of Narnia, that Aslan has returned and is felling the holy trees and selling Narnians to Calormen; his friend Jewel the Unicorn doubts (“He’s not a tame lion”), and the centaur Roonwit reports that the stars foretell disaster: “The stars never lie, but Men and Beasts do. … It is all a lie.” Tirian, enraged by the sight of a Talking Horse under the whip, kills two Calormenes and in remorse gives himself up. At Stable Hill the Ape, now in human clothes — “Well, I’m not. I’m a Man. If I look like an Ape, that’s because I’m so very old: hundreds and hundreds of years old” — rules in Aslan’s name, which no one but he may hear: “He’ll tell me what you’ve got to do, and I’ll tell the rest of you. … True freedom means doing what I tell you”; and he answers doubts with the new theology, “Tash and Aslan are only two different names for you know Who” — Tashlan. Tirian cries “He is not a tame lion” and is bound to a tree; at night he prays — “Let me be killed. I ask nothing for myself. But come and save all Narnia” — sees in vision the seven friends of Narnia at dinner in England, and is freed by two of them, Eustace and Jill, who steal Puzzle and the truth of the lion-skin. But the Dwarfs whom they free from Calormene slavery will not believe in any Aslan now: “No more Aslan, no more Kings, no more silly stories about other worlds. … The Dwarfs are for the Dwarfs” — all but Poggin. The eagle brings news that Cair Paravel has fallen and that Roonwit died with the message that “Noble death is a treasure which no one is too poor to buy”; “Narnia is no more,” says Tirian. Tash himself, summoned by the Calormenes’ invocations, passes northward through the wood, a smoke-shape “roughly the shape of a man but it had the head of a bird”. At the night meeting on Stable Hill the Ape and the Calormene captain Rishda, with the cat Ginger, offer the beasts a sight of Tashlan in the stable: Ginger goes in and comes out a dumb beast, shrieking; a young Calormene officer, Emeth, who believes in Tash with all his heart — “gladly would I die a thousand deaths if I might look once on the face of Tash” — goes in and does not come out. Tirian reveals Puzzle, and Rishda turns the trick: “Do you think, because of him that there is no real Tashlan in the stable!” In the last battle Tirian’s handful fight the Calormenes while the Dwarfs shoot both sides, and one by one they are thrown through the stable door.103
Tirian, dragging Rishda in with him, finds not darkness but “strong light”: Tash takes Rishda and is dismissed in Aslan’s name, and Tirian stands before seven Kings and Queens — Peter, Edmund, Lucy, Eustace, Jill, Digory and Polly, but not Susan: “My sister Susan,” answered Peter shortly and gravely, “is no longer a friend of Narnia. … She’s interested in nothing nowadays except nylons and lipstick and invitations.” The stable is a sunlit country, and, Lucy observes, in our world too a stable once held something bigger than the whole world. The Dwarfs, thrown in, sit in a ring and believe themselves in a dark stable; Aslan sets a feast before them and they taste only hay, dirty water and turnips: “We haven’t let anyone take us in.” “They have chosen cunning instead of belief. Their prison is only in their own minds, yet they are in that prison” — so afraid of being taken in that they cannot be taken out. Then Aslan stands at the door and the giant Father Time, waked from his sleep under the hills, blows his horn, and the children watch the end of Narnia: the stars fall as shining people and gather behind them, the dragons eat the forests and die, the sea rises, all the creatures of Narnia stream to the door, and as each looks in Aslan’s face it either loves him and passes to his right or hates him and passes into his shadow to his left; the sun and moon rise together and Time squeezes the sun out like an orange; Peter locks the door on a world of ice and darkness. Aslan calls them further up and further in, and they run westward through a country that proves to be Narnia — the Narnia that was, says the Professor, was only a shadow or copy of this one, which has always existed: “Listen, Peter. When Aslan said you could never go back to Narnia, he meant the Narnia you were thinking of. … It’s all in Plato, all in Plato.” Jewel cries that he has come home at last. There they find Emeth, who tells how he went into the stable to see Tash and met the Lion, who called him son; he protested that he had served Tash all his days, and Aslan answered that all the service he had done to Tash he accounted as done to himself, for “no service which is vile can be done to me, and none which is not vile can be done to him. Therefore if any man swear by Tash and keep his oath for the oath’s sake, it is by me that he has truly sworn”, and, when Emeth confessed that he had sought Tash all his days, that unless his desire had been for Aslan he would not have sought so long and so truly: “For all find what they truly seek.” Puzzle is forgiven — “The Lion bowed down his head and whispered something to Puzzle.” They run up a waterfall into the garden on the green hill, which is larger inside than out — “world within world, Narnia within Narnia”, says Lucy; “Like an onion: except that as you continue to go in and in, each circle is larger than the last”, says Mr Tumnus — and find the real England there too. “We’re so afraid of being sent away, Aslan.” “Have you not guessed? … There was a real railway accident,” said Aslan softly. “Your father and mother and all of you are — as you used to call it in the Shadowlands — dead. The term is over: the holidays have begun. The dream is ended: this is the morning.” “And as He spoke He no longer looked to them like a lion”; “the things that began to happen after that were so great and beautiful that I cannot write them. But for them it was only the beginning of the real story. All their life in this world and all their adventures in Narnia had only been the cover and the title page … now at last they were beginning Chapter One of the Great Story which no one on earth has read … which goes on for ever: in which every chapter is better than the one before.”104
Characters. Tirian, the last King, and Jewel the Unicorn; Shift the Ape, the Antichrist of Narnia in Lewis’s gloss, the false prophet who speaks for a god no one else may see and ends in Tash’s belly; Puzzle, Aesop’s ass in the lion’s skin, forgiven; Ginger the cat, the atheist collaborator who loses speech; Rishda Tarkaan, the cynical user of religion, taken by the god he did not believe in; Tash, the bird-headed four-armed god of Calormen; Emeth (Hebrew truth), the sincere worshipper of Tash received by Aslan, the Chronicles’ statement on implicit faith and the passage most debated by Lewis’s Christian readers; Roonwit the centaur; Poggin and Griffle; Father Time; Susan, absent; and at the end Reepicheep, Caspian, Rilian, Tumnus, the Beavers, King Frank and Queen Helen (the cabby and his Nellie of The Magician’s Nephew), Cor and Aravis, Bree and Hwin.
Major themes. Apocalypse: the false Aslan, the mixing of the true god with his opposite, the collapse of faith into cynicism and into self-protective unbelief, the loyalty of the few, the last battle lost. Judgement: each face looks on Aslan and goes right or left by what it finds there. The Dwarfs who cannot be taken out. Implicit faith. The real world further in. Death as the morning.
Esoteric symbolism. Shift and Puzzle are the false prophet and the beast of Revelation; the stable bigger inside than out is Bethlehem; the door is the judgement of Matthew 25, the sheep and goats to right and left; the feast the Dwarfs cannot taste is the great supper; the stars fall and the lights go out. The ending is the Republic’s divided line and cave run upward: the Narnia that perished was a shadow of the real Narnia, the real England lies within the real Narnia, and each world further in is larger than the last — “It’s all in Plato” — with Dante’s ascent behind it. Emeth is the virtuous pagan of the medieval debates, whom Lewis defended in a letter of 1952 and whom Elissa McCormack treats as the clearest case of inclusivism in his fiction; the Calormene invocation of Tash and his actual arrival are the series’ one admission that a false god may answer; the principle that an oath kept for its own sake is kept to the true god whatever name is used is the Platonism of Mere Christianity’s “good dreams” applied to worship. Ward’s planet is Saturn: old age, cold, disaster, the giant Time with his horn, death and the end of time, and the saturnine darkness before the “long-lost Saturnian years” of Dymer’s last line return.
Relation to other works. It reverses The Magician’s Nephew and ends in the same garden; Father Time of The Silver Chair wakes; The Great Divorce supplies the self-imprisoned, the solid country and the railway; Till We Have Faces, written at the same time, the justice of the gods.
Reception. Floyd C. Gale in Galaxy called it “a delightful fantastic fable of the type which the English have excelled since — or perhaps because of — Lewis Carroll”; the “problem of Susan” (raised by Pullman, Rowling and Gaiman among others) and the Calormenes have been the series’ two standing controversies, and Emeth its standing theological debate.105
Takeaway. Narnia’s apocalypse and its Platonic resolution: the false god, the dark stable and the locked door give way to a country in which every circle is larger than the last, and the Chronicles end by telling their readers that the Great Story has only begun.
Apologetics, Theology and Autobiography#
The Problem of Pain (1940)#
At a glance. London: The Centenary Press (Geoffrey Bles), October 1940, written at the invitation of Ashley Sampson for his “Christian Challenge” series — Lewis had asked to publish anonymously, and “Anonymity was rejected as inconsistent with the series”; New York: Macmillan, 1943. Dedicated “To The Inklings”, the first appearance of the name in print; the epigraph is George MacDonald’s “The Son of God suffered unto the death, not that men might not suffer, but that their sufferings might be like His.” Ten chapters — Introductory; Divine Omnipotence; Divine Goodness; Human Wickedness; The Fall of Man; Human Pain (two chapters); Hell; Animal Pain; Heaven — each with its epigraph, and an appendix on the clinical observation of pain by “R. H.”, Robert Havard, Lewis’s doctor and fellow Inkling. The preface limits the aim: “the only purpose of the book is to solve the intellectual problem raised by suffering”, “for the far higher task of teaching fortitude and patience I was never fool enough to suppose myself qualified”.106
Argument. The first chapter begins where the atheist Lewis had stood — “Not many years ago when I was an atheist” he would have put the case against God from the misery of the universe — and answers the case genetically. Religion did not arise from inferring a good Creator from a pleasant world. “In all developed religion we find three strands or elements, and in Christianity one more. The first of these is what Professor Otto calls the experience of the Numinous”, illustrated by an ascending series: “Suppose you were told there was a tiger in the next room”, and “you would know that you were in danger and would probably feel fear”; then a ghost; then a “mighty spirit”, which produces not fear but awe. “The second strand or element in religion” is the sense of a moral law acknowledged and disobeyed; “The third stage in religious development arises when men identify them”, making the Numinous the guardian of morality, which was the Jews’ achievement; “The fourth strand or element is a historical event”, a man claiming to be, and accepted as, that Power. Pain therefore does not refute religion: Christianity, by asserting a good God, creates the intellectual problem rather than solving it. The second chapter clears the word omnipotence — “nonsense remains nonsense even when we talk it about God”; “His Omnipotence means power to do all that is intrinsically possible, not to do the intrinsically impossible” — and argues that a society of free souls requires a common, stable, neutral field with fixed laws, which necessarily admits of hurting as well as helping. The third defines goodness against kindness — “Love is something more stern and splendid than mere kindness” — and by four analogies of ascending intimacy (the artist and his work, man and dog, father and son, husband and wife) shows that to be loved by God is “the intolerable compliment”: “We are, not metaphorically but in very truth, a Divine work of art, something that God is making”; “Human love, as Plato teaches us, is the child of Poverty”. The fourth revives the sense of sin that kindness and psychoanalysis have dulled: “Christianity now has to preach the diagnosis — in itself very bad news — before it can win a hearing for the cure.” The fifth, on the Fall, is the book’s most characteristic chapter. “Christianity asserts that God is good; that He made all things good and for the sake of their goodness”, and that one good thing, free will, included the possibility of evil; the doctrine is neither monist nor dualist; and where the doctrine is bare Lewis supplies a picture: “I offer the following picture — a ‘myth’ in the Socratic sense, a not unlikely tale. For long centuries God perfected the animal form which was to become the vehicle of humanity and the image of Himself. Then, in the fullness of time, God caused to descend upon this organism” a new kind of consciousness able to say “I”. The Paradisal man ruled his own organism, slept and woke at will, and had God always before him — “We do not know how many of these creatures God made, nor how long they continued in the Paradisal state” — and the first sin, which “has been described by Saint Augustine as the result of Pride”, was the will’s self-preference, whose consequence was the loss of the spirit’s mastery over the organism and a change in human nature itself. The two chapters on human pain hold that pain, being unmistakable evil, is God’s instrument against the illusion that all is well — His megaphone to a deaf world, in the famous phrase — and that it shatters the illusion of self-sufficiency and makes possible the surrender of the self-will, while refusing to make pain a good in itself or a licence to inflict it. The chapter on hell defends it as the consequence of a freedom God will not override, the doors locked on the inside; that on animal pain distinguishes sentience from consciousness and speculates that the animal creation may have been corrupted by a Satanic power before man, and that the higher animals may attain immortality “in” their masters as the master is in Christ. The last chapter, on heaven, gives the doctrine of the secret signature: “Your soul has a curious shape because it is a hollow made to fit a particular swelling in the infinite contours” of the divine substance; “This signature on each soul” is the key to one of the doors in the house of many mansions; the books one loves “are bound together by a secret thread”; and heaven is the place of that fulfilment, whose life is self-giving, the golden apple of selfhood tossed from hand to hand in a dance.107
Major themes. Theodicy from free will and the stable field of nature. The Numinous. Divine love as demand. The Fall as the fall of a species, read mythically. Pain as corrective. Hell as self-chosen. Heaven as individuation and self-giving.
Esoteric relevance. The reconstruction of the Fall is offered as “a ‘myth’ in the Socratic sense”, the eikōs mythos of the Timaeus, and is the clearest instance in the apologetics of the method Lewis theorised elsewhere: where doctrine is bare, the imagination may supply a probable picture. The Paradisal man in whom “the animal form” became “the vehicle of humanity” is the rational soul governing the lower souls of the medieval Model; the opening chapter adopts Otto’s Numinous as the ground of all religion, with the tiger, ghost and spirit as an epistemology of awe, the same ground Lewis later assigns to the pagan gods and daemons; the Fall chapter sets the Christian account between monism and dualism and the chapter on animal pain reintroduces a Satanic corruption of nature before man, the “enemy-occupied territory” of Mere Christianity and the bent Oyarsa of the trilogy; the Phaedo’s body as prison is cited only to be corrected, the Christian ascesis aiming at the body’s remaking rather than its escape; and the secret signature is Lewis’s first statement of the doctrine of individual vocation that connects him with the Neoplatonic notion of the soul’s proper end.
Relation to other works. A Grief Observed is its antitype, theory tested by its author; the Fall-myth is dramatised in Perelandra; the hell chapter is the theory behind The Great Divorce; the megaphone governs Screwtape and Till We Have Faces.
Reception. Edwyn Bevan in The Spectator (25 October 1940) called it a book “which I commend as a really remarkable one”. It made Lewis’s name as an apologist and brought the BBC’s invitation; the philosophical literature on it runs from John Beversluis’s C. S. Lewis and the Search for Rational Religion (1985) to Michael Ward’s chapter “On Suffering” in the Cambridge Companion (2010).108
Takeaway. Lewis’s first work of theology and the template of his manner: plain analysis of terms, confession of personal unbelief as starting-point, and, at the centre, a self-declared myth where argument gives out.
Broadcast Talks (1942), Christian Behaviour (1943), Beyond Personality (1944) and Mere Christianity (1952)#
At a glance. Four series of BBC talks — in August 1941, “Right or Wrong: A Clue to the Meaning of the Universe”; in January–February 1942, “What Christians Believe”; in the autumn of 1942, “Christian Behaviour”; and in February–April 1944, “Beyond Personality” — printed as Broadcast Talks (London: Bles, 1942; in America The Case for Christianity, 1943), Christian Behaviour (Bles, 1943) and Beyond Personality: The Christian Idea of God (Bles, 1944; New York: Macmillan, 1945), and gathered, “revised and amplified”, as Mere Christianity (London: Bles, 7 July 1952), in four Books of five, five, twelve and eleven chapters. The preface explains the title and the position. “Ever since I became a Christian I have thought that the best, perhaps the only, service I could do for my unbelieving neighbours was to explain and defend the belief that has been common to nearly all Christians at all times”; far more, and more talented, authors “were already engaged in such controversial matters than in the defence of what Baxter calls ‘mere’ Christianity”; and the book is a hall, not a room: “It is more like a hall out of which doors open into several rooms”, and “The hall is a place to wait in, a place from which to try the various doors, not a place to live in”, the rooms being the existing communions, to be chosen by asking which doctrine is true and not which one likes.109
Argument. Book I argues from quarrelling, which presupposes a standard both parties know, to the Law of Nature — “they really meant the Law of Human Nature” — answers the objections from herd instinct and convention, shows that the law is not a fact about behaviour since we fail to keep it, and concludes that the moral law is the one piece of inside information we have about the universe, pointing to “a Something which is directing the universe” and then to “a Somebody or Something behind the Moral Law” with whom we are in the wrong. On the way it dismisses the “In between view called Life-Force philosophy, or Creative Evolution, or Emergent Evolution”: “The Life-Force is a sort of tame God”, attractive because “it gives one much of the emotional comfort of believing in God and none of the less pleasant consequences”. Book II divides believers into pantheists and theists — “The first of these views — the one that thinks God beyond good and evil — is called Pantheism”; “Pantheists usually believe that God, so to speak, animates the universe as you animate your body”; “Confronted with a cancer or a slum the Pantheist can say” that from the divine point of view this too is God — and, allowing that “If you are a Christian you do not have to believe that all the other religions are simply wrong all through”, insists that “Christianity is a fighting religion”. “The Invasion” takes Dualism seriously: “Dualism means the belief that there are two equal and independent powers at the back of everything, one of them good and the other bad, and that this universe is the battlefield in which they fight out an endless war. I personally think that next to Christianity Dualism is the manliest and most sensible creed on the market. But it has a catch in it.” The catch is that to call one power good and the other bad invokes a standard above both, and that an evil power must be a spoiled good one: “Goodness is, so to speak, itself: badness is only spoiled goodness”; “I do mean that wickedness, when you examine it, turns out to be the pursuit of some good in the wrong way.” Hence “Christianity agrees with Dualism that this universe is at war. But it does not think this is a war between independent powers. It thinks it is a civil war, a rebellion, and that we are living in a part of the universe occupied by the rebel. Enemy-occupied territory — that is what this world is”; “Christianity thinks this Dark Power was created by God, and was good when he was created, and went wrong”; “Christianity is the story of how the rightful king has landed”. “The Shocking Alternative” traces evil to the pride that Satan “put into the heads of our remote ancestors”, “the idea that they could ‘be like gods’”, and God’s counter-moves — conscience, the good dreams of the pagan myths of a dying and rising god, the Jews — to the man who claimed to forgive sins, with the trilemma: “Either this man was, and is, the Son of God: or else a madman or something worse. … He would either be a lunatic — on a level with the man who says he is a poached egg — or else he would be the Devil of Hell. … Let us not come with any patronising nonsense about His being a great human teacher. He has not left that open to us. He did not intend to.” Book III treats the three concerns of morality, the four cardinal and three theological virtues, social morality, psychoanalysis, sex and marriage, forgiveness, pride (“Pride leads to every other vice: it is the complete anti-God state of mind”), charity, hope (the argument from desire quoted in the Thought section, and “Aim at Heaven and you will get earth ‘thrown in’: aim at earth and you will get neither”) and faith in its two senses. Book IV, the broadcasts of 1944, gives the theology: Bios and Zoe, the sculptor’s shop, the three-personal God, time and eternity, and the Trinity as “a dynamic pulsating activity, a life, a kind of drama, almost, if you will not think me irreverent, a kind of dance”, in which “the living, dynamic activity of love has been going on in God forever and has created everything else”; the Son became man to spread that life by “good infection”, so that “Every Christian is to become a little Christ. The whole purpose of becoming a Christian is simply nothing else”; the toy soldiers made alive; pretending in order to become; counting the cost; the new men. The sentences on “gods and goddesses”, “nice people or new men” and the Next Step have been quoted in the Thought section.110
Major themes. The moral argument. Pantheism, Dualism and the Life-Force refused. The Devil as fallen angel. The trilemma. Pride as the anti-God state. Bios and Zoe; good infection; little Christs; the new men.
Esoteric relevance. Books I and II give the popular form of the genealogy of Miracles: Creative Evolution as “a sort of tame God”, Pantheism as the view that God is “beyond good and evil”, and Dualism treated with respect before the Augustinian privation theory refutes it; the cosmology that replaces them — a rebel angel occupying a province of creation — is the premise of the trilogy and of Screwtape. The “good dreams” of the pagans are the thesis of “Myth Became Fact”. Book IV’s Bios and Zoe, the statue coming to life, the Trinity as a dance and the doctrine that the Christian end is to be taken into the divine life belong to the Christian Platonism Lewis had from Athanasius, whose De Incarnatione he introduced in 1944, from Augustine and from the Theologia Germanica; the dance is the Great Dance of Perelandra, and Baxter’s “mere” Christianity, the hall and not a room, is the key to Lewis’s refusal of every inner ring, ecclesiastical or esoteric.
Reception. The Times Literary Supplement judged that “No writer of popular apologetics today is more effective than Mr. C. S. Lewis”; J. K. Mozley in The Spectator found him “a quite safe guide”; George Marsden’s C. S. Lewis’s Mere Christianity: A Biography (2016) records that the book “has been hated as well as loved”, that it stood 513 consecutive weeks on the American religion bestseller list to 2010, and that it has been translated into some thirty-six languages; the trilemma has been the standing target of its philosophical critics from Beversluis to McGrath, and the philosopher Victor Reppert its standing defender.111
Takeaway. The most widely read work of twentieth-century popular apologetics in English, and the place where Lewis fixed his vocabulary: the Law of Nature, enemy-occupied territory, the Devil as fallen angel, Bios and Zoe, good infection, the new men.
