Art History

The Last Gleam

Gustave Moreau, Dejanira (Autumn), about 1872–73

In a gorge of autumn trees, at the edge of a dark stream, the centaur Nessus carries off Dejanira, the wife of Hercules.

Orientation

The Artwork

Dejanira, draped in pale fabric with one arm raised, is carried by the centaur Nessus beside a dark stream beneath tall autumn trees in Gustave Moreau’s Dejanira (Autumn).
Gustave Moreau, Dejanira (Autumn), about 1872–73. J. Paul Getty Museum, Los Angeles.

The Last Gleam

Gustave Moreau (1826–1898), Dejanira (Autumn) (L’Automne. Déjanire; sold in 1881 as Enlèvement de Déjanire par le centaure Nessus), about 1872–73. Oil on panel, 55.1 × 45.4 cm. Los Angeles, J. Paul Getty Museum, 84.PB.682. Signed lower left: Gustave Moreau.1

Overview

In a gorge of autumn trees, at the edge of a dark stream, the centaur Nessus carries off Dejanira, the wife of Hercules. The story, from Ovid, ends with an arrow, a poisoned shirt and a hero burned alive, yet nothing in Moreau’s small panel is fighting: Dejanira is held upright in front of the centaur, her arm raised and her eyes all but closed, Nessus looks up at her, and Hercules is a small figure in the shadow of the rocks. When the collector who commissioned it asked what it meant, Moreau said he had left the story aside and painted a season: autumn, “a last gleam, a last smile of nature and of life”, with a white form that the centaur tries to hold and that “is about to escape him”.2 The picture turns an abduction into an image of holding on to what is already going, and it shows what Moreau wanted from myth: not the plot, but the feeling it could carry.

Background

The story is told in the ninth book of Ovid’s Metamorphoses. Hercules had won Dejanira, daughter of the king of Calydon, by wrestling the river god Achelous for her. Taking his bride home, he came to the river Evenus, “swollen by winter storms, thick with whirlpools and impassable”. The centaur Nessus (half man, half horse) offered to carry her across while the hero swam, and Hercules handed him the girl, “pale with fear, afraid of the river and of Nessus himself”. He was picking up his bow on the far bank when he heard her voice: the centaur was about to make off with her. “I shall catch you with a wound, not with my feet,” he shouted, and shot Nessus in the back with an arrow carrying the poison of the Hydra, the many-headed serpent he had killed. Dying, Nessus gave Dejanira his tunic, soaked in his blood, “as if it were a spur to love”.3 Years later, afraid of losing Hercules to another woman, she sent it to him; it burned him, and he died on a pyre on Mount Oeta and was taken up among the gods.4

The painting began with a letter. On 11 May 1872 Louis Helmut Lepel-Cointet (1829–1881), a Paris stockbroker and collector, asked Moreau for a picture and left the choice to him: “the subject matters little”, he wrote, being “assured in advance” that Moreau would do it justice.5 Moreau chose Dejanira and worked the composition out in a long run of drawings, most now in the Musée Gustave Moreau in Paris; on one, squared for transfer (ruled with a grid so that it could be copied at a larger size), he labelled the figure “Automne”. As Scott Allan shows in his essay for the Getty Museum (2021), the struggle drained out of the studies as they went on: the figures grew smaller, the landscape larger, and Hercules withdrew into the shadows. An X-radiograph, which shows the paint layers under the surface, reveals that Dejanira’s hand was first flung out to the side, as in the drawings, before Moreau repainted it raised high above her head.6 The collector asked what the picture meant, and sent a reminder on 9 October 1873. After his death the panel was sold at the Hôtel Drouot, the Paris auction rooms, in June 1881 under the plain title Abduction of Dejanira by the Centaur Nessus.7 It has been in the Getty since 1984.

Description

The panel is small and upright, and most of it is landscape. A narrow gorge opens upwards to a cloudy grey sky. Dark cliffs and shadowed woods fill most of the left half, autumn trees in rust and gold the right. The group rises from the water at the lower right to about half the height of the panel, and Ovid’s torrent has become a dark, still stream streaked with light. The design is built of verticals: the tallest of the pale trunks, which Allan identifies as a white poplar, the cliff faces, a waterfall dropping through the shadows of the gorge beside Dejanira’s head, and Dejanira herself, the brightest thing below the sky, her raised arm continuing the line of her body.

Her left arm is raised high, the hand open and the fingers upward; her right hand rests at her breast. Her head tilts towards her raised arm, on Nessus’s side, and her eyes are closed or almost closed. A white veil falls from her raised wrist behind her head, a transparent gauze crosses her body, and she wears a jewelled band high on her left thigh. Her left foot hangs free: she is being carried, and she is not struggling. Around her the drapery flies: a salmon-pink mantle balloons out on the left with a loose red cord and two green-gold tassels, the end of the veil streams off to the right, and a long red cloth hangs from beneath her to the water.