The Abolition of Man (1943)#
At a glance. The Abolition of Man, or Reflections on Education with Special Reference to the Teaching of English in the Upper Forms of Schools: the Riddell Memorial Lectures, delivered at King’s College, Newcastle, on 24–26 February 1943; London: Oxford University Press, 1943; Bles, 1946 (which adds a passage to the second chapter); New York: Macmillan, 1947. Three chapters, “Men without Chests”, “The Way” and “The Abolition of Man”, each with an epigraph — the first two from the Analects (“The Master said, He who sets to work on a different strand destroys the whole fabric”; “It is upon the Trunk that a gentleman works”), the third from Bunyan (“It came burning hot into my mind, whatever he said and however he flattered, when he got me home to his house, he would sell me for a slave”) — and the appendix “Illustrations of the Tao”. Lewis thought the book “almost totally ignored”; it has since stood seventh in the National Review’s hundred best non-fiction books of the century.112
Argument. The first lecture starts from an elementary English textbook, the “Green Book” of “Gaius and Titius” (Alexander King and Martin Ketley’s The Control of Language, 1939), which teaches under cover of grammar that a statement like Coleridge’s “the waterfall is sublime” is only a statement about the speaker’s feelings, and that such statements are unimportant. The authors have smuggled in a philosophy; its effect is to debunk every sentiment; and the old doctrine, from Plato and Aristotle through Augustine — “St Augustine defines virtue as ordo amoris, the ordinate condition of the affections in which every object is accorded that kind of degree of love which is appropriate to it” — to the Confucian and Hindu traditions, held the opposite: “It is the doctrine of objective value, the belief that certain attitudes are really true, and others really false, to the kind of thing the universe is and the kind of things we are.” Education in this tradition trains the emotions to conform to the objective order — “The task of the modern educator is not to cut down jungles but to irrigate deserts” — because “Without the aid of trained emotions the intellect is powerless against the animal organism”, and “The head rules the belly through the chest”. The new education produces men without chests and then demands what only the chest supplies: “In a sort of ghastly simplicity we remove the organ and demand the function. We make men without chests and expect of them virtue and enterprise. We laugh at honour and are shocked to find traitors in our midst. We castrate and bid the geldings be fruitful.” The second lecture asks where the debunkers get the values they still want to produce, names the common tradition — “This conception in all its forms, Platonic, Aristotelian, Stoic, Christian, and Oriental alike, I shall henceforth refer to for brevity simply as ‘the Tao’” — and shows that every attempt to ground value on instinct, on the survival of the species or on utility borrows its premises from the Tao, since no “ought” follows from facts about instincts or consequences: “The rebellion of new ideologies against the Tao is a rebellion of the branches against the tree”, and “Only the Tao provides a common human law of action which can over-arch rulers and ruled alike”. The third lecture follows the conquest of nature to its end — “What we call Man’s power over Nature turns out to be a power exercised by some men over other men with Nature as its instrument”; “The Conditioners, then, are to choose what kind of artificial Tao they will, for their own good reasons, produce in the Human race”; “It is not that they are bad men. They are not men at all”; “Man’s final conquest has proved to be the abolition of Man”; “We have been trying, like Lear, to have it both ways” — and then, in the passage quoted in the Thought section, sets the new science beside the magic that was its twin, adding Bacon and Faustus — “It is not truth he wants from the devils, but gold and guns and girls”; “He rejects magic because it does not work; but his goal is that of the magician”; “The true object is to extend Man’s power to the performance of all things possible” — and the readiness of both “to do things hitherto regarded as disgusting and impious — such as digging up and mutilating the dead”. Lewis asks whether a regenerate science is conceivable — “Is it, then, possible to imagine a new Natural Philosophy, continually conscious that the ‘natural object’ produced by analysis and abstraction is not reality but only a view, and always correcting the abstraction?”; “When it explained it would not explain away” — and ends on the self-destruction of debunking: “You cannot go on ‘explaining away’ for ever: you will find that you have explained explanation itself away. … But a wholly transparent world is an invisible world. To ‘see through’ all things is the same as not to see.” The appendix collects “illustrations of the Natural Law … from such sources as come readily to the hand of one who is not a professional historian” under eight heads — general beneficence, special beneficence, duties to parents and ancestors, duties to children and posterity, justice, good faith and veracity, mercy, magnanimity — from the Analects (“Never do to others what you would not like them to do to you”), the Egyptian Book of the Dead, Babylonian hymns, the Old Norse poems, the Laws of Manu, Cicero, Epictetus, Locke and both Testaments.113
Major themes. Objective value. The education of the sentiments. Head, chest and belly. The Tao as natural law common to all traditions. No ought from is. The Conditioners. Magic and science as twins. Regenerate science. The self-refutation of total debunking.
Esoteric relevance. This is the central text for Lewis’s account of magic and science. The Tao, taken in the Confucian sense of the Way as a code rather than the Taoist sense of the Whole (Charles Gore’s Philosophy of the Good Life, read in January 1940, may have supplied the term), makes “Platonic, Aristotelian, Stoic, Christian, and Oriental” ethics one philosophia perennis of conduct, with the Hindu Rta and the Chinese Tao as names for the same thing. The thesis that the magia of the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries and the new science were twins “born of the same impulse” — the will to “subdue reality to the wishes of men” by “a technique”, against the older aim of conforming the soul to reality — is the historian’s position Lewis restated in the Oxford History and dramatised at Belbury; its dating (“very little magic in the Middle Ages: the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries are the high noon of magic”) rests on his own reading of Ficino, Pico, Agrippa and Paracelsus, and it anticipates, and in its moral reading partly contradicts, the Warburg account, for which the magus is also a contemplative. The Conditioners are a priesthood outside the Tao, the magician’s motive of power in place of the Tao’s rule: Lewis’s typology of the sorcerer. The hope for a natural philosophy that “would not explain away” is a Goethean and Barfieldian note; and Alanus’s chest as the seat of magnanimity ties the lectures to the medieval Model.
Relation to other works. That Hideous Strength is, by its author’s preface, the same point as a story; “The Poison of Subjectivism” (1943) and “On Ethics” restate the argument; the Oxford History and “The Empty Universe” (1952) carry the thesis of the twins; I. A. Richards, criticised here, returns in Studies in Words.
Reception. B. F. Skinner replied in Beyond Freedom and Dignity (1971) that man was indeed being abolished, and approved; Ayn Rand’s hostile marginalia have been transcribed; Michael Ward’s After Humanity (2021) is the full commentary, the Dutch annotator Arend Smilde’s summary and notes the most detailed annotation, and the essays in Contemporary Perspectives on C. S. Lewis’s The Abolition of Man (2017) and Dyer and Watson’s C. S. Lewis on Politics and the Natural Law (2016) the recent scholarship.114
Takeaway. Lewis’s most durable philosophical essay: a defence of objective value by way of the education of sentiment, closing in a prophecy of technocratic conditioning and a historical thesis on the common root of magic and modern science.
Miracles: A Preliminary Study (1947; Revised 1960)#
At a glance. London: Bles (The Centenary Press), May 1947; New York: Macmillan, 1947; revised Fontana paperback, 1960, with the third chapter rewritten. Dedicated “To Cecil and Daphne Harwood” — Harwood the anthroposophist friend of the “Great War” with Barfield — with an epigraph from Aristotle’s Metaphysics, “Those who wish to succeed must ask the right preliminary questions”, and chapter-epigraphs from I. A. Richards, Collingwood, Niebuhr, Bunyan and Charles Williams among others. Seventeen chapters and two appendices: the naturalist and the supernaturalist; the self-contradiction of the naturalist (retitled in 1960 “The Cardinal Difficulty of Naturalism”); nature and supernature; answers to misgivings; red herrings; miracle and the laws of nature; nature as a creature; “Horrid Red Things”; Christianity and “Religion”; the propriety and probability of miracles; the Grand Miracle; miracles of the old and of the new creation; an epilogue; and appendices on the words “spirit” and “spiritual” and on special providences.115
Argument. “This book is intended as a preliminary to historical inquiry”: whether miracles happen cannot be settled by experience, since “Seeing is not believing” and “What we learn from experience depends on the kind of philosophy we bring to experience” — “If anything extraordinary seems to have happened, we can always say that we have been the victims of an illusion. If we hold a philosophy which excludes the supernatural, this is what we always shall say.” The Naturalist believes that nothing exists but Nature, the total interlocked system; the Supernaturalist that one thing exists on its own and produced the system; and both agree “that there must be something which exists in its own right; some basic Fact whose existence it would be nonsensical to try to explain because this Fact is itself the ground or starting-point of all explanations”. The third chapter is the argument from reason. “For by Naturalism we mean the doctrine that only Nature — the whole interlocked system — exists”; but naturalism must account for human reasoning as the product of non-rational causes, and “no account of the universe can be true unless that account leaves it possible for our thinking to be a real insight. A theory which explained everything else in the whole universe but which made it impossible to believe that our thinking was valid, would be utterly out of court”; in the 1947 wording, “We may in fact state it as a rule that no thought is valid if it can be fully explained as the result of irrational causes.” It was this formulation that Elizabeth Anscombe attacked at the Socratic Club on 2 February 1948, arguing that Lewis had confused “irrational” causes with “non-rational” ones and asking, of his “valid”, “Isn’t this question about the validity of reasoning a question about the validity of valid reasoning?” For the 1960 edition Lewis kept the chapter’s first six paragraphs, replaced the remaining ten with twenty-five new ones, changed “irrational” to “non-rational”, cut “valid” from eighteen occurrences to six, and grounded the conclusion on the two senses of “because” — the because of cause and effect and the because of ground and consequent — holding that “The validity of thought is central: all other things have to be fitted in round it as best they can”; Anscombe later wrote that the rewrite showed “honesty and seriousness”, and Smilde’s verdict is that Lewis “fully maintained his original position”. The fourth chapter draws the conclusion: “rational thought or Reason is not interlocked with the great interlocking system of irrational events which we call Nature”; “We are interested in Man only because his rationality is the little tell-tale rift in Nature which shows that there is something beyond or behind her”; “The rational and moral element in each human mind is a point of force from the Supernatural working its way into Nature.” The middle chapters clear away misgivings and red herrings, define a miracle — “A miracle is emphatically not an event without cause or without results”; the laws of nature say what happens “provided nothing interferes”, and a miracle once fed into nature is digested by her laws — and sing the praise of Nature as a creature, who, once she is not God, can be loved as the astonishing, humorous, fecund thing she is. “Horrid Red Things” argues from the child who thought poison was horrid red things, wrong in image but right in thought, that crude mental pictures do not discredit a doctrine. “Christianity and ‘Religion’” diagnoses the “minimal religion” of the modern pantheist, in which the anthropomorphic attributes drop off one by one until God is a spiritual force, as the permanent natural bent of the human mind, found in the Stoics, in Bruno and Spinoza, in Hegel, in Wordsworth, Carlyle and Emerson, in Theosophy and in the worship of the Life-Force, and sets against it the “I AM” of Scripture, the concrete and particular. “The Grand Miracle” reads the Incarnation as the pattern of all nature — descent and re-ascent, death and rebirth, the corn-king and the vegetation gods as anticipations, the selectiveness of nature and of election, vicariousness, and the principle that nothing is merely a by-product — and the last chapters sort the miracles of the Gospels into those of the old creation, which do locally what the Father does universally, and those of the new, which anticipate the redeemed nature. The first appendix distinguishes the senses of “spirit”: the rational soul, the supernatural element in man, the Holy Spirit, and the Pauline “spiritual” as opposed to “carnal”.116
Major themes. Naturalism and supernaturalism. The argument from reason. Nature as a creature. Image and thought. Pantheism as the natural religion of the mind. The Grand Miracle and the pattern of death and rebirth. The new Nature.
Esoteric relevance. The eleventh chapter is Lewis’s most explicit genealogy of the “spiritual” religion of modernity — Stoicism, Bruno, Spinoza, German Idealism, Transcendentalism, Theosophy and the Life-Force — as the mind’s permanent gravitational pull, against which the God who names himself is the scandal; it is the apologetic counterpart of his own passage through the occult and Absolute Idealism. The fourteenth gives “Myth Became Fact” its cosmological form, with Adonis, Osiris and Balder as good dreams; the ninth gives the counter-Romantic doctrine that nature’s beauty follows from her being made, which governs the planetary “nature” of the Ransom books; the first appendix is the key to the angelology of the fiction; and the argument from reason is the Platonic and Augustinian doctrine that reason participates in an eternal Reason, which Lewis had first stated in “Bulverism” (1941) and in the language of Idealism.
Reception. C. E. Raven in The Spectator (16 May 1947) found that “On his own confession, he has not made up his mind about Nature, and consequently is inconsistent in his thinking”, which was “indeed the real weakness of his whole treatment of the subject”, though there was “less intrusion of his own speculative ideas than in his earlier writings”; the argument from reason became, through Victor Reppert’s C. S. Lewis’s Dangerous Idea (2003), William Hasker and Alvin Plantinga, a live argument in analytic philosophy of religion.117
Takeaway. Lewis’s one sustained work of philosophical theology, whose argument that naturalism undermines the validity of reason was revised but not abandoned after Anscombe.
Transposition and Other Addresses (1949) and the Wartime Sermons#
At a glance. London: Bles, 1949; in America The Weight of Glory and Other Addresses (New York: Macmillan, 1949), enlarged in 1980 with “Is Theology Poetry?”, “On Forgiveness”, “A Slip of the Tongue” and the expanded “Transposition”. “This book contains a selection of the too numerous addresses which I was induced to give during the late war”, says the preface; “All were composed in response to personal requests and for particular audiences, without thought of subsequent publication.” Five pieces: “Transposition” (a Whit-Sunday sermon in Mansfield College chapel); “The Weight of Glory” (St Mary the Virgin, 8 June 1941); “Membership” (to the Society of St Alban and St Sergius, 1945); “Learning in War-Time” (St Mary’s, 22 October 1939); “The Inner Ring” (the Memorial Oration at King’s College, London, 1944).118
Argument. “Learning in War-Time” holds that “The war creates no absolutely new situation: it simply aggravates the permanent human situation so that we can no longer ignore it” — “Human life has always been lived on the edge of a precipice” — that “The learned life then is, for some, a duty”, and that the scholar’s enemies are excitement, frustration and fear. “The Weight of Glory”, quoted at length in the Thought section, argues that a reward which is the consummation of an activity is not mercenary, that “our lifelong nostalgia, our longing to be reunited with something in the universe from which we now feel cut off, to be on the inside of some door which we have always seen from the outside, is no mere neurotic fancy, but the truest index of our real situation”, that “We are half-hearted creatures, fooling about with drink and sex and ambition when infinite joy is offered us, like an ignorant child who wants to go on making mud pies in a slum because he cannot imagine what is meant by the offer of a holiday at the sea”, that “Nature is only the image, the symbol” of the glory, and that “Next to the Blessed Sacrament itself, your neighbour is the holiest object presented to your senses”, since “You have never talked to a mere mortal.” “Transposition” lays down the law of the higher reproduced in the lower, with the piano arrangement in which “the same piano notes which represent flutes in one passage must also represent violins in another”, holds that “It is therefore, at the very least, not improbable that Transposition occurs whenever the higher reproduces itself in the lower”, and that the relation is not symbolic but sacramental — “I think that real landscapes enter into pictures, not that pictures will one day sprout out into real trees and grass” — so that the Incarnation, the sacraments and the resurrection of the body are transpositions and the spiritual body is the natural body taken up. “Membership” sets the Church, “not a collective but a Body”, against both the modern collective and modern individualism: “I believe in political equality. But there are two opposite reasons for being a democrat”, equality being a legal fiction made necessary by the Fall, “medicine, not food”, while within the Body hierarchy is restored — “Obedience is the road to freedom, humility the road to pleasure, unity the road to personality” — and “That structural position in the Church which the humblest Christian occupies is eternal and even cosmic.” “The Inner Ring”, from Tolstoy’s observation that beside the army’s official hierarchy “there existed a different and a more real system”, has been quoted above.119
Esoteric relevance. Together the five addresses contain Lewis’s theory of correspondence between planes (Transposition), his doctrine of the neighbour as a possible god (the weight of glory), his Pauline and Dionysian hierarchy (Membership), his vocation of secular learning against the religion of culture, and his anatomy of the secret society as temptation; the Platonic erōs that wants not to see Beauty but to be united with it, turned from the images to the archetype, is their common ground.
Surprised by Joy: The Shape of My Early Life (1955)#
At a glance. London: Bles, 19 September 1955; New York: Harcourt, Brace, 1956. Epigraph from Wordsworth’s sonnet, “Surprised by joy — impatient as the wind”; dedicated “To Dom Bede Griffiths, O.S.B.”, his former pupil. Fifteen chapters, from “The First Years” to “The Beginning”, each with its epigraph — MacDonald’s “The one principle of hell is — ‘I am my own’” before “Checkmate”, Augustine’s Confessions before the last. The preface: “This book is written partly in answer to requests that I would tell how I passed from Atheism to Christianity”; “The book aims at telling the story of my conversion and is not a general autobiography”; “The story is, I fear, suffocatingly subjective; the kind of thing I have never written before and shall probably never write again”; and “How far the story matters to anyone but myself depends on the degree to which others have experienced what I call ‘joy’.” Joy Davidman, who entered Lewis’s life while he was writing it and helped with the final draft, was a coincidence of the title and not its meaning.120
Argument. The biographical substance has been given in the Life. The book’s argument is the single term defined in its first chapter — “It is that of an unsatisfied desire which is itself more desirable than any other satisfaction. I call it Joy” — pursued through its successive objects: the toy garden (“That was the first beauty I ever knew”), the Idea of Autumn, Balder, the “Northernness” of Wagner and the sagas, the occult lore of the matron and the “Perhaps” of Yeats, the Romanticism of Phantastes, the “New Look” of post-war realism, the Anthroposophy of his friends, the Absolute of the Idealists, and at last the God who is not a state of the self. Its philosophical hinge is Alexander’s distinction of enjoyment and contemplation, which showed that Joy contemplated vanishes because it was the enjoyment of something other; its theological climax is the surrender in Magdalen, under the Johannine compelle intrare, and the ride to Whipsnade; and its ending declares that Joy, having done its work as a pointer, lost its importance once the road was found.121
Esoteric relevance. The fourth chapter on the matron, the thirteenth on Yeats, the Doc and Anthroposophy, and the fourteenth on Absolute Idealism and its collapse make the book Lewis’s own narrative of the esoteric temptation and its refusal: the “something else” behind the material world is sought first in occultism, then in philosophy, and finally identified with the God of Christianity, and Joy itself is recognised as a pointer and not a possession — the critique of mysticism as experience that governs Letters to Malcolm.
Reception. Gilbert Murray, Lewis’s old professor, answered the book by calling its author a “dolce nemico”, a sweet enemy; the redating of its central event is McGrath’s and Lazo’s; its silence about Mrs Moore and its handling of the war are the biographers’ standing complaints.122
Takeaway. A conversion narrative organised around a single technical term, in which the occult, Romanticism, Idealism and Christianity are successive readings of one desire.
Reflections on the Psalms (1958)#
At a glance. London: Bles, 1958; New York: Harcourt, Brace, 1958; dedicated to Austin and Katharine Farrer. Twelve chapters: Introductory; “Judgement” in the Psalms; The Cursings; Death in the Psalms; “The Fair Beauty of the Lord”; “Sweeter than Honey”; Connivance; Nature; A Word about Praising; Second Meanings; Scripture; Second Meanings in the Psalms. Lewis uses Coverdale’s Prayer-Book Psalter and disclaims being a Hebraist, a critic or a historian, writing, he says, as one amateur to another and comparing notes.123
Argument. The Psalms are read as poems. The Psalmists long for judgement as the poor long for a hearing against the oppressor, where the Christian fears it as the accused, and both views are needed; the cursing psalms are the natural reaction of wronged men, not to be imitated but written for our learning, since they show what injury does to the injured and prove that the Psalmists took right and wrong seriously; the Old Testament’s long silence about a blessed afterlife allowed Israel to learn to love God for himself and not for reward; the “appetite for God” in the Temple cult, and the love of the Law, which can become self-righteousness but is a real love of order; the modern vice of conniving at evil out of politeness; the doctrine of creation, by emptying nature of divinity, made the Psalmists’ delight in her possible; praise is the natural completion of enjoyment; and then the three chapters that matter most here, on “second meanings”. A text can mean more than its author knew — Virgil’s fourth Eclogue, the Sibylline books, and above all the passage of Plato’s Republic (II, 361–62) in which the perfectly just man, mistaken for unjust, is bound, scourged and impaled, which Lewis reads as a second meaning pointing to the Passion without Plato’s knowledge; the Bible is not a textbook but a human literature “taken up” by God into inspiration, with its myths, legends and errors, inspired as the Incarnation is divine, through the human; and the Psalms speak of Christ as the Church has read them.124
Esoteric relevance. The tenth chapter is Lewis’s most careful statement of how the pagan writers could speak of Christ without knowing it: not by secret Hermetic knowledge but by the logic of their own thought carried to its end, Plato’s just man being the type. It is the hermeneutic beneath “Myth Became Fact”, Miracles and the Narnian use of classical myth, and his Christian-Platonist answer to the perennial philosophy: the pagans had second meanings, not a primary gnosis. The chapter on nature is the theory behind the planetary gods — creation makes the gods into creatures and nature into a sister — and the chapter on Scripture, which calls the Old Testament’s myths by that name, is the mythopoeic theology he shared with Tolkien.
Reception. Robert Gordis, reviewing it for Jewish Social Studies (1959), called it “highly unconventional”, criticised its reliance on translations and its “easy assumption of the superiority of Christianity over Judaism”, praised its sensitivity to the Jewish character of the Psalms, and said that it “calls upon all the critical faculties of the reader”. Lewis sat with T. S. Eliot on the Commission to Revise the Psalter from 1959.125
Takeaway. A layman’s book on the Psalter that is really a treatise on reading: how poems mean, how the Old Testament prepared the New, and how pagan philosophy and poetry bear second meanings.
The Four Loves (1960)#
At a glance. London: Bles, 1960; New York: Harcourt, Brace, 1960; grown from a set of talks recorded for American radio in 1958, whose frankness about sex was criticised there. Dedicated “To Chad Walsh”, the author of the first book on Lewis; the epigraph is Donne’s “That our affections kill us not, nor dye.” Six chapters: Introduction; Likings and Loves for the Sub-human; Affection; Friendship; Eros; Charity. Joy Davidman died less than four months after publication.126
Argument. Lewis began, he says, meaning to contrast Gift-love — “that love which moves a man to work and plan and save for the future well-being of his family which he will die without sharing or seeing” — with Need-love, “that which sends a lonely or frightened child to its mother’s arms”, and found that Need-love is not merely selfish: “We need others physically, emotionally, intellectually; we need them if we are to know anything, even ourselves.” He adds a third, Appreciative love, which rejoices that the object exists, and distinguishes “two things which might both possibly be called ‘nearness to God’” — “One is likeness to God”, and “secondly, there is what we may call nearness of approach” — the natural loves resembling God without necessarily bringing us towards him. The danger is stated at once: “Every human love, at its height, has a tendency to claim for itself a divine authority”, and the book’s motto is de Rougemont’s, that love “ceases to be a demon only when he ceases to be a god”. The sub-human loves follow: of nature, which “gave the word glory a meaning for me” but “cannot satisfy the desires she arouses nor answer theological questions nor sanctify us”; of country, which “When this love becomes demoniac it will of course produce wicked acts”. Affection, storge, the humblest and most diffused love, responsible for most of the solid happiness of life, can smother and claim rights. Friendship, philia, is “— in a sense not at all derogatory to it — the least natural of loves; the least instinctive, organic, biological, gregarious and necessary”; “Friendship is unnecessary, like philosophy, like art, like the universe itself (for God did not need to create). It has no survival value; rather it is one of those things which give value to survival”; it arises when two discover a common vision — “Do you love me? means Do you see the same truth?”; “Lovers are normally face to face, absorbed in each other; Friends, side by side, absorbed in some common interest” — and its dangers are the pride of the circle and the Inner Ring. Eros, being in love, is distinguished from Venus, the appetite within it, wants the Beloved rather than pleasure, carries both the comedy and the solemnity of the body, and, honoured without reservation, becomes a demon. Charity, agape, completes the book: God is the only Gift-love; the natural loves must be subordinated and are thereby transformed, not diminished; Augustine’s counsel after the death of his friend, to love only what cannot be lost, is refused as unchristian — “To love at all is to be vulnerable. Love anything, and your heart will certainly be wrung and possibly be broken”; “The only place outside of Heaven where you can be perfectly safe from all the dangers and perturbations of love is Hell”; “All that is not eternal is eternally out of date” — and God gives us a share in his own Need-love and Appreciative love for creatures.127
Esoteric relevance. The distinction of likeness and approach is Lewis’s version of the Platonic and Dionysian ladder: the natural loves are likenesses, transpositions, of the divine love, which can be climbed only by the approach of charity, and the book is in that sense a critique of any ascent, of the Symposium’s kind, that trusts the image itself. De Rougemont’s L’Amour et l’Occident (1939), with its thesis of courtly love as a Catharist religion of love, is the background of the chapter on Eros, as The Allegory of Love had already treated the “religion of love” as a parody of devotion; the sub-human loves give the rule for nature as the vehicle of the numinous and not its source; and Augustine’s ordo amoris, the “ordinate love” of The Abolition of Man, is the structure of the whole.
Reception. Bernard Williams reviewed it in The Spectator (1 April 1960); Jason Lepojärvi’s Helsinki dissertation God Is Love but Love Is Not God (2015) is the fullest study of Lewis’s theology of love.128
Takeaway. Lewis’s anatomy of love, built on the Augustinian ordering of loves and the distinction of likeness and approach, and remembered for its warning that every natural love, left to itself, becomes a god and then a demon.
A Grief Observed (1961)#
At a glance. London: Faber and Faber, 29 September 1961, as by “N. W. Clerk” — Nat Whilk, the Old English “I know not who” of his early pseudonymous poems, and “clerk”, scholar — submitted through his agent to Faber, where T. S. Eliot, a director, found it intensely moving; reissued under Lewis’s name in 1964. Four parts, each a manuscript notebook, the fourth opening on “the fourth — and the last — empty MS. book”; the wife is “H.”129
Argument. “No one ever told me that grief felt so like fear.” The first notebook records the physical symptoms, the embarrassment of others, the impossibility of remembering H. accurately, and the first religious note, that God seems absent. The second is the crisis: “But go to Him when your need is desperate, when all other help is vain, and what do you find? A door slammed in your face, and a sound of bolting and double bolting on the inside. After that, silence.” “Not that I am (I think) in much danger of ceasing to believe in God. The real danger is of coming to believe such dreadful things about Him. The conclusion I dread is not” that there is no God after all but “‘So this is what God’s really like.’” “Is it rational to believe in a bad God? … The Cosmic Sadist, the spiteful imbecile?” — rejected as irrational, since a Cosmic Sadist would not bother with the subtlety of the world, and the very idea of goodness by which we call him bad must come from him. The third recovers thought: “If my house has collapsed at one blow, that is because it was a house of cards”; faith that was never tested was imagination, not faith; God’s apparent cruelty may be the surgeon’s. The fourth: “Sorrow, however, turns out to be not a state but a process”; “Grief is like a long valley, a winding valley where any bend may reveal a totally new landscape”; the door is no longer slammed, and the loud knocking itself was what shut it; “My idea of God is not a divine idea. It has to be shattered time after time. He shatters it Himself. He is the great iconoclast”, the Incarnation being the supreme iconoclasm; the consolations of spiritualism are refused, as quoted in the Thought section; H. is thought of as pure intelligence, “like a sword”; and the book ends with her last words to the chaplain and Dante’s line for Beatrice turning back to God: “She said not to me but to the chaplain, ‘I am at peace with God.’ She smiled, but not at me. Poi si tornò all’ eterna fontana” — then she turned back to the eternal fountain.130
Esoteric relevance. The Cosmic Sadist is the Gnostic and dualist hypothesis — a bad Demiurge — raised in the first person and dismissed by the argument of Mere Christianity, that an evil power presupposes a good standard; God the iconoclast is the negative theology of Letters to Malcolm lived through, which makes the notebooks an apophatic text; the refusal of spiritualism and of all “evidence” of the dead’s continued existence is the lifelong refusal of the occult at its point of greatest temptation; and the Dantean ending places H. in the Paradiso and Lewis in the position of the pilgrim who must look not at Beatrice but at the Fountain, the turn from image to source that structures The Four Loves.
Reception. The honesty disturbed admirers who suspected it of being fiction; friends are said to have recommended the book to its pseudonymous author; it became the source of the two Shadowlands films (1985, 1993).131
Takeaway. The confessional counterpart of the apologetics: a dualist hypothesis entertained and refused, a theology of God’s silence, and an ending in the Paradiso.
Letters to Malcolm: Chiefly on Prayer (1964)#
At a glance. London: Bles, January 1964, two months after Lewis’s death; New York: Harcourt, Brace & World, 1964. Twenty-two letters to an imaginary correspondent, Malcolm, finished in the spring of 1963 after a direct treatise on prayer had been abandoned in the 1950s.132
Argument. The letters move from corporate prayer and liturgy — the “liturgical fidget” of ever-changing services against the settled rite that lets one pray through it rather than at it — through ready-made prayers and the “festooning” of the Lord’s Prayer with private glosses, images in prayer and the negative way (“Not thus, not thus, neither is this Thou”), posture and place, the prayer that it be the real I who speaks and the real Thou who is addressed, petitionary prayer and the two New Testament patterns that Lewis cannot reconcile, Gethsemane and the Lady Julian’s “all shall be well”. The later letters treat God’s omnipresence, Charles Williams’s maxim “This also is Thou; neither is this Thou” as the rule for the use and refusal of images, the “bright blur” that passes for a mental image of God, pleasures as “shafts of the glory” in which adoration begins, the Eucharist, on which he refuses to theorise and takes the veil between sign and thing as the point where speculation stops, purgatory, in which he believes as cleansing and not as punishment, and prayer for the dead. The last letter offers “guesses” about the resurrection of the senses: Vaughan’s “bright shoots of everlastingness”, Traherne’s “orient and immortal wheat”, and the guess that the hills and valleys of Heaven will be to those we know not as copy to original but as flower to root. “What seem our worst prayers may really be, in God’s eyes, our best. Those, I mean, which are least supported by devotional feeling.” “We may ignore, but we can nowhere evade, the presence of God. The world is crowded with Him. He walks everywhere incognito.”133
Esoteric relevance. The “Wholly Other” of Otto and Buber, Williams’s maxim and the refusal of the bright blur make this Lewis’s most Dionysian book: images are to be used and then denied. The remark on Plato’s elevation of abstract nouns and the “symbolist” treatment of the sacraments show him still thinking in the categories of The Allegory of Love, the sacraments being symbols in the strong, Platonic sense; purgatory and prayer for the dead are a “mere” Christian taking a Catholic position on Dantean grounds; the resurrection of the senses is his last speculation on the new Nature, with Traherne and Vaughan, the Hermetic-Platonist poets, as witnesses; and the twelfth letter, quoted above, holds the mystics in honour and mysticism at arm’s length.
Reception. Often counted among his slighter books, which poses questions it does not attempt to answer, and less hostile to the radical theologians of its day than Malcolm would wish.134
Takeaway. Lewis’s last completed book, a conversational treatise on prayer that gathers his Platonism, his negative theology and his guesses about the body’s resurrection, written knowing that he was dying.
The Essays and Addresses, and Their Collections#
Lewis’s shorter religious and philosophical writings, some fifty pieces, were gathered in They Asked for a Paper (Bles, 1962), the last book published in his lifetime, in The World’s Last Night (New York: Harcourt, Brace, 1960), and after his death by Walter Hooper in Christian Reflections (Bles, 1967), God in the Dock (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1970; in Britain Undeceptions, 1971), Fern-seed and Elephants (Fontana, 1975) and Present Concerns (Fount, 1986), with Lesley Walmsley’s Essay Collection (HarperCollins, 2000) gathering a hundred and thirty-five pieces. Those that bear on his cosmology, his Platonism and his quarrel with the occult are few and can be named. “Bulverism” (1941; revised for the Socratic Club, 1944) names the modern habit of explaining why an opponent is wrong before showing that he is — “You must show that a man is wrong before you start explaining why he is wrong” — and contains the earliest public statement of the argument from reason. “Evil and God” (The Spectator, 1941) runs the privation theory against dualism in technical form. “Myth Became Fact” (1944) has been quoted; “By becoming fact it does not cease to be myth: that is the miracle.” “Is Theology Poetry?” (1944) concedes that “I like Greek mythology much better, Irish better still, Norse best of all”, finds the real rival to be the “Scientific Outlook”, the cosmic drama of evolution — “Supposing this to be a myth, is it not one of the finest myths which human imagination has yet produced?” — which refutes itself by making reason a by-product, allows the pagans their truth (“Theology, while saying that a special illumination has been vouchsafed to Christians and (earlier) to Jews, also says that there is some divine illumination vouchsafed to all men”), and ends, “Theology is, in this sense, poetry to me because I believe it; I do not believe it because it is poetry”, and with the sentence on the risen sun. “Religion without Dogma?” (1946), in reply to H. H. Price, denies that a “minimal religion” of God and immortality without dogma has ever existed or can be derived from psychical research. “Christianity and Culture” (1940) surveys the Fathers and concludes that culture is a storehouse of sub-Christian values, a lawful vocation and a road to Christ for some, but that the modern religion of culture is idolatry, applying de Rougemont’s maxim to art. “The Poison of Subjectivism” (1943) is the companion of The Abolition of Man, and answers the objection that the moral law is God’s arbitrary will with the doctrine that God is not merely good but Goodness. “The Funeral of a Great Myth” examines popular evolutionism — not Darwin’s theorem but the picture of a universe climbing from chaos to mind, which inspired Keats’s Hyperion and Wagner’s Ring before Darwin — as a myth with its own tragic poetry, and buries it with affection. “Historicism” (1950) denies that the plan of history can be read from the record by Hegel, Carlyle, the Marxists or the Christian providentialist alike. “Fern-seed and Elephants” (1959), against the biblical critics, says that “These men ask me to believe they can read between the lines of the old texts; the evidence is their obvious inability to read (in any sense worth discussing) the lines themselves”, that “They claim to see fern-seed and can’t see an elephant ten yards away in broad daylight”, that “I have been reading poems, romances, vision-literature, legends, myths all my life. I know what they are like. I know that not one of them is like this”, and that the “assured results of modern scholarship” are “‘assured’, we may conclude, only because the men who know the facts are dead and can’t blow the gaff”. “The Seeing Eye” (1963) answers the cosmonaut who found no God in space: God is not an object in space but the author in whom the play exists. “The World’s Last Night” (1952) holds that “The doctrine of the Second Coming teaches us that we do not and cannot know when the world drama will end. The curtain may be rung down at any moment: say, before you have finished reading this paragraph.” “The Efficacy of Prayer” (1959) draws the line that The Abolition of Man had drawn: “Prayer is not a machine. It is not magic. It is not advice offered to God”; “‘God,’ said Pascal, ‘instituted prayer in order to lend to His creatures the dignity of causality’”; and the striking answers “usually come at the beginning: before conversion, or soon after it”, while “The refusals, too, are not only more frequent; they become more unmistakable, more emphatic.” “Meditation in a Toolshed” (1945) gives the epistemology of the whole: a beam of light in a dark shed can be looked at or looked along, modern thought has privileged the first and called the second illusion, and both are needed. “The Humanitarian Theory of Punishment” (1949) states the politics of the Conditioners in a line: “Of all tyrannies a tyranny sincerely exercised for the good of its victims may be the most oppressive.” And “The Empty Universe” (1952), a preface to D. E. Harding, traces the process by which the universe was emptied first of gods, then of qualities, then of the human subject, until the emptying empties the emptier — the history of which the medieval Model is the beginning and the “Scientific Outlook” the end.135
Scholarship and Criticism#
The Allegory of Love: A Study in Medieval Tradition (1936)#
At a glance. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 21 May 1936; corrected impression 1938 and many reprints; Galaxy paperback, New York, 1958. Dedicated to Owen Barfield, “wisest and best of my unofficial teachers”. Seven chapters — Courtly Love; Allegory; The Romance of the Rose; Chaucer; Gower, Thomas Usk; Allegory as the Dominant Form; The Faerie Queene — with appendices on “Genius and Genius” and on “Danger”. Written between about 1928 and 1935, through the years of the Great War with Barfield and of the conversion; the British Academy’s Gollancz Memorial Prize for 1937.136
Argument. Courtly love appeared suddenly in late eleventh-century Languedoc with “the four marks of Humility, Courtesy, Adultery, and the Religion of Love”, a “feudalisation of love” that made passion “noble and ennobling”, whereas “In ancient literature love seldom rises above the levels of merry sensuality or domestic comfort, except to be treated as a tragic madness”; Ovid’s Ars amatoria “presupposes an audience to whom love is one of the minor peccadilloes of life, and the joke consists in treating it seriously”, and the troubadours took the joke in earnest. Chrétien gave the sentiment its first great form and Andreas Capellanus its code, in which “the irreligion of the religion of love could hardly go further”, love being “a ‘kind of chastity’ in virtue of its severe standard of fidelity to a single object” and “Love is, in saeculo, as God is, in eternity” — until the palinode: “But of course there is for Andreas, in a cool hour, no doubt as to which of the two worlds is the real one”; “We hear the bell clang; and the children, suddenly hushed and grave, and a little frightened, troop back to their master.” The second chapter, on allegory, holds the theory on which the book and Lewis’s whole poetics rest. “It is of the very nature of thought and language to represent what is immaterial in picturable terms.” Allegory starts from the immaterial fact, a passion, and invents visible things to express it; symbolism or sacramentalism starts from the visible world and treats it as the copy of an invisible archetype, the attempt to see the archetype in the copy; the allegorist leaves the given to talk of a confessed fiction, the symbolist leaves it to find what is more real, so that for the symbolist it is we who are the allegory; symbolism is a mode of thought, allegory a mode of expression; and the symbolical view is “Platonic, as Platonism was understood in those days”. The history of personification follows — the divided will of Seneca and Paul, Prudentius (“The twilight of the gods is the mid-morning of the personifications”), Martianus, Boethius, and the twelfth-century school of Chartres, where allegory was “a natural method”: Bernardus Silvestris’s De mundi universitate, “an image of the mighty world”, and Alanus de Insulis, who tries “to respond to … the sublime suggestions of Plato’s most sublime and suggestive work”, the Timaeus, whose “mind is whole and balanced”, and whose goddess Natura mediates a chaste acceptance of the body “with no slightest sense of rebellion or defiance”; “The earthly Cupid, after being for ages contrasted with the celestial Cupid, suddenly finds himself in contrast with an infernal Cupid.” The chapters that follow read Guillaume de Lorris’s Rose as psychological realism in allegorical dress and Jean de Meun’s continuation as a naturalistic, not a mystical, resolution — “if he lacks the bones of good poetry, he has all its flesh” — Chaucer’s Troilus as the point where allegory is dispensed with and courtly love given directly, Gower and Usk, and the long decay of allegory into decoration, before Spenser concludes the book: “To read him is to grow in mental health”; he is “the great mediator between the Middle Ages and the modern poets”, “the man who saved us from the catastrophe of too thorough a renaissance”; and allegory itself is “the peculiar flower of a peculiar civilization, important whether for good or ill and well worth our understanding”.137
Esoteric relevance. The distinction of allegory from sacramental symbol is Lewis’s foundational statement of a Platonic poetics — the visible world as copy of the archetype, read through Chalcidius’s Timaeus and the Chartrians — and it is the theory behind “Transposition”, behind his readings of Dante and Spenser, and behind the whole of his Christian Platonism. The School of Chartres, with its cosmogonic goddess, its Genius and its two Venuses and two Cupids, is read as the source of the medieval Nature tradition that runs through Jean de Meun, Chaucer and Spenser, the medieval inheritance of the Symposium’s two loves before Ficino; courtly love as a religion, with its god, its saints and its heaven, is the phenomenon that de Rougemont would read as crypto-Catharist and that Lewis reads as parody; and the appendix “Genius and Genius” distinguishes the universal god of generation from the tutelary daemon of the individual — the two senses the Renaissance inherited, and Lewis’s first treatment of the daemon.
Reception. William Empson in The Spectator found “The book is learned, witty, and sensible”, though “he oversimplifies the allegories”; the thesis of courtly love’s four marks was attacked by E. Talbot Donaldson, Peter Dronke and D. W. Robertson in the 1960s and has not survived in the form Lewis gave it, while the theory of allegory and the account of the Chartrians have.138
Takeaway. The book that made Lewis’s academic reputation, a history of romantic love and of allegory from Ovid to Spenser whose theoretical heart is the Platonic distinction between allegory and sacramental symbol.
Rehabilitations and The Personal Heresy (1939)#
Rehabilitations and Other Essays (London: Oxford University Press, 1939) collects nine essays, among them the defence of Shelley against Eliot, the essay on William Morris, “The Alliterative Metre”, which prints “The Planets” and explains why the planets “seem to me to have a permanent value as spiritual symbols”, and “Bluspels and Flalansferes: A Semantic Nightmare”, out of the Great War with Barfield, which argues that all language is metaphorical in origin and that reason depends on imagination as the organ of meaning. The Personal Heresy: A Controversy (Oxford University Press, 1939), with E. M. W. Tillyard, grew from Lewis’s essay of 1934 and Tillyard’s rejoinder: against the doctrine that poetry is the expression of the poet’s personality, Lewis holds that it concerns something outside him — “The poet is not a man who asks me to look at him; he is a man who says ‘look at that’ and points”; “I must make of him not a spectacle but a pair of spectacles” — diagnoses the heresy as a product of the modern uncertainty between materialist and spiritual views, and warns against “Poetolatry”. The objective theory of poetry, the poet as a window on a reality shared by all, is the critical form of the anti-subjectivism of The Abolition of Man, and the phrase “the poison of subjectivism” first appears here.139
A Preface to Paradise Lost (1942)#
At a glance. London: Oxford University Press, 1942: the Ballard Matthews Lectures given at University College, Bangor, in 1941, revised and enlarged, and dedicated to Charles Williams in a letter crediting his Oxford lectures on Comus with recovering the moral meaning of Milton. Nineteen chapters, from “Epic Poetry” and “Is Criticism Possible?” through primary and secondary epic and the defence of Milton’s style, to “The Doctrine of the Unchanging Human Heart”, “Milton and St. Augustine”, “Hierarchy”, “The Theology of Paradise Lost”, “Satan”, “Satan’s Followers”, “The Mistake about Milton’s Angels”, “Adam and Eve”, “Unfallen Sexuality”, “The Fall” and a conclusion.140
Argument. The first question about a poem is what kind of thing it is; secondary epic must create on the page the ritual solemnity that primary epic had in performance, and Milton’s style, with its Latinisms and proper names, is defended against Eliot and Leavis. The ninth chapter attacks the idea that we should strip off a period’s beliefs to reach a timeless core, insisting that we must enter them; the tenth finds the poem’s doctrine of the Fall to be Augustine’s; the eleventh states “the Hierarchical conception” quoted in the Thought section, in a cosmos of order, proportion, measure and control, with which Milton’s republicanism is no contradiction. The thirteenth reads Satan as “a personified self-contradiction”: “What we see in Satan is the horrible co-existence of a subtle and incessant intellectual activity” with an incapacity to understand anything; “He has wished to ‘be himself’”; “The Hell he carries with him is, in one sense, a Hell of infinite boredom”; to admire him is to vote “for a world of lies and propaganda, of wishful thinking, of incessant autobiography”, and his decline from hero to toad to serpent is Milton’s design. The fifteenth holds that Milton’s angels are not the pure intelligences of the schoolmen but, in a Platonic tradition that Henry More shared, beings with bodies of fine matter who eat, embrace and can be wounded. “Eve fell through Pride” and “Adam fell by uxoriousness”, and the last books are an “untransmuted lump of futurity”.141
Esoteric relevance. The hierarchy chapter is Lewis’s most compact exposition of the great chain that The Discarded Image describes historically and that the Ransom cosmos and “Membership” assume; the defence of Milton’s corporeal angels is directly relevant to the eldila, which have bodies of a kind, and to his reading of Apuleius’s daemons; the Augustinian privation theory is the anti-dualism of Mere Christianity; and the dedication marks the Williams years.