Nessus is beside her on the right, half behind her, young, beardless and far darker than she is. His head, wreathed with dark leaves touched with red, comes up to just below her breast, and he looks up into her face. His left hand grips the gauze at her waist; his right, reaching round behind her, rests on her far hip. A spiral armlet of red beads circles his upper arm, a red cloak flares behind him, and behind his shoulder rises a dark curved shaft with a curled tip, its lower end in a dark blue case: a bow, by the look of it. His pale horse body is stepping out of the stream, one foreleg lifted over the rocks.

A white bird takes flight beside Dejanira’s raised arm. In the gorge behind the couple, on the rocks to the left, stands a small, loosely painted figure with something pale, a skin or a cloak, streaming from his head and shoulders: Hercules, by the Getty’s reading.

Impressions

Moreau’s reply to his patron explains the picture. “The Dejanira is one of four compositions representing the four seasons of the year,” he wrote; the series was never carried out.8 “Leaving the fable aside”, he had tried to render “the harmony that can exist between outward nature at a certain moment of the year and certain phases of human life”. In “a veiled landscape cut by a ray of light, the centaur seeks to embrace and keep hold of this white, airy form which is about to escape him. It is … a last gleam, a last smile of nature and of life … winter threatens; soon the night. It is autumn.”9 The picture is an allegory, a scene in which figures stand for an idea, and the idea is holding and losing. The centaur is the one who holds; Dejanira, pale, still and lit, is the light that is going. The white bird leaving her side may be the same thought said again in small.

The calm is the point. Allan calls Dejanira “an image of calm self-absorption”, and the repainted hand, in his word, “hieratic”: stiff and formal, like a figure in an icon. Moreau reused her pose for an allegory of Fortune. The landscape repeats the figures: the pale poplar echoes her “rigid verticality and otherworldly pallor” and the gnarled tree the centaur’s twisting pose and darker colour, and in Moreau’s work, Allan argues, the white poplar stands for “the poetic aspiration to the divine”. Moreau gave his centaur something of Apollo, god of poetry, and took his pose from the famous ancient bronze of a dancing faun, as if to show the divine part of a creature that is half beast.10 In art, he wrote elsewhere, the body is a material envelope that also reflects the soul.11

The idea that the seasons mirror the ages of life is ancient, and it is in Ovid himself: in the last book of the Metamorphoses Pythagoras describes autumn as “ripe and mellow, midway in temper between youth and age, its temples sprinkled with grey”, before “aged winter comes with trembling step”.12 In classical poetry the poplar was Hercules’ tree, “dearest to Alcides” (that is, to Hercules) in Virgil’s line, and in the zodiac the last month of autumn belongs to Sagittarius, the centaur archer; nothing ties Moreau to either.13 Read with the ending in mind, the hand raised high above her head might be taken as a sign of the hero’s coming ascent to the gods; Moreau’s own explanation points to the season instead.

Critics’ Take

Moreau’s centaur belongs to an argument about how centaurs should look. His friend Jules-Élie Delaunay had shown a Death of Nessus at the Paris Salon of 1870, the official annual exhibition, and the critic Marius Chaumelin complained of it, in a book of 1873, that there was “nothing divine about this centaur. He weeps and grimaces like a mere mortal.”14 Most of Moreau’s studies, Allan observes, set out to give Nessus the “mythic nobility” that Chaumelin had found lacking.

Later writers have followed Moreau’s explanation. The Getty’s online text says the two figures “resemble dancers performing a ballet rather than opponents struggling for sexual conquest”.15 Allan calls the hidden Hercules “the ghostly residue of a once heated drama”. Online, the blogger M.C. (Art is the Solution, 2021) reads the scene as “the calm before the storm”, with Dejanira as “the fading summer”.16

One claim needs correcting. The Getty’s online text invites viewers to find Hercules “drawing his bow to fire a poisoned arrow at the Centaur”.17 In the painting he is a small standing man in a loincloth, loosely painted: one arm is thrust out towards the left, away from the couple, and no bow, string or arrow can be made out.

Things You May Not Have Noticed

Hercules is in the picture, by the Getty’s reading: the small figure on the rocks in the gorge behind the couple, at the left, with something pale streaming from his head and shoulders.

A bird takes flight beside Dejanira’s raised arm, level with her head: white, like her.

Nessus wears a wreath of dark leaves touched with red, and a spiral armlet of red beads.

Dejanira wears a jewelled band high on her left thigh, and a transparent gauze, which Nessus grips at her waist.

Her left foot hangs in the air. She is carried, not standing.

A dead branch, splintered at its tip, sticks out from the big tree against the sky; Moreau first painted it reaching right across to the poplar.18

A waterfall drops through the shadows of the gorge beside Dejanira’s head.