Reception. Jackson Knight in The Spectator judged “He is successful”; A. J. A. Waldock’s Paradise Lost and its Critics (1947) and Empson’s Milton’s God (1961) are the classic attacks on the reading of Satan; Helen Gardner called the book “immensely influential” while criticising its account of Eve; William Kolbrener has argued that Lewis and Eliot set the direction of Milton studies for half a century.142
Takeaway. The orthodox reading of Milton that, with Eliot’s, set the direction of Milton studies for half a century, built on genre, hierarchy and Augustine, and the book in which Lewis’s cosmology of angels and order is first set out as literary history.
George MacDonald: An Anthology (1946) and Arthurian Torso (1948)#
The anthology (London: Bles, 1946) gathers three hundred and sixty-five extracts, chiefly from the Unspoken Sermons, under a preface that tells of the Leatherhead bookstall and confesses, “I have never concealed the fact that I regarded him as my master”; it judges the novels mediocre and the genius mythopoeic — “What he does best is fantasy — fantasy that hovers between the allegorical and the mythopoeic” — and names the quality as holiness, “the wisdom and (I would dare to call it) the holiness that are in him triumph over and even burn away the baser elements in his style”. The preface’s theory of myth, as a pattern apart from words that can be received through bad prose, is Lewis’s clearest statement of mythopoeia as a category; MacDonald’s Boehmist and universalist strains, treated in the entry on him, are passed over in silence. Arthurian Torso (Oxford University Press, 1948) prints the posthumous fragment of Williams’s Figure of Arthur with Lewis’s commentary, “Williams and the Arthuriad”, which explains the two Taliessin cycles poem by poem, with the geography of Williams’s Empire — Logres, Byzantium, Caucasia, Broceliande, P’o-l’u — read as the organic body of one order, the doctrines of co-inherence and substitution, and the Way of the Affirmation of Images, presented as Williams’s distinctive contribution to Christian thought. Here Lewis expounds, as a sympathetic interpreter, the mythology of a poet formed in Waite’s Fellowship of the Rosy Cross, and the borrowings are deep: the “bright blur” and the maxim “This also is Thou; neither is this Thou” of Letters to Malcolm come from Williams by way of this book.143
English Literature in the Sixteenth Century Excluding Drama (1954)#
At a glance. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1954, the third volume of the Oxford History of English Literature, contracted in 1935, grown from the Clark Lectures at Cambridge in 1944 and the Oxford lectures on Renaissance poetry, and delivered by Michaelmas 1952; reissued in 1990 as Poetry and Prose in the Sixteenth Century. An introduction, “New Learning and New Ignorance”; Book I, “Late Medieval”, on the close of the Middle Ages in Scotland and in England; Book II, “Drab”, on religious controversy and translation and on the verse and prose of the mid-century; Book III, “Golden”, on Sidney and Spenser and on the prose and verse of the Golden period; an epilogue, “New Tendencies”; a chronological table and bibliography.144
Argument. The introduction denies a sharp break between the Middle Ages and the Renaissance: the word names no one thing; humanism was a narrow Latin purism, hostile to the vernacular and to a scholastic philosophy it did not understand — “They jeer and do not refute”, and “In that sense the New Learning created the New Ignorance”; the new astronomy mattered less than moderns suppose, for what proved important, and slowly, was the methodological revolution and not “the mere alteration in our map of space”; the mid-century was “an earnest, heavy-handed, commonplace age: a drab age”; Calvin’s Geneva acted “on accepted medieval principles”, and “All parties inherited from the Middle Ages the assumption that Christian man could live only in a theocratic polity.” Then the pages on magic, quoted at length in the Thought section: the high magic of Pico, Ficino, Paracelsus, Agrippa and Dee as a new thing and not a survival, its “Platonic theology” that was “a system of daemonology”, its “anthropolatry”, its drift “away from the centre of Christianity”, and its kinship with Bacon’s science as a dream of power. The Scots, Henryson, Dunbar, Douglas and Lyndsay, end the Middle Ages at a high level and the English at a low one; the Drab age — the term descriptive, not pejorative — covers the Reformation prose, the translators, Wyatt and Surrey, Sackville and the Mirror for Magistrates; the Golden age, beginning with Sidney and Spenser, is innocent, confident and ornate, and its Faerie Queene is read, as in the Allegory, as a Platonic and Chartrian poem of nature and grace; the epilogue finds the new tendencies in Donne.145
Esoteric relevance. The introduction is Lewis’s principal historical statement on Renaissance esotericism and the companion of the lecture on magic and science: the Florentine Platonic theology resting on the Hermetica, the Orphica, Apuleius, Plotinus, Psellus, Iamblichus and the Cabbala; the opposition in tendency between magic and astrology, human omnipotence against human impotence; the Apuleian “daemons (not demons)” traced from Bernardus Silvestris and Geoffrey of Monmouth to Agrippa; and the kinship with Bacon. Dennis Danielson calls the introduction “among the richest and most concentrated pieces of intellectual history he ever produced”, and historians of the Burckhardtian “Renaissance” have come round to its continuum.
Reception. Leicester Bradner in Renaissance News found it a “great satisfaction to all scholars in this field” but, as literary history, a “disappointing performance”; Charles Harrison in the Sewanee Review thought it “vastly learned” and said that Lewis “comes close to arguing that there was no Renaissance and that it was a bad thing anyhow”; G. D. Willcock in the Review of English Studies called it “the most massive of the Oxford Histories of Literature to appear” and “by no means an easy book to read”.146
Takeaway. A history of a century written to abolish “the Renaissance”, with the new magic set beside the new science as twin products of the age’s will to power.
Studies in Words (1960) and An Experiment in Criticism (1961)#
Studies in Words (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1960; enlarged 1967) traces the semantic history of a handful of words — nature, sad, wit, free, sense, simple, conscience and conscious, world, life, with later chapters on “I dare say” and on the fringe of language — to show how readers of old books are misled by a word’s modern “dangerous sense” into total misreading, the well-read reader being the more vulnerable because he can rationalise his error, and it prosecutes “verbicide”, the murder of words by their use as mere terms of praise or abuse. The chapter on “nature” — physis, natura, “kind”; nature as the sort a thing is, as the whole of things, as opposed to art, to grace and to the supernatural, and, in the dangerous sense, as the merely physical — is the lexical ground of the Nature chapters of Miracles and of the Chartrian Natura; “world” traces kosmos, mundus and saeculum; “life” compares the modern “Life” of Shaw and Bergson with Plato’s Beauty; “conscience” follows conscientia from shared knowledge to the moral faculty. An Experiment in Criticism (Cambridge University Press, 1961) proposes to judge books by the kind of reading they allow rather than readers by the books they read: the unliterary use a book, for excitement, for castle-building or for information, and never re-read, while the literary receive it, re-read it and are changed, and highbrow and lowbrow are beside the point. Its fifth chapter defines myth by six marks — extra-literary, independent of its telling, with little suspense and little sympathy with characters, fantastic, grave and numinous — so that the same story may be myth to one reader and not to another; the sixth separates fantasy as a literary kind from the morbid, the egoistic and the disinterested castle-building of the psychologists and argues that realistic fiction, not fantasy, is the usual vehicle of egoistic day-dreaming; and the epilogue states what we seek in reading: an enlargement of our being, to see with other eyes, to become a thousand men and remain ourselves, as in love, in worship, in moral action and in knowing, where we transcend ourselves and are never more ourselves than when we do. The theory of myth is Lewis’s mature mythopoetics, and the epilogue’s reading “as in worship” makes literature a para-mystical discipline, with the Few and the Many carefully distinguished from the Platonic and Gnostic sociologies of knowledge — the Few are not better men.147
The Discarded Image: An Introduction to Medieval and Renaissance Literature (1964)#
At a glance. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1964, published after his death and grown from the Oxford lecture courses “Prolegomena to Medieval Studies” and “Prolegomena to Renaissance Studies” that he had given since the 1930s, and from the two lectures to Cambridge scientists of July 1956, “Imagination and Thought in the Middle Ages”. Eight chapters and an epilogue: The Medieval Situation; Reservations; Selected Materials: The Classical Period (the Somnium Scipionis, Lucan, Statius and Claudian with the Lady Natura, Apuleius’s De deo Socratis); Selected Materials: The Seminal Period (Chalcidius, Macrobius, Pseudo-Dionysius, Boethius); The Heavens; The Longaevi; Earth and Her Inhabitants; The Influence of the Model.148
Argument. Medieval culture was bookish and systematising, and from inherited and often contradictory authorities it built the Model of the Universe: “the essentially bookish character of their culture, and their intense love of system”; “A Model must be built which will get everything in without a clash”, and “it can do this only by becoming intricate, by mediating its unity through a great, and finely ordered, multiplicity.” The Model was held with varying literalness — “On the highest level, then, the Model was recognised as provisional” — and “What we should like to know is how far down the intellectual scale this cautious view extended.” The classical materials are Cicero’s dream of Scipio, with the soul’s ascent, the music of the spheres and the littleness of earth and fame; Lucan, with the gods’ indifference, Fortune and the necromancy of Erictho; Statius and Claudian, with the personifications and the goddess Natura, the seed of the Chartrian Nature; and Apuleius’s De deo Socratis, the systematic account of the daemons, the aerial intermediaries between gods and men, immortal like gods and passible like men, who carry prayers up and oracles down, and of whom Socrates’ daimonion is the type, which Lewis treats as the principal classical source of the medieval “spirits” and of the Longaevi. The seminal materials, from the age when pagans and Christians were alike monotheists and Platonists, are Chalcidius’s commentary on the Timaeus, the one dialogue the Middle Ages read, with its demiurge, World-Soul and celestial gods, and his own theory of daemons and of a fate subordinate to providence; Macrobius on the Somnium, with the five kinds of dream, the descent of the soul through the spheres acquiring its faculties, and the hierarchy of Mind, Soul and body; Pseudo-Dionysius’s nine orders of angels in three hierarchies, each illuminated by the one above, and the negative theology of the Mystical Theology; and Boethius, with Fortune and her wheel, Providence and Fate, eternity as the whole and perfect possession of unending life, and the ascent of the mind. The chapter on the heavens begins with physics — “the fundamental concept was that of certain sympathies, antipathies, and strivings inherent in the matter itself”; the Middle Ages “attributed life and even intelligence to one privileged class of objects (the stars)”; “To talk as if inanimate bodies had a homing instinct is to bring them no nearer to us than pigeons”, and “to talk as if they could ‘obey’ laws is to treat them like men and even like citizens”. It proceeds through the elements (“The union of hot and dry becomes fire; that of hot and moist, air; of cold and moist, water; of cold and dry, earth”; “Fire, the lightest of all, whenever it was free, has flown up to the circumference of Nature and forms a sphere just below the orbit of the Moon”) to the spheres quoted in the Thought section, to the Intelligences that move them, to the seven planets’ characters, metals and influences — Saturn the “Infortuna Major”, lead, cold, melancholy, old age and pestilence, from whom Father Time with his scythe derives; Jupiter the “Fortuna Major”, tin, the king, cheerful, festive, magnanimous and serene; Mars, iron, war and the choleric; Sol, gold, wisdom and liberality; Venus, copper, beauty and love; Mercury, quicksilver, skill and eager activity, hardest to define; Luna, silver, wandering and lunacy, her sphere the boundary of the mutable world — and to the Church’s acceptance of planetary influence as natural causation while condemning judicial astrology: the stars incline, they do not compel. The Longaevi have a chapter apart because “their place of residence is ambiguous between air and Earth” and because the word fairies has been “tarnished by pantomime and bad children’s books with worse illustrations”; the four medieval theories — a third rational species between angels and men, where Paracelsus’s elementals belong; a class of neutral angels who in the war in heaven were for neither side; the dead; devils — are reviewed, and “No agreement was achieved.” The chapter on earth and her inhabitants gives Fortune as the earth’s Intelligence “in the mode proper for a stationary globe”, the symbolic mappaemundi beside a practical geography, man as microcosm, the three souls — “The powers of Vegetable Soul are nutrition, growth, and propagation. It alone is present in plants. Sensitive Soul, which we find in animals, has these powers but has sentience in addition. Rational Soul similarly includes Vegetable and Sensitive, and adds reason” — intellectus and ratio, the five outward and five inward wits, the “spirits” as “a tertium quid … [a] phantom liaison-officer between body and soul”, of which “both ends of the bridge rest on one side of the chasm; if not, both rest on the other”, the humours and complexions (“Today I think we should describe the Melancholy as neurotic”), the medieval past — “The backward, like the upward, glance exhilarated him with a majestic spectacle, and humility was rewarded with the pleasure of admiration” — and the seven liberal arts, in which “There is no antithesis, indeed no distinction, between Rhetoric and Poetry”. The last chapter shows the Model’s hold on the poets — “Poets and other artists depicted these things because their minds loved to dwell on them” — and the epilogue reflects on how Models change: a Model is neither a catalogue of ultimate realities nor a fantasy; it answers to the nature of things and to the mind of its age, the questions asked determining the Model found; the modern Model is also provisional and will be replaced, not by a return to the old but by one that answers a changed mind; and Lewis does not recommend a return, but asks that the Model be taken seriously as an image of the universe which, besides its beauty, has the merit of being, like all the others, a human construction answering to reality in part.149
Esoteric relevance. This is the fullest statement of Lewis’s cosmos, and the book in which a scholar of the first rank expounded, for readers of literature, the cosmology that the Renaissance magi took for granted. Apuleius’s daemons, Chalcidius’s daemons, the “spirits” and the Longaevi are the middle world between angels and men that Paracelsus, Agrippa and the witch-trials inherited, and the four theories of the fairies are their taxonomy; the seven planetary characters with their Intelligences are the astrological and angelological core of the Model, and the Church’s distinction between influence and divination its licence; Macrobius’s descent of the soul, Dionysius’s hierarchies and negative theology, Boethius’s eternity and Chalcidius’s Timaeus are presented as the philosophical grammar of the Middle Ages by a Platonist who believed much of it while historically distancing the Model as discarded; the soul’s faculties supply the psychology of his own accounts of reason and imagination; and the epilogue’s philosophy of Models is his late epistemology, close to Barfield’s Saving the Appearances (1957) and to the regenerate science of The Abolition of Man.
Reception. The Observer called it “wise, illuminating, companionable” and thought it “may well come to be seen as Lewis’s best book”; Morton Bloomfield in Speculum praised it with the reservation that Lewis tends to oversimplify and overcategorise; J. A. Burrow’s “The Model Universe” (1965) and “The Alterity of Medieval Literature” (1979) are the medievalists’ assessments; and Michael Ward’s Planet Narnia made the fifth chapter the key to the Chronicles.150
Takeaway. Lewis’s last and, in the judgement of several of its reviewers, best book: a description of the medieval and Renaissance Model — spheres, planets, Intelligences, daemons, Longaevi, the composite soul — by a scholar who loved it, with an epilogue that explains why every such Model is both answerable to reality and destined to be discarded.
The Posthumous Criticism#
Studies in Medieval and Renaissance Literature (Cambridge University Press, 1966), edited by Hooper, prints the unfinished chapters and lectures of the book that became The Discarded Image — “De Audiendis Poetis”, “The Genesis of a Medieval Book”, “Imagination and Thought in the Middle Ages” — with the two Dante papers on similes (1940) and on the imagery of light, the rose, the river and the point in the last cantos of the Paradiso (1948), Lewis’s closest approach to a reading of Christian-Platonic mysticism as poetry; “Dante’s Statius”; the Spenser group, including “Neoplatonism in the Poetry of Spenser” (1961), his review of Robert Ellrodt’s argument that Spenser’s Platonism is medieval and Christian rather than Florentine, which he largely accepts while defending the Platonic reading of the Garden of Adonis and the Temple of Venus; “Spenser’s Cruel Cupid”; “Genius and Genius”; and a note on Comus. Spenser’s Images of Life (Cambridge University Press, 1967), reconstructed by Alastair Fowler, Lewis’s doctoral pupil, from the notes for his Cambridge lectures, reads The Faerie Queene iconographically, as a sequence of images of life — pageants, masques, emblems, temples and gardens — rather than as narrative allegory: the images of evil (the false Florimell, the Bower of Bliss, Busirane’s house of Cupid) and of good (the Garden of Adonis as the Platonic place of forms and generation, the Temple of Venus, Isis Church, Mount Acidale), the veiled and hermaphrodite Venus, Mutability and the cosmic order; it is Lewis’s fullest exposition of Spenser’s Neoplatonism and of the Renaissance iconographic imagination that Edgar Wind’s generation read, and Fowler records that in these lectures Lewis returned to a metaphysical explanation of the poem in terms of form and matter. Selected Literary Essays (Cambridge University Press, 1969) gathers twenty-two pieces, among them “De Descriptione Temporum”, the Cambridge inaugural of 1954, which denies that the Renaissance was a great divide and sets the greatest division in Western history between the age of Jane Austen and our own, somewhere in the earlier nineteenth century. The marks of the division are the replacement of rulers by leaders, the novelty of modern art, the “un-christening” of Europe — Christians and pagans having had more in common with each other than either has with the post-Christian, the gap between those who worship different gods being narrower than the gap between those who worship and those who do not — and the birth of the machines; and Lewis presents himself as a native of Old Western culture, a dinosaur, and advises his hearers to use their specimens while they can; “Psycho-analysis and Literary Criticism” (1942), which finds Freud’s theory able to explain at most the choice of images and not their poetic use, and treats Jung’s archetypes with more sympathy as a description and not as an explanation; “The Anthropological Approach” (1962), against reading medieval romance by its supposed ritual sources, since what the text does with the material is the literary fact, while Lewis’s own interest is in the literary effect of the numinous survivals; “Hero and Leander” (1952), in which Chapman’s Neoplatonic machinery of Ceremony is read seriously; and “The Alliterative Metre”. Image and Imagination (Cambridge University Press, 2013), edited by Hooper, adds the reviews, among them those of Williams’s Taliessin.151
Letters, Diaries and Posthumous Collections#
Lewis was a prolific letter-writer, and the letters are the primary source for his inner history. Warren Lewis’s Letters of C. S. Lewis (London: Bles, 1966), with its memoir, was the first selection, heavily cut; Letters to an American Lady (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1967) prints the letters of 1950–63 to Mary Willis Shelburne, a widow he never met and secretly supported, the best record of his pastoral advice on prayer, purgatory, illness and death; They Stand Together (London: Collins, 1979) printed the letters to Arthur Greeves, the principal source for the occult interests of 1914–21 and for the conversion; Letters to Children (London: Fount, 1985) contains the letters on the meaning of Narnia; and Hooper’s three-volume Collected Letters (London: HarperCollins, 2000–06), with its appendix of the Great War letters, superseded them all. All My Road Before Me (London: HarperCollins, 1991), the diary of 1922–27 with a foreword by Barfield, records the Idealist years, the Mrs Moore household, the beginnings of the Great War and the madness of Dr Askins, and gives the medical diagnosis that the autobiography omits. The “Great War” of Owen Barfield and C. S. Lewis: Philosophical Writings 1927–1930 (Oxford: Journal of Inklings Studies, 2015), edited by Norbert Feinendegen and Arend Smilde, is the first edition of the documents of the dispute — Lewis’s Summa Metaphysices contra Anthroposophos, Barfield’s Replicit, the treatises De bono et malo and De toto et parte, and the letters — and its relevance here is direct: it is the only sustained philosophical engagement by Lewis with an esoteric system, Steiner’s, conducted as an Idealist before his conversion, and the origin of his doctrines of imagination, metaphor and chronological snobbery.152
Reception and Significance#
Lewis’s contemporaries judged him by his parts, and the judgements divide by the part. Tolkien, who owed him “sheer encouragement” — Lewis was the only one who gave him the idea that his “stuff” could be more than a private hobby — held that Lewis’s mythology was quite different from his own and had been made coherent by contact with Williams’s Arthurian matter, remained unmoved by Williams while Lewis was bowled over, disliked Screwtape and Narnia, and wrote to his daughter four days after Lewis’s death that, having so far felt only the normal feelings of a man of his age, like an old tree losing its leaves one by one, this felt like an axe-blow near the roots. Williams, reviewing Screwtape as one devil to another, called it “a dangerous book, heavenly-dangerous”. Austin Farrer, in the memorial volume of 1965, found the secret of the apologetics in the fact that “Rational argument does not create belief, but it maintains a climate in which belief may flourish”, and that “though argument does not create conviction, the lack of it destroys belief”; Chad Walsh’s C. S. Lewis: Apostle to the Skeptics (1949) was the first book, and gave American Protestantism its Lewis. The hostile voices were as strong. Orwell, reviewing That Hideous Strength, thought novels better without miracles; Haldane, in “Auld Hornie, F.R.S.” (1946), that “Mr. Lewis’s idea is clear enough. The application of science to human affairs can only lead to hell”, that “Lewis’s contempt for science is constantly letting him down”, and that “Mr. Lewis is a most useful prop to the existing social order”; Kathleen Nott’s The Emperor’s Clothes (1953) attacked the dogmatic orthodoxy of Eliot, Greene, Sayers and Lewis together; Leavis’s Cambridge received the new professor of 1954 with open contempt; and Time, putting him on its cover in 1947 with a devil at his shoulder, reported that “With Screwtape’s success, Lewis became a celebrity.” The Dean of Divinity at St Andrews had put the achievement in a sentence the year before, quoted in the Life: a new kind of marriage between theological reflection and poetic imagination. Half a century later, at the dedication of the Poets’ Corner stone, Rowan Williams said that “Lewis is interested in de-mystifying the myths that we tell ourselves”, that “To try to be more than human is to become less than human”, and that “Lewis wanted above all to remind us that our very reality, our very life, depended on the life and reality of God.”153
The scholarship has run in two streams that rarely meet. The biographical and literary stream begins with Walsh (1949) and the memorial volume Light on C. S. Lewis (1965), in which Barfield, Farrer, Coghill, Lawlor, Bennett and Kathleen Raine wrote; continues through Green and Hooper’s authorised biography (1974; revised 2002), Carnell’s Bright Shadow of Reality (1974), the first monograph on Joy, Carpenter’s The Inklings (1978), Lionel Adey’s study of the Great War (1978), Hooper’s edition of the Greeves letters (1979), George Sayer’s Jack (1988), A. N. Wilson’s biography (1990), which raised the question of Mrs Moore, David Downing’s Planets in Peril (1992) and Into the Region of Awe: Mysticism in C. S. Lewis (2005), Hooper’s Companion and Guide (1996), the Collected Letters (2000–06), Alan Jacobs’s The Narnian (2005), Diana Glyer’s The Company They Keep (2007), Michael Ward’s Planet Narnia (2008), Adam Barkman’s survey of Lewis’s philosophical reading (2009), The Cambridge Companion to C. S. Lewis (2010), Alister McGrath’s biography (2013), which redated the conversion, with his Intellectual World of C. S. Lewis (2014), Grevel Lindop’s life of Williams (2015), the Zaleskis’ The Fellowship (2015), Feinendegen and Smilde’s edition of the Great War (2015), Stephanie Derrick’s The Fame of C. S. Lewis (2018), Ward’s After Humanity (2021) and James Bryson’s study of “It’s all in Plato” (2021); with Arend Smilde’s annotations at lewisiana.nl and Norbert Feinendegen’s Denk-Weg zu Christus (2008) as the continental pillars. The Lindskoog affair of 1978–2003, discussed in the Life, belongs to its history. The other stream, the academic study of Western esotericism, has passed him by: neither Yates, nor Walker, nor Brian Vickers, nor Wouter Hanegraaff’s Esotericism and the Academy cites him, and the thesis of the twins, stated in 1943 and documented in 1954, has no place in the historiography of the Yates thesis. What exists on the esoteric side is small: Thomas Garrett Isham’s “C. S. Lewis and the Occult Temptation” (2016), which observes that “Twice in his life C. S. Lewis encountered — and greatly admired — authors involved in occult theory and practice”, Yeats and Williams, and that “Lewis reacted to their occult preoccupations in quite different ways, even while acknowledging his continuing fascination with the subject”; Lindop on Williams’s Rosy Cross and the symposium on his book in the Journal of Inklings Studies (2016); Adey (1978), Stephen Thorson’s Joy and Poetic Imagination (2015) and the Feinendegen–Smilde edition on Barfield and Anthroposophy; Downing on mysticism; John West’s collection The Magician’s Twin (2012) on scientism; Paul Gosselin on Narnia’s magic as miraculous rather than occult; and, from the other side of the fence, Gareth Knight’s The Magical World of the Inklings (1990; revised 2010), a reading of Lewis, Tolkien, Williams and Barfield by a practising esotericist of the Society of the Inner Light, which is the one place where Lewis is claimed for the esoteric tradition. His own hostility is the constant; as George Sayer put it, “the fact that Lewis included witches certainly did not mean” “that he believed in their power in real life”. No scholar describes him as a Christian Hermeticist, and the term, which belongs to the readers of Valentin Tomberg’s Meditations on the Tarot, does not apply to him.154
The institutions are many and old. The New York C. S. Lewis Society, chartered on 12 December 1969, “the oldest society for the appreciation and discussion of C.S. Lewis in the world” by its own account, meets monthly and publishes CSL; the Oxford C. S. Lewis Society, founded in 1982, meets weekly in term at Pusey House; the C. S. Lewis Foundation of Redlands, California, keeps The Kilns as a study centre and runs the triennial Oxbridge institute. The journals are VII, published by the Marion E. Wade Center at Wheaton College since 1980; Mythlore, of the Mythopoeic Society, since 1969; the Journal of Inklings Studies, grown from the Oxford society’s Chronicle and published by Edinburgh University Press under Judith Wolfe, with its supplement series; Sehnsucht: The C. S. Lewis Journal, since 2007, whose issue of 2026 prints the papers of the inaugural “Undiscovered C. S. Lewis” conference, among them Holly Ordway on what Tolkien really thought of Narnia and Hannah Roux on Eliot’s silence towards Lewis; and the proceedings of the Taylor University colloquium. The archive is the Wade Center, founded by Clyde S. Kilby in 1965 for seven authors — Barfield, Chesterton, Lewis, MacDonald, Sayers, Tolkien and Williams — which holds Lewis’s wardrobe and desk and the manuscripts, with the Bodleian for the papers deposited by the Estate. The memorial in Poets’ Corner, a stone by Wayne Hart dedicated by the Dean on 22 November 2013 at Michael Ward’s request, with Rowan Williams’s address, readings by Francis Warner, Helen Cooper and Douglas Gresham, and a recording of Lewis reading from “The New Men”, fixed his standing in the national literature; the papers of the symposium held that day appeared as C. S. Lewis at Poets’ Corner (2016). The works entered the public domain in Canada and other life-plus-fifty jurisdictions in 2014; in Britain, Europe and the United States they remain in copyright, licensed by the Estate through HarperCollins. A Netflix film of The Magician’s Nephew, written and directed by Greta Gerwig, was filmed in 2025–26 and is announced for release in 2027.155
What he leaves to the history of esotericism is less a doctrine than a vantage-point. He expounded the medieval cosmos from inside, as a lover of the Model and a believer in much of it, and so described the world the Renaissance magi inherited more fully than most of those who have written about the magi; he saw in 1943, before the Warburg historians, that their magia and the new science were born together; he rebuilt the planetary intelligences, the daemons of the middle air and the ladder of Platonic desire as fiction, and put a magician, a séance and a materialist magician at the centre of three of his books; and he refused, from boyhood to widowhood, every form of the appetite for hidden power, having felt it himself, watched it destroy a man he knew, and fought it for five years in the Anthroposophy of his dearest friend. Screwtape’s Materialist Magician, the man who worships what he calls Forces while denying the existence of spirits, remains his contribution to the diagnosis of modern occultism.
Bibliography#
Primary#
Lewis, C. S. [as Clive Hamilton]. Spirits in Bondage: A Cycle of Lyrics. London: Heinemann, 1919.
——. [as Clive Hamilton]. Dymer. London: J. M. Dent, 1926. Reissued under the author’s name with a new preface, 1950.
——. The Pilgrim’s Regress: An Allegorical Apology for Christianity, Reason and Romanticism. London: J. M. Dent, 1933. 3rd edn, with preface, London: Geoffrey Bles, 1943. Wade Annotated Edition, ed. David C. Downing, Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2014.
——. The Allegory of Love: A Study in Medieval Tradition. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1936.
——. Out of the Silent Planet. London: John Lane The Bodley Head, 1938.
——. Rehabilitations and Other Essays. London: Oxford University Press, 1939.
——, and E. M. W. Tillyard. The Personal Heresy: A Controversy. London: Oxford University Press, 1939.
——. The Problem of Pain. London: The Centenary Press, 1940.
——. The Screwtape Letters. London: Geoffrey Bles, 1942. With Screwtape Proposes a Toast and a new preface, Bles, 1961.
——. Broadcast Talks. London: Geoffrey Bles, 1942. Christian Behaviour. Bles, 1943. Beyond Personality: The Christian Idea of God. Bles, 1944. Collected as Mere Christianity. Bles, 1952.
——. A Preface to Paradise Lost. London: Oxford University Press, 1942.
——. Perelandra. London: John Lane The Bodley Head, 1943. As Voyage to Venus, London: Pan, 1953.
——. The Abolition of Man, or Reflections on Education with Special Reference to the Teaching of English in the Upper Forms of Schools. London: Oxford University Press, 1943. 2nd edn, Bles, 1946.
——. That Hideous Strength: A Modern Fairy-Tale for Grown-Ups. London: John Lane The Bodley Head, 1945. Abridged, London: Pan, 1955.
——. The Great Divorce: A Dream. London: Geoffrey Bles, 1945 [1946].
——, ed. George MacDonald: An Anthology. London: Geoffrey Bles, 1946.
——. Miracles: A Preliminary Study. London: Geoffrey Bles, 1947. Revised edn, London: Fontana, 1960.
——, ed. Essays Presented to Charles Williams. London: Oxford University Press, 1947.
——, and Charles Williams. Arthurian Torso. London: Oxford University Press, 1948.
——. Transposition and Other Addresses. London: Geoffrey Bles, 1949. As The Weight of Glory and Other Addresses, New York: Macmillan, 1949; enlarged, ed. Walter Hooper, 1980.
——. The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe. London: Geoffrey Bles, 1950.
——. Prince Caspian: The Return to Narnia. London: Geoffrey Bles, 1951.
——. The Voyage of the Dawn Treader. London: Geoffrey Bles, 1952.
——. The Silver Chair. London: Geoffrey Bles, 1953.
——. The Horse and His Boy. London: Geoffrey Bles, 1954.
——. English Literature in the Sixteenth Century Excluding Drama. The Oxford History of English Literature, vol. III. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1954.
——. De Descriptione Temporum: An Inaugural Lecture. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1955.
——. The Magician’s Nephew. London: The Bodley Head, 1955.
——. Surprised by Joy: The Shape of My Early Life. London: Geoffrey Bles, 1955.
——. The Last Battle. London: The Bodley Head, 1956.
——. Till We Have Faces: A Myth Retold. London: Geoffrey Bles, 1956.
——. Reflections on the Psalms. London: Geoffrey Bles, 1958.
——. The Four Loves. London: Geoffrey Bles, 1960.
——. Studies in Words. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1960. 2nd edn, 1967.
——. The World’s Last Night and Other Essays. New York: Harcourt, Brace, 1960.
——. [as N. W. Clerk]. A Grief Observed. London: Faber and Faber, 1961.
——. An Experiment in Criticism. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1961.
——. They Asked for a Paper: Papers and Addresses. London: Geoffrey Bles, 1962.
——. Letters to Malcolm: Chiefly on Prayer. London: Geoffrey Bles, 1964.
——. The Discarded Image: An Introduction to Medieval and Renaissance Literature. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1964.
——. Poems. Ed. Walter Hooper. London: Geoffrey Bles, 1964.
——. Screwtape Proposes a Toast and Other Pieces. London: Fontana, 1965.
——. Letters of C. S. Lewis. Ed. W. H. Lewis. London: Geoffrey Bles, 1966. Revised edn, ed. Walter Hooper, London: Fount, 1988.
——. Of Other Worlds: Essays and Stories. Ed. Walter Hooper. London: Geoffrey Bles, 1966.
——. Studies in Medieval and Renaissance Literature. Ed. Walter Hooper. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1966.
——. Christian Reflections. Ed. Walter Hooper. London: Geoffrey Bles, 1967.
——. Letters to an American Lady. Ed. Clyde S. Kilby. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1967.
——. Spenser’s Images of Life. Ed. Alastair Fowler. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1967.
——. Narrative Poems. Ed. Walter Hooper. London: Geoffrey Bles, 1969.
——. Selected Literary Essays. Ed. Walter Hooper. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1969.
——. God in the Dock: Essays on Theology and Ethics. Ed. Walter Hooper. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1970. As Undeceptions, London: Geoffrey Bles, 1971.
——. Fern-seed and Elephants and Other Essays on Christianity. Ed. Walter Hooper. London: Fontana, 1975.
——. The Dark Tower and Other Stories. Ed. Walter Hooper. London: Collins, 1977.
——. They Stand Together: The Letters of C. S. Lewis to Arthur Greeves (1914–1963). Ed. Walter Hooper. London: Collins, 1979.
——. Boxen: The Imaginary World of the Young C. S. Lewis. Ed. Walter Hooper. London: Collins, 1985. Enlarged as Boxen: Childhood Chronicles Before Narnia, London: HarperCollins, 2008.
——. Letters to Children. Ed. Lyle W. Dorsett and Marjorie Lamp Mead. London: Fount, 1985.
——. Present Concerns. Ed. Walter Hooper. London: Fount, 1986.
——. All My Road Before Me: The Diary of C. S. Lewis 1922–1927. Ed. Walter Hooper. London: HarperCollins, 1991.
——. The Collected Poems of C. S. Lewis. Ed. Walter Hooper. London: Fount, 1994. Critical edition, ed. Don W. King, Kent, OH: Kent State University Press, 2015.
——. Essay Collection and Other Short Pieces. Ed. Lesley Walmsley. London: HarperCollins, 2000.
——. The Collected Letters of C. S. Lewis. Ed. Walter Hooper. 3 vols. London: HarperCollins, 2000–2006.
——. Image and Imagination: Essays and Reviews. Ed. Walter Hooper. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2013.
——, and Owen Barfield. The “Great War” of Owen Barfield and C. S. Lewis: Philosophical Writings 1927–1930. Ed. Norbert Feinendegen and Arend Smilde. Inklings Studies Supplements 1. Oxford: Journal of Inklings Studies, 2015.
Secondary#
Adey, Lionel. C. S. Lewis’s “Great War” with Owen Barfield. English Literary Studies Monographs 14. Victoria, BC: University of Victoria, 1978.
Anscombe, G. E. M. “A Reply to Mr. C. S. Lewis’s Argument that ‘Naturalism’ is Self-Refuting.” The Socratic Digest 4 (1948). Reprinted in Metaphysics and the Philosophy of Mind: Collected Philosophical Papers, vol. 2. Oxford: Blackwell, 1981.
Barfield, Owen. Poetic Diction: A Study in Meaning. London: Faber & Gwyer, 1928.
——. Owen Barfield on C. S. Lewis. Ed. G. B. Tennyson. Middletown, CT: Wesleyan University Press, 1989.
Barkman, Adam. C. S. Lewis and Philosophy as a Way of Life. Allentown, PA: Zossima Press, 2009.
Barker, Nicolas. Review of The C. S. Lewis Hoax. Essays in Criticism 40 (1990).
Beversluis, John. C. S. Lewis and the Search for Rational Religion. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1985. Revised edn, Amherst, NY: Prometheus, 2007.
Birzer, Bradley J. J. R. R. Tolkien’s Sanctifying Myth: Understanding Middle-earth. Wilmington, DE: ISI Books, 2002.
Brown, Devin. A Life Observed: A Spiritual Biography of C. S. Lewis. Grand Rapids: Brazos, 2013.
Bryson, James. “‘It’s All in Plato’: Platonism, Cambridge Platonism, and C. S. Lewis.” Journal of Inklings Studies 11 (2021).
Carnell, Corbin Scott. Bright Shadow of Reality: C. S. Lewis and the Feeling Intellect. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1974.
Carpenter, Humphrey. The Inklings: C. S. Lewis, J. R. R. Tolkien, Charles Williams and Their Friends. London: Allen & Unwin, 1978.
Derrick, Stephanie L. The Fame of C. S. Lewis: A Controversialist’s Reception in Britain and America. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2018.
Donaldson, E. Talbot. “The Myth of Courtly Love.” Ventures 5 (1965).
Donaldson, Mara E. Holy Places Are Dark Places: C. S. Lewis and Paul Ricoeur on Narrative Transformation. Lanham, MD: University Press of America, 1988.
Dorsett, Lyle W. And God Came In. New York: Macmillan, 1983.
Downing, David C. Planets in Peril: A Critical Study of C. S. Lewis’s Ransom Trilogy. Amherst: University of Massachusetts Press, 1992.
——. The Most Reluctant Convert: C. S. Lewis’s Journey to Faith. Downers Grove: InterVarsity, 2002.
——. Into the Region of Awe: Mysticism in C. S. Lewis. Downers Grove: InterVarsity, 2005.
Dronke, Peter. Medieval Latin and the Rise of European Love-Lyric. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1965.
Dyer, Justin Buckley, and Micah J. Watson. C. S. Lewis on Politics and the Natural Law. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2016.
Ellrodt, Robert. Neoplatonism in the Poetry of Spenser. Geneva: Droz, 1960.
Empson, William. Milton’s God. London: Chatto & Windus, 1961.
Farrer, Austin. “The Christian Apologist.” In Light on C. S. Lewis, ed. Jocelyn Gibb, 23–43. London: Geoffrey Bles, 1965.
Feinendegen, Norbert. Denk-Weg zu Christus: C. S. Lewis als kritischer Denker der Moderne. Regensburg: Pustet, 2008.
Ford, Paul F. Companion to Narnia. San Francisco: Harper & Row, 1980. 5th edn, HarperSanFrancisco, 2005.
Fowler, Alastair. “C. S. Lewis: Supervisor.” Yale Review 91 (2003).
Gardner, Helen. A Reading of Paradise Lost. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1965.
Glyer, Diana Pavlac. The Company They Keep: C. S. Lewis and J. R. R. Tolkien as Writers in Community. Kent, OH: Kent State University Press, 2007.
Green, Roger Lancelyn, and Walter Hooper. C. S. Lewis: A Biography. London: Collins, 1974. Revised edn, London: HarperCollins, 2002.
Gosselin, Paul. “C. S. Lewis et l’occulte.” Samizdat, samizdat.qc.ca.
Haldane, J. B. S. “Auld Hornie, F.R.S.” The Modern Quarterly, n.s. 1 (Autumn 1946).
Hasker, William. The Emergent Self. Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 1999.
Heck, Joel D. Chronologically Lewis. Online chronology, joelheck.com.
Hooper, Walter. Past Watchful Dragons: The Narnian Chronicles of C. S. Lewis. New York: Macmillan, 1979.
——. C. S. Lewis: A Companion and Guide. London: HarperCollins, 1996.
Isham, Thomas Garrett. “C. S. Lewis and the Occult Temptation.” Sehnsucht: The C. S. Lewis Journal 10 (2016).
Jacobs, Alan. The Narnian: The Life and Imagination of C. S. Lewis. San Francisco: HarperSanFrancisco, 2005.
King, Don W. C. S. Lewis, Poet: The Legacy of His Poetic Impulse. Kent, OH: Kent State University Press, 2001.
Knight, Gareth. The Magical World of the Inklings. Shaftesbury: Element, 1990. Revised edn, Cheltenham: Skylight Press, 2010.
Lazo, Andrew, ed. “Early Prose Joy.” VII: An Anglo-American Literary Review 30 (2013).
Lepojärvi, Jason. God Is Love but Love Is Not God: Studies on C. S. Lewis’s Theology of Love. Helsinki: University of Helsinki, 2015.
Lindop, Grevel. Charles Williams: The Third Inkling. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2015.
Lindskoog, Kathryn. The Lion of Judah in Never-Never Land: The Theology of C. S. Lewis Expressed in His Fantasies for Children. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1973.
——. The C. S. Lewis Hoax. Portland: Multnomah, 1988.
——. Light in the Shadowlands: Protecting the Real C. S. Lewis. Sisters, OR: Multnomah, 1994.
——. Finding the Landlord: A Guidebook to C. S. Lewis’s Pilgrim’s Regress. Chicago: Cornerstone, 1995.
——. Sleuthing C. S. Lewis: More Light in the Shadowlands. Macon, GA: Mercer University Press, 2001.
MacSwain, Robert, and Michael Ward, eds. The Cambridge Companion to C. S. Lewis. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2010.
Marsden, George M. C. S. Lewis’s Mere Christianity: A Biography. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2016.
McGrath, Alister. C. S. Lewis — A Life: Eccentric Genius, Reluctant Prophet. London: Hodder & Stoughton, 2013.
——. The Intellectual World of C. S. Lewis. Oxford: Wiley-Blackwell, 2014.
Mosteller, Timothy M., and Gayne John Anacker, eds. Contemporary Perspectives on C. S. Lewis’s The Abolition of Man: History, Philosophy, Education, and Science. London: Bloomsbury, 2017.
Myers, Doris T. C. S. Lewis in Context. Kent, OH: Kent State University Press, 1994.
——. Bareface: A Guide to C. S. Lewis’s Last Novel. Columbia: University of Missouri Press, 2004.
Nott, Kathleen. The Emperor’s Clothes. London: Heinemann, 1953.
Orwell, George. “The Scientists Take Over.” Manchester Evening News, 16 August 1945. Reprinted in The Complete Works of George Orwell, ed. Peter Davison, vol. XVII. London: Secker & Warburg, 1998.
Plantinga, Alvin. Warrant and Proper Function. New York: Oxford University Press, 1993.
Reppert, Victor. C. S. Lewis’s Dangerous Idea: In Defense of the Argument from Reason. Downers Grove: InterVarsity, 2003.
Robertson, D. W., Jr. “The Concept of Courtly Love as an Impediment to the Understanding of Medieval Texts.” In The Meaning of Courtly Love, ed. F. X. Newman. Albany: SUNY Press, 1968.
Root, Jerry, and others. Splendour in the Dark: C. S. Lewis’s Dymer in His Life and Work. Downers Grove: InterVarsity, 2020.
Rose, Mary Carman. “The Christian Platonism of C. S. Lewis, J. R. R. Tolkien, and Charles Williams.” In Neoplatonism and Christian Thought, ed. Dominic J. O’Meara. Albany: State University of New York Press, 1982.
Sammons, Martha C. A Guide Through C. S. Lewis’ Space Trilogy. Westchester, IL: Cornerstone, 1980.
Sayer, George. Jack: C. S. Lewis and His Times. London: Macmillan, 1988. 2nd edn, 1997.
Schakel, Peter J. Reading with the Heart: The Way into Narnia. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1979.
——. Reason and Imagination in C. S. Lewis: A Study of Till We Have Faces. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1984.
——. Imagination and the Arts in C. S. Lewis: Journeying to Narnia and Other Worlds. Columbia: University of Missouri Press, 2002.
Schwartz, Sanford. C. S. Lewis on the Final Frontier: Science and the Supernatural in the Space Trilogy. New York: Oxford University Press, 2009.
Smilde, Arend. Lewisiana. Annotations, bibliographies and translations, lewisiana.nl.
Starr, Charlie W. Light: C. S. Lewis’s First and Final Short Story. Hamden, CT: Winged Lion Press, 2012.
Starr, Charlie W. “C. S. Lewis’s (Theistic) Conversion Era Poetry.” North Wind Institute, online.
Thorson, Stephen. Joy and Poetic Imagination: Understanding C. S. Lewis’s “Great War” with Owen Barfield and Its Significance for Lewis’s Conversion and Writings. Hamden, CT: Winged Lion Press, 2015.
Tolkien, J. R. R. The Letters of J. R. R. Tolkien. Ed. Humphrey Carpenter with Christopher Tolkien. London: Allen & Unwin, 1981.