At the lower left a large bird flies low against the dark bank, and below it a long-necked bird with raised wings is half hidden in shadow.

The signature, Gustave Moreau, is in red at the lower left, between dashes.

Sources

Scott C. Allan, “Dejanira (Autumn)”, J. Paul Getty Museum, museum essay (March 2021). — Gustave Moreau, Écrits sur l’art (Fontfroide, 2002). — Catalogue de tableaux … collection de feu M. Lepel-Cointet, Hôtel Drouot, 9–10 June 1881. — Ovid, Metamorphoses, books 9 and 15. — Virgil, Eclogues. — Marius Chaumelin, L’Art contemporain (1873). — Google Arts & Culture, “Dejanira (Autumn)” (J. Paul Getty Museum). — Morgan Library & Museum, collection record 2005.99. — M.C., Art is the Solution (2021).

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Select a question to open Socrates with this artwork and essay held close.

Source ApparatusNotes18 notes
  1. Reproductions should not be trusted for exact colour. The details described here can all be seen in the Getty Museum’s own photograph (Open Content).

    ↩
  2. Moreau, draft letter to Lepel-Cointet, after 9 October 1873, in Moreau, Écrits sur l’art (2002), I, 89–90, quoted by Allan 2021, n. 22: “C’est […] une dernière lueur, un dernier sourire de la nature et de la vie”; “cette forme blanche et légère qui va lui échapper”.

    ↩
  3. Ovid, Metamorphoses 9.101–133: “uberior solito, nimbis hiemalibus auctus, / verticibusque frequens erat atque inpervius amnis” (105–6); “pallentemque metu, fluviumque ipsumque timentem” (111); “vulnere, non pedibus te consequar” (126); “dat munus raptae velut inritamen amoris” (133). The Achelous episode is 9.1–100.

    ↩
  4. Ovid, Metamorphoses 9.134–272.

    ↩
  5. Lepel-Cointet to Moreau, 11 May 1872, Paris, Musée Gustave Moreau, quoted by Allan 2021, n. 24: “Le sujet n’importe peu, assuré à l’avance qu’interpreté par vous […]”.

    ↩
  6. Allan 2021. The study labelled “Automne” is Musée Gustave Moreau, des. 2004; the Fortune that reuses her pose, des. 2783.

    ↩
  7. Catalogue de tableaux … composant la collection de feu M. Lepel-Cointet, Hôtel Drouot, 9–10 June 1881, lot 30: “Enlèvement de Déjanire par le centaure Nessus”, 54 × 45 cm, which matches the Getty panel.

    ↩
  8. The Morgan Library, which owns a study for the picture (Study for Nessus abducting Dejanire, 1872–73, 2005.99), notes that the series “was never realized”.

    ↩
  9. Moreau, draft letter to Lepel-Cointet (Écrits sur l’art, I, 89–90): “La Déjanire fait partie de quatre compositions représentant les quatre saisons de l’année”; “Laissant de côté la fable, voici ce que j’ai imaginé”; “l’accord qui peut exister entre la nature extérieure à un certain moment de l’année et quelques phases de la vie humaine”; “Dans un paysage voilé, coupé d’un rayon lumineux”; “le centaure cherche à étreindre et retenir cette forme blanche et légère qui va lui échapper”; “l’hiver menace; bientôt la nuite [sic]. C’est l’automne.”

    ↩
  10. Allan 2021.

    ↩
  11. Moreau, quoted by Allan 2021, n. 17.

    ↩
  12. Ovid, Metamorphoses 15.209–212: “excipit autumnus, posito fervore iuventae / maturus mitisque inter iuvenemque senemque / temperie medius, sparsus quoque tempora canis. / inde senilis hiems tremulo venit horrida passu”.

    ↩
  13. Virgil, Eclogues 7.61: “Populus Alcidae gratissima”. The sun passes through Sagittarius from late November to the December solstice.

    ↩
  14. Marius Chaumelin, L’Art contemporain (Paris, 1873), 390, quoted by Allan 2021, n. 15: “Au reste, rien de divin dans ce centaure. Il pleure et grimace comme un simple mortel”.

    ↩
  15. Google Arts & Culture, “Dejanira (Autumn)”, text supplied by the J. Paul Getty Museum.

    ↩
  16. M.C., “Dejanira (Autumn) by Gustave Moreau (Interpretation and Analysis)”, Art is the Solution, 22 September 2021.

    ↩
  17. Google Arts & Culture, “Dejanira (Autumn)” story, text credited to the J. Paul Getty Museum. Allan, more cautiously, has him “obscured in the shadow of the rock face”.

    ↩
  18. Allan 2021, n. 45, from the X-radiograph.

    ↩