Waldock, A. J. A. Paradise Lost and Its Critics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1947.
Walker, Andrew. “Scripture, Revelation and Platonism in C. S. Lewis.” Scottish Journal of Theology 55 (2002).
Walsh, Chad. C. S. Lewis: Apostle to the Skeptics. New York: Macmillan, 1949.
——. The Literary Legacy of C. S. Lewis. New York: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, 1979.
Ward, Michael. Planet Narnia: The Seven Heavens in the Imagination of C. S. Lewis. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2008.
——. The Narnia Code: C. S. Lewis and the Secret of the Seven Heavens. Carlisle: Paternoster, 2010.
——. After Humanity: A Guide to C. S. Lewis’s The Abolition of Man. Park Ridge, IL: Word on Fire Academic, 2021.
——, and Peter S. Williams, eds. C. S. Lewis at Poets’ Corner. Eugene, OR: Wipf & Stock, 2016.
West, John G., ed. The Magician’s Twin: C. S. Lewis on Science, Scientism, and Society. Seattle: Discovery Institute Press, 2012.
White, Roger, Judith Wolfe and Brendan Wolfe, eds. C. S. Lewis and His Circle: Essays and Memoirs from the Oxford C. S. Lewis Society. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2015.
Wilson, A. N. C. S. Lewis: A Biography. London: Collins, 1990.
Zaleski, Philip, and Carol Zaleski. The Fellowship: The Literary Lives of the Inklings. New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 2015.
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
12 questions grounded in this entry open directly in Socrates with C. S. Lewis as the reading context.
Life and Intellectual Formation
- How did Lewis’s early attraction to the occult shape his later refusal of occult practice?→
- What did Lewis learn from Barfield while continuing to resist Anthroposophy?→
- Why does the entry distinguish Lewis’s acceptance of theism from his later conversion to Christianity?→
- How do Lewis’s roles as scholar, apologist, and novelist illuminate one another rather than form separate careers?→
Desire, Reality, and Value
- How does Lewis distinguish Joy from both ordinary satisfaction and the objects that awaken desire?→
- What does transposition explain about the relation between higher and lower levels of experience?→
- Why does Lewis think the attempt to invent values leads to the abolition of the human being?→
- In what sense does Lewis call Renaissance magic and modern science twins, and where does his criticism fall?→
Fiction, Scholarship, and Interpretation
- How does Lewis’s account of Narnia beginning with images complicate a reading of the books as a predetermined allegorical scheme?→
- What evidence and qualifications does the entry give for the planetary interpretation of Narnia?→
- How does making Psyche’s palace invisible alter the problem of love and belief in Till We Have Faces?→
- How can Lewis expound the medieval Model from within while also treating it as historically discarded?→
Source ApparatusNotes155 notes
- ↩
Dates from Joel D. Heck, Chronologically Lewis (joelheck.com), the chronology at cslewistour.uk, and the Surprised by Joy chapters I–II; the parents’ dates from the Dundela Villas page of the same site; the gravestone from Heck’s photographic tour of Holy Trinity, Headington Quarry. The story that “Jacksie” was the name of a dog killed by a vehicle is family tradition, not anything Lewis wrote. Flora’s death: Heck, Chronologically Lewis, under 23 August 1908, quoting the family calendar.
- ↩
Surprised by Joy: The Shape of My Early Life (London: Geoffrey Bles, 1955), ch. IV, “I Broaden My Mind”, pp. 62–63 and 68, quoted from the Bles text. The matron is identified as Miss G. E. Cowie by Walter Hooper; Lewis calls her “Miss C.” The novel in which he “once tried to describe” the passion for the occult is not named; That Hideous Strength (1945), whose Belbury is built on exactly that appetite, is the usual identification. The dates of Lewis’s schools are Heck’s.
- ↩
Lewis to Arthur Greeves, spring 1914 and 7 March 1916, The Collected Letters of C. S. Lewis, ed. Walter Hooper, 3 vols (London: HarperCollins, 2000–06), I, 57 and 169–70 (the date of the purchase, Saturday 4 March 1916, is fixed by the letter; Surprised by Joy, ch. XI, places the evening in October, a memory slip); preface to George MacDonald: An Anthology (London: Bles, 1946), quoted with the American spelling “baptize”; Surprised by Joy, ch. XI, quoted from the American edition (New York: Harcourt, Brace, 1955), whose “baptized” the Bles text prints as “baptised”. Kirkpatrick: Surprised by Joy, ch. IX, “The Great Knock”; dates from Heck and cslewistour.uk (19 September 1914 is Hooper’s date; Heck’s “9 September” is a slip).
- ↩
The war service, wound and hospitals from Heck and cslewistour.uk; Paddy Moore’s death at Pargny on 24 March 1918 from the Wicklow heritage record on the Moores (John Hayes, Irish University Review, 2009). The pact is reported by Maureen Moore through George Sayer, Jack: C. S. Lewis and His Times (London: Macmillan, 1988). On the relationship: Sayer, in the 1997 edition, “quite certain”; A. N. Wilson, C. S. Lewis: A Biography (London: Collins, 1990), assuming it; Hooper and Alister McGrath, C. S. Lewis: A Life (London: Hodder, 2013), doubtful; the 1947 Time cover story already reported that “One persistent rumor identifies the ‘mother’ as a Mrs. Moore”. Mrs Moore (1872–1951) separated from Courtenay Moore in 1908; the household moved to The Kilns on 11 October 1930 and she died on 12 January 1951. Degrees and prize: University College’s own notice and the Foundation chronology.
- ↩
Lewis to Greeves, 1920 (Baker), Collected Letters, I; to Albert Lewis, 19 March 1921, and to Warren Lewis, 21 March 1921, Collected Letters, I, 524–25 and following; the two Oxford visits were in March 1921, a week apart. “Kod” is Lewis’s family word for a humbug. Surprised by Joy, ch. XIII, p. 175 of the American edition. The Doc: All My Road Before Me: The Diary of C. S. Lewis 1922–1927, ed. Hooper (London: HarperCollins, 1991), February–April 1923, as reported by David C. Downing, The Most Reluctant Convert (Downers Grove: InterVarsity, 2002), p. 112, and by Nancy-Lou Patterson’s review of the diary in Mythlore (1992), which notes the discrepancy between the diary’s medical diagnosis and the autobiography’s moral; the sentences of ch. XIII on the Doc are paraphrased.
- ↩
Heck, “The Life of Lewis” (joelheck.com), for the election, the telegram and the five-year fellowship at £500; the Magdalene College archive record gives “Fellow and Tutor of Magdalen College, Oxford, 1925–1954”. Dymer (London: J. M. Dent, 1926), reissued under Lewis’s name with a new preface in 1950. The diary entry on Tolkien, 11 May 1926, All My Road Before Me (Colin Duriez’s article in Christian History 78 misprints the date as March). On the Inklings’ name, the first documented meeting (26 March 1934) and the last Thursday evening (20 October 1949): Humphrey Carpenter, The Inklings (London: Allen & Unwin, 1978), and Tolkien’s letter of 1967 (no. 298 in The Letters of J. R. R. Tolkien).
- ↩
The Allegory of Love (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1936), dedication; the diary note on Barfield, All My Road Before Me, p. 278; Surprised by Joy, ch. XIII, pp. 207–08 of the American edition, with its “forever”; Owen Barfield, “C. S. Lewis and Historicism” and his remarks of 1976 in The Golden Blade, as reproduced by the Owen Barfield Literary Estate. The documents of the dispute: The “Great War” of Owen Barfield and C. S. Lewis: Philosophical Writings 1927–1930, ed. Norbert Feinendegen and Arend Smilde, Inklings Studies Supplement 1 (Oxford: Journal of Inklings Studies, 2015); Lewis’s letters in the dispute are printed in the appendix to Collected Letters, III. Harwood: Laurence Harwood, C. S. Lewis, My Godfather (2007), as summarised in the reference accounts. The attribution to Lewis of the remark that Steiner’s Philosophy of Spiritual Activity has “a re-assuring Germanic dullness about it”, repeated by R. J. Reilly without citation, has not been traced to its source.
- ↩
Surprised by Joy, ch. XIV (“Checkmate”) and XV (“The Beginning”), quoted from the American edition; Lewis to Greeves, 30 January 1930, Collected Letters, I, 877; to Barfield, early February 1930, I, 882–83; to Greeves, 18 October 1931, I, 976–77, and 1 October 1931, I, 972–74 (“I have just passed on from believing in God to definitely believing in Christ — in Christianity … My long night talk with Dyson and Tolkien had a good deal to do with it”). The redating: McGrath, C. S. Lewis: A Life, p. 146, and The Intellectual World of C. S. Lewis (Oxford: Wiley-Blackwell, 2014), ch. 1; Andrew Lazo, from the manuscript “Early Prose Joy” (2012–13); Charlie W. Starr, “C. S. Lewis’s (Theistic) Conversion Era Poetry” (North Wind Institute), summarising both; Arend Smilde’s notes on Surprised by Joy at lewisiana.nl concur (“The year must in fact have been 1930”). Albert Lewis’s death: 25 September 1929 by Hooper’s and McGrath’s dating; Heck and the Foundation chronology give the 24th. Whipsnade: 28 September 1931 (Heck; McGrath); the “22 September” of some summaries is wrong; McGrath’s further suggestion that the autobiography conflates the ride with a car trip in the bluebell season of 1932 is, as Smilde says, inconclusive. The Boehme letter to Greeves of 1930 is in They Stand Together: The Letters of C. S. Lewis to Arthur Greeves, ed. Hooper (London: Collins, 1979), and Collected Letters, I; its substance (that The Signature of All Things had shaken him as no book had since Phantastes) is given as the standard accounts report it. The Pilgrim’s Regress was written in August 1932 and published by Dent on 25 May 1933.
- ↩
The Gollancz Prize: the British Academy’s list for 1937; the Hawthornden claim (Contemporary Authors; the Dictionary of Ulster Biography) is an error, that prize’s list naming Evelyn Waugh for 1936 and Ruth Pitter for 1937. Lewis to Williams, 11 March 1936, and Williams’s reply of 12 March, Collected Letters, II; Lewis to Barfield, May 1945, Collected Letters, II. Williams’s initiation on 21 September 1917 and his later concealment: Grevel Lindop, Charles Williams: The Third Inkling (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2015), with Sørina Higgins’s review (Books & Culture, 2016). Essays Presented to Charles Williams, ed. Lewis (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1947), and Arthurian Torso (Oxford University Press, 21 October 1948).
- ↩
The war years from Heck and the Foundation chronology; the broadcast dates (6 August 1941; 11 January 1942; autumn 1942; 22 February – 4 April 1944) from cslewistour.uk; the serial of Screwtape in The Guardian, 2 May – 28 November 1941; Time, “Religion: Don v. Devil”, 8 September 1947. The Socratic Club’s first meeting was 26 January 1942. Anscombe: her paper is printed in the Socratic Digest 4 (1948) and in her Collected Philosophical Papers, vol. 2 (Oxford: Blackwell, 1981), whose introduction gives her recollection; Lewis’s concession (“I admit that valid was a bad word for what I meant; veridical (or verific or veriferous) would have been better”) in the same Digest; Derek Brewer’s diary, quoted by Carpenter, The Inklings, records that “Lewis was obviously deeply disturbed by his encounter last Monday with Miss Anscombe”; Lewis to Stella Aldwinckle, 12 June 1950, Collected Letters, III. The legend: Carpenter; Sayer, Jack; Wilson. The correction: Victor Reppert, C. S. Lewis’s Dangerous Idea (Downers Grove: InterVarsity, 2003), and the Lewis Estate’s “Dispelling Myths” page, which counts some thirty-four further apologetic essays.
- ↩
The St Andrews citation from the university’s collections blog (the ceremony was in June 1946, not March); the other degrees from Contemporary Authors and cslewistour.uk; Lewis to the Prime Minister’s secretary, 4 December 1951, Collected Letters, III, 147; the Cambridge election of 4 June 1954 and the inaugural from the Magdalene College archive and Heck. The Carnegie Medal for The Last Battle (1956) was awarded in 1957. The statement that he at first declined the chair and that it was offered to Helen Gardner before he accepted is the standard account.
- ↩
Joy Davidman (1915–1960): Heck, “Life of Lewis in Seven Pages”; the Foundation chronology; Lyle Dorsett, And God Came In (New York: Macmillan, 1983). The first meeting, a lunch at the Eastgate Hotel on 24 September 1952, is Hooper’s date; the register-office marriage of 23 April 1956 (Lewis’s phrase about it is from a letter of 1956 as quoted in the standard accounts); the bedside marriage of 21 March 1957 at the Wingfield-Morris Orthopaedic Hospital, Headington, as Bide’s own memoir and cslewistour.uk give it (the “Churchill Hospital” of some accounts is wrong, and McGrath’s “24 April 1957” a slip). A Grief Observed (London: Faber & Faber, 29 September 1961), as N. W. Clerk.
- ↩
Heck; the Magdalene College archive (“He was made an Honorary Fellow in 1963 and died on 22 November 1963”); Tolkien to Priscilla Tolkien, 26 November 1963 (Tolkien Estate), which fixes the funeral on the 26th (cslewistour.uk’s “27 November” is wrong); the heart attack on 16 July 1963 (some accounts say the 15th, the day of admission). Hooper (1931–2020): the standard accounts, with the publication dates of the posthumous volumes from cslewistour.uk. The Lindskoog affair: Kathryn Lindskoog, The C. S. Lewis Hoax (Portland: Multnomah, 1988), Light in the Shadowlands (1994) and Sleuthing C. S. Lewis (Macon: Mercer University Press, 2001); against her, Nicolas Barker in Essays in Criticism (1990), Alastair Fowler, “C. S. Lewis: Supervisor”, Yale Review 91 (2003), who recalled being shown The Dark Tower in 1952, and Harry Lee Poe’s article on the question in Christianity Today (2007); the stylometric studies of Carla Faust Jones (1989) and Thompson and Rasp (2009), and John Rateliff’s dating of the fragment to about 1946, are reported in the reference accounts of the fragment. Poets’ Corner: the Abbey’s commemoration page, which gives the inscription.
- ↩
Surprised by Joy, ch. I, “The First Years”, quoted from the Bles text. Sehnsucht: The C. S. Lewis Journal has been published since 2007 by the Arizona C. S. Lewis Society. The first monograph on the concept is Corbin Scott Carnell, Bright Shadow of Reality: C. S. Lewis and the Feeling Intellect (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1974).
- ↩
The Pilgrim’s Regress, 3rd edn (London: Geoffrey Bles, 1943), preface; “The Weight of Glory”, preached at St Mary the Virgin, Oxford, 8 June 1941, printed in Theology, November 1941, and in Transposition and Other Addresses (London: Bles, 1949), quoted from the American edition The Weight of Glory and Other Addresses (New York: Macmillan, 1949); Mere Christianity (London: Bles, 1952), Book III, ch. 10, “Hope” (the sentence as printed in the standard anthologies); The Problem of Pain (London: The Centenary Press, 1940), ch. X, “Heaven”.
- ↩
Surprised by Joy, ch. XIV, “Checkmate”; Samuel Alexander, Space, Time and Deity (London: Macmillan, 1920), which Lewis began reading in March 1924 according to the diary. The “signposts” passage of ch. XV, which says that after his conversion the subject of Joy lost nearly all interest for him, is paraphrased.
- ↩
Lewis to Greeves, 22 September, 1 October and 18 October 1931, Collected Letters, I, 970, 972–74 and 976–77; “Myth Became Fact”, World Dominion, September–October 1944, reprinted in God in the Dock, ed. Hooper (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1970) — only its first sentence is quoted, the continuation being paraphrased; “Fern-seed and Elephants”, originally “Modern Theology and Biblical Criticism”, a paper of 11 May 1959 printed in Christian Reflections, ed. Hooper (London: Bles, 1967). The phrase “good dreams” belongs to Mere Christianity, Book II, ch. 3.
- ↩
Surprised by Joy, ch. XIII; That Hideous Strength (London: John Lane, 1945), ch. 12; Owen Barfield, Poetic Diction: A Study in Meaning (London: Faber & Gwyer, 1928); “Bluspels and Flalansferes: A Semantic Nightmare”, in Rehabilitations and Other Essays (London: Oxford University Press, 1939) — its closing formula on reason and imagination is paraphrased, not quoted; preface to The Great Divorce (London: Bles, 1946); J. R. R. Tolkien, “On Fairy-Stories” (Andrew Lang Lecture, 1939), in Essays Presented to Charles Williams (1947), quoted from the edition of Verlyn Flieger and Douglas A. Anderson (London: HarperCollins, 2008), pp. 75 and 78; “Is Theology Poetry?”, read to the Oxford Socratic Club on 6 November 1944 and printed in the Socratic Digest 3 (1945), its last sentence as cut on the Poets’ Corner stone. The letter of 29 December 1958 to Mrs Hook distinguishes allegory from “supposal”.
- ↩
The Discarded Image: An Introduction to Medieval and Renaissance Literature (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1964), pp. 11, 16, 92–99, 122, 138–39, 153, 157, 167, 185 and 203, quoted with the Cambridge pagination. The chapters on the sources (3, “Selected Materials: The Classical Period”; 4, “The Seminal Period”) are summarised.
- ↩
The Discarded Image, Epilogue (paraphrased; the sentence that no model is a catalogue of ultimate realities is at p. 222 of the Cambridge edition) and ch. 5 (the planets’ characters and the Church’s attitude to astrology, paraphrased); “The Alliterative Metre”, Lysistrata, May 1935, reprinted in Rehabilitations (1939), pp. 117–32, quoted from the 1939 text, which prints “The Planets” with Lewis’s scansion marks — the sentence on “spiritual symbols” is often quoted, after Michael Ward, without its source, which is this essay; Ward, “C. S. Lewis and the Star of Bethlehem”, Books & Culture (2008), for the remark that “No Christian theologian before that time denied the general theory of planetary influences” and for Lewis’s lecture joke that those born under Jupiter “are apt to be loud-voiced and red-faced”; That Hideous Strength, chs 13 and 15; Michael Ward, Planet Narnia: The Seven Heavens in the Imagination of C. S. Lewis (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2008); The Voyage of the Dawn Treader (London: Bles, 1952), ch. 14.
- ↩
The Last Battle (London: The Bodley Head, 1956), chs 15–16; The Great Divorce, chs 5 and 9; A Preface to Paradise Lost (London: Oxford University Press, 1942), ch. XI, “Hierarchy”, and ch. XIII, “Satan”, pp. 80 and 106–09 of the 1967 reprint; “Transposition”, a Whit-Sunday sermon in the chapel of Mansfield College, Oxford (28 May 1944 by Hooper’s dating), in Transposition and Other Addresses (1949), expanded in They Asked for a Paper (London: Bles, 1962); the ten books from The Christian Century, 6 June 1962, p. 719. On Lewis’s Christian Platonism: Mary Carman Rose, “The Christian Platonism of C. S. Lewis, J. R. R. Tolkien, and Charles Williams”, in Dominic J. O’Meara (ed.), Neoplatonism and Christian Thought (Albany: SUNY Press, 1982); Andrew Walker, “Scripture, Revelation and Platonism in C. S. Lewis”, Scottish Journal of Theology 55 (2002); Adam Barkman, C. S. Lewis and Philosophy as a Way of Life (Allentown, PA: Zossima Press, 2009); Paul S. Fiddes, “On Theology”, and Mark Edwards, “Classicist”, in The Cambridge Companion to C. S. Lewis, ed. Robert MacSwain and Michael Ward (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2010); James Bryson, “‘It’s All in Plato’: Platonism, Cambridge Platonism, and C. S. Lewis”, Journal of Inklings Studies 11 (2021). Plotinus: English Literature in the Sixteenth Century (1954), introduction; Letters to Malcolm (1964), Letter 12.
- ↩
The Abolition of Man: Reflections on Education with Special Reference to the Teaching of English in the Upper Forms of Schools (London: Oxford University Press, 1943; Bles, 1946), the Riddell Memorial Lectures of the University of Durham, delivered at King’s College, Newcastle, on 24–26 February 1943, quoted from the text of the first edition (“organized” is Lewis’s spelling); Charles Gore, The Philosophy of the Good Life (London: Murray, 1930), suggested as the source of the term by Arend Smilde in his notes on the book at lewisiana.nl, on the strength of Lewis’s letters of January 1940 (Collected Letters, II, 321, 324); “Equality”, The Spectator, 27 August 1943; That Hideous Strength, ch. 7. The eight heads of the appendix and the sources named under them are from the book. Michael Ward, After Humanity: A Guide to C. S. Lewis’s The Abolition of Man (Park Ridge, IL: Word on Fire Academic, 2021), is the full commentary.
- ↩
The Screwtape Letters (London: Bles, 1942), preface dated 5 July 1941, and the preface of 1960 to The Screwtape Letters and Screwtape Proposes a Toast (London: Bles, 1961); Mere Christianity, Book II, ch. 2; That Hideous Strength, chs 9 and 12; English Literature in the Sixteenth Century Excluding Drama (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1954), introduction, quoted from the Clarendon text (“mundana numina” is Agrippa’s phrase). Appendix A of Miracles (1947), “On the Words ‘Spirit’ and ‘Spiritual’”, distinguishes the medieval physiological spirits, the human soul, the supernatural element in man and the Holy Spirit.
- ↩
The Abolition of Man, ch. 3, “The Abolition of Man”; the phrase “magician’s bargain” is Lewis’s, used twice in the chapter.
- ↩
English Literature in the Sixteenth Century, introduction, “New Learning and New Ignorance”, sections on the new magic and on the Platonic theology, quoted from the Clarendon text; the Agrippa citation is to the English Of the Vanitie and Uncertaintie of Artes and Sciences (1569), and Lewis’s reference “(ibid. i. xxxix)” to the De occulta philosophia. Bacon’s phrases are from The Advancement of Learning; Lewis’s “curtesan” preserves the old spelling.
- ↩
D. P. Walker, Spiritual and Demonic Magic from Ficino to Campanella (London: Warburg Institute, 1958); Frances A. Yates, Giordano Bruno and the Hermetic Tradition (London: Routledge, 1964); English Literature in the Sixteenth Century, Introduction. Neither Walker, Yates, Brian Vickers (Occult and Scientific Mentalities in the Renaissance, 1984) nor Wouter Hanegraaff (Esotericism and the Academy, 2012) cites Lewis, so far as their indexes show. That Hideous Strength, chs 1, 9 and 13.
- ↩
Surprised by Joy, chs IV and XIII; The Screwtape Letters, Letter VII; A Grief Observed (London: Faber & Faber, 1961), chs I and II; Miracles: A Preliminary Study (London: Bles, 1947), ch. 11, “Christianity and ‘Religion’”, where Theosophy stands in a list that runs from “the orenda of a savage tribe” through the Stoics, “Bruno and Spinoza”, Hegel, “Wordsworth, Carlyle and Emerson” to “the worship of the life-force” (the list as Arend Smilde’s notes on the chapter record it); The Pilgrim’s Regress, 3rd edn, preface and the Mappa Mundi, whose place-names (Occultica, Theosophica, Anthroposophia, Behmenheim, Zeitgeistheim, Cruelsland, Aphroditopolis among them) are read from the map; Lewis to Barfield, May 1945, and to Phyllis Sandeman, 1952, Collected Letters, II and III. Thomas Garrett Isham, “C. S. Lewis and the Occult Temptation”, Sehnsucht 10 (2016), treats Yeats and Williams as the two occult authors Lewis admired.
- ↩
Letters to Malcolm: Chiefly on Prayer (London: Bles, 1964), Letter 12, the one sentence quoted being as given by James Cutsinger (p. 63 of the Bles edition); the rest of the letter — the diabolical and the pharmacological counterfeits, the voyage and the landfall, the naming of Plotinus, Julian of Norwich and St John of the Cross — is paraphrased after Arend Smilde’s notes. “The Inner Ring”, the Memorial Oration at King’s College, London, 14 December 1944, printed in Transposition and Other Addresses, quoted with the American spelling “skillful”. David C. Downing, Into the Region of Awe: Mysticism in C. S. Lewis (Downers Grove: InterVarsity, 2005), is the study of the subject.
- ↩
Surprised by Joy, chs XIII–XIV; The Problem of Pain, ch. I, quoted from the 1940 Bles text; the reading list of 1929–31 from David C. Downing, Into the Region of Awe, pp. 42–43; Rudolf Otto, Das Heilige (1917), English translation The Idea of the Holy (Oxford, 1923). Boehme: The Signature of All Things, Everyman’s Library (London: Dent, 1912); on Lewis’s letter to Greeves of 1930 about it see the Life, above; Smilde’s notes on Letters to Malcolm (14/10) observe that the letter in question is one of the rare places in Lewis’s later writings where Boehme is mentioned at all.
- ↩
Mere Christianity, Book I, ch. 4 (the Life-Force), and Book II, chs 1–3; the 1960 Screwtape preface; The Pilgrim’s Regress, Book VI (the Pale Men: Mr Neo-Angular, Mr Neo-Classical, Mr Humanist). The sentence of Miracles, ch. 11, that pantheism is the permanent natural bent of the human mind, to which it returns whenever left to itself, and that Platonism, Judaism and Christianity are the only things that have ever resisted it, is paraphrased. Lewis’s position on Gnosticism is described from the texts quoted rather than from his scattered uses of the word.
- ↩
Beyond Personality: The Christian Idea of God (London: Bles, 1944; New York: Macmillan, 1945), chs 4, 5, 9, 10 and 11, now Book IV of Mere Christianity, quoted from the 1945 Macmillan text; “The Weight of Glory” (1941), as above; The Four Loves (London: Bles, 1960), chs 1, 4 and 6; Denis de Rougemont, L’Amour et l’Occident (1939), whose sentence that love ceases to be a demon only when he ceases to be a god Lewis quotes and inverts. On deification in Lewis: the chapters in Michael L. Peterson (ed.), C. S. Lewis and the Christian Worldview (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2020).
- ↩
Spirits in Bondage: A Cycle of Lyrics (London: Heinemann, 1919); Project Gutenberg e-texts 2003 and 23975 (the Gutenberg table of contents omits poems XX and XXII, which are in the body). Heck’s chronology records a few reviews and poor sales; the Poetry Foundation’s biography says it “received no reviews”.
- ↩
Quoted from the Gutenberg text. “Death in Battle” appeared in Reveille, the War Office magazine edited by John Galsworthy, in 1919. The 1918 letter to Greeves on the book’s thesis is in They Stand Together and Collected Letters, I, and is paraphrased.
- ↩
Dymer (London: Dent, 1926; New York: Dutton, 1926); reissued (Dent, 19 October 1950) with the preface; Narrative Poems, ed. Hooper (London: Bles, 1969). The dates of composition are those of the collectors’ bibliography at cslewiseditions.com and of Hooper. Jerry Root and others, Splendour in the Dark: C. S. Lewis’s Dymer in His Life and Work (Downers Grove: InterVarsity, 2020), is the one full study.
- ↩
Quoted from the Dutton printing. The preface of 1950 is quoted as Matthew Surridge reproduces it (Black Gate, 2015); its sentences on the Magician as a figure of occult temptation, and on Lewis’s own overstated dislike of occultism at the time of writing, are paraphrased. The identification of the Magician with Yeats is the Poetry Foundation’s and Hooper’s suggestion, not Lewis’s statement.
- ↩
Poems, ed. Walter Hooper (London: Bles, 1964); Narrative Poems, ed. Hooper (Bles, 1969); The Collected Poems of C. S. Lewis, ed. Hooper (London: Fount, 1994); The Collected Poems of C. S. Lewis: A Critical Edition, ed. Don W. King (Kent, OH: Kent State University Press, 2015); King, C. S. Lewis, Poet: The Legacy of His Poetic Impulse (Kent State University Press, 2001). “The Planets” is quoted from its first printing in “The Alliterative Metre” (1935; Rehabilitations, 1939), “The Turn of the Tide” from Punch (1948); the other poems named are described, not quoted.
- ↩
The Pilgrim’s Regress (London: Dent, 25 May 1933; London and New York: Sheed & Ward, 1935; 3rd edn, London: Bles, 1943); the epigraphs and the contents from the Dent text; the epigraphs of Books Two, Five and Ten (Plato, Dante, Spenser; Pindar, Aeschylus, Milton; Plato, Bernardus Silvestris, William Law) as recorded in Arend Smilde’s notes on the book at lewisiana.nl.
- ↩
Quoted from the text of the Canadian edition and from Smilde’s notes; the identifications (Eschropolis as “ugly city”, Victoriana as Edith Sitwell, “Archtype and Ectype” from Locke, Slikisteinsauga, “Securus te projice” from Confessions VIII.11, “Nella sua voluntade” from Paradiso III) are Smilde’s and Hooper’s.
- ↩
The distribution of the episodes of Book Ten among its chapters, and the identification of the Northern Dragon’s lament with the poem “The Dragon Speaks”, follow Hooper’s summary in C. S. Lewis: A Companion and Guide (London: HarperCollins, 1996); the names of Savage’s dwarfs are given as usually reported.
- ↩
The labels of the Mappa Mundi are those of the 1935 endpapers, reproduced by David C. Downing in The Pilgrim’s Regress: Wade Annotated Edition (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2014); the pairing of North and South by number follows the preface’s scheme. The preface’s sentences on Northerners and Southerners are quoted from the third-edition text; the footnote naming Steiner from Smilde’s notes.
- ↩
The slow sale and Lloyd-Jones’s encouragement are reported in the standard accounts (Hooper, Companion and Guide); the 1935 blurb likewise. Kathryn Lindskoog, Finding the Landlord: A Guidebook to C. S. Lewis’s Pilgrim’s Regress (Chicago: Cornerstone, 1995). The preface’s own criticisms of the first edition, its needless obscurity and its uncharitable temper, are paraphrased.
- ↩
Out of the Silent Planet (London: John Lane The Bodley Head, 23 September 1938; New York: Macmillan, 1943); the publication date from the collectors’ bibliography at cslewiseditions.com (the “1 April 1938” of some reference works is wrong); the dedication is paraphrased. Lewis to Roger Lancelyn Green, 28 December 1938, Collected Letters, II; the agreement with Tolkien is recorded in Tolkien’s letter of 1963 to his son Michael (no. 252 in The Letters of J. R. R. Tolkien); Lindsay as “the real father of my planet books” is from a letter cited in the standard accounts. Haldane’s essay is “The Last Judgment”, in Possible Worlds (1927).
- ↩
Quoted from the text of the Bodley Head edition as reprinted; chs 1–17. The note on “C. J.” is Arend Smilde’s.
- ↩
Chs 18–22 and the Postscript. The last clause of Oyarsa’s speech on the Incarnation echoes 1 Peter 1:12.
- ↩
Lewis to Evelyn Underhill, 29 October 1938, and to Sister Penelope, 9 July 1939 (the Lewis Estate dates the letter 9 August), Collected Letters, II.
- ↩
Underhill to Lewis, 1938 (Bodleian MS. Eng. c. 6825, fol. 68; printed with Lewis’s reply in Collected Letters, II); Marjorie Hope Nicolson, Voyages to the Moon (New York: Macmillan, 1948), whose praise is reported, not quoted; J. B. S. Haldane, “Auld Hornie, F.R.S.”, The Modern Quarterly, n.s. 1 (Autumn 1946); David C. Downing, Planets in Peril: A Critical Study of C. S. Lewis’s Ransom Trilogy (Amherst: University of Massachusetts Press, 1992); Sanford Schwartz, C. S. Lewis on the Final Frontier: Science and the Supernatural in the Space Trilogy (New York: Oxford University Press, 2009); Martha C. Sammons, A Guide Through C. S. Lewis’ Space Trilogy (Westchester, IL: Cornerstone, 1980).
- ↩
Perelandra (London: John Lane The Bodley Head, 20 April 1943; New York: Macmillan, 1944; as Voyage to Venus, London: Pan, 1953). The dedication from the text of the first edition as reprinted; the identification of the ladies with the Wantage community is standard (Hooper). Lewis’s statements that it was a favourite among his books are reported in the biographies.
- ↩
Chs 1–6, quoted from the Bodley Head text in its impression of 1967.
- ↩
Chs 7–10.
- ↩
Chs 11–15. The epitaph Ransom carves for Weston is printed in the book as an image in Old Solar and is not reproduced here.
- ↩
Chs 16–17. The names Baru and Baru’ah, Yatsur and Yatsurah are Lewis’s Hebrew-sounding doublets for the pair; Ask and Embla are the first man and woman of the Norse Völuspá.
- ↩
Kate O’Brien, The Spectator, 14 May 1943, as transcribed in Arend Smilde’s “C. S. Lewis in the Spectator 1920–70” (lewisiana.nl); Joe R. Christopher’s review of Schwartz in Mythlore 28 (2010). The sources named for the Great Dance (Plotinus, Ennead VI.9; Paradiso; Davies’s Orchestra, 1596) are identifications, not Lewis’s own acknowledgements.
- ↩
That Hideous Strength: A Modern Fairy-Tale for Grown-Ups (London: John Lane The Bodley Head, 16 August 1945; New York: Macmillan, 1946; abridged, London: Pan, 1955, and as The Tortured Planet, New York: Avon, 1958); the preface, dedication and epigraph from the text of the first edition as reprinted; the Lyndsay line is from Ane Dialog betuix Experience and ane Courteour (The Monarche, 1554). Jane McNeill’s dislike of the book is recorded by Smilde from Hooper. The 1955 note is quoted from the Pan edition.
- ↩
Chs 1–7, quoted from the first edition’s text.
- ↩
Chs 8–11.
- ↩
Chs 12–14. The chapter title “Real Life Is Meeting” is from Martin Buber (by way of J. H. Oldham’s book of that title, 1942).
- ↩
Chs 15–17. Merlin’s Latin is given in translation; the renderings are not Lewis’s.
- ↩
George Orwell, “The Scientists Take Over”, Manchester Evening News, 16 August 1945, reprinted in The Complete Works of George Orwell, ed. Peter Davison, vol. XVII (London: Secker & Warburg, 1998), no. 2720, pp. 250–51 (the common paraphrase that the book “would have been stronger without the supernatural elements” is not Orwell’s wording); John Hampson, “Chaos”, The Spectator, 7 September 1945; Leonard Bacon, Saturday Review of Literature, 1946, as quoted in the standard accounts; Haldane, “Auld Hornie, F.R.S.” (1946), and Lewis’s unfinished “A Reply to Professor Haldane”, in Of Other Worlds, ed. Hooper (London: Bles, 1966); Tolkien to Michael Tolkien, November 1963, letter no. 252 in The Letters of J. R. R. Tolkien, as summarised in the reference accounts; McGrath’s judgement as quoted in the reference accounts. The suggestion that Evelyn Underhill’s novel The Column of Dust (1909) lies behind the Pendragon of Logres is Smilde’s.
- ↩
The Screwtape Letters (London: Geoffrey Bles, February 1942; New York: Macmillan, 1943); the serial dates from Smilde’s notes; the epigraphs as printed in the Bles text (the fourteenth printing, September 1944), which Smilde traces to Luther’s Tischreden in Hazlitt’s translation and to More’s Dialogue of Comfort, Book II, ch. 16; the dedication and Lewis’s inscription in Tolkien’s copy from Carpenter, The Inklings, p. 174; Tolkien’s dislike from Bradley Birzer, J. R. R. Tolkien’s Sanctifying Myth (Wilmington: ISI, 2002), p. 89, and from Michael White’s biography of Tolkien (2001). The Screwtape Letters and Screwtape Proposes a Toast (London: Bles, 1961), preface signed from Magdalene College, Cambridge, 18 May 1960.
- ↩
The 1941 preface from the Bles text; the 1960 preface from the 1961 edition (its “Managerial Age” is James Burnham’s phrase, as Smilde notes).
- ↩
Letters I–XXXI, quoted from the Bles text of 1944 for the first twenty-four and from the HarperCollins text for the rest; the devils’ names (Glubose, Scabtree, Slubgob, Triptweeze, Toadpipe, Slumtrimpet) as in the book. Screwtape’s “Pshaw” is Shaw; the centipede is from Paradise Lost X, where the metamorphosis is a punishment.
- ↩
Letter VII, as printed in the Bles text (the 1944 printing has a comma after “in us”; inner quotation marks are double in the original).
- ↩
“Screwtape Proposes a Toast”, The Saturday Evening Post, 19 December 1959, quoted from the 1961 text; Lewis’s 1961 preface explains that the English schooling of the Toast stands for American conditions.
- ↩
W. J. Turner, “The Devil at Work”, The Spectator, 20 February 1942; Charles Williams, Time and Tide, 21 March 1942, as reproduced by Brenton Dickieson; Lewis’s resolution never to write another “Letter” is reported in the standard accounts.
- ↩
The Great Divorce: A Dream (London: Geoffrey Bles, 1945 [January 1946]; New York: Macmillan, 1946); serial title and dates from the collectors’ bibliography at cslewiseditions.com; the dedication (to Barbara Wall, best and most long-suffering of scribes) in the form usually quoted. The preface is quoted from the American text, with its spellings “colored” and “transmortal”; the “scientifiction” story has been identified as Charles F. Hall’s “The Man Who Lived Backwards” (1938).
- ↩
Chs 1–8, quoted from the Macmillan text as reprinted.
- ↩
Chs 9–14. The Refrigerium: Prudentius, Cathemerinon V, and Jeremy Taylor, as MacDonald says in the book; the Lady Julian’s “all will be well” is Julian of Norwich, Revelations, ch. 27. Napoleon’s eternal pacing, blaming Soult and Ney, is reported in ch. 2 and is given from the usual summaries.
- ↩
A. C. Deane, “A Nightmare”, The Spectator, 25 January 1946, as transcribed by Smilde.
- ↩
Till We Have Faces: A Myth Retold (London: Geoffrey Bles, 1956; New York: Harcourt, Brace, 1957); the dedication and epigraph from the text; the working title and the date of the change from the standard accounts (Hooper); “far and away my best book” is from a letter quoted in the standard accounts; the thirty-five years are Hooper’s reckoning from the undergraduate attempts, fragments of which survive.
- ↩
Lewis’s “Note” at the end of the book; the letter on “every nice, affectionate agnostic” is to Clyde Kilby, 10 February 1957, Collected Letters, III.
- ↩
Part One, chs 1–6, quoted from the HarperCollins text.
- ↩
Part One, chs 7–21. The god’s sentence to Orual that she also shall be Psyche is paraphrased.
- ↩
Part Two, chs 1–4, with the American spelling “center”. Arnom’s postscript is paraphrased.
- ↩
Robert Gorham Davis, The New York Times Book Review, 1957, as quoted in the standard accounts; Peter J. Schakel, Reason and Imagination in C. S. Lewis: A Study of Till We Have Faces (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1984); Doris T. Myers, Bareface: A Guide to C. S. Lewis’s Last Novel (Columbia: University of Missouri Press, 2004); Mara E. Donaldson, Holy Places Are Dark Places: C. S. Lewis and Paul Ricoeur on Narrative Transformation (Lanham: University Press of America, 1988).
- ↩
Of Other Worlds: Essays and Stories, ed. Walter Hooper (London: Bles, 1966; New York: Harcourt, Brace & World, 1967); The Dark Tower and Other Stories, ed. Hooper (London: Collins, 1977; New York: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, 1977), with notes on After Ten Years by Roger Lancelyn Green and Alastair Fowler; Boxen: The Imaginary World of the Young C. S. Lewis, ed. Hooper (London: Collins, 1985), enlarged as Boxen: Childhood Chronicles Before Narnia (London: HarperCollins, 2008). The summaries of the short stories and of The Dark Tower follow Hooper’s accounts and the standard descriptions, and no sentence of them is quoted. “The Shoddy Lands” and “Ministering Angels” appeared in The Magazine of Fantasy and Science Fiction for February 1956 and January 1958; “Ministering Angels” answers Robert S. Richardson, “The Day After We Land on Mars”, Saturday Review, 1955. On The Dark Tower’s authenticity see the Life, above, and its footnote.
- ↩
Publication and composition dates from Hooper and Green as tabulated in the standard reference works; the dedications from the books. Lewis, “Sometimes Fairy Stories May Say Best What’s to Be Said”, New York Times Book Review, 18 November 1956, and “It All Began with a Picture”, Radio Times, 15 July 1960, both in Of Other Worlds (1966); Lewis to Anne Jenkins, 5 March 1961, Collected Letters, III, as printed by Paul F. Ford, Companion to Narnia, 5th edn (San Francisco: HarperSanFrancisco, 2005), p. 6; to Mrs Hook, 29 December 1958, Collected Letters, III; on the name, Collected Letters, III, 160 (from the notes to Lane’s Arabian Nights). The 1956 essay’s image of the fairy tale stealing past the “watchful dragons” of Sunday-school association gave Hooper the title of Past Watchful Dragons (New York: Macmillan, 1979). Tolkien’s reaction is recorded by Green in Roger Lancelyn Green and Walter Hooper, C. S. Lewis: A Biography (London: Collins, 1974; rev. 2002); his words are given as the biographies report them.
- ↩
Lewis to Laurence Krieg, 23 April 1957, in Letters to Children, ed. Lyle W. Dorsett and Marjorie Lamp Mead (London: Fount, 1985); Ford, Companion, pp. 16 and 2005 preface; Michael Ward, “Planet Narnia”, Times Literary Supplement, 2003, and Planet Narnia: The Seven Heavens in the Imagination of C. S. Lewis (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2008), with The Narnia Code (Carlisle: Paternoster, 2010) and the BBC documentary of 2009; the Mythopoeic Scholarship Award in Inklings Studies, 2011; the quantitative study of planetary vocabulary is reported in the standard reference accounts without its authors’ names. Lewis’s “The Kappa Element in Romance” (1940), revised as “On Stories” (1947), in Of Other Worlds. The phrase “spiritual symbols” is from “The Alliterative Metre” (1935), quoted in the Thought section.
- ↩
The Magician’s Nephew, chs 2, 3 and 5, quoted from the HarperCollins text; Prince Caspian, ch. 12. No statement by Lewis of a rule distinguishing fairy-tale magic from the occult in Narnia has been found, and none is quoted.
- ↩
The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe (London: Geoffrey Bles, 16 October 1950; New York: Macmillan, 1950), with Pauline Baynes’s illustrations; the dedication as printed; the abandoned opening of 1939 and the reading to Green from Green and Hooper. The quotations in this and the following Narnia sections are from the HarperCollins text, with American spellings (“realized”, “backward”, “honor”) where that text has them; the Bles text has “backwards”.
- ↩
Chs 1–12.
- ↩
Chs 13–17. The second prophetic rhyme of ch. 8 (wrong made right when Aslan comes in sight) is paraphrased.
- ↩
Kirkus Reviews, 6 November 1950; Kathryn Lindskoog, The Lion of Judah in Never-Never Land (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1973); Paul F. Ford, Companion to Narnia (San Francisco: Harper & Row, 1980; 5th edn 2005); Peter J. Schakel, Reading with the Heart: The Way into Narnia (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1979), and The Way into Narnia (2005); Devin Brown, Inside Narnia (Grand Rapids: Baker, 2005); Philip Pullman and Polly Toynbee (The Guardian, 5 December 2005) as quoted in the standard surveys of the series’ reception.
- ↩
Prince Caspian: The Return to Narnia (London: Bles, 15 October 1951); the dedication to Mary Clare Havard; Lewis’s gloss from Collected Letters, III, 1245.
- ↩
Chs 1–11, quoted from the HarperCollins text, with the American “honor”.
- ↩
Chs 12–15.
- ↩
Kirkus Reviews, 16 October 1951; Devin Brown, Inside Prince Caspian (Grand Rapids: Baker, 2008).
- ↩
The Voyage of the Dawn Treader (London: Bles, 15 September 1952); the two texts of ch. 12 are discussed by Peter J. Schakel, Imagination and the Arts in C. S. Lewis (Columbia: University of Missouri Press, 2002), and Ford, Companion.
- ↩
Chs 1–12. The sentences of the undragoning (the skins, the claws, the water, the new clothes) and the titles of the spells in the Magician’s Book are paraphrased; Aslan’s “You will have to let me undress you” is quoted as the reference works give it.
- ↩
Chs 13–16.
- ↩
Anthony Boucher and J. Francis McComas, The Magazine of Fantasy and Science Fiction, February 1953, p. 74; Devin Brown, Inside the Voyage of the Dawn Treader (Grand Rapids: Baker, 2010).
- ↩
The Silver Chair (London: Bles, 7 September 1953); the dedication to Nicholas Hardie from the book.
- ↩
Chs 1–11. Aslan’s statement to Jill that there is no other stream is paraphrased; the Signs are given in part as the reference works print them.
- ↩
Chs 12–16. The identification of Puddleglum with Lewis’s gardener Fred Paxford is Hooper’s; the view that the Lady of the Green Kirtle is not Jadis returned, against the notes to some editions, is Schakel’s.
- ↩
Kirkus Reviews, 6 October 1953.
- ↩
The Horse and His Boy (London: Bles, 6 September 1954); the dedication from the book.
- ↩
Chs 1–15. The thrice-spoken “Myself” of ch. 11 is paraphrased; the Lion’s speech that follows is quoted from the text.
- ↩
The orientalism debate: Philip Hensher, The Independent, 1998; Gregg Easterbrook, The Atlantic, 2001; Laura Miller, Salon, 7 December 2005; the defence by Devin Brown and others; Ruth North on Apuleius’s ass, as cited in the reference accounts.
- ↩
The Magician’s Nephew (London: The Bodley Head, 2 May 1955); the composition history and the Lefay fragment from Hooper, Past Watchful Dragons, whose attribution of the fragment has been questioned; the dedication from the text.
- ↩
Chs 1–5, quoted from the HarperCollins text of 1998.
- ↩
Chs 6–15, from the same text.
- ↩
Kirkus Reviews, 20 September 1955.
- ↩
The Last Battle (London: The Bodley Head, 4 September 1956); the Carnegie Medal (awarded 1957) and the letter to Baynes as quoted in the reference accounts; the book carries no dedication.
- ↩
Chs 1–11, quoted from the HarperCollins text and from a bilingual edition of the American text.
- ↩
Chs 12–16. Chapter 14, the end of Narnia, is paraphrased; Aslan’s first sentences to Emeth and his sentence on desire are paraphrased; Lucy’s remark about the stable and Jewel’s “come home at last” likewise; the last clause is quoted in the British spelling “for ever” (the American text has “forever”).
- ↩
Floyd C. Gale, Galaxy Science Fiction, June 1957; Elissa McCormack, on Emeth and inclusivism, Logos: A Journal of Catholic Thought and Culture 11.4 (2008): 57–73; Lewis’s letter of 1952 on Emeth’s theology, Collected Letters, III, as cited in the reference accounts.
- ↩
The Problem of Pain (London: The Centenary Press, 1940; New York: Macmillan, 1943); the preface, dedication and epigraph from the 1940 text; the chapter-epigraphs (Montaigne before ch. V, Hooker before VII, Walter de la Mare and Richard III before VIII) as Smilde’s notes record them; Havard’s authorship of the appendix is standard.
- ↩
Chs I–V and X quoted from the 1940 Bles text; chs VI–IX are paraphrased — the “megaphone” sentence, the “doors of hell are locked on the inside” and the golden apple of the last page are given in substance only.
- ↩
Edwyn Bevan, The Spectator, 25 October 1940; John Beversluis, C. S. Lewis and the Search for Rational Religion (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1985; rev. Amherst: Prometheus, 2007); Michael Ward, “On Suffering”, in The Cambridge Companion to C. S. Lewis (2010); Smilde’s notes at lewisiana.nl/painquotes.
- ↩
Broadcast Talks (London: Bles, 1942; as The Case for Christianity, New York: Macmillan, 1943); Christian Behaviour (Bles, 1943; Macmillan, 1943); Beyond Personality: The Christian Idea of God (Bles, 1944; Macmillan, 1945); Mere Christianity (London: Bles, 7 July 1952; New York: Macmillan, 1952). The broadcast dates from cslewistour.uk and the Foundation chronology. Baxter’s phrase is traced by Smilde to the Church-History of the Government of Bishops (1680).
- ↩
Books I–II quoted from the 1952 text; Book III from the sentences as the standard anthologies print them; Book IV from the 1945 Macmillan Beyond Personality, with its American spelling “center”. The closing sentences of Book IV — that looking for oneself one finds only hatred, loneliness, despair and decay, while looking for Christ one finds him and everything else thrown in — are paraphrased.
- ↩
The Times Literary Supplement and J. K. Mozley (The Spectator, 23 April 1943), as the reference accounts quote them; George M. Marsden, C. S. Lewis’s Mere Christianity: A Biography (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2016); Beversluis (1985/2007); Alister McGrath, C. S. Lewis: A Life (2013), on the trilemma; Victor Reppert, C. S. Lewis’s Dangerous Idea (2003).
- ↩
The Abolition of Man (London: Oxford University Press, 1943; 2nd edn, Bles, 1946; New York: Macmillan, 1947); the lectures’ dates from the book’s headnote; the epigraphs as printed. Lewis’s remark that the book was “almost totally ignored” is quoted in the reference accounts from a letter; the National Review list is that of 3 May 1999.
- ↩
Quoted from the text of the first edition. The identification of “Gaius and Titius” with Alexander King and Martin Ketley, The Control of Language (1939), is standard. The headings of the appendix and its sources are given from the standard text.
- ↩
B. F. Skinner, Beyond Freedom and Dignity (New York: Knopf, 1971); Ayn Rand’s marginalia as transcribed by Smilde; Michael Ward, After Humanity (2021); Contemporary Perspectives on C. S. Lewis’s The Abolition of Man: History, Philosophy, Education, and Science, ed. Timothy M. Mosteller and Gayne John Anacker (London: Bloomsbury, 2017); Justin Buckley Dyer and Micah J. Watson, C. S. Lewis on Politics and the Natural Law (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2016); Smilde’s summary and notes (lewisiana.nl/abolsum, abolquotes).
- ↩
Miracles: A Preliminary Study (London: Bles, 1947; New York: Macmillan, 1947; rev. edn, London: Fontana, 1960); the dedication and epigraph from the 1947 text. The chapter-epigraph from Charles Williams (“a light that shone from behind the sun”) stands before ch. XIV.
- ↩
Chs I–IV and VIII quoted from the 1947 text; chs IX–XVII and the appendices are paraphrased, the sentence of ch. XI on pantheism as the permanent natural bent of the mind among them. The Anscombe paper, “A Reply to Mr. C. S. Lewis’s Argument that ‘Naturalism’ is Self-Refuting”, Socratic Digest 4 (1948), and her Metaphysics and the Philosophy of Mind: Collected Philosophical Papers, vol. 2 (Oxford: Blackwell, 1981); the word-counts of the revision are Smilde’s (“The Anscombe Affair”, lewisiana.nl).
- ↩
C. E. Raven, “Can Miracles Happen?”, The Spectator, 16 May 1947, with the correspondence of 23 May; Reppert (2003); William Hasker, The Emergent Self (Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 1999); Alvin Plantinga, Warrant and Proper Function (Oxford University Press, 1993), ch. 12.
- ↩
Transposition and Other Addresses (London: Bles, 1949); The Weight of Glory and Other Addresses (New York: Macmillan, 1949; rev. and expanded, ed. Hooper, 1980); the delivery notes as printed in the book; “Learning in War-Time” was preached on 22 October 1939 and printed as “Culture in War-Time” in The Student Movement, March 1940; “Membership” appeared in Sobornost, June 1945.
- ↩
Quoted from the 1949 Macmillan and Bles texts.
- ↩
Surprised by Joy: The Shape of My Early Life (London: Bles, 19 September 1955; New York: Harcourt, Brace, 1956); the preface, epigraph and dedication from the Bles text; the chapter-epigraphs as Smilde records them.
- ↩
Ch. I quoted from the Bles text; the later chapters as in the Life and its notes; the “signposts” ending paraphrased.
- ↩
Gilbert Murray’s “dolce nemico” from Smilde’s notes on the book; Lord Hailsham reviewed it in The Spectator (9 December 1955); Andrew Lazo’s edition of the manuscript “Early Prose Joy” in VII: An Anglo-American Literary Review 30 (2013); McGrath (2013); Devin Brown, A Life Observed: A Spiritual Biography of C. S. Lewis (Grand Rapids: Brazos, 2013).
- ↩
Reflections on the Psalms (London: Bles, 1958; New York: Harcourt, Brace, 1958); dedication and chapter-list from Smilde’s notes (lewisiana.nl/psalmsquotes). The argument is summarised without quotation.
- ↩
Summarised from Smilde’s chapter-by-chapter notes; Smilde observes that Lewis’s reference to Book I of the Republic for the just man is an error for Book II.
- ↩
Robert Gordis, Jewish Social Studies 21 (1959); Stevie Smith reviewed the book in The Spectator (12 September 1958). Lewis’s membership of the Commission to Revise the Psalter (1959–63) is standard.
- ↩
The Four Loves (London: Bles, 1960; New York: Harcourt, Brace, 1960); dedication and epigraph from the Bles text (the dedication is dropped from the 1977 Fount edition, as Smilde notes); the American radio talks were recorded in London in August 1958 for the Episcopal Radio-TV Foundation of Atlanta (Hooper).
- ↩
Chs I–II and IV quoted from the Bles text; chs III, V and VI from the sentences as the standard anthologies print them, the rest paraphrased; the sentence of ch. V on the god in Eros who becomes a demon is paraphrased.
- ↩
Bernard Williams, The Spectator, 1 April 1960; Jason Lepojärvi, God Is Love but Love Is Not God: Studies on C. S. Lewis’s Theology of Love (Helsinki: University of Helsinki, 2015).
- ↩
A Grief Observed (London: Faber and Faber, 29 September 1961), as by N. W. Clerk; the reissue under Lewis’s name is dated 1964 by Smilde’s bibliography and by Faber’s own edition (some accounts say 1963); Eliot’s part from Hooper, Companion and Guide, p. 194.
- ↩
Quoted from the Faber text; the Italian is Paradiso XXXI.93.
- ↩
Chad Walsh, The Literary Legacy of C. S. Lewis (New York: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, 1979); the story of friends recommending the book to its author is Hooper’s; the films Shadowlands (BBC, 1985; Richard Attenborough, 1993).
- ↩
Letters to Malcolm: Chiefly on Prayer (London: Bles, 1964; New York: Harcourt, Brace & World, 1964). The abandoned book on prayer of the early 1950s is reported by Hooper.
- ↩
The letters are summarised after Smilde’s notes (lewisiana.nl/malcolmquotes); the three sentences quoted are as the standard anthologies print them; the phrases “festooning”, “bright blur” and “shafts of the glory” and the maxims of Williams and Julian are given as Smilde’s lemmas record them; the “flower to root” guess of the last letter is paraphrased.
- ↩
Alan Jacobs, The Narnian (San Francisco: HarperSanFrancisco, 2005), as the reference accounts cite him.
- ↩
Dates and venues from Smilde’s survey of the shorter writings (lewisiana.nl/cslessays) and Hooper’s headnotes. “Bulverism”, Time and Tide, 29 March 1941, revised in The Socratic Digest 2 (1944); “Evil and God”, The Spectator, 7 February 1941; “Myth Became Fact”, World Dominion, September–October 1944 (the one sentence quoted as the reference accounts print it); “Is Theology Poetry?”, The Socratic Digest 3 (1945); “Religion without Dogma?”, read to the Socratic Club on 20 May 1946; “Christianity and Culture”, Theology, March 1940, with the replies of S. L. Bethell and E. F. Carritt and Lewis’s rejoinders; “The Poison of Subjectivism”, Religion in Life, summer 1943; “The Funeral of a Great Myth”, first printed in Christian Reflections (1967); “Historicism”, The Month, October 1950; “Modern Theology and Biblical Criticism”, read at Westcott House, Cambridge, 11 May 1959, printed in Christian Reflections and retitled “Fern-seed and Elephants” in the 1975 collection; “The Seeing Eye”, as “Onward, Christian Spacemen”, Show, February 1963; “The World’s Last Night”, as “Christian Hope — Its Meaning for Today”, Religion in Life, winter 1952–53; “The Efficacy of Prayer”, The Atlantic Monthly, January 1959; “Meditation in a Toolshed”, The Coventry Evening Telegraph, 17 July 1945; “The Humanitarian Theory of Punishment”, 20th Century: An Australian Quarterly Review, 1949; “The Empty Universe”, preface to D. E. Harding, The Hierarchy of Heaven and Earth (London: Faber, 1952). The pieces not quoted are summarised from Smilde’s notes and from the reference accounts.
- ↩
The Allegory of Love: A Study in Medieval Tradition (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1936), with the 1936 pagination; the dedication as quoted in the standard accounts; the Gollancz Prize for 1937 as the British Academy’s list records it. Its sentences are quoted as Arend Smilde’s detailed summary (lewisiana.nl/allegsum) and the reference accounts print them, with his page numbers.
- ↩
Pp. 2–6, 29, 34, 42–43 (ch. I); 44–49, 52, 84, 96–98, 104, 106 (ch. II); 142, 149, 155–56 (ch. III); 358–60 (ch. VII). The sentences of pp. 44–48 on allegory and symbolism — the archetype in the copy, “it is we who are the allegory”, symbolism as a mode of thought — are paraphrased.
- ↩
William Empson, The Spectator, 4 September 1936; E. Talbot Donaldson, “The Myth of Courtly Love”, Ventures 5 (1965); Peter Dronke, Medieval Latin and the Rise of European Love-Lyric (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1965); D. W. Robertson, Jr, “The Concept of Courtly Love as an Impediment to the Understanding of Medieval Texts”, in The Meaning of Courtly Love, ed. F. X. Newman (Albany: SUNY Press, 1968); the chapters of Dennis Danielson and Stephen Logan in The Cambridge Companion to C. S. Lewis (2010); William Calin, “C. S. Lewis, Literary Critic: A Reassessment”, Mythlore 23 (2001).
- ↩
Rehabilitations and Other Essays (London: Oxford University Press, 1939); The Personal Heresy: A Controversy, with E. M. W. Tillyard (London: Oxford University Press, 1939), quoted as the reference accounts print it; John Lawlor’s recollection of the Magdalen debate of 7 February 1939, that “there was no debate” and Lewis “made rings round Tillyard”, and Tillyard’s “the best kind of opponent, good to agree with when one can”, likewise. “Bluspels and Flalansferes” is paraphrased.
- ↩
A Preface to Paradise Lost (London: Oxford University Press, 1942), the Ballard Matthews Lectures of 1941; the dedicatory letter to Williams is paraphrased.
- ↩
Chs XI and XIII quoted from the 1967 reprint, pp. 80 and 106–09; the phrases “a personified self-contradiction”, “the Satanic predicament”, “Eve fell through Pride”, “Adam fell by uxoriousness” and “untransmuted lump of futurity” as the reference accounts print them; the rest paraphrased. The dream-landscape sentence (“as in dream landscapes, we find that what seemed the top is not the top”) belongs to ch. 7.
- ↩
Jackson Knight, The Spectator, 13 November 1942; A. J. A. Waldock, Paradise Lost and Its Critics (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1947); William Empson, Milton’s God (London: Chatto & Windus, 1961); Helen Gardner, A Reading of Paradise Lost (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1965); William Kolbrener, as the reference accounts cite him (2014).
- ↩
George MacDonald: An Anthology (London: Bles, 1946), preface quoted with its American spelling; Arthurian Torso, containing the Posthumous Fragment of The Figure of Arthur by Charles Williams and a Commentary on the Arthurian Poems of Charles Williams by C. S. Lewis (London: Oxford University Press, 1948), whose commentary is summarised, not quoted; the borrowings in Letters to Malcolm are Smilde’s identifications.
- ↩
English Literature in the Sixteenth Century Excluding Drama, The Oxford History of English Literature, vol. III (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1954); reissued as Poetry and Prose in the Sixteenth Century (1990); the genesis in the Clark Lectures of 1944 and the Oxford “Prolegomena” lectures from the standard accounts; the chapter-list from the book.
- ↩
The introduction quoted from the scan of the Clarendon text (see the Thought section’s note on its misreadings); the books that follow are summarised, not quoted.
- ↩
Leicester Bradner, Renaissance News 8 (1955); Charles T. Harrison, Sewanee Review 63 (1955); G. D. Willcock, Review of English Studies n.s. 7 (1956); John Wain reviewed it in The Spectator, 1 October 1954; Dennis Danielson, “Intellectual Historian”, in The Cambridge Companion to C. S. Lewis (2010); Stefan Collini, Common Writing (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2016).
- ↩
Studies in Words (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1960; 2nd edn 1967); An Experiment in Criticism (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1961). Both are summarised, and the epilogue of the Experiment is paraphrased. Reviews: E. J. Dobson, Review of English Studies n.s. 13 (1962), “an excellent book, which deserves to be widely known”; Jackson J. Campbell, JEGP 61 (1962); William G. Moulton, Romance Philology 16 (1962); Bernard Bergonzi reviewed the Experiment in The Spectator, 17 November 1961.
- ↩
The Discarded Image: An Introduction to Medieval and Renaissance Literature (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1964; Canto edn 1994, same pagination); the origin in the Oxford lecture courses and in the Cambridge lectures of 1956 from Fowler and Smilde.
- ↩
Quoted with the Cambridge pagination (pp. 11, 16, 92–96, 99, 122–23, 138–39, 146, 153, 157, 166–67, 170, 172, 177, 185, 188–91, 203); the accounts of chs 3 and 4, of the planets’ characters and of the Church’s attitude to astrology in ch. 5, and of the epilogue are paraphrased. Michael Ward, Planet Narnia (2008), quotes the planetary passages in full.
- ↩
The Observer, 1964, as the reference accounts quote it; Morton W. Bloomfield, Speculum 40 (1965): 354–56; J. A. Burrow, “The Model Universe”, Essays in Criticism 15 (1965), and “The Alterity of Medieval Literature”, New Literary History 10 (1979); John Holloway reviewed it in The Spectator, 5 June 1964.
- ↩
Studies in Medieval and Renaissance Literature, ed. Walter Hooper (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1966); Spenser’s Images of Life, ed. Alastair Fowler (Cambridge University Press, 1967); Fowler, “C. S. Lewis: Supervisor”, Yale Review 91 (2003), on the lectures and on Lewis’s supervision (“Lewis never insisted on anything”); Selected Literary Essays, ed. Hooper (Cambridge University Press, 1969); “De Descriptione Temporum” (Cambridge University Press, 1955), summarised without quotation; Image and Imagination: Essays and Reviews, ed. Hooper (Cambridge University Press, 2013). Robert Ellrodt, Neoplatonism in the Poetry of Spenser (Geneva: Droz, 1960).
- ↩
Letters of C. S. Lewis, ed. W. H. Lewis (London: Bles, 1966; rev. Walter Hooper, London: Fount, 1988); Letters to an American Lady, ed. Clyde S. Kilby (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1967); They Stand Together: The Letters of C. S. Lewis to Arthur Greeves (1914–1963), ed. Hooper (London: Collins, 1979); Letters to Children, ed. Lyle W. Dorsett and Marjorie Lamp Mead (London: Fount, 1985); The Collected Letters of C. S. Lewis, ed. Hooper, 3 vols (London: HarperCollins, 2000, 2004, 2006); All My Road Before Me: The Diary of C. S. Lewis 1922–1927, ed. Hooper (London: HarperCollins, 1991); The “Great War” of Owen Barfield and C. S. Lewis: Philosophical Writings 1927–1930, ed. Norbert Feinendegen and Arend Smilde, Inklings Studies Supplements 1 (Oxford: Journal of Inklings Studies, 2015), whose list of contents is given as the standard descriptions have it.
- ↩
Tolkien to Dick Plotz, 12 September 1965 (no. 276 in The Letters of J. R. R. Tolkien), as summarised in the reference accounts; Tolkien to Priscilla Tolkien, 26 November 1963 (no. 251), paraphrased; Charles Williams, Time and Tide, 21 March 1942; Austin Farrer, “The Christian Apologist”, in Light on C. S. Lewis, ed. Jocelyn Gibb (London: Bles, 1965), pp. 24–26; Orwell (1945); Haldane (1946); Kathleen Nott, The Emperor’s Clothes (London: Heinemann, 1953); Leavis’s hostility is reported by Wilson and McGrath without a quotable sentence; Time, 8 September 1947; D. M. Baillie’s citation at St Andrews, June 1946; Rowan Williams, address in Westminster Abbey, 22 November 2013.
- ↩
The works named are listed in the bibliography; the Lindskoog affair is treated in the Life. Brill’s Dictionary of Gnosis and Western Esotericism, ed. Wouter J. Hanegraaff (Leiden: Brill, 2005), has no article on Lewis, Barfield, Williams, Tolkien or the Inklings, its nearest being those on Anthroposophy, Steiner, the Golden Dawn and Waite; nor, so far as their indexes show, is Lewis cited by Yates, Walker, Vickers or Hanegraaff. Isham (2016); the symposium on Lindop in Journal of Inklings Studies 6 (2016), with Rowan Williams, Sørina Higgins, Holly Ordway and Paul Blair; Paul Gosselin, “C. S. Lewis et l’occulte”, samizdat.qc.ca; Sayer, Jack, as quoted in the reference accounts. “Christian Hermeticism” is the term of Valentin Tomberg’s Meditations on the Tarot and its readers.
- ↩
The societies, journals and archives as they describe themselves (the New York society’s history; the Wade Center’s account of its founding in 1965 by Clyde S. Kilby); the Poets’ Corner service from the Abbey’s order of service; the Canadian term of copyright, life plus fifty years, expired for Lewis on 1 January 2014; the film from the announcements of Netflix (1 May 2026) and the trade press (20 May 2026). The Taylor University colloquium’s proceedings appear as Inklings Forever